Wizards of the Coast spokeswoman Tolena Thorburn finally called me back after yesterday’s Slog post about WotC layoffs. She said that she’s unable to comment on the layoffs because it’s a “personnel issue.”

Worlds in a Handful of Dice estimates the layoffs at four people, including the head designer of the 4th edition of Dungeons & Dragons, the most recent edition of the game. Last year, WotC laid off nearly a quarter of its staff.

The comments on yesterday’s Slog post provides an interesting look at the way fans perceive the company and the 4th edition of D&D:

what you non-nerds need to know about this:

Wizards of the coast recently released the 4th edition (actually more like 6th, it’s complicated) of Dungeons and Dragons.

It really, REALLY sucks. they basically tried to make D&D more like World of Warcraft. But they forgot that World of Warcraft isn’t actually fun.

So, while lots of nerds, like me, bought the first book or three (its convenient for each player to have their own copy of one of the books, the DM basically has to have 3) we soon found out we didn’t want to play anymore. so people aren’t buying the books after the first 3. Obviously, this is not good for their business.
Posted by guy on December 8, 2009 at 8:06 AM

WotC has been perceived to be in decline for some time now—I looked at the 4th Edition when it was first released, and found it wanting. That they allegedly fired a major mastermind behind the 4th Edition is a big deal; does this mean that they’re going to try to save the brand, or that they’re giving up on it?

34 replies on “Update on Wizards of the Coast Layoffs”

  1. WOTC really dropped the ball with 4th Ed. If I find myself in need of a RPG optimized for the gaming needs of 8 year olds, I’ll just simplify the far superior 3.5 rules myself.

  2. I’m a geek and I have to disagree with the comment you highlighted.

    I don’t know how it did from a business perspective, or amongst “hardcore” dnd players but 4th edition struck as fun and versatile with combat that was way more exciting and tactical then the previous versions.

    So yeah, you don’t speak for all nerds, guy.

    That said, DnD has been on a slow decline for some time now.

    Also the comment about WoW is insane. Millions of people play a game that, “isn’t fun.” I quit the game, myself, because it’s a time sink, but saying no one thinks it’s fun is pretty wrong.

  3. People are writing their own story lines for this with little basis. 4E has been quite successful for them, but WotC always fires some folks at the end of the year.
    The lead designer, Rob Heinsoo, was let go, but’s hardly surprising given that the system is pretty well codified at this point. By the time everything that he was working on is released it will have been 2 years since the launch of the system. This is the point in their cycle where they move more into content creation and power creep.
    The online-flash they showed at that launch party never materialized. The game is still just about getting together with your friends around a table; poker night for nerds.

  4. recently met a bunch of people from there……wow….those guys take the concept of gaming nerd to a whole new level. Good reminder of why I’ve drifted very very very far away from that world.

  5. “It really, REALLY sucks. they basically tried to make D&D more like World of Warcraft. But they forgot that World of Warcraft isn’t actually fun.”

    Yeah, that’s the kind of well-reasoned, sound argument I’m used to hearing from gamers, who never have silly fanboy agendas at all.

  6. Yeah, guy doesn’t speak for all nerds. I’ve really enjoyed 4th ed. But you kind of have to look at it on its own, because it really is a completely different game from its predecessors. You’ve hit upon here a debate that is very heated in nerdland.

  7. Anyone who’s really enjoyed 4e hasn’t been playing D&D long. I bought the books, and read through them and that is about it. And the comment about it being like WoW is dead on. D&D is not Kill, Level, Loot, Repeat. Maybe they should have marketed it like “D&D, but not like the D&D you enjoyed previously. Actually, it barely resembles the game.”

  8. 4th Edition D&D kicks so much ass, I have to change my pants after playing. Every time D&D changes editions there’s always a few blowhards that don’t like the new system because they can’t stand change. Those people will be left behind and join the nerd subculture of curmudgeon gamers, forever trying to convince the rest of us that THEIR system is the one true Dungeons and Dragons. It won’t work of course, just ask the 2nd Edition enthusiasts.

  9. Just throwing in – I dig the simplicity and quick setup offered by the 4th edition system, even though I find the content of the associated adventures somewhat lackluster. That said, as a DM I tend to make up my own adventures anyway, so this particular weakness isn’t a dealbreaker.

  10. Eh, a couple of friends I play DnD with infrequently have been playing since early 2nd edition and they like it quite a lot, but they aren’t loyal to the DnD system in general. I just know I like it and a lot of others do.

    I don’t really mind one bit if someone prefers the older systems, it’s just the blanket statement by Paul and the comment he used that I took offense at.

    In my opinion, the reason they took a page out of the WoW book when doing this edition is because it’s relevant, easy to understand, and offers a lot of variety without having to add complexity. If that’s not your bag then don’t give it a try.

  11. These people are the exception to the rule. WOTC made the mistake of not involving 3rd Ed players because they wanted to go a new direction and alienated longtime fans. Despite these fans who are seeking vengeance against WOTC the game is very popular.

    D&D 4th edition has made the game more accessible and more fun. From my perspective the characters are more interesting and allow for a variety combinations of different races and classes. The guides are well written, well organized and the books are beautiful. I am not alone in my opinion. The game café I play at now has seven games a week of D&D where it had none before. They are all playing 4th edition. In home games and Living Forgotten Realm games I have seen more new players come play, stay playing and keep playing then any other edition of D&D.

    People who spout off these generalities about the game have me doubting they have ever played the new edition or even read the books. Again, where I play 4th Ed the tables are reserved through March. The most recent gaming convention here in addition to there normal gaming ran 60 D&D 4th edition games over a 4 day period and they were turning people away.

    This game is fun there is no doubt about it. Its said to see the perceived betrayal by long time fans sour them to what is a good time.

  12. From this and the previous post (other than the first comment of the other post), you’d think D&D was the only thing WotC was responsible for.

    Didn’t they just release Magic 10th Ed. at PAX?

  13. Gamers allow the perfect to be the enemy of the good to the point that it permanently fractures their universe. Live long and Prosper D&D.

  14. @13- People still buy Magic? I had to give up because they were basically reprinting cards with new names and lower casting costs. Very few new mechanics were coming out, it was just “Here’s Drain Life but for colorless mana! Here’s a Craw Worm but it’s trample and costs half as much!” There was so little reward for the money it cost.

  15. Maybe WotC will get into so much financial trouble, they’ll have to sell the Star Wars license back to WEG, and D6 will come back.

    Look, I can dream, okay?

  16. @15 Magic is popular, and WOTC has done an excellent job on consistently keeping the game fresh while avoiding power creep.

    I was chatting with the clerk at Gamma Ray Games on Saturday night in between rounds of a Zendikar draft and he said that Magic is more popular this year than it had been in the last several years. He thinks that Magic is more popular in a recession as folks are less likely to sink their money into video games, etcetera.

  17. I’m one of the nerds who doesn’t love 4e. I can see why it’s more accessible, and I think the rulebooks are much better written (4e DMG is the most relevant in preparing DM’s, in my opinion), but I’m still really irked by many of their changes (alignments, healing surges, lame class reworking, etc.).

    The good thing is they can’t revoke or invalidate the old books ^_^

  18. Paul> Not sure that the slant on this story is right at all…

    First you’ve given a lot of space to Guy’s opinion of Fourth Edition. There are those who don’t like 4E, who feel like WOTC should support whichever edition of the rules they prefer. (3.5, 3e, some old school revisionists who think that WOTC should support TSR’s 2e rule set, or purists who claim that DnD stopped being cool when they appended ‘Advanced’ to the name, and the only real truth comes from the mouth of Gygax…)

    These folks are wrong. I don’t think that 4E is for everyone. But 4E is the first version of the game that I have been able to regularly play. Accessibility may not mean something for the uber-nerds, but I thank The Traveler I don’t have to understand THAC0. The older editions of Dungeons and Dragons didn’t stop existing when WOTC switched to D&D, but I’ve been able to play in a regular game and have a good understanding of the rules with 4E, something that never happened with previous editions of the game. Old books will continue to sell on the second-hand market as long as people have nostalgia for them, but that’s no reason for WOTC to stop advancing the game. Friends have told me about their characters in 3.5 and it sounded like they had a lot of fun minmaxing their character, but it wasn’t a game I wanted to play…

    I don’t think that 4E is failing and I think it’s foolish to look at layoffs and read them as a failure for the game. It’s unfortunate that people have lost their jobs, and it’s easy to speculate the cause of the job losses. As it stands, D&D is the most popular RPG, and as a hobby roleplaying and board and card gaming (the clutch of activities I’ve heard refferred to as “analog gaming”) have a lot of room to continue to grow. When Microsoft announced layoffs last year, no one said Windows is failing. Businesses hire people and lay them off. It happens. And as someone with many friends in the gaming industry I am glad that WOTC has done a good job with 4E. It has it’s faults, it’s not for everyone, but it’s a very good product for most people who want to roleplay and it employs a good number of folks.

  19. Just my 2 cents: didn’t anyone catch a clue that WotC was on the declined when they closed all their retail stores?

    I was a contract employee for WotC immediately after they closed all the stores. My desk was in the building that used to be the retail dept. It was pretty cool being able to run around and play with Nerf guns and use the abandoned desks and cubicles as forts.

  20. Second the premise that Magic is doing quite well; my friendly local comic shop (Merlyns, in Spokane) still holds weekly tournaments, and there’s always people buying the cards.

  21. D&D is (supposed to be) a role-playing game. WoW is not. The whole point of RPGs is that you can theoretically do whatever you want. Want to chop your hand off? Ouch, but no problem! Want to climb a tree while upside-down? Roll some dice and let’s see you go! Want to boil your feces in a pot of stew? Bon Appetit!

    There are literally billions of unique things you can do in a paper and pencil RPG that will probably never be possible in a computer RPG, simply because video games have to have SOME limits.

    WoW, and all other computer “RPGs” aren’t role playing at all. They’re just the shell of an RPG with a typical video game beneath.

  22. I’m personally not a fan of 4e at all. If you like it, fine, you’re entitled to, but I think it’s oversimplified, and the writing is atrocious. I will most likely remain a 3.5 fan. 4e is definitely a grab at WoW players; the simplified, slicker design (not to mention transparent attempt to push miniatures SUPER-hard) are all aimed at bringing in new blood. Which is a reasonable thing for a business to do, but many of us felt that 4e was sort of a middle finger. especially those of us who enjoy Eberron, which 4e pisses all over.

  23. For hardcore gamers, 4e was an unnecessary slimming-down of the rules and regulations. However, it’s golden for newcomers: it’s simpler, faster to set up and less daunting for a would-be gamer. For years I have cajoled and begged a number of reluctant friends to start playing, and only when I said “look, easy, right?” with 4e did they hop on board.

  24. OK. I admit that I just might find an actual use for 4e when The Nephew turns 8, closing on 3 more years down the path. But that doesn’t recommend it to the kind of cerebral, political, boy this world is fucked let’s take it over! games I prefer to play and run.

  25. I’ve been playing D&D since 1979 and I really like 4e. I like the rules and I like the “flavor” changes too – the new cosmology and alignment system are much less silly to me than the old way of doing things (even though I’ll always have some affection for them). Some decry the changes as being too simplistic but I don’t see that they limit you in any way and things are easier to change on the fly than in 3x. High-level play in 3.5 makes me want to fall on my sword.

  26. I have to second that plenty of nerds don’t share Guy’s opinion. I like 4th quite a bit, and i’ve been playing since 1st. There will always be people like Guy, who say that one game about sitting in your basement pretending to be a magical elf is “immature” and “for kids” while clearly THEIR favorite game about sitting in your basement pretending to be a magical elf is mature and sophisticated. But there are just as many who realize the ridiculousness of statements like that and just play games to have fun, not to prove their vast levels of maturity. 4th edition is a lot of fun.

Comments are closed.