Crap! I nearly forgot to torture you guys with my daily iPad post! Cutting it pretty close there.

Several big-name tech journalists have had iPads for a week or more, and all their hands-on reviews are popping up tonight.

The general consensus is what we’ve been hearing a lot since the thing was unveiled: you don’t really get it until you’ve used one, and when you’ve used one, it’s pretty amazing.

One surprise is that both David Pogue and Walt Mossberg found that the iPad’s battery lasted significantly longer than Apple’s claims, finding they could play video for over 12 hours and 11.5 hours, respectively.

USA Today’s Ed Baig: “The first iPad is a winner.”

Chicago Sun-Times‘ Andy Ihnatko: “I’m suddenly wondering if any other company is as committed to invention as Apple.”

The Wall Street Journal‘s Walt Mossberg: “I believe this beautiful new touch-screen device from Apple has the potential to change portable computing profoundly, and to challenge the primacy of the laptop.”

The New York Times‘ David Pogue’s review stands out from the rest by reviewing the iPad twice—once for “techies,” and once for everyone else—and by focusing significantly more on the iPad’s shortcomings. He claims that techies will be consumed by these limitations, while everyone else will just consume.

Tonight’s episode of ABC’s Modern Family also completely revolved around the iPad, with one of the main characters whispering, “I love you” to his new device as the credits rolled.

Whatever you think of the iPad, nobody does hype like Apple. Sorry, but it’s not over yet.

Anthony Hecht is The Stranger's Chief Technology Officer. He owns no monkeys.

13 replies on “First Hands-On iPad Reviews”

  1. How exciting! People who like Apple will like Apple even more! People who don’t will dislike it even more! This changes EVERYTHING

  2. I personally really enjoy it when shitty comments get posted more than once because of a sluggish server or some other technical problem, especially when it is MY shitty comment

  3. Ugh. I hate when shows integrate product placement. I could never watch Chuck because of the constant Subway plugs (well, ok… there might have been more problems with the show than that) but it really kills me to see Modern Family suckling on the corporate teet.

    (Can’t tell you why I’m surprised- I just am. Maybe because it’s a show I appreciate.)

  4. Yeah because the first name people go to for gadget reviews is the USA Today….?

    Next time type your daily ipad post on an actual ipad and see how long it takes you… crap you can only use one hand because you have to hold it with the other. Wait, now you’re setting it down on a table to type but the screen isn’t facing towards you and it keeps rocking back and forth because of ipad has a convex back. Need to check a source on a different website? Sorry the ipad has less ram than any laptop on the market and the tablet may not be able to handle it.

  5. @1 – Yes, the writers for these papers are well known for accepting money for positive reviews. You nailed them. Huh?

    @7 – That logic just doesn’t work. People aren’t interested in this thing for its processing power, or to be a primary computer that they’ll type on all day (you can connect an external or Bluetooth keyboard in any case). Comparisons like yours miss the point of what’s interesting and different about it.

    It’s interesting that no one who has actually used one has this complaint about it rocking when you type.

  6. “you don’t really get it until you’ve used one, and when you’ve used one, it’s pretty amazing.”

    I was able to use one for about 30 to 45 minutes at the iPad launch (time stopped! remarkable!), and it’s true. The experience is like touching something from the future.

    However, that doesn’t mean people, after having a transcendent material experience, will open their wallets. But it’s damn cool. It feels like you’re inside one of those prototype videos of products that will never be made.

  7. Well of course the battery lasts 12 hours. When you can’t run multiple apps simultaneously, only have 32Gb of flash-drive memory storage, wimpy RAM, no DVD drive, no stereo speakers, etc., etc., then, yeah that makes total sense.

    But, I’m still confused – what exactly does this thing do that makes it superior to my two year-old tablet that can do all the above, and more?

Comments are closed.