*Do not bother reading this post if you don’t know what a Cylon is. You have been warned. Also, in other nerd news, Slog is getting its very own Lost open thread this week. Look for it Wednesday night.
Battlestar Galactica was great for about three years but last season the show was a complete train wreck and I kind of lost interest.
This season, I’ve watched a few episodes—I’m planning on catching up while I’m on vacation next week—but everything feels so rushed and it’s just not very engaging anymore.
Still, the show apparently still has plenty of crazy, obsessive fans.
Exhibit A: This 1700 word essay sent to me earlier today:
Dear Stranger Readers,
We need to have a chat. Sit down. Pull up a chair. Grab a beer because this might take awhile.
Why aren’t you watching Battlestar Galactica? Is it the name? Are you worried your friends will make fun of you? They will, mind you. Are killer robots just not your thing? Did you see one episode and it made the kind of sense that, you know, doesn’t? Bygones people. I’m sick of these petty excuses.
Read the rest of this absurdly long cry for help after the jump.
Okay, yes. The show takes place in space and maybe you don’t like space shows. You drew the line at Star Wars and even then, you only watched it because everybody else had (If everybody else jumped off a cliff…). And yes, it does have to do with technology turning against its creators in an effort to wipe out the human race (ala 2001: A Space Odyssey with less monkeys clubbing each other over the head and more sexy model like seductresses), but these are just the surface plots. I mean, sure, Battlestar Galactica may take place in space, but it is not about space. And okay, robots did cause the genocide of the human race in the first episode, but if it were as simple as that, there would have been no continuation after the mini-series.
I admit. It took me four years to get off my ass (or is that on my ass?) and check out the first three seasons. I had seen the mini-series and it was a little bit slow and although the plot was intriguing, I wasn’t too thrilled with the metal looking machines that were killing off all of humanity. Yawn. I’d seen it before. I was indifferent. Uninspired. Mostly though, I was stupid. I was naïve, and finally, I was pathetically impatient. It took me a full three years and some odd number of months, plus a long trip to China where DVDs were much more in my price range (shh…don’t tell the authorities) to change my opinion. And changed it has! I am a convert, my friends. I have to resist using “frak” in everyday conversation. I make Cylon jokes that I expect everybody else to not only get, but admire and I was this close to breaking into a charity fundraiser where Edward James Olmos was making a speech (I regret, in fact, that I did not hop under a catering cart and follow through with my ingenious plan). But I feel terribly alone. Witness this typical party exchange:
Naïve non-fan: You watch Battlestar Galactica? *snicker*
Me, indignant: Your point?
Naïve non-fan: Isn’t that the show on Sci-Fi about killer robots?
Me, now angry: Yes, I know it takes place in space and it has to do with killer robots, but it’s really good. I swear.
(Naïve non-fan goes and gets more beer. I glower.)Oh, you uninformed masses. Don’t listen to the media. Not everything on the Sci-Fi network will inevitably result in you attending Star Trek conventions and talking in Klingon. Exhibit A! I sit—convention free. And you are missing out. You are wasting the brilliance of modern television watching The Hills because your roommate raves about Lauren Conrad’s sense of style (gag me) when you could be expanding your mind and reveling in the perfection that is Battlestar Galactica’s epic exploration of the human condition. You could be, but you aren’t. And it is sad. And it is tragic. And it needs to stop.
But I digress. Right now you are probably confused and questioning my sanity. Valid. Let’s be kind and rewind. Since the majority of the television viewing audience has failed to give this show a chance (for shame, viewing audience, for shame), I’ll help you play catch up by summarizing the most complex show on TV in a mere paragraph. In the very first episode, the twelve planets that are home to the entirety of the human race are simultaneously attacked by their own creation — the Cylons, robotic designs intended to serve the human race, but instead evolving and developing a god-like complex of superiority. In one day, all that remains of humanity is 40,000 people (a number that drastically decreases in the months that follow) who have desperately banded together around the last defensive battle ship in the universe, an old and outdated clunker known as TheBattlestar Galactica. With no other options, humanity has found itself in an endless struggle for survival. But this is only the beginning.
What must under no uncertain terms be understood is that what makes Battlestar Galactica fantastic is not its premise. Countless movies have started with the same basic format, but few have continued it with the finesse and subtlety that Glen Larson (the show’s brilliant creator) has consistently managed. The complexity of this show is unparalleled. It tackles the very basics of founding philosophical principles. What exactly does it mean to be human? What makes us so special? As the robotic Cylons develop more and more agency, questioning their roles in the universe and even regretting their previous decision to annihilate the human race, they stop being simply machines and begin to be indistinguishable from humanity. This is first seen through Sharon, a Cylon that falls in love with a member of the air force who at first believes her to be completely human. When her true nature is eventually revealed (and believe me, this is all much more complicated than I’m making it sound), Helo can no longer see her as a robot. She feels. She loves. She bleeds. She is no different from any other human being. Through Sharon, the members of the crew are forced to look their enemy in the eye and come to terms with the fact that it is not a machine staring back at them. It is a girl. How utterly terrifying this development is! The black and white world they so relied on has been dissolved!
You see, simplicity is how wars are fought and won. If one can view his enemy as a thing — something different and foreign — one can hold up a gun and fire without guilt. It is when the enemy becomes a person that complications arise. In a memorable moment in the series, Sharon tries to explain the Cylon position to Admiral Adama, eventually saying, “Does the human race deserve to be saved?” Does it have any more right to survive than the Cylons? Adama has no answer because in the end, human history is besieged with bloody battlefields and betrayal. Are we a noble race? Are we better than the enemy? Perhaps not.
And here we encounter the true brilliance of Battlestar Galactica. It has managed to take a completely absurd situation and link it fully and effortlessly with the problems facing our society today. Exhibit one: religion. At the core of the conflict between humans and Cylons lies the irreconcilable difference about their beliefs in a greater power. In a twist, the Cylons believe they are fulfilling the “one, true God’s” plan, whereas the humans are mostly polytheistic. Ahh, war bred from a difference in religious ideology where both sides are absolutely sure they are correct. Sound familiar? It should. Further still, as the Cylons infiltrate what remains of the human race as sleeper agents, we cannot help but relate to the paranoia (unfounded or not) the characters feel when anybody could be the enemy. Trust is abolished. Lines have become blurred. The bad guys are not easily distinguishable by their pointy hats and cackling laughs and the good guys are not always stalwart and true. Where, pray tell, does this leave us?
In its final season, Battlestar Galactica has become more twisted and complicated than ever before. Kara Thrace, a once strong, snarky and cocky pilot, has spent the majority of the episodes practically insane with what she deemed a divine calling to guide the fleet to its one refuge — Earth (and let’s face it, we were all behind Starbuck. Her craziness, although hard to watch, was as endearing as every other failed attempt she’s made over the years to do what’s right). Like most things that people don’t understand, Kara is shunned and scorned. She is our Antigone, dignified and tragic, fighting against the tyranny of Creon and willing to die for her cause. Meanwhile, the Cylons are facing the first civil war in their short yet eventful history. They have become the very things they were so sure they were greater than: human, a beautiful yet terribly flawed race of beings. Four out of five of the final Cylon copies were revealed in the fleet and our guts clenched because they were our heroes and they were not supposed to be the bad guys and we just can’t hate them. It’s Sharon all over again and it leaves the audience unsure who to root for and who to condemn.
I am a TV junkie. When I find a show I like, I engage myself fully and whole heartedly. I try to get into the minds of the characters until I rejoice at their triumphs and cringe at their failures. But it is rare when I find a show that actually teaches me something about this terrible and heart breaking world we live in. Battlestar Galactica is a diamond in a rough of television that is sub-par, that allows its audience to watch an episode and forget it a mere hour later. It is not a show about killer robots. It is a show about the tragedy of the human race. And that’s just a little bit beautiful.
I have said my piece. I have made my case. You are entirely in command of your own fate. But c’mon. Don’t you want to be on my good side at a party? No? You don’t care?
Well frak you.
You’re missing out.
Emily K. Goll

Jonah, you really need to get caught up. Season four is back to being awesome.
Battlestar Galactica is one of those shows that I really wished I had watched when it first came out. My brother keeps telling me how great it is, and how much I’ll like it, and it sounds like I really would. But… I will probably never devote the time to watching 3-4 seasons of a TV show, unless I get sick for a week or something…
I love BSG. I’ve seen every episode (and Razor, and the webisodes). This mess will not make someone who doesn’t like the show give it another shot, and it also does nothing to clear the reputation of fans.
Emily, it’s not other partygoers’ fault that you don’t know how to make small talk. Also, you’re angered by people making fun of the Sci-Fi Channel show you’re clearly obsessed with, so you make fun of people who go to conventions? Classy.
My wife and I got into it by watching the first two seasons on DVD and then starting the TV run at the beginning of season three. Since then, we’ve lent our DVDs to a few friends of ours, and they’ve all marathoned the seasons in a week or two.
i got sucked into trying to catch up on the season break via tivo. characters are shooting themselves in the head in one episode and whoopsie, back on deck an hour later. i don’t know how gaida lost his leg.
i’ve looked all over for one place that could give me a simple blow by blow without the TWP snark but can’t find it. cry for help: anyone got a quick rundown URL?
it’s kind of like watching ‘lost’ so unfortunately this feels deliberate even though i know it isn’t.
i’m pretty sure the president’s wearing a wig in most episodes now, so maybe i caught up
That last episode was a mess.
@5,
Are you watching them out of order? That one character who shot herself did not wind up on deck in the next episode.
If you are watching them out of order, you’ll soon find out what happened to Gaeta’s leg.
I didn’t watch the show for the first three seasons because I didn’t have cable. I finally Netflixed the first season. Blew through that in a week. Bought the rest of the seasons on DVD in order to get caught up in time for the season 4 premiere. It is truly the best TV drama, IMO. Lost, although it is consistently awesome now, frequently stumbled because of bad acting or poor pacing. Every actor on BSG, from Edward James Olmos down to the bit part extras, is top notch.
Incidentally, while I agree with a lot of Emily’s points, the creator of the new BSG is Ronald D. Moore. Glen Larson created the original show, which was basically a cheesy Trek ripoff with a sprinkling of Mormonism. Moore took the original concept of people surviving a genocide and stayed faithful to the questions that would arise from such a horrific event.
Fucking nerd alert.
This half-season is the best since season one. The show always suffered when they weren’t moving the main story forward, and now that it’s all downhill to the finale it’s as good as ever.
I mean everything that’s going on here. Not just the initial letter.
Emily K. Goll scares me a little bit.
Jonah, you should get caught up. All the answers are spilling out right now, and you’ll likely bump in to someone, read, or overhear something that might potentially spoil it for you. Also I want you to find something else to do so you can stop panicking over Watchmen. 🙂
I tried watching an episode or three of BSG, but I had the same problem with it that I have with Lost (which I love): 100-lb. women consistently beating the crap out of much bigger, stronger guys. I know, I know, it’s just TV, but it just rings false to me.
Bring on the accusations of sexism and all the stories of tough girls, I guess…..
Brian sounds like a nerd closet case to me.
@13: I wasn’t going to comment on this thread, but you’re right about the incongruity of 100-lb. people landing blows! It freaks me out when Angelina Jolie, who’s built like Judy Garland, supposedly punches people. They reel back when in fact her wrists would break.
When it comes to remakes of 70s sci-fi, I say, forget Lorne Greene, how about ITV’s “UFO”?
http://z.hubpages.com/u/270186_f520.jpg
All those lunar buggies bouncing on cheesy Moonscapes…yea!
@5 try and find “What the Frak is up with BSG?” There are two of them and they are short (two minutes?) videos that catch you up on a whole lot (like a seasons worth) all at once. They have the added bonus of being really funny and cool too. The most recent one was (still might be?) on On Demand on Comcast, but I imagine they are both on the web somewhere.
Nothing is more annoying than when I really get into something, and have nobody I can empathize with. It’s frustrating, everyone thinks you’re crazy because you like something that isn’t popular. Emily Goll is not crazy. At least, no more so than most people are about football. What’s even worse is when people who I know are just like me make fun of my obsessions so that theirs will seem better by comparison.
News Flash: Nobody cares that you like BSG but you’re not “a crazy obsessive fan”, because to the rest of the world you’re just another nerd.
@8 The original Galactica was directly copied from Star Wars, not Star Trek; to the point that LucasFilm sued the producers.
I’ve watched the new show pretty regulary from season two on…never backtracked to catch up, and probably should have, because even after regular viewing for a couple of seasons, I get characters mixed up and have trouble following the various plot and character arcs. Guess I’m kind of dumb.
@5: Salon had a good rundown last month. http://www.salon.com/ent/tv/feature/2009…
It was season two that went off the rails around the middle, there, but season three was almost uniformly great (episode three of that season was flat-out the coolest space action on TV, well, ever). The new season’s been great so far, if rushed a bit.
Galactica and Lost are the only shows I watch on TV, and both are ending soon. I’m seriously considering cancelling cable when they both end, and ending the TV watching portion of my life at age 40, on a high note.
Nic for the insightful win @1.
BSG is way better this season.
@16:
The Andersons tried doing a remake/update of “UFO”. Unfortunately, what they ended up with was “Space: 1999”.
I’m in geek heaven with this silly thread….
The last three episodes have been awesome. I am very ready to see how it ends. Only four episodes left.
I didn’t like it at first, but want to go back and rewatch the early episodes.
I agree with most of the letter from Emily. The show has been truly tragic this year, in a way that television rarely is. It also plays with the natures of humanity and religion in interesting ways. Deadlock was kind of a mess, but Ellen continues to be a fascinating character (OK, and that’s a huge spoiler if you’ve missed the last two episodes, but what the hell).
Um, Glen Larson created the Original Battlestar Galactica, in the 70’s. The one that was more campy space opera than grim portrayal of the human condition. Not that the Original doesn’t have a certain nostaligic charm, but the rest of the essay clearly discusses the new version, revisioned by Ron Moore. Because if you’re going to devote 1700 words to an essay on cult TV, you really ought to keep track of the showruners.
Emily is a writer at examiner.com. This wasn’t intended to be a “letter-to-the-editor.” It’s an article on the website:
http://www.examiner.com/x-4972-Seattle-T…
I already read this article on examiner.com.
http://www.examiner.com/x-4972-Seattle-T…