This Mashable review of the hilariously priced iPad Report from Resolve Market Research offers some weird details on iPad users, including the claim that 28% use it mainly for playing games*. This has provoked some mild hysteria about how the tablet will knock out handheld gaming platforms like Nintendo’s DS, but the numbers just aren’t there yet: Apple has sold about 3 million iPads (about 1 million mostly for gaming, apparently), and Sony and Nintendo have collectively sold about 200 million of their current generation of handhelds. In the absence of an iPad-exclusive, Mario-esque must-play title, it seems more likely that the gaming giants will swipe the interface tricks that work really well for gaming, like tilt-motion and touchscreen gestures, for their next generations—unless Steve Jobs decides he needs to own games like he owns music.
- VACANT FEVER VIA FLICKR
- This is you.
* We have no idea how reliable this number is, of course, as we haven’t reviewed the methods. For all we know, they used magic. But maybe that number isn’t too surprising, given that 37% of iPhone users say they play games daily.
The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner and Paul Hughes.


My guess is Apple is far more concerned about the HTC.
Based on my very limited hands-on experience, the iPad is a much more compelling gaming experience than the DS. Obviously the iPad won’t surpass it, at least in this generation, but I also don’t think the 3DS is exactly a step in the right direction for Nintendo either. Two things iPad games have over the DS are convenience and price. For convenience, nothing beats being able to download a game directly to your device, versus having to go buy a physical product from a brick-and-mortar or wait for it in the mail. On price, I’ll just say that I can’t see Nintendo continuing to be able to charge 30+ bucks for the latest Super Mario iteration while Angry Birds is, what 5 bucks? But hey, like Apple, Nintendo are the masters of charging premium price for exclusive IP and hardware accessories, so maybe they can keep it up. What you said about the “interface tricks” is spot-on. I would add the capability for direct download and add-on content to that. Like the iPhone before it with mobile device interaction and data usage, the iPad will redefine many people’s expectations about portable gaming and the other players (i.e. Nintendo & Sony) will have to adapt. Who knows, maybe there is an Android-based gaming platform that can beat Apple at it’s own game down the road.
The cartridge is dead. Long live the new cartridge.
Why does it have to be one or the other? I play games on my iPhone and would love to play games (if I could afford it) on the iPad, but they don’t substitute for a ds or a console or a pc. They’re all different because all games are different and their gameplay is different and their experiences are different. Gaming is not homogeneous and there can never be a one-size-fits-all system.
The ipad is always going to be hamstrung by the fact that it doesn’t have a physical means of control which makes any game that requires the slightest bit of dexterity a chore.
@2 yes but the 3DS plays 3D games. The iPad doesn’t, sadly.
@4 you can buy a wireless keyboard for your iPad – heck, you can even hook it up by AppleShare over Wireless N to your new Mac Mini hooked up to your 1080p HDTV set.
Totally different sort of games, and I don’t see much overlap. What @4 said, touch screens just aren’t that precise.
Actually $1,750 is a totally reasonable amount to pay for an analyst’s study (if they’re reputable). I’ve seen them go for far more. One WSJ staffer I know was okayed to pay $3400 for an Android study only to have the info get scooped by another paper.
Yeah WOW, The idea that APPLE, (APPLE PEOPLE), APPLE will in anyway succeed at gaming is laughable. NEVER. They have 0% gaming skills, knowledge, resource…
Just never. NOW, if they came out with a GAME DEVICE that was somehow super amazing and blew you in ways the DS never could, IT WOULD STILL FAIL, because gamers are different than the rest of the zombies, and they wont buy that thing that isnt the thing they already have/want.
Reasons why it wont be able to compete with DS or PSP.
#1) No physical buttons.
#2) Not designed to fit your hand like a glove, like most game controllers do.
#3) Cant lend games out to friends.
#4) When the battery dies (and it will) and you ship it back to Apple for a BRAND NEW iPAD! If you dont do a back up (through iTunes), you lose all your games.
#5) Apple doesn’t make games. If they did, they could make kick ass games only for the iPad giving buyers another incentive to buy the iPad. If Nintendo didn’t make games, why would you buy a Wii if Wii Sports, Mario Galaxy, Zelda Twilight Princess or even Super Smash Bros didnt exist?
#6) Its 500$ minimum to pay to play those games.
#7) Games would go through a hit/miss application approval process, which even after it gets approved, can get pulled for any reason. With retail games, EBGames isnt going to pull Super Mario Fluffer from the shelf because Nintendo told them to.
The iPad will be great for point/click games like World of Warcraft or Starcraft. Or Flash based pick up games that keep you entertained while the bus hits the tunnel and you cant surf the web. I have these games on my Android, Kitten Cannon, Othello, Solitare & Yahtzee.
@9…but…they…are succeeding. That’s the whole point of the study and this post. The iPad isn’t a dedicated gaming platform but it’s proving to be a viable one, just as it is not a dedicated e-reader but is helping to make inroads into the e-book market, and creating competition along the way. Amazon responded to the iPad by dropping the price of the Kindle and enjoyed a 3x increase in sales. They released the iPhone and Android rose to meet the challenge. I thought that’s what everyone wanted in the first place.
@11 Yeah I did a real lousy job of arguing my point, and I’m gonna do a bad job reiterating it now.
Gamers wont buy into that gay apple shit because gamers are assholes and brand aware. Eventually anything could make its way into the gamer market, but the people apple will market to first will be examples for gamers to balk at and dismiss.
I like the idea of the DS getting a real rival (The PSP is just silly) so if the ipad spurns that, more power to it. There is still a whole generation of gamers that attribute Apple to no-games (They got burned when the emac came out.)