- This store, at 534 Summit Ave E, is called Indian Summer, and it’s open today through Sunday, 1-7 pm, with an opening party from 5-10 pm Saturday. Plus Cairo next door has rock shows this weekend. It’s a whole block celebration, and you should go.
Two days ago I walked by an unmarked storefront on Summit, then performed two separate acts of laziness and blindness.
One, I assumed the fashion display in the window—a cowboys-and-Indians theme (I use the word “Indian” intentionally, because that’s the trope)—was an act of appropriation on the part of white people.
Two, I posted here a poll, carelessly asking whether tribal fashion in general is racist—abstracting the issue rather than looking into the specifics.
I am genuinely sorry. I failed both as a journalist and as a white girl committed to examining white race politics.
From the comments:
Hi all, my name is Adria Xuala Garcia, and the window display in question is mine. I’m a half Taine/ Seminole Indian & half Irish . The window reflects my personal heritage as a first people and people who settled here people who actually are cowboy and ranchers. Those flags belonged to my grand father, who’s family settled the west and who were all Soldiers ( family fighting in every American war ). The window is meant to reflect how I feel , a child a two cultures ( native american barely ever represented ). The headdress is a piece traded at a pow wow , that I danced in , given to me as thanks.
I AM NATIVE AMERICAN and COWBOYS .
Not Racist !
I did this to reflect the life of one native women ,finding her identity . To show people when I where my headress , I am proud.
When white people make racist mistakes, we usually follow up by making the issue, once again, about us. Most often we deny it. We almost never get beyond these two statements: “I’m not racist!” or “This isn’t about race!” And both of those statements, in addition to being conversation-enders, are self-centered and dismissive. They’re also convenient. You don’t have to deal with a problem if you insist it doesn’t exist.
But it does exist. White race politics have been stalled in denial for years. I was once formally accused by a (white) student of mine of being racist for admitting in class that I am racist in the context of a conversation about black artists coping with white racial cluelessness. It’s that kind of tautological logic we’re stuck in. And it’s up to us to work to end it with acts of imagination.
This week, I failed to commit a basic act of imagination. In my haste to put people in neat categories and start a discussion without doing any actual work toward making sure the context was at least informed, I didn’t even consider the possibility that what is literally a mixed-race display actually represents a mixed-race personality and consciousness. (When the previous store, Spencer Moody’s great Anne Bonny, closed, I talked to two white guys about the future store, and I mistakenly assumed they were the owners.) Not okay.
And you’d think I’d be more thoughtful: All this is going on while I’m reading Coll Thrush’s 2007 book Native Seattle: Histories from the Crossing-Over Place. I’m only about a hundred pages in, but I think that if the book has a single message, it’s that the story of Native Americans in Seattle is massively mis-told as a ghost story—as a series of steady and/or sudden erasures, when the truth is that native people have been part of this town all along, and in fact the race politics of early Seattle were far more nuanced than they are today.
Take the amazing story of Ling Fu, told on page 64 of Native Seattle:
Sometime in the 1870s, a Chinese man named Ling Fu was brought before Judge Cornelius Hanford in Seattle’s courthouse, accused of not having the proper citizenship papers. Facing deportation, Ling Fu argued that he did not need to carry papers: he had been born on Puget Sound. To test him, Judge Hanford quickly shifted his inquiry into Chinook Jargon, which had become nearly as common as Whulshootseed or English in Puget Sound country. “Ikta mika nem? Consee cole mika?” (What is your name? How old are you?), he demanded of Ling, who in turn replied, “Nika nem Ling Fu, pe nika mox tahtlum pee quinum cole” (My name is Ling Fu, and I am twenty-five years old). Clearly surprised, the judge responded, “You are an American, sure, and you can stay here.” He then turned to the bailiff and decreed, “Ling Fu is dismissed.”
The little store on Summit Avenue East is called Indian Summer, and it is having its grand opening this weekend. I’ll be there, and I hope Garcia will let me in.
As for the rest, I have yet another reminder that I have my work cut out for me, and I’m still committed to doing it.

It’s always good to see some one admit to being wrong with a well thought out, sincere apology like this one. Good for you, and it’s a good reminder to all of us to not to judge on face value and assumption, or rest assured in one’s open-mindedness to the point of falling into closed-mindedness.
Classy follow up Jen.
Thanks.
Hey neat! I always like seeing apologies, so many these days from officials or media people are JUST BULLSHIT.
Way too many “I am sorry if anyone took offense to my statement, it wasn’t intended to hurt anyone.”
You identify your fault, you properly correct your fault and you start a discussion so that gawkers and assholes can get it off their chests.
Thanks!
Looking at the pictures, racial addendum aside, I would change my vote to “not racist.” The initial description was far more inflammatory than the actuality of the display.
Coll Thrush’s book is full of fun surprises. The tone gets old, but it is worth reading. Did you know there was a big village in Ballard where the Locks are now, called ‘Tucked-Away-Inside’? Right where the fish & chips place with the fake totems is.
Did you see a doctor about your knee jerk? I kid, I kid.
I think a lot of us can learn something from your experience. Or as my dad used to say: Don’t assume, it makes and ass out of u and me,
That was nicely done, Ms. G. Usually when I get that embarrassed I just change handles and avatars. Way to take the high road.
Get over it, Jen. Sure, you made an assumption, but that is a journalistic mistake– not a racist one. You used the cues that our society gave you to provide context to a display in a window. No one walking by it (of any race or cultural background) would be able to discern the creator’s intentions at face value. As a journalist, it should make you curious. As a human, it should be internalized and processed with your unique perspective. And just being white, and having a white perspective does not automatically make it a racist one.
Classy. (I’m not being sarcastic. Is it possible to call something classy without coming off as sarcastic?)
It’s a conversation that more of us should be having.
THAT’S the window you were referring to in your poll? Jesus. You need to leave the city more. That window reminds me of every small town in the West. That window screams out that the owner is someone who has a serious interest in chronicling and understanding the story of the american west from multiple viewpoints.
You are confusing racist irony with history.’ How ironic.
It occurred to me about ten years ago that I was just flat-out lying whenever I said, “I’m not a racist!” Two ideas then presented themselves: 1) I am a racist, but I’m working on it and that will have to be good enough for most intents and purposes; and 2) in certain contexts, the fact that I’m a racist or that I engaged in some form of racist reasoning does not necessarily invalidate my argument, or make true statements less true. African Americans don’t score as well on the SATs; that’s a true statement even if it comes out of the mouth of a grand dragon of the KKK. Of course there’s more to it, but the statement itself was true last time I checked.
The left/liberal approach to racism and people who say or do racist things is actually sort of a political version of the idea that hookers have poor eyesight.
Will you marry me?
the dirty little secret of this country isn’t race, it’s CLASS.
Did you really learn anything though? I really doubt it.
You just have some amount of guilt right now about this specific story. I hope you feel better about yourself.
I read somewhere that the term “Indian Summer” was derogatory towards Native Americans. According to the writer, Indian Summer is a fake summer – a trick and is, therefore like Indians. They tricked and ambushed the settlers. Is that right?
Right on. Take this recognition into the schools, where most of us are taught dead-end denial of race politics. There’s a teacher-training program called “Courageous Conversations” that helps teachers recognize the dynamics you write about here, articulate them, and make them visible and tractable. That’s the starting point of change or, at least, consciousness. If they don’t have it where your kids go to school, ask about it. They’ve got it here in Portland and it has made my kid’s racially-mixed public elementary school a much better place for all involved. Second, of course, everyone needs to read Coll Thrush’s awesome book, because it is great!
Good job Jen Graves
I feel like I just found my people!
I’m Native American (Pottawatomie) AND Irish too!
I’ll be at the grand opening for sure.
Maybe I’ll bring along the peace pipe my grandfather carved so we can have a blessing and smoke to honor the new space.
And Jen, don’t sweat the race stuff. You did right but owning up to your mistake.
If you really want to do right, write a piece on how our government celebrates genocide with Columbus Day every year.
@9: When I want to be sarcastic I spell it Klassy. Of course we have to examine any use of the word in light of @14…
This is why I was personally gunning for the native american cultural center in the place where the Chihuly BJ Palace is apparently going in. We don’t really have any prominent cultural facilities in Seattle that remind us that the Native heritage is living and ongoing, interacting with the city’s larger culture, and it’s something we desperately need. Victoria and Vancouver both have good, prominent Native American cultural representation, but in Seattle it’s almost invisible.
Jen, I don’t always appreciate or agree with your art criticism, but I have nothing but respect for your follow up on this. Well done.
thanks for this, jen. just a year ago, I was shocked and frightened by an email that arrived in my inbox late one sunday night. in the email I was accused by a student of being an ingorant and dangerous racist and was instructed to make an immediate public apology.
I had made a comment in class in what I thought was a neutral and explanatory way, and in the context of what I thought was a supportive learning environment. I was wrong all over the place. shocked and humiliated by the accusation that my explanation was racist, I was humbled by the power of what felt like a sudden punch to my gut.
in this email, I was told to make an immediate apology in class the following week, which was painful but a good learning experience about the power of language and my racist assumptions. I was also told that if I made any attempt to contact this individual personally or to identify this individual to anyone, I would be subject to the full power of retribution including a lawsuit.
this punch to my gut was appropriate. I took it, and it hurt. a lot. it cost me dearly and had dramatic ripple effects in my life, including the loss of a friendship.
in reading your post, this all came flooding back
like a flashback. though painful, it’s good to remember. it’s so difficult to see ourselves in the harsh light of our racist ways and assumptions, despite our efforts.
thank you for your post, jen, and for the opportunity to resonate with your experince without the threat of retribution.
@11 No kidding. Apparently in knee-jerk land, any image that’s identifiably associated with a race or ethnic group = racism, regardless of how it’s portrayed.
class act. nice move on your part graves.
now, go and get some threads coz’ INDIAN SUMMER is awesomeness out of control.
Nicely done follow-up, Jen!
It’s nice to see a Stranger writer willing to admit, and write about, that upon receiving more information on a subject, they realize that their initial reactions were wrong.
(Something I wish Charles could manage.)
Told you it was cute.
thanks jen, it’s nice to see someone willing to own up to their mistakes. definitely go check out adria’s store – your wardrobe will never be the same!
Thank you Jen Graves, for your heartfelt response. I know how difficult it is to admit to wrong doing, not to mention the moments when we speak before thinking. Sometimes we can’t imagine the damage created by … words; this is a beautiful example in teaching us that they (words) are so powerful. Racism is often manifested and pursued as an UNconcious thought process, which is what makes it so dangerous. It is inside of these moments that we realize how intensively we assimilate to the discourse of our cultural and social upbringing. This SLOG is a heroic self examination, and I applaud your bravery in coming to Indian Summer this weekend to attend the Grand Opening! Bravo!
Wow. What a melodramatic display of white guilt. It’s great to admit one’s errors, but way to turn this into a passion play for all whitey’s sins. And using one’s Cultural Studies reading list to show one’s open-mindedness seems to me like a step away from the “I have a black friend” disclaimer.
A simple “I’m sorry” would have sufficed.
@ OP
lulz. idiot.
I think the store owner needs to take ownership over the ambiguity of her statement.
I didn’t care about the original poll, but after reading the owner’s comment I now have visceral hatred of the place. “I AM NATIVE AMERICAN and COWBOYS.” has “I went to Evergreen!” written all over it, in highlighter.
My mom was Tulalip & I grew up on the Rez & I can’t completely blame you Jen. There’s a certain denim/rodeo aesthetic that’s completely synonymous with Shabby Chic…
My mom was Tulalip & I grew up on the Rez & I can’t completely blame you Jen. There’s a certain denim/rodeo aesthetic that’s completely synonymous with Shabby Chic…
Hey Jen – thanks for the Native Seattle plug (and Ling Fu is one my all-time favourite moments in the archives)!
What I’ve found in years of teaching and writing is that we’re all really woefully impoverished when it comes to knowing our history – and by “us” I mean everyone. With a few exceptions, we all went to the same crappy schools. Thanks for the thoughtfulness of your comments – and let me know what you think of the rest of the book.
And as for the “fake totems” at the fish and chip shop in Ballard: they’re real. Carved in the 1930s by a man from the same Nuu-chah-nulth nation as John Williams, the carver who was recently shot to death by a Seattle cop. So much for assumptions, eh?
Coll Thrush, Vancouver, BC.
Thank you, Ms. Graves. Let the healing begin.
Very nice apology and well intended. Your ‘mea clupe’ is refreshing in light of this huge f$&k up. I hope this stands as a message to you to see how much damage and hurt you can wield with your sword and ignorance. I can only hope you DID learn from this experience and will think about HOW MANY TIMES YOU’VE SPOKEN ABOUT ARTISTS AND THEIR ART AND NEVER REALLY SPOKEN TO THEM DIRECTLY OR CONSIDERED THE OUTCOME OF YOUR CARELESS REMARKS. You’re NOT the “art police” or Seattles version of Roberta Smith, Jen, please try to remember that and get the community involved for a change. THIS STANDS AS THE PERFECT EXAMPLE OF JUST HOW BAD IT’S GOTTEN AND HOW FAR OFF COURSE YOU’VE GONE.
Warmth,
Hibrow
So when do straight white males get an apology?
Black males commit over half of all murders in Seattle annually, even though black males make up less than 3% of Seattle’s population.
Black males commit over half of all murders in Seattle annually, even though black males make up less than 3% of Seattle’s population.
TO THE CENSOR : YOU ARE ESSENTIALLY CENSORING THE SEATTLE P-I’S OWN ARTICLES BY CENSORING MY POST AND ALSO PROVING THAT YOU DO NOT WANT THE PUBLIC TO KNOW THE PLAIN UNVARNISHED TRUTH!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!!!!!!
http://tinyurl.com/no5knk
Extrapolated from the article “List of 2008 homicides in Seattle” from the Seattle PI
selected from the list of the 28 Seattle homicides in 2008….
Allen Joplin, Jan. 4 — black killed by black
De’Che Morrison, Jan. 10 — black killed by black
Maurice “Moe” Allen Jr., Jan. 26 — black killed by black
Degene Barecha, Jan. 30 — black killed by black
Perry Henderson, Feb. 6 — black killed by black
Stephan Dwaine Stewart, April 2 — black killed by black
Eldora Earlycutt, July 4 — black killed by black
James Paroline, July 10 — white killed by black
Troy Peters, July 22 — black killed by black
Pierre Lapoint, Aug. 5 — black killed by black
Jane Kariuki, Oct. 16 — woman of unknown race killed by black man named Christel D. Murphy
Quincy S. Coleman, Oct. 31 — black killed by black
Edward McMichael, the “Tuba Man”, Nov. 3 — white killed by multiple blacks
Nathaniel Lee Thomas, Nov. 23 — black killed by black
Blacks (8% of Seattle) were the killers in at least half (that’s at least 50%) of the murders in the Seattle area in 2008. At least five of the other murderers were latinos.
Now let’s take a look at 2009!
http://www.seattlepi.com/local/413827_ho…
http://tinyurl.com/2aa88vd
The link above is to the Seattle PI’s article on homicides in Seattle in 2009.
At least twelve of the 21 murders in Seattle in 2009 were committed by blacks, only 8% of Seattle.
Of the 27 officers that were shot and killed by criminals in the last 20 years in King and Pierce county, 21 of them were shot by black men, even though black men make up less than 3% of the population.
Its important to remember that Indians were a stone age people who practiced cannibalism, slavery and human sacrifice before the European conquest. They had no written language, beasts of burden, wheel or knowledge of the outside world either. Hey if anyone owes anyone a thank you I would say it’s the Indians to their White masters. Don’t be hating. I Just keeping it real. chillax and keep it real yo.
I don’t understand how this is racist. It looks like the window display from any western wear store. Where are you from, Jen, New York? Oh, yeah, you are! A headdress and a hatchet on a drunken frat bro= racist. A Pendleton blanket= not racist.
I’m glad you are taking the time to learn about the intricate history of the Pacific Northwest.