“So why don’t you… ah, pick a vegetable, and show us how much you… LOVE IT.” —PETA
Will these outtakes from their rejected 2010 Superbowl ad, Veggie Love, become their 2011 Superbowl ad? Hmmm.
Love Our Arts & Culture Coverage?
You can help fund it!
“So why don’t you… ah, pick a vegetable, and show us how much you… LOVE IT.” —PETA
Will these outtakes from their rejected 2010 Superbowl ad, Veggie Love, become their 2011 Superbowl ad? Hmmm.
Kelly O—formerly a Stranger staff photographer, music writer, Drunk of the Week columnist, and more!—finished art school and a soul-crushing internship at a corporate advertising agency in Detroit,... More by Kelly O
Comments are closed.
Sign up for our newsletter for news recaps, updates, and more!
We'll send a verification code to %EMAIL%.
Why is it so impossible for PETA to do any sort of protest or marketing that doesn’t debase or objectify women? This isn’t a sex-positive vs. prude situation. Women can be engaged in policy issues, make coherent arguments, be persuasive, protest, etc. They have more to offer than standing naked outside a butcher shop or pretending to give a blow job to a cucumber and titty fuck a carrot.
I think PETA are among the worst people in the world.
Plus meat tastes good.
Kelly O is a national treasure.
What schmacky said.
As someone pointed out in the comments on HP, that sure looks like a leather couch.
@1 yes, the idea that animals should somehow be given constitutional rights is certifiably crazy. And yes they are delicious. I stopped eating them anyway for a number of reasons none of which invoke animal rights.
@1
As long as people are willing to give them space on their websites or blogs, PETA will continue this method of operation, which is “If you cant sell your message with common sense, then use sex”.
Meat is murder!
Tasty, tasty murder…..
On the bright side, at least they’re focused on promoting their diet rather than condemning mine.
Remember recently when Hostel 2, which showed a woman slicing open another woman with a scythe and bathing in her blood, got an R rating? While Blue Valentine got an NC-17 for having realistic sex?
That’s America for you. And it’s the reason why PETA must use sex. Sex freaks USians out. Sex will get your Superbowl ad banned — and after all they want their ad banned, for the free publicity that mindlessly spews from lazy bloggers posting on autopilot. Very likely if they hadn’t used sex, they’d have to actually cough up $3 million to get the ad seen by anybody. PETA are the all time grand champions of free publicity, since they know which way the knee jerks.
So PETA will stop using sex when Americans grow up. When puritanical second wave feminists stop going into hysterics over “exploited” women, and their partners, hypocritical Christianists. stop seeing the devil in every expanse of cleavage. Don’t hold your breath.
Fuck PETA. They make people who do real work for animals a bad name. They are ridiculous and hypocritical, asking people to stop eating meat because it is cruel, but killing pretty much all the animals they “rescue” and encouraging shelters to do the same. They should have no place in this conversation, regardless of their approach.
Perhaps because absolute animal rights is incompatible with human rights.
@11 – explain how.
C’mon, people. IT’s the SUPERBOWL.
Why is sex so EVIL?
So how come people who read this site hate on anyone who is uptight about sex/strippers/etc. — that is, until someone posts about PETA using sex, and then you all become super uptight about it?
@12 Nature eats us, we eat nature. Circle of life, etc.
These ads were never “rejected” for airing during the Super Bowl. It’s clever of them to say so—a little extra outrage to appeal to the persecution complex—but they weren’t ever going to pony up $3M for a 30-second spot.
Peppered amongst these marketing shenanigans, PETA does occasionally do some good work in the animal rights field; and if I were a donor that genuinely believed they were going to spend their resources that way, it’d be my last donation.
Also, that ad works just as well with a hot dog.
Also, nice.
@15 that argument can also be made with a vegan diet, so it doesn’t really explain how animal rights and human rights are incompatible.
@5, No one is saying animals should have constitutional rights. They don’t want to vote in elections or carry firearms or be elected to positions of public office. They just want to live in fucking peace without the constant threat of someone raping them, breaking their limbs, or slicing their throat open. The same shit we expect people not to do to dogs and cats. It’s not really a stretch of the imagination.
Also, lots of things are delicious or fun or exciting or fulfilling but that doesn’t mean we should do them. “Sex with kids is exhilarating! Why do you want to take away my god given right to do what feels good?! You terrorist monster!!!”
“Studies”?
@17 No it can’t. Vegans, just like libertarians, have others do the dirty work for them.
And if I you read carefully, I never said animals can’t have rights. I said they cannot have absolute rights. Animals have the rights we give them when we feel bad about killing them and only when it’s convenient; when we can afford to feel bad. For example, it’s very convenient for Brigitte Bardot to be against seal hunting. For those who live from the hunt, it’s not. It’s when PeTArds start to think that humans and animals have equal rights (nobody’s this dumb at Greenpeace) that your system of values gets all screwed up. Anyone who can’t see the difference between the Holocaust and a chicken coop is a sociopath.
So eating meat and raping a child is the same thing. Noted.
The problem with assigning “rights” to animals is that animals by their nature do not operate in the world of morality. They are purely instinctual. There are no animal operated courts for example.
While you may not be fussy about the use of the word “rights” it’s a big deal to our legal system. Rights are constitutional rights. There is nothing stopping us from protecting animals from cruelty. We do that now. By all means go out and convince people to enact more protections for animals but don’t invoke “animal rights.”
@20 Explain how vegans have others “do the dirty work” for them. Also explain what the dirty work is in this scenario.
Regardless, let’s just break this down. We (and by “we” I mean human beings living in first world urban economies) do not HAVE to kill animals for food/clothing. Forget all the other arguments about people who live in arctic locales with no vegetation, far enough from any form of human interaction that would afford them the opportunity to readily access fruits, veggies and so forth. We don’t have to do these things. So what gives us the right to? What makes it okay to kill these things over here but not these things over there?