Straight men would do everything gay men do if straight men could but straight men can’t because straight women won’t.
If there were straight bathhouses full of women who wanted to have anonymous sex with straight men, straight men would go to straight bathhouses. If there were straight public-sex environments—parks and truck stops and toilets—where straight women cruised for anonymous sex with straight male strangers, straight men would cruise straight public-sex environments.
Not all straight men would go to straight bathhouses and straight cruising areas, of course, just as not all gay men go to gay bathhouses and gay cruising areas. But a lot of straight men would. If they could. But they can’t. Because women won’t.
It’s important to remember this when we talk about HIV infection rates and syphilis rates among gay men. The problem isn’t that these men are gay. The problem is that these gays are men.
Straight men have an external check that makes it more difficult for them to spin out of control sexually. Whether you believe that female sexual reserve/reluctance/caution is about socialization or biology or both, or that it’s a reaction to sad fact the many unpleasant consequences of sex fall disproportionately on women (greater risk of pregnancy (um, duh), much likelier to be the victims of sexual and intimate-partner violence, easier for STIs to be transmitted from male-to-female than female-to-male), female sexual reserve/reluctance/caution exists. It’s consequently much harder for straight men to get laid than it is for gay men to get laid. Gay men tend to get laid more, as a result, some gay men get laid lots, and a core group of hypersexual gay men get laid like crazy and these core group members, according to epidemiologists, fuel the HIV and STI epidemics in gay male communities. (And core group members don’t just sleep with other core group members.)
The challenge that gay men face—and it’s something that HIV “educators” and gay men working in the laughably ineffectual “gay men’s health movement” refuse to acknowledge or address—is that gay men have to find an internal check to avoid spinning out of control sexually. Gay men should be encouraged to find that internal check, challenged to find it, and confronted when they fail to find it.
As I’ve said before: straight people should have more sex, and more sex partners, than they do; gay people should have less sex, and fewer sex partners, than we can. Somewhere there’s a balance.

@258
A high school buddy of mine pedalled a boat to Alaska from Seattle. He took his degree in journalism in Arizona spending 2 of his 4 years in Mexico City, and taught Samba (Mamba, Ramba something like that….) dancing in South America someplace, where he met his long term girlfriend. He worked with the UN as an observer all over Asia and in East Timor. Now he owns a house in Livorno and a country place in the same village we do. In fact, my house had been part of his. In exchange for restoration of his place, we got ours. (And boy did I get the better end of THAT deal. Spending a year in Italy restoring 3000 square feet of a nearly untouched 800 year old house was a gift, not a job. Working with hand planes and routers to replicate the look of old wooden trim, working with he and his very knowleageble and tasteful girlfriend to keep the place authentic but comfortably modern: Every real craftsmen drools at the thought. I should have paid him for the experience, not he pay me for the work.)
Now, HIS life is interesting. Mine, not at all. I’m just a carpenter who loved village life in Italy, realized life is short and I’d rather be happy than rich and got a place there, and loves old British cars. Sorry to disappoint.
@261 Those of us who ARE looking for wham-bam-thank-you-ma’am sex with strangers are definitely best off not minding beer bellies, casual clothes and a wide variety of hair/facial hair choices. Looking back at blah’s list @50, I would say that some arrogance is a plus, though insisting on anal (on the first date! Or sticking it in “by accident”!) or mocking my vibrator are definite negatives.
Guess one can’t hope to control what men say about us the next day, though it would be nice if ragging on a sex partner were less acceptable gossip among both men & women.
@260 The Black Party is definitely the exception to the rule, and they flaunt it. It’s not necessarily the Manhattan scene so much as THAT scene. Like I said, the Folsom of circuit parties.
Also, I’ve heard stories of dark rooms and BJs on the dance floor at circuit parties. YMMV and all that.
It’s not unusual though. At Ozzfest I saw some chick giving head to her bf while their male friends made a loose prison-esque half circle.
@263 Mocking your vibrator? Huh. That’s a new one.
@202
I was a medical researcher, and although I’m not an expert on STI’s, I’d say the reason we don’t have a vaccine for Chlamydia, gonorrhea, or syphilis is more or less the same reason we never developed a vaccine for scarlet fever. It’s much, much easier to treat most bacterial infections with antibiotics than it is to develop a vaccine. Most of the diseases we vaccinate for are viruses: influenza, polio, Hepatitis (A&B), the MMR group, etc. The bacterial vaccines we do have generally offer partial immunity or short-term immunity (e.g. Tetanus, Pertussis, Typhoid).
The reason these STI’s are still widespread while scarlet fever is not, is that if you get strep throat (it’s basically the same bacteria strain), you know it because it hurts so you go to a doctor and get an antibiotic. Chlamydia and Gonorrhea are often entirely asymptomatic and Syphilis typically has a long asymptomatic latent stage after the initial symptoms.
I wouldn’t say there’s a stigma against working on STI’s in medical research, the way there’s a stigma against THC research, but in academic research there is a bias towards things that are novel, unique, complicated, or poorly understood. Work on HIV and Hepatitis C is much more likely to be published in the top scientific journals than work on older STI’s. And drug companies are biased towards making money. If enough parents would freak out about a syphilis vaccine the way they freaked out about the HPV vaccine, than the drug company is going to worry about whether they’ll sell enough doses to make the whole thing worthwhile.
@264, new as in you didn’t know about it, or new as in you don’t think that happens often?
@266 New as in I hadn’t heard of that phenomenon. I’d heard rumors of guys being intimidated by a vibe, but not stories of actual open mocking. I guess intimidation leads to mocking to out that dirty, dirty vibe in its place, but I wasn’t aware of it actually happening.
@259: Of course we can’t criminally convict a pedophile of pedophilia! We convict him of child molestation.
You are intentionally not seeing the point here. Sexuality is not chosen. How we act on our sexual urges is. And our standard for which sexual activities are legal (and which are not) is consent. Legally, we cannot and should not discriminate between any sexual acts so long as they do not involve closely related persons or non-consenting living things.
Nobody chooses their IQ. But you are certainly choosing to be an idiot here.
Oh, I’m sorry I gave that impression. They’re not mean, they’re just nervous, and I’m nervous about bringing out the huge vibe, and they say things like “wow, it’s so big,” and “that’s so noisy.” Or they laugh when I turn it on. Honestly, saying anything at all about it, in their nervousness, just makes me sorry I got it out. It only comes out if the guy just had his own orgasm, so it would be nice if they could just be quiet, or ask matter-of-factly if they can lend a hand.
(Not a problem recently, hanging out more with BDSM folks who have seen hitachi vibes before. But it was a problem with cute guys I picked up on OKCupid.)
@268 – No, he’s choosing to juggle definitions to his own advantage. It reminds me a little of Miss Jean Brodie, “who always made difficulties over words when she scented heresy.” One member of her set, Eunice Gardiner, was attracted to the Team Spirit, and missed the set’s chance to witness the dancing of Pavlova because of “a social.” Miss Brodie’s retort was that Eunice was using an adjective as a noun, and that the set would be having its own social gathering in the company of the great Pavlova. “She is the Prima Ballerina; it is the Corps de Ballet that has the team spirit.”
Stopping now before I make a reference to Patience.
@Seattleblues: I hope while on your hike that you fall into a ravine and are eaten by weasels. Have fun!
@269 That was more the type of response I would be expecting. Then, again, I’ve given that reaction when I’ve opened up other people’s toy chests too.
272/Ken, that’s what I was thinking too, that he might be talking about the choice to act on the attraction, not the attraction itself. Regardless of how he would answer your question, it’s obvious he thinks gays and lesbians shouldn’t make the choice to act on their attraction to people of the same sex and someone who believes that a person should never express their love and affection for another human being (a consenting adult human being) in a physical way is, in my opinion, very mean-spirited.
250/Marrena: Some are really cold and contemptuous after they’ve ejaculated and can’t stand the sight of me.
Maybe I’m incredibly naive because I’ve never fucked a guy but I would think that if I was a woman I’d be able to get some sense of how a guy would treat me in bed after spending some time with him, talking with him. These guys you mention who become contemptuous and can’t stand the sight of you after they’ve come…did not they give any indication beforehand that they might be selfish jerks? Also, I hate to brag here, but every woman I’ve ever been intimate with has told me that they knew I’d be giving in bed because of how I acted with them and treated them beforehand. So if they can get a good read on a guy like me, isn’t there some kind of a selfish vibe you can pick up from these guys you mentioned? But, like I said, I’ve never fucked a guy. If I was a woman, meeting guys and fucking them, maybe I’d be surprised at how guys who seem thoughtful and considerate beforehand can be very selfish in bed.
Because sexual pleasure itself is greatly increased for a woman if there is an emotional bond.
I agree with you on that.
@275 Guys can be charming & flattering, and if they’re also charismatic and intelligent, it’s hard to realize it’s all an act to get you into bed. (Jerks who act like jerks from the get-go don’t get laid much.) The danger of this is amplified when one is looking for NSA sex. If I were looking for a second husband, I’d get to know the guy longer (probably) before jumping into bed. His kindness or twititude would come out over time. But it’s hard to differentiate between kindness and charismatic charm in a couple of hours talking over drinks.
SB, I have a sincere question for you. As a gay man, I know that I didn’t choose it. It just is. I grew up being attracted to men, not to women. Now, you say I did choose this. So here are my questions.
By saying I chose it, you are saying that I started out being attracted to Women, and somewhere along the way, decided to ignore that attraction, and take on attraction to men instead. Well, how would that work, exactly? First, if I truly was attracted to woman, and just ignoring/suppressing that, and deciding to like men instead, then that would make me bisexual (being attracted to both). But I’m homosexual, meaning I’m only attracted to men. Trust me when I say this, if I had attraction to women as well as men, I would say I’m bisexual, not say I’m homosexual. I can’t even imagine suppressing my (in your mind) attraction to women so much that I would not even say I was bisexual. So how do you think this works, exactly? Can you imagine ignoring your attraction to woman and making yourself attracted to men, like you would say I’m doing? Attraction is a strong thing. If I had attraction to woman, no matter how much I told myself no, I won’t act on it, I want to be attracted to men instead, that attraction would still come out in other ways. I’d respond to woman physically, I’d pay more attention to them when they come into view, I’d want to look at pictures of them, etc. No matter how hard I tried to choose being gay instead, the attraction to women would still be there. So how in the heck do you think I could manage to be completely oblivious to woman, and only be attracted to men, if I’m choosing to be gay? Obviously the attraction to men was there all along. I respond to men physically, I want to look at pictures of men, I get all flustered when a hot guy comes near, I dream about men when I’m sleeping, I daydream about men when I’m awake, I get thrilled when a cute guy pays attention to me, but never do I do any of this with women. Can you imagine how I could choose to do that? And if my (in your mind) natural attraction to women was so suppressed that I don’t even know it’s there, then obviously I”m not choosing to be gay. I can’t even begin to imagine ignoring my attraction to men and choosing to be attracted to women instead, so how could I do the reverse? Could you? And if not, why do you think I could?
I’ve tried to like other things I don’t like, and it never works. You always go back to what you do like. So if I was choosing to be gay, at some point it just wouldn’t work out and I”d go back to my (in your mind) attraction to women. But I’m 46 and that hasn’t happened yet. Still no attraction to woman, not when I was 16 and not at 46.
I can tell you unequivocally that I did not choose being gay. I just naturally react to men differently than women. Show me a picture of Jake Gyllenhall and my libido will just explode. I sure didn’t say I’m going to like him (even though I don’t really). It just IS……
Anyhow, say I decide to agree with you, and I decide I don’t want to choose being gay anymore. Well, I sure can’t pretend to be attracted to women, it just won’t work. I can try and pretend, but my heart just isn’t in it. When a beautiful woman walks by, my head just isn’t going to turn, and even if I make it, you can see the difference. And when good looking guy walks by, my head is going to look up, no matter how hard I try to suppress that. So how could I prove to you that I was not going to act on my attractions to men, so that I would be “normal” in your eyes? I could never sleep with men, try really hard to not notice them, but as I cannot be attracted to women no matter how hard I try, (and really, now fair would that be to her? She deserves to be with someone who truly wants her, not me trying hard to be “normal”), I would have to stay single and celibate my whole life. I could tell you until I’m blue in the face that I’m not choosing to be gay, that I want to be just like you so that society will accept me, but you won’t buy it. You’ll notice at 46 that I’m not married to a woman. You’ll notice when my head looks up involuntarily when a cute guy walks by. You’ll figure out I’m gay inside and then treat me as badly as you do out and proud gay people. So trying really, really hard to not choose to be gay is not going to get me anywhere. I’ll be single, lonely, depressed, and most straight people are going to treat me as if I’m gay anyway. I could lie and say I”m straight, but astute people will decide I’m gay in there head. Not to mention that I won’t be getting any benefits from the govt for being straight, since I won’t have a wife.
So do you really think I could pull this off? Just so that you’ll like me, you’ll really really like me?
I’m sure you can see where I’m going with this. No matter how much you think I’m choosing being gay, I’m gay whether I like it or not, whether I act on it or not, and whether I try hard to pretend or not. There is nothing I can do to convince you to treat me better than you do.
I would love to hear what you think I should do to rectify this and become Hallelujah!! straight like you so that I will get all the benefits that will accrue to being straight and not having all the negatives to being gay happen to me. (You know, gay bashing, not having rights, not having my partner recognized, having people hate me just because, etc). What do you think, in your infinite wisdom, I should do? Hmmm?
>>However criminality requires volition, and by your own arguments sexuality isn’t chosen. By your own arguments we could institutionalize a pedophile, but we could never convict one criminally.<<
Behavior or any sort requires volition; we criminalize acts, not inclinations. As such, pedophilia, in and of itself, is not a crime. Statutory rape is a crime, which speaks to the important element of crime–a perceived harm, ideally one that can be empirically demonstrated, visited upon a participant who either did not consent to participate or is held to be incapable of consent. We cannot, then, blame the pedophile for wanting to have sex with minors; we can only blame him for having sex with minors–not because he chose the proclivity, but because, in acting on it, he has run afoul of a more that can be usefully explained in terms of civic utility.
An apt comparison might be the kleptomaniac–we do not blame the kleptomaniac for being a kleptomaniac. We blame him for stealing–not because he chose to do it, not even because we happen to find the act morally repugnant for any of a number of subjective reasons, but because respect for property is held to be an extension of respect for person, which in turn nods at the primacy of life as a foundational value (for it has no intrinsic value, except by way of subjective philosophical construct, but no other value of any kind can be created but by a living organism).
1. Oh, Dan. Your argument kind of makes sense — kind of — but it reminds me a little bit of the conservative thing “We MUST punish homosexuality! Because otherwise ALL the men will want to be gay! Because the gays get to have so much sex! Ladies, you’re a drag and the only reason we put up with you now is the fear of God.” Which is kind of dispiriting to me, as a lady. I’m the only thing keeping men from having a wild good time? Is fucking my boyfriend twice a day not good enough? Am I simultaneously not sexy enough to satisfy a man and too sexy to serve my social function as a curb on sexuality?
2. Have you guys ever heard of a small world graph? You don’t NEED a lot of highly sexually-active people to spread disease — you only need a few with lots of partners. It’s really a remarkable result. Erdos-Renyi. Look it up.
ALL of them?
please cite…..
I’ve got a girlfriend, but I need more sex partners? really? geez I wasn’t aware of that.
Straight bathhouses would be ridiculous, although maybe a nice idea for some.
They’d be sausagefests with a few women not giving a shit about whether they get STDs (I’m the type that doesn’t trust condoms %100). On that suspicion I would totally avoid them.
This is the only thing I can nitpick at, everything else Dan writes here sounds right on
@281: Care to cite a credible study concluding that sexuality is chosen?
Here are a few good ones indicating that it isn’t:
http://www.pnas.org/content/89/15/7199.s…
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/261/51…
http://archpsyc.ama-assn.org/cgi/content…
Those implicate, respectively, brain structure, polymorphism on the X chromosome, and possible uterine factors.
You can say that it’s because they’re men that they do that, but I think that gay culture is as much if not more so to blame. They are often found saying that gay men have libidos that can’t be controlled, that gay men are expected to have many partners simply to fit in with other gay men, and that gay men are simply to be defined by their sexuality rather than found to have it only be a small component of who they are.
Is that a product of biology or culture? I think that a lot of it was produced during the era when gay sex was considered a real stigma and sex was found nearly exclusively in clandestine situations like cruisy bathrooms and other such places. When a “gay culture” started to emerge, it was full of people who expected that that’s how things were.
Gay culture is so obsessed with sex that even when faced with an epidemic, rather than encourage fewer partners, they go with an approach they consider pragmatic and say “Don’t have less sex, just use more condoms.”
I have a few friends who are a few years younger younger online who are faced with pressures not by their family and friends for being gay, but faced with pressures from other gay men. They are facing them from other gay people their own age, and older, and I can see how they try to change to fit these pressures. I’ve seen some really nice guys who would never have considered going out and having sex with strangers suddenly planning it out because they’ve been told by other gay men that they will never fit in without doing so. They certainly ever wouldn’t be told by other gay men that having sex with many strangers can be damaging to their bodies or harmful to their psyches.
I think there’s something fundamentally flawed in gay culture that’s causing that. I think that the best thing that can be done is to realize that the solution isn’t found in gay culture. If something is considered accepted and normal, why would a separate gay culture be necessary? Sure, men may have a higher libido than women, but culture defines what’s acceptable. That’s why I no longer consider myself gay. I am attracted to other men and homosexual certainly applies to me, but gay to me means I am involved in gay culture.
You can say that it’s because they’re men that they do that, but I think that gay culture is as much if not more so to blame. They are often found saying that gay men have libidos that can’t be controlled, that gay men are expected to have many partners simply to fit in with other gay men, and that gay men are simply to be defined by their sexuality rather than found to have it only be a small component of who they are.
Is that a product of biology or culture? I think that a lot of it was produced during the era when gay sex was considered a real stigma and sex was found nearly exclusively in clandestine situations like cruisy bathrooms and other such places. When a “gay culture” started to emerge, it was full of people who expected that that’s how things were.
Gay culture is so obsessed with sex that even when faced with an epidemic, rather than encourage fewer partners, they go with an approach they consider pragmatic and say “Don’t have less sex, just use more condoms.”
I have a few friends who are a few years younger younger online who are faced with pressures not by their family and friends for being gay, but faced with pressures from other gay men. They are facing them from other gay people their own age, and older, and I can see how they try to change to fit these pressures. I’ve seen some really nice guys who would never have considered going out and having sex with strangers suddenly planning it out because they’ve been told by other gay men that they will never fit in without doing so. They certainly ever wouldn’t be told by other gay men that having sex with many strangers can be damaging to their bodies or harmful to their psyches.
I think there’s something fundamentally flawed in gay culture that’s causing that. I think that the best thing that can be done is to realize that the solution isn’t found in gay culture. If something is considered accepted and normal, why would a separate gay culture be necessary? Sure, men may have a higher libido than women, but culture defines what’s acceptable. That’s why I no longer consider myself gay. I am attracted to other men and homosexual certainly applies to me, but gay to me means I am involved in gay culture.
I’m gay. I’m 42. I’m negative.
All we gays need to do is wear condoms. That’s it.
It pisses me off that the Gay health people don’t just say that. And that we gays don’t hold ourselves to it.
(Also, what REALLY pisses me off is the new phrase ‘men who have sex with men’ which has been coined to have a word other than ‘gay’ for black men to get services. F them — they are gay when they’re having sex with another man. (Remember bi = Gay & Straight — which includes gay.) (BTW — they’re gay, they’re being straight is just a way to be in the closet. Blacks need to drop the heterosexism!)
Also, it’s just the bottom who needs worry.
I’m gay. I’m 42. I’m negative.
All we gays need to do is wear condoms. That’s it.
It pisses me off that the Gay health people don’t just say that. And that we gays don’t hold ourselves to it.
(Also, what REALLY pisses me off is the new phrase ‘men who have sex with men’ which has been coined to have a word other than ‘gay’ for black men to get services. F them — they are gay when they’re having sex with another man. (Remember bi = Gay & Straight — which includes gay.) (BTW — they’re gay, they’re being straight is just a way to be in the closet. Blacks need to drop the heterosexism!)
Also, it’s just the bottom who needs worry.