Nate Silver:

The trendline—derived through regression smoothing—estimates that about 50 percent of Americans now support gay marriage and that 46 percent are opposed, with a small percentage of voters undecided. By contrast, at this time two years ago, the numbers were 42 percent in favor and 53 percent opposed, according to the same technique. The change—about a 4 percentage-point shift in favor of gay marriage in each of the last two years—is about double the longer-term rate of progress for supporters of gay marriage, which has been between 1 and 2 percentage points per year.

There is a margin of error associated with the calculation of the trendline, so it is too soon to say with confidence that support for gay marriage has become the plurality position (let alone the majority one). Other polls — like a Pew survey released in March — continue to show opinion split about evenly.

However, opponents of gay marriage almost certainly no longer constitute a majority; just one of the last nine polls has shown opposition to gay marriage above 50 percent.

The sand in the lube, of course, is that older people tend to be less supportive of marriage equality… and much more likely to actually show up and vote when the civil rights of gays and lesbians are forced on to the ballot. (And only our rights ever make it to the ballot.) But it won’t be long before Maggie Gallagher embraces the whole concept of minority rights and starts showing up on the teevee arguing that banning same-sex marriage is the only way to protect the civil rights of the increasingly embattled minority group that she represents.

Haters rights! Haters rights!

27 replies on “Gay Marriage Opponents Now An Embattled, Abused, Oppressed Minority”

  1. So, to review, Maggie is against gay marriage because it will make it difficult for fundies to be bigots? I really did try to understand her argument at the doma hearing, but all I vould parse from her rambling was that straight marriage is embattled enough, and gay marriage will make it worse…seriously, does she have a coherent statement anywhere?

  2. But Dan, old people are statistically proven to die SOONER than most people.

    Actually, have you seen ‘Coma’? Being the authorized voting agent t for a comatose person will probably become gainful employment soon once the $8/hr McJobs run out.

  3. Well, the cry of persecuted majority *is* getting old. Anecdotally, I’ve met several 65+ Californians card carrying GOP members who express shame and embarrassment over voting infavor of Prop 8. Shows one is never too old to figure out they’ve been suckered into scare tactics. The only thing those individuals have in common, besides pestering me, they have got to know same-sex families personally. Obviously they lack Maggie’s ability to dismiss a family when they meet them face to face. The arc of justice just keeps on bending…

  4. @4 is correct.

    Get used to 4/20 and Gay Marriage Day being national holidays, old people, cause society is changing faster than you can tweet about it.

  5. Why are they pestering you, dear Kim? Do they wish to make amends? All is forgiven if they vote on their new convictions.

    “Go thou, and sin no more.” In all seriousness.

  6. @9 trust me, it’s going to happen. I’ve already talked to Tasha, and she’s going to enact it when she’s President.

  7. This poll is largely meaningless. It’s been shown time and again, that respondants will tell pollsters they are in favor of rights for LGBT (or other groups, perhaps), because they don’t want to appear bigoted, even to someone they don’t know and will never meet. They want to come across as being for equality, and they know anti-gay bigotry is not popular nowadays.
    But when push comes to shove, and they’re in the privacy of the voting booth (or similar voting method), the majority will vote to constrict equality for LGBT.
    The only real value of this poll is to show that the trend continues.

  8. Hi rob,

    It isn’t about repentance. They know that they have been rejoiced over by me for their change of attitude and that their actions speak louder than words when they vote their new convictions.

    I freak them out by my lack of compliance to the GOP values I was raised on. They said I’d be back and I haven’t come back.

  9. Those of us who acted up in the 1960s are rapidly becoming the “old people.” I was born in 1950, and so were most of my pro-marriage equality friends. So watch what you say about old people. The issue does not divide very comfortably by age. People can be sniveling bigots at any age.

  10. @12: The first step is to make bigotry socially unacceptable.

    @13: More gay people out of the closet doesn’t mean there are more gay people — just that more of them acknowledge it publicly.

    @15: Polling shows a very clear divide on this issue by age. Cope.

  11. @12: that is a really interesting point. but hopefully once we get to the point where people won’t ADMIT to being bigots, the next step will be de jure civil rights for the queer crowd. it’s at least a nice step in the right direction, if only a small one.

  12. @17 Thanks, I had been wondering about that just last week. Of course, the supreme irony in all of this is that people like Maggie don’t see themselves as bigots and bullies, don’t realize that their attitudes are what contribute to the climate in which someone is targeted for their orientation. What people like Maggie are doing is so diametrically opposed to the teachings of the man in whose name they conduct their bigotry. Logic fail.

  13. “Sand in the lube” is so much better than “fly in the ointment.”

    @17 Yes, thanks for sharing. That is very good news indeed. As far as I’m concerned, there’s no wrong place to learn that homophobic bullies are actually being held accountable for their actions.

  14. Do the people against same-sex marriage not see the economic boost that would come with it? Legalize it and the monstrous wedding industry would see at least a 5% boost, which I am guessing would pump millions of dollars into all sorts of businesses, not to mention the economic growth from all those new clients for divorce lawyers, child custody mediators, marriage counselors, etc. Think about all those bed-and-breakfasts run by Republican voters – wouldn’t they like a boost in honeymooner revenue? Wouldn’t those massive corporate hotel chains (probably pro-Republican) like a 5% boost in honeymoon customers?

    There are also all those marriage license fees that counties are missing out on, and those are user fees, about as conservative a tax as you can get.

    I don’t see how marriage as an institution will be hurt by gay marriage. All I know is that marriage as an _industry_ stands to gain millions.

    I don’t have any figures on this, but I get the impression that nowadays gay couples may be more eager to get married than straight couples are. If you want to save marriage, I would say gay people are the greatest allies, actually.

  15. @12 the clear trendline there shows that even if some of those people are lying, the fact is that acceptance is increasing. We’re not yet to the level where we could expect a victory on a national vote, because the electorate tends to be older and more religious (and whiter, altho that has less relevance on this question) than the overall population. There’s also an issue in how enthusiastic supporters vs. opponents are, as that can affect turnout.

    The fact is that fifteen years ago when less than a third of people would say they were in favor of marriage equality, none of the states that have legalized gay marriage would have done so, and it wouldn’t have survived in those states even if the legislature passed it. Also the voting results in states like Maine and California support the basic accuracy of the polls. The polls showed a divided electorate, and the bigots won a narrow victory. In combination with other factors that could have swayed the vote (turnout patterns, mostly), this shows that even if some people are lying, the great majority of the gay marriage supporters aren’t.

    While there is reason to be cautious, I think your pessimism is unwarranted. Besides what I mentioned about important to note the decline/stagnation in support in 2004, when there was a sustained and strong campaign against gay marriage. We can’t assume that this means we’re in the position to win as of now. But we’re almost there, and certainly we should start seeing even more state-level victories beginning to pile up in the near future.

  16. @21, the people against gay marriage aren’t thinking about economics, they’re thinking about “morals”. You’re not going to convince them with that dollar stuff.

    Re old people, most of the baby boomers–probably the most philosophically/politically liberal generation ever–are now getting into their 60s. If you think that’s old, then you should shift your attitude about what old people think. If you’re talking about 80-year-olds, then they’ll probably die soon or stop voting, so don’t count them.

    And polls are not statistics.

  17. It may be an American (or to a lesser extent Western) phenomenon that the mantle of victimhood can be extended to groups that are simply losing a battle. Curiously, the same people who were against “group victimhood” when they were the majority may end up embracing its rhetorics as soon as they become a minority.

    The sad consequence is that this banalizes the concepts of “victimhood” and “oppression”. It is, in a way, a new form of oppression by itself — call it ‘cognitive oppression’ if you will: it takes the meaning out of the word ‘victim.’

    How long till we get the equivalent of the It Gets Better campaign… for bigots?

  18. Elephant in the room: minority opposition to gay rights.

    This is relevant for one reason: unlike old folks, who will take their opposition to gay rights with them to the grave sooner than later, the non-white portion of the population is /growing/. 9 out of 10 non-European immigrants (legal or not) is dead-set against letting gays have any rights. If it were up to them, homosexuality would be illegal, period.

    This is something the gay community needs to address more forcefully than it has, I think.

  19. Old people die, and immigrants assimilate. The more worrying division is geographic: while Blue States may become more and more accepting of equality, we have yet to make any serious inroads in the South.

    If 50% of the nation is pro-marriage, then you can have 55-45 in favor in a big state like New York, but still have 80-20 opposed in a small state like Alabama.

    See chart from 2009 here:
    http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/200…

  20. I haven’t seen any evidence for immigrant assimilation in this area. If anything, new immigrants tend to assimilate right, not left. That’s just my personal experience, but I’d be interested in seeing data.

  21. @25 If that were the case how come the polls in California suggested that Hispanics voted only a few percentage points higher in favor of Prop 8 than the white population?

    Hispanics in California were not overwhelming against gay marriage, as you suggest.

    You also didn’t even look at the actual CNN poll numbers that Nate Silver was referring to, because it breaks down the numbers by white vs. non-white.

    White respondents were 52%-46% in favor of gay marriage, non-white respondents were 51%-48% in favor. I’m sure that a more detailed poll could give more useful information about various ethnicities (Hispanics may be included in both the white and non-white numbers there) such as Hispanics, blacks, Asians and other groups. Polls in California have supported the notion that Hispanics who are younger, more educated and/or female support gay marriage more, which is the same kind of pattern you see for the white non-Hispanic population. Sure they support it less than white non-Hispanics, but it definitely doesn’t support your view that non-European immigrants are opposed to gay marriage at supermajority levels and that they won’t assimilate on this issue.

    Not to mention that recent immigrants tend to vote in lower numbers than other groups, if they’re even citizens, so the most socially conservative section of the immigrant community, the ones who just arrived, won’t be affecting the vote as much.

Comments are closed.