Sigh:

rivviewsharks.jpg

“As a principal of a high school, I have to take the paternal side and make sure he’s going to be okay,” said Heilmann, afraid the boy would be bullied. “Anytime anyone goes out from, quote, ‘the norm’ or anytime anyone wants to make a statement, you have to be willing to take what comes with it.” … Some students really took the issue to heart, organizing a small protest. “One boy wore a dress on Monday and after we chatted about it, he decided not to,” said Heilmann, saying that boy went and changed his clothes. “I was concerned about his safety.”

No statements allowed at Riverview High School—they might invite bullying. And rather than punishing the bullies, or letting the bullies know in advance that bullying won’t be tolerated at Riverview, Principal Heilmann is letting the queer and gender-nonconforming kids know that their “statements” won’t be tolerated.

Principal Heilmann added that he had to pull that kid out of class for wearing heels because it might cause a “distraction.” And now students are organizing protests, the school is making national news, and the principal’s email address is here on Slog.

Distraction averted!

52 replies on “Boy Kicked Out of Class for Wearing Heels”

  1. Things like this really remind me how different my high school experience was. I went to a progressive arts school in Oregon. I can safely say that my school was pretty much anything goes so far as dress went. We had guys dressed as girls, Girls dressed as cats, and half the student population would commonly come to school looking like the patron saints of metal and leather. Two out of three students had hair in some shade of Neon. I will never forget when one girl showed up to school in a skintight spandex suit, full fairy face paint and huge wings strapped to her back, its the only time I ever saw the teachers make someone change.

  2. Dear Mr. Heilmann,

    While some may outright condemn you for your actions with regard to your students who choose to wear gender non-conforming attire, I won’t be among them. Rather, I would prefer to educate you, if, in fact, you do wish to act in the best interests of the students in question. Full disclosure: I am a trans woman myself, and I have been fortunate enough to be able to transition in my current job without fear of reprisal, and in fact, with full support of management and HR. I wanted to write to you today to tell you more about my own experiences, and those of the trans women I’ve met in hopes that you might reconsider your policy the next time such an event takes place.

    When I was in high school, a time when I started to understand that I wasn’t “like” the boys I was in class with, I had the misfortune of being in an all-boys Catholic school because it was “better,” even though it wasn’t. Not only was education and discipline at the school simply non-existent, even from the top severe homophobia was encouraged and defended. Obviously, this wasn’t the place or time for me to explore my confusion, instead I trapped it deep down, suffering as the male I knew I wasn’t.

    For my senior year, I was lucky in that I had suffered long enough as a “fag” or a “pussy,” or whatever taunt was in style at the time for those of us who weren’t popular, or who didn’t “man up,” to whatever challenge we got. I told my dad that I needed to leave that school, under any circumstances, and if he didn’t help me transfer to a public school of my choice, I wouldn’t be returning to high school, and he wouldn’t be able to stop me. So it was that I was put into a public high school for advanced students, to be part of the first graduating class there since the school had been recommissioned.

    People were nice. The staff was supportive, and the students were intelligent, and genuinely unconcerned about who you were, as long as you were nice, too. I want to say that I made my shining transition there, but after so much practice at repression, I still wanted to hide from it. Besides, how could I tell my new friends, actual friends, who I was, and why, when I barely understood it myself. Eventually though, I did expand my internal gender identity, and allow it to come out in subtle ways. I began healthily discovering who I was, and while I never dressed noticeably out of the male norm, perhaps if I’d had the brave examples your students provided, I might have ventured that risk myself, despite whatever personal risk I was in.

    Regardless of these students’ gender identities, whether they truly were transgendered or questioning, or they were simply choosing to make a statement about gender roles, they should be allowed to indulge in that and make their statements. If they were exploring their own gender, they need support more than ever in their growth and development, or else they, too, could be forced into a similar repression. In some cases, that kind of action spurs them eventually to attempt to take their own lives. If their safety and best interests are truly at heart, you should permit them to explore within reason. Clearly, anything you would not have on one of your female students is inappropriate, but the choice to wear clothes within the societally acceptable norm should be allowed.

    So I ask again, reconsider your misguided, if well intentioned, policy. Instead of the students only trying to express something of themselves in a place where, up until that point, they felt safe enough to do so, why you encourage that, and reprimand the bullies? Show the bullies (as they will no doubt learn later in life, in much harsher fashions) that authority does not protect their rights to harass others, instead, it protects the rights of those being harassed. Stand up for the harder, but just fight.

    Regards,

    – Kathryn Fortunato

Comments are closed.