A few years ago, book reviewers were chastised for mostly reviewing books by men. Those reviewers then pointed out that the vast majority of books sent to them for review are written by men. And now, Tor UK’s editorial director Julie Crisp says that out of all the manuscripts they receive, only 32% are written by women. The vast majority of those submissions by women are in the urban fantasy/paranormal romance and young adult genres. Crisp concludes:
So here’s the thing. As a female editor it would be great to support female authors and get more of them on the list. BUT they will be judged exactly the same way as every script that comes into our in-boxes. Not by gender, but how well they write, how engaging the story is, how well-rounded the characters are, how much we love it.
Which, you know, is fine. But I imagine that this paragraph gives sexists the warm fuzzies: “See? Men just write more books! It’s not sexist, it’s just the way it is!” But that’s a stupid conclusion. The problem is that literary culture has for centuries convinced women that men write important, great books, and that very occasionally a woman will break through and stand alongside the giants. We all need to agree to change that message. It’s the publishing industry’s job—from publishers on down to reviewers—to ensure that female authors start on the same playing field as male authors. Speaking as a reviewer, I can do that by aiming toward gender equity in my book section.
(Via i09, with thanks to Slog tipper Paul.)
