Every year around this time, people who write about music professionally and amateurishly (and in many cases, both) are beset by the temptation to summarize the preceding 12 months into organizing principles of meaning. The year of the this. The year of the that. What the success of Adele proves. What Kendrick Lamar’s artistic triumph augurs. Why both musical theater and contemporary country music aren’t necessarily the worst anymore maybe.
The impulse is understandable and frequently entertaining. But it’s also sort of wishful—magical realism as the new new journalism. I read the hell out of these lists, partly because I’m still that kind of nerd, and partly because they are a useful primer on all the records I didn’t have time to encounter when they came out. But they make me long for the days when time wasn’t such a fucking asshole, before having a job meant having a job and not three-for-the-price-of-one-if-you’re-lucky, when the question “What do you mean you haven’t heard the new ____ record?” didn’t have such an easy and obvious answer…
