Someday videogame movies will have their Ghost World, their American Splendor—a breakout film that will bring a marginalized medium a degree of mainstream recognition. Maybe Jake Gyllenhaal will even star in that movie. But in the meantime, courtesy of Disney and the guy who directed Mona Lisa Smile, videogames make another predictably awkward transition to the big screen in Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time—a movie whose primary selling points are Gyllenhaal’s admittedly compelling abs.

Gyllenhaal plays one of the three princes of Persia, an orphan plucked as a boy from the streets by the king and raised as a brother to the king’s two sons. When the king is gruesomely killed by a poisoned cloak (oh, the sentences get sillier), Gyllenhaal is blamed—even though the real bad guy is obviously the bald uncle (Ben Kingsley). Never trust a bald uncle, guys.

Gyllenhaal flees the scene of the king’s death with quite a to-do list: He has approximately 80 minutes to clear his name, win over a grumpy princess, and prevent his uncle from unleashing a killer sandstorm by stabbing a giant underground hourglass with a magical dagger. The magical dagger also has the power to turn back time—goodbye narrative tension, hello awkward CG time-travel sequences!

While it’d be delusional to expect much in the way of plot or character development from a movie in which the “sands of time” are taken so literally, it should be safe to assume that a $200 million budget would at least translate to some decent effects. Not so. Persia is notably chintzy looking—jumbled action sequences, lurching crowd shots, and excitement-sapping slow-mo fight sequences conspire to wilt whatever action-movie boner you may have been nurturing.

And for those whose Persia lust is a little less abstract, let’s return for a second to the question of Gyllenhaal’s abs. For all the media attention they’ve received (he cultivated his torso, he claimed in an interview, by “washing his hair”), Gyllenhaal’s tummy in fact spends most of Prince of Persia demurely tucked under several layers of vest, tunic, and whatever the white shirts they wear on the covers of romance novels are called. There are few men in this world crying out for objectification quite so insistently as Gyllenhaal. Suffice to say that opportunities for glistening, flexing, and slow-motion body pans were missed.

There’s some degree of camp here—tipped into utter absurdity at one point by the inclusion of a running ostrich gag—but Persia is neither bad enough to laugh at nor clever enough to laugh with. But really, what’d you expect? It’s based on a videogame, after all. recommended

12 replies on “Chesty Jake”

  1. …. Okay, was willing to run with you that Persia’s a lackluster, mediocre movie, but then you end it with “But that’s okay because it’s from a lackluster, bad medium!” and, um, what?

  2. I actually quite liked this film. I thought it was fun and silly and I quite liked the human aspect of the story (I’m too used to fighting dust monster zombies in the games!)

    I supposed the biggest issue with games films is that most games are built on a concept. The first Sands of Time game was a revolutionary concept in that if you weren’t too good at games, and there was a pit you kept falling down in, all you had to do was press a button and you’d rewind time. Usually you’d have to restart the level all over again and endure boring loading screens, but with this, it was like holding a TV remote and redo the bits you messed up.

    Also the game was gorgeous. The midnight to dusk hues, the architecture of the arabian buildings and the mix of eastern and rock music really gave the game a sense of romance not usually seen in games. I suppose that was the biggest draw to making this a film, using a charismatic character like the prince and his steadily diminishing wardrobe would always be an appealing factor.

    But it’s very tricky with games. When a game becomes popular and profitable for it’s gaming mechanics and being so immersive, things like rewinding time don’t have the same effect on film.

    With the recent news of Mass Effect becoming a film, I hope that too doesn’t fall into the same trappings. The games are famed for their legendary dialogue and making even the fantastical believable so I hope there is always that hope that games will make it as a legendary film. We might not see it in a Ghost World or American Splendor way anytime soon, but hopefully more in a Star Wars or Dark Knight way sooner.

    Well, that’s what I hope as a gamer.

    Mike.G. stevebob.com

  3. Soooo, is that last line supposed to be insulting films based on video games, or video games altogether? It’s an important question, because one of those answers is really, really stupid!

  4. @2: I’ve played several version of PoP, and I always thought the instant rewind conceit could have made for a compelling movie, if you made it a humorous action flick. Rewinding things to fix them could have brought the sane wit to the story that you see in Groundhog Day.

    That said, you’d need talented writers, director and actors to pull it off.

  5. Seriously, it’s like saying, “Well, the Narnia movies were crap, but that’s because they used to be kid’s books, amirite?” And they were crap, solid, pure crap, but that doesn’t have any bearing on where they came from.

  6. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time was an amazingly clever, charming, inventive game. Everything after it has been a slurry of shit and angst, and I had no doubt the movie would tend towards that. Executives simply cannot comprehend or accept that gamers and moviegoers WILL accept an interesting, well-written, nontraditional hero, or a strong (but NOT bitchy, just capable of existing without a man to lean on) love interest/ support character. I knew it’d be garbage from the get-go. Prince of Persia should’ve died after the Sands of Time. It’s better to leave them wanting more than to taint the greatness of an unexpected hit with derivative, bland sequels and movies.

  7. @3 I’m seriously guessing it’s simply pointing out that video-game adaptations have, as a rule, sucked more balls than the busiest hooker in Vegas.

  8. I am a huge Jake Gyllenhaal fan, and I confess I went to this based almost entirely on my Gyllenhaal infatuation.

    He was okay as an action star. He performs his stunt scenes well enough. And he had a few charming moments. But his accent… holy crap it was bad. I’m not sure whose idea it was that everyone had to talk with a British accent (do Persians speak with a Brit accent?). Gyllenhaal, for all his charms, doesn’t do accents well. It was pretty inconsistent, and he sounded ridiculous half the time.

  9. Problem is, filmmakers don’t know how to make epics no more. Remember Stone’s hideous ‘Alexander’? Now we’ve either got warmed over Lucas-puke or the strained seriousness of Sir Ridley.

    Problem is, the studios have to ‘deal’ with the vid game competition, which is making almost as much money as the porno field.

    Me? I’ll stick with Anthony Mann, Sam Bronston, Joe Mankiewicz, and yes, Cecil B. DeMille.

    (PS: I wonder if this picture is a neocon plan to slap Ahmadinejad in the crotch?)

    (RIP: D. Hopper)

Comments are closed.