Meet Matthew Cooke, a Stranger reader who has vowed to do everything The Stranger suggests for the entire month of February. Look for his reports daily on Slog. —Eds.

The Stranger’s suggestions have been hit-or-miss in these first tentative days of my “Yesterday” tenure, but last night’s seemed bulletproof. Hot dogs! What could possibly go wrong?

But alas, hot dogs and I have a strange relationship. Something in me rebels against such quintessential Americana. If I’m going to be that cheesy, I have to go all the way and eat one in a classic setting—a baseball game, say, or a summer barbecue. And the well-worn phrase “lips and assholes” has a way of gripping the mind (my mind, at least).

three_dog_night_sm.jpg

Duty called, so I was willing to give Po Dog a fair shot. Aware of my bias, I brought my wife, Susan, a hot dog fiend. “In the interest of science,” she suggested getting three varieties. We ordered a plain dog with mustard and relish as a control; the Chicago, which the attractive lass behind the counter said was the most popular; and the bacon-wrapped Deep Fried Danger, just because it sounded fucking awesome.

We managed to eat almost all of it, obviously a good sign. But do I actually agree with The Stranger recommendation? Based on my wife’s enthusiastic approval, yes. Personally, I’d rather have a bratwurst, especially if I’m paying seven goddamn dollars per dog (thank God it’s on Savage’s dime). But between the Macrina buns, the anything-goes ingredients, and the industrial-chic décor, it’s easy to forget about the markup. So go there, grab a beer, and have at it.

Just don’t expect some kind of grand hot dog revelation. Even Susan noticed they were using the same Hebrew Nationals you get at Costco for $1.50. Po Dog has added glitz and glamour—but, as always, a weenie is a weenie.

25 replies on “Yesterday The Stranger Suggested: Po Dog”

  1. Yeah, I agree with you. The only times it ever occurs to me to eat a hot dog are those “classic settings”. It’s not that I have a problem with hot dogs being sold for exorbitant prices in a well-decorated sit down restaurant, it’s just that I will likely never feel inclined to go there. So thank you, Matthew Cooke, for this vicarious experience.

  2. Your wife is a hot dog fiend. ha.

    I totally agree on the quality of the meat itself. Hebrew national is fine (i.e. no lips or assholes) but it’s not worth the markup. Dante’s inferno dogs are vastly superior, even if I do like the dressings and buns at Po Dog.

    The other good thing about Po Dog is the stubby bottles of Session Lager.

  3. this argument that a hot dog should never be elevated because it never has been is a dumb one. should all pizza stay 99 cents a slice and have the option of cheese or pepperoni? should beer always remain the “working man” version of budweiser? should mac anc cheese always have a two-for-a-buck powdered cheese appeal? just because chefs try to improve on a food or elevate a humble ingredient into something more refined doesn’t mean they are declaring class warfare or looking down on you for going to costco.

  4. @10–Dante’s serve Boar’s Head dogs, which are awesome. They have that beautiful crunchy casing. But they sell them for what, $4? Which I still think is too much.

  5. what about the fries? didn’t you try the fries?!? THEY ARE AWESOME! plus, they have all kinds of special sauces for them! wasabi mayo, chipotle ketchup. i liked the dogs but will return for the fries.

    okay, i’ll calm down now.

  6. @11 Who is arguing that the hot dog shouldn’t be elevated? It sounds like he’s just saying that if he’s paying $7, it’s weird that they’re just using Hebrew National dogs and not something more “elevated” type of meat. “Elevating” the hot dog is not a new schtick — most places that have done so (like say, Hot Doug’s in Chicago) are also interested in elevating the meat in addition to the toppings.

  7. Costco bought the Hebrew National factory in Illinois because the INS kept shutting it down for illegal aliens. They’re the same dogs with the Kirkland label. Geez………..and don’t forget that you pay $35-$75 a year for the ability to go into Costco which is hardly in the neighborhood.

    And another thing – pay the fucking $5 – the people working there have to earn a living.

  8. Jesus Christ, so many mentions of this place in Stranger and Slog lately. Lips and assholes = Gross. I’m willing to bet none of you would kill a pig, dig out its asshole and eat it

  9. See, I love hot dog flavor, ESPECIALLY Polish dogs in all their greasy smoky glory (what ever happened to Oscar Mayer Little Smokies, anyway?), and grill char just makes it that much better.

    But there’s always a little chunk of gristle in there somewhere that I bite down on that goes *GRONCH*, and then I can’t stop thinking about what kind of elbow cartilage or penis ligament or heart valve or hoof root it was that I just chewed and swallowed.

  10. Matthew Cooke, here.

    @15: I considered getting the fries…I love fries. But the task seemed centered on the hot dog thing. I mean, I also considered getting the homemade chips, which Yelp says are insanely delicious. I had to draw the line somewhere, and three hot dogs already seemed like plenty of food.

    @6: My sentiments exactly.

Comments are closed.