Take it back. Never too late to right a wrong. You'll probably be greeted with smiles, a laugh as you predict, and likely an espresso for being honest.

You can literally never go there again now.

@1,

I don't disagree in principal, but in practice, I'm sure food safety guidelines would dictate the product be tossed. To prevent it's being wasted, he should just keep and use it.

*principle, I suppose that is

@3: Good point. But don't just keep it. Buy a new container sugar by the same brand or at least go into the shop and explain to relieve the guilty conscious.

So, Now we can
add Sugar Thief
to the List?

Oh, Magoo, you've
done it, Again!

but
Yeah
go Back
Next Sunday

Sharpie in Hand

& LABEL
that MoFo for
ALL you Magoos

make it BIG
make it BOLD

and Enjoy!

or, there's Always
@2's Final
Solution