Looking out the back door of his house in Maple Valley, about 20
miles southeast of Seattle, Peter Heydorn can see a massive stand of
trees growing across the street. But unlike most rural land in
unincorporated King County, the 156 acres behind his house are
completely surrounded by the city.

“It’s a real geographic anomaly,” says King County Council member
Reagan Dunn, whose district includes Maple Valley. Neighbors of the
land call it the Donut Hole, but King County, which has owned the
property since the 1950s, has another way of describing it: for
sale.

In a bidding process overseen by King County Executive Ron Sims, the
county initially offered developer YarrowBay Group a no-bid contract to
build a large mixed-income housing development on the site. After an
outcry from Dunn and residents of the surrounding areas, Sims agreed to
open the process, allowing a 60-day window for bids. That brief window
closed in late April and, just as before, YarrowBay was the only
bidder.

Although Sims’s push to add housing in exurban Maple Valley
certainly seems out of step with his commitment to growth management
(which concentrates development in urban areas), Sims points out that
the YarrowBay purchase allows the county to preserve another threatened
piece of rural land—the 276-acre Icy Creek site along the Green
River, which YarrowBay was seeking to develop.

Nonetheless, the prospect of an influx of new residents has Maple
Valley officials and residents fuming.

Under the latest proposal for the site, Maple Valley city manager
Anthony Hemstad says, the county could allow up to 2,000 new housing
units in the Donut Hole—or as many as 6,000 new residents. For
all practical purposes, those newcomers would live in Maple
Valley—a bedroom community of 21,000 people. But because the
county owns the land, the newcomers wouldn’t be governed by the city.
The county could pocket construction fees and annual property taxes,
while surrounding Maple Valley residents would have to foot the bill
for roads leading to and from the development, plus police officers,
libraries, schools, and parks.

“This is going to bottleneck the whole city with traffic,” says
Heydorn, who started an online petition to demand that the county give
citizens more input on the project.

Although YarrowBay’s proposal is still pending, it appears that the
developer and county have no plans to improve the roads around the
Donut Hole. According to Jennifer Lindwall of King County’s Capital
Improvement Program, certain state roads, including Highway 169, are
exempt from county rules requiring road improvements when new residents
move in. Existing Metro bus service offers no relief, with buses
stopping less than once per hour on weekdays (and with no service at
all on weekends).

Masterminding this land deal without planning for its impacts
represents an apparent about-face for Sims, who has historically
opposed new rural developments in areas that lack the infrastructure to
support them and encouraged cities to annex unincorporated county land.
For example, in February, Sims announced that the county had granted
the city of Auburn $1.25 million for annexing rural county land,
arguing that under the state Growth Management Act, “cities generally
are the unit of government most appropriate to provide services in
urban areas.”

King County’s environmental sustainability director, Rod Brandon,
says the area needs more “workforce housing”—affordable to people
making less than King County’s median income. But that goal could
create a clash between the lower-wage newcomers and the suburbanites
who currently use the land, which, in addition to trees, also contains
a golf course.

Hemstad insists Maple Valley residents aren’t opposed to
growth—after all, Maple Valley is a booming exurb that has
doubled in size since it incorporated a decade ago. But, he says, “We’d
like it to be planned… rather than plunked down with no comment from
the community.”

“Had I known about this development,” Heydorn adds, “I would have
never bought a house in Maple Valley.” recommended

dominic@thestranger.com


More in NEWS

Local (and not-so-local) news from your favorite writers.