David Frum points out that the shooter is rumored to be a pot smoker. So, hey, maybe it’s time to “regulate” marijuana:

After horrific shootings, we hear calls for stricter regulation of guns. The Tucson shooting should remind us why we regulate marijuana. Jared Lee Loughner, the man held as the Tucson shooter, has been described by those who know as a “pot smoking loner.” …After the Tucson shooting, there may be renewed pressure to control the weapons that committed the crime. But what about the drugs that may have aggravated the killer’s mental disease? The trend these days seems toward a more casual attitude and easier access to those drugs. Among the things we should be discussing in the aftermath of this horror is the accumulating evidence of those drugs’ potential contribution to making some dangerous people even more dangerous than they might otherwise have been.

Marijuana is illegal—illegal to grow, sell, distribute—and federal, state, and local governments spend billions of dollars annually trying to stamp out pot. And yet pot remains cheap and readily available. They can’t keep it out of prisons. Yes, some people shouldn’t smoke pot, just as some people shouldn’t, oh, own guns.

But if we want to more effectively regulate pot—if we want to do a better job of keeping pot out of the hands of those who shouldn’t use it (because they’re too young or too messed up)—we need a legal and regulated marijuana market, not the illegal and regulated market we have now.

Look, David, pot is as accessible as it is because it’s illegal. So long as it’s illegal to sell pot to anyone, an unlicensed pot dealer has no incentive to make distinctions between selling to a child or a nut or a responsible adult. Indeed, he has an incentive to sell to anyone, to move his supply. But if pot dealers were licensed to sell their product—if pot dealers had licenses they could lose—they would be very careful not to sell pot to children or nuts, just as bar owners with liquor licenses to lose are careful not to serve minors or over-serve drunks. It’s not a perfect system—some minors manage to get their hands on booze—but it would do a better job of keeping pot out of the hands of kids, fuckups, and nuts than the system we’ve got now.


More in NEWS

Local (and not-so-local) news from your favorite writers.

27 replies on “Reefer Madness”

  1. Gun dealers have licenses they could lose and they sell guns to nuts all the time. And if no gun dealer will sell them a gun then they go buy one at a gun show. And if that doesn’t work, there is a thriving black market for guns, even though guns are legal but highly regulated. Kind of the same as how it would be if pot were legal.

    The thing that guns and pot really have in common is high demand.

  2. Wait, he was a loner? Perhaps we should regulate that too. Nobody is allowed to be alone for more than 20 minutes, otherwise, they just might go on a killing spree.

    We should find out every potential thing that could possibly cause someone to go crazy, and regulate it. If we do that, I’m positive everyone will live happily ever after. Positive.

    Also, @1, another thing guns and drugs have in common is that they’re both easy to misuse.

  3. I agree with the general sentiment, but the key difference between alcohol and pot is that while it is pretty hard to brew a single 6 pack with ordinary kitchen supplies and no know-how, it is really easy to grow enough pot for a couple of joints. Anyone who can keep a houseplant alive can do it. The big hydroponic rigs with all the fancy lights are only needed by the pros. So any teenager with the least desire for the stuff will always be able to get it, if they really want it. The answer, as always, is the much harder one of needing parents who are engaged with their kids and aware of all the things in their kids’ lives (which is hard even in well-adjusted families). At least ending the prohibition on marijuana will end the thrill of doing something illegal.

  4. What Frum is completely ignoring is that while there’s little to no evidence that smoking pot directly leads to any increase in gun violence, guns are involved in roughly 100% of gun-violence cases. But he thinks we should skip over the guns and look to the weed. Or maybe his diet?

  5. Have you ever heard of anyone ever taking MDMA and then getting into a fist fight, let alone going on a killing spree. Of course not!

    So the solution is that everyone take MDMA once a week.

    If the killer had only taken MDMA, he wouldn’t have done what he did. Instead he would have hugged the Congresswoman and invited her to a “cuddle puddle” instead.

    Frum’s a dumbass and is full of shit for continuing to propagate the lies of the failed drug war.

    He probably believes that no one should ever have the right to smoke a joint but that everyone should have the right to own an M-60. You know, for hunting and self protection.

  6. Fuck David Frum with a big gummy Thai stick. He’s a former speechwriter for Ronald Reagan, and Nancy got her just-say-no claws into him way back when. I’ve been hearing Frum for more than 25 years. When the Dems are super-strong, he sounds (regular commenter on NPR) all conciliatory and common-sense and kum-bay-yah. When the Cons are in the ascendancy, he’s in batshitcrazy land, hoping someone with power will notice and bring him back on board.

  7. When did Frum go from talking about pot to talking about “those drugs”?
    The association of pot with other street drugs (meth in particular) is what makes pot a good “gateway drug”. This will change when it is legalized, too, also the people who sell the pot won’t readily supply meth as an alternative/supplemental buzz.

  8. part of the suppression by the pot lobby is they do not recognize the cravings, the habituation and the manic paranoia that comes with a heavy user not getting his fix.

  9. Re: 7, the batshit NPR commentator I was thinking of was former Minnesota congressman Vin Weber, who was never a Reagan speechwriter, and neither was David Frum, whose efforts to make George W. Bush sound more intelligent were doubtless appreciated. Drunk slogging on a Sunday night. I was apparently mixing up four or five different people. @9 & 10 clued me in, and thanks.

    But fuck David Frum anyway.

  10. i don’t buy the whole cannabis exacerbating mental illness argument. i imagine that may be the case in some instances, but people with certain mental illnesses use cannabis–among other drugs–to control the excesses of the diseases from which they suffer. i feel there may be a correlation/causation conflation issue here.

  11. Regulating pot would do nothing to keep it out of the hands of people with mental illness. What’s the shop owner going to do, a mini psych evaluation? Are we going to force people to carry around proof of their sanity if they wish to buy pot or booze? This article is ridiculous, as is the bs Frum is spouting.

    Yes, weed can push a psychotic into mania/psychosis. Big fucking deal. So can staring at the sun or listening to beethoven.

  12. He smoked pot so pot is bad. He likes guns so guns are bad. He is an atheist so atheists are bad. He likes the gold standard so libertarians are bad.

    This game is easy to play and pointless.

  13. @ 14 – BS. I and many, many people I know are living proof that you don’t know what you’re talking about (not to mention all the studies which have already demonstrated that this isn’t a problem).

    But really, people, the problem with pot is that it removes the will to do anything too strenuous (more than, let’s say, grabbing a bag of chips). I seriously doubt it led this guy to pick up a gun and go shoot people.

  14. From the Time article Frum quotes: “But here’s the conundrum: while marijuana went from being a secret shared by a small community of hepcats and beatniks in the 1940s and ’50s to a rite of passage for some 70% of youth by the turn of the century, rates of schizophrenia in the U.S. have remained flat, or possibly declined. For as long as it has been tracked, schizophrenia has been found to affect about 1% of the population.

    One explanation may be that the two factors are coincidental, not causal: perhaps people who have a genetic susceptibility to schizophrenia also happen to especially enjoy marijuana. Still, some studies suggest that smoking pot can actually trigger the disease earlier in individuals who are predisposed, and yet researchers still aren’t seeing increases in the overall schizophrenia rate or decreases in the average age of onset.”

    Also: “The access issue may also help explain why some studies find better — not worse — cognitive functioning in people with schizophrenia who smoke marijuana. That’s what Pamela DeRosse, a research scientist at Long Island’s Feinstein Institute for Medical Research, and her colleagues found in a study of 455 people with schizophrenia published in Schizophrenia Research in July. The research showed that patients who smoked marijuana had faster brain processing speed, greater verbal ability and better memory than patients who didn’t smoke — not attributes usually associated with being high.”

    What conclusion is to be drawn when one has multiple controlled studies with conflicting/contradictory results, while real-world data indicate no connection between the variable and observed correlates? We have either sampling bias (definitely present in the study Frum cites, as the correlation vanished when confounding factors like race, socioeconomic status, and gender were accounted) or a drug with divergent effects depending on the individual (also a distinct possibility: if marijuana helps control symptoms in some people and worsens symptoms in others, lowers age-of-onset in some while increasing it in others, the population statistics could be a wash even if the drug has a strong effect). We should also consider the sampling bias built into any study like this: we only know people suffer from schizophrenia because they exhibit symptoms. In the event that marijuana use is suppressing symptoms in an individual for a VERY long time, like one’s entire life, that individual will be invisible to the study, as sie will never be diagnosed. The only way to really determine causation here is the sort of study that’s illegal due to ethical problems and logistically impractical: it would require controlling large populations of individuals from birth (from a variety of ethnic and economic backgrounds), such that one could have two groups (or more, if we want to try to determine causation with relation to when one smokes marijuana), one that smoked (was made to smoke) marijuana, and one that was prevented from smoking marijuana. The random sampling and forced smoking/not-smoking is necessary to prevent correlations from appearing if, for example, individuals with schizophrenia were more inclined to smoke marijuana. These groups could be tracked over their lifetimes to see if any differential patterns emerge.

    Obviously we can’t do this, and shouldn’t even if we could, but it’s really the only way to account for self-selection or other sampling biases. We’re basically asking, “How does marijuana use affect schizophrenics who are noticeably to strongly symptomatic as marijuana smokers?”

    Finally, let’s assume that the worst-case prediction is correct, and marijuana use triggers schizophrenia in at-risk individuals who otherwise wouldn’t develop symptoms. So what? The fact that something is potentially harmful to 7 or 8 out of every 1000 individuals is not a good reason to ban that thing. High-sugar beverages can trigger symptoms in diabetics who don’t take their medication, and even some who do: let’s ban those! (I realize that some people are trying to do so: they’re fucking nuts too.)

    @3: “…while it is pretty hard to brew a single 6 pack with ordinary kitchen supplies and no know-how.” Actually, it’s really easy to do both. In fact, a lot of things will ferment and create alcohol if you simply leave them to their own devices, hence the restirctions on kombucha, which was turning into a beer-level alcoholic beverage sitting on store shelves (and marijuana plants will replicate too; go life!). Google “brew beer” and “grow marijuana”, simple.

    @4: I think he was being ironic, given Frum’s comment “should remind us why we regulate marijuana”.

    @8: Relative to what? A liter of Knob Creek runs about the same price around here as 1/8 oz. and provides fewer nights of revelry.

    @14: Probably because that doesn’t happen all that much. Even if it did, though, the problem there seems to be with *not* smoking marijuana, not with smoking it. Cheap readily-available weed would solve any problems associated with withdrawal, because potheads would never need to stop. 😛

    @21: And lived in Arizona, so we should probably just lock the whole state up just to be safe.

  15. i’ve already been confronted with this weed-made-him-crazy canard by a (presumably former) pot-smoking conservative childhood acquaintance on FB.

  16. John Horstman makes some excellent points.

    I was always under the impression that the severely mentally ill (like schizophrenics) chose to self-medicate with cigarettes and weed because these substances made them less symptomatic. I don’t have any useful data to back that assertion up, though.

  17. You’re stoned if you think that legalizing pot will get you that amount of control. You can buy weed ‘legally’ in Holland provided you’re old enough, but the kids are still getting it from other illegal venues.

    I’m also not willing to dismiss stories about the dangers of weed entirely. I’ve been hearing them from friends, who are rabidly pro-drugs and experienced users also.

Comments are closed.