OneSeattle, the big-business-backed group organized around Seattle’s minimum wage legislation, has been relatively quiet recently. But a source who attended their last meeting says the group is hard at work drafting an initiative that would water down the minimum-wage law that Seattle’s city hall is considering, and that they’re potentially considering a lawsuit to change the definition of small business.
The legislation moving through city hall may well be cause for celebration by many—the mayor’s office has curated a stash of positive national coverage of his proposal—but despite assurances that there is broad labor and business support for the deal, apparently not everyone is celebrating.
“I think there was a lot of anxiety,” says OneSeattle spokesman Alex Fryer of what he calls the “mood of the room” at last week’s coalition meeting. “It’s a big meeting with people who are anxious, who are really worried about their future.”
OneSeattle’s coalition represents large business groups like the Seattle Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce and the local offshoot of the National Restaurant Association, plus smaller business groups like neighborhood chambers, plus individual local business owners (including some members of the mayor’s minimum wage advisory committee who hashed out his compromise deal).
A leak from a previous OneSeattle meeting outlined their strategy of putting small businesses and small business employees front and center, even though their powerful political backing is from the big guys—the chamber of commerce represents big businesses like Boeing, Microsoft, and Vulcan, while the Seattle Restaurant Alliance is affiliated with the state and national restaurant associations that represent McDonald’s, Burger King, Starbucks, Subway, Olive Garden, etc.
At this most recent meeting, according to a source who asked not to be named, the group discussed initiative language that was already being drafted. (Presented with this source’s recounting of the meeting’s discussions, including the initiative talk, Fryer did not dispute the source’s version of events; he merely sought to add context.) The initiative language, according to this source, will be brought back to OneSeattle members for final approval in the near future, but during the meeting the group was asked to identify the top issues the ballot measure should address.
Most popular?
Permanent total compensation.
In the proposal from the mayor’s committee, a limited amount of tips and benefits can be counted toward a small-business employer’s minimum compensation obligation, but only during a transitional period that will last till 2025. At the end of that time, the inclusion of tips and benefits will completely phase out, so that the ordinance doesn’t redefine Washington State’s definition of a minimum wage (state law doesn’t count tips or benefits, just wages). This was a big point of contention during the mayoral committee’s negotiations, and the compromise they reached is central to the deal’s success.
This draft initiative, a business-side counter to 15 Now’s ongoing insistence that they may run their own ballot measure, would dissolve that deal and set a precedent of redefining the wage floor in this state. The group also discussed, according to this source, the addition of a training wage—reportedly one person at the meeting suggested a training wage for “immigrants, non-English speakers, and youth.”
OneSeattle spokesman Fryer says there’s “nothing new” about the idea of OneSeattle running their own initiative. “We’ve said for weeks that that’s a possibility, and it remains a possibility.” As to what it would contain, and what coalition members identified as top priorities, he says he “couldn’t say” whether permanent total compensation led the pack. “There were people at the meeting who it was important for, and people who it wasn’t as important for,” Fryer says. As for training wages, he shies away from specifics and refers back to the four main principles the coalition has agreed should be in a minimum wage law, which he characterizes as: training wages, total compensation, “no exceptions,” and a phase-in.
But that wasn’t all that was discussed at the meeting, according to this source, who said that someone from the hotel industry announced they were in talks with their national brand to look at potential litigation around the city’s definition of what constitutes a small business. Fryer, for his part, says “I did not hear anyone talk about litigation in that meeting, [but] I could’ve missed it.”
Another coalition member reportedly discussed the idea of Seattle businesses shutting down for a day in protest of the higher minimum wage. Says Fryer, “There was a lot of things discussed, a lot of people expressed an opinion… How serious that comment was made and how widely it was shared, I can’t tell you.”
There are multiple organizations working to affect the outcome of the mayor’s proposal, and they have every right to do so. So in evaluating the source’s reports from the OneSeattle meeting, it’s important to look at the broad scope of this debate, which Council Member Kshama Sawant and 15 Now activists have repeatedly pointed out is far from over. That repeated reminding is, in itself, a reminder that advocates on the left are also threatening an initiative if things don’t go their way. What this account of the OneSeattle meeting highlights is that similar threats continue to be made on the business side of things—it’s just that some of the more bold threats are being made behind closed doors.
Meanwhile, the mayor talks about the legislation as a done deal and a big mayoral accomplishment. The reality: It still has to go through city council’s legislative process, and as it gets ready for its journey through the legislative branch, everyone’s looking for maximum lobbying leverage (including folks who represented business organizations on the mayor’s committee, who for a while now have been hedging after pledging their support to the proposal, saying that in their mayoral committee votes they were speaking only for themselves, not for the members of the organizations they represent). Based on this account of OneSeattle’s recent meeting, the search for leverage on the part of some of its members is getting intense.
