Thousands of people listened to the oral arguments live-streamed today from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
Thousands of people listened to the oral arguments live-streamed today from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. AGOWA

Sponsored
Produce at Eight Row in Greenlake isn’t just about tasty food: it’s about supporting a community.
It honors flavors and fixings from Washington’s farms and orchards, as well as on families’ tables.

Audio is up from today's Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals hearing on Washington State's case against President Donald Trump over his Muslim ban executive order.

If you missed the hearing, which was live-streamed for an audience of thousands, the Ninth Circuit's three-judge panel grilled Washington State's solicitor general Noah Purcell on the standing of the case and the merits of his claims. But they also grilled the Department of Justice's August Flentje on the merits of the White House's appeal.

Ninth Circuit judges William Canby and Michelle Friedland questioned the DOJ's Flentje about the president's rationale for the ban in the first place. They also asked Flentje about the limits of authority granted to the president to issue such executive orders.



But Judge Richard Clifton seemed particularly skeptical of the Washington Attorney General's claim that the president's executive order amounted to religious discrimination. He pressed Purcell on whether the Washington Attorney General's claim was legitimate if the ban only affected a fraction of the Muslim world.

Support The Stranger


A lot of different legal predictions about the outcome of the hearing are circulating on Twitter, but either way, it looks likely that the Ninth Circuit could issue a decision as early as tonight. If the court rules in favor of the Washington AG, debating the constitutionality of POTUS's Muslim ban would go back to Federal District Court Judge James Robart in Seattle.


Sponsored