
Rock music, generally speaking, is not in good shape. It hasn’t been in sound condition—at least artistically—for about a quarter century; some observers might go back even further in time to pinpoint when rock last was in rude health. As a force in the charts, rock has been mostly waning since the Bill Clinton era. It doesn’t speak well for a genre when your biggest-selling acts are Imagine Dragons, Twenty One Pilots, and Portugal. The Man, with Metallica and the Beatles still outselling much younger acts by a large margin.
As someone who’s been listening to rock daily for more than 50 years and who’s been going to rock shows since 1979, I think I can speak with a smidgen of authority about what I perceive to be rock’s moribund state. To be sure, good-to-great rock music is still being created—albeit in diminishing quantities since its peak years of creativity (1965-1981). However, in recent decades, it has become increasingly harder to find artists doing innovative—let alone revolutionary—things within the genre. I would like to propose one way to reanimate rock, to shake it out of its stagnant period… perhaps!
But before we get to that, let’s set the scene, as I hear it. For every artist doing something exceptional within rock parameters—e.g., Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band, Stooges, Velvet Underground, Jimi Hendrix Experience, pre-Autobahn Kraftwerk, Et Cetera, Hampton Grease Band, Annette Peacock, CAN, Julie Tippetts, Faust, This Heat (whose catalog Light in the Attic is mercifully reissuing), Nico, Neu!, Hovercraft, Boredoms, My Bloody Valentine, Lightning Bolt, Slits, Raincoats, Contortions, Labradford, Wire, Residents, Chrome, 75 Dollar Bill, and Black Dice—there are 10,000 groups reiterating past glories in less auspicious manners, coloring within the lines in primary hues, paying conservative homage to tried-and-true forms and moves.
Make no mistake, that sort of thing can be very satisfying; aural comfort food is a necessary part of any healthy musical diet. But the sheer cumulative bulk of this kind of rock has saturated the airscape with gray clouds of rehashed (ad infinitum) ideas, inspiring a chronic been-there/heard-that exhaustion. One tires of 21st-century rock’s predictability, its limited range of sonic textures, its rhythmic and structural staidness. As Adam & the Ants sang way back in 1980 on “Antmusic,” “That music’s lost its taste/So try another flavor.”
How to manifest this new flavor? How to revive rock’s questing spirit? How to make it more aesthetically interesting, if not more commercially viable? (If you’re looking to me for advice on the latter issue, you’ll inevitably be disappointed.)
My answer is so simple, I’m surprised it’s not been attempted by more than a handful of artists: abandon the usual guitar/bass/drums arsenal (I’m not yet ready to dissuade you from using keyboards/synths) and employ instruments not traditionally used in a rock format. Why not bring instruments such as triangle, tuba, clavinet, flute, kazoo, marimba, mbira, sitar, tamboura, and tabla—or dozens of others from every blessed corner of the planet—to the front? As much as I love guitar/bass/drums, I (and I’d wager many other listeners) would welcome frequent deviations from this setup.
Granted, some of these tools are harder to acquire and to master than guitar/bass/drums, but if you want to distinguish your band from the conforming masses, it may behoove you to go to this extra effort. If you’re really ambitious, you may want to invent your own instruments, or modify existing ones. Or maybe give just intonation a whirl.
Now, possessing an array of unusual instruments obviously won’t guarantee that you’ll create fascinating, ground-breaking music. But it will give you the advantage of an unexpected source of timbres that could potentially unwrinkle rock’s visage and reinvigorate its blood flow. As it stands now, though, rock needs to do something/anything (to quote an album title by that restless rock original, Todd Rundgren) to rouse it out of its doldrums.
You have a better idea? Let’s hear it.
