Street Carnage has some photos from next month’s V Magazine, in which a model-sized model and a “plus size model” (a size 12) face off in the same outfits*. Both women are five foot nine and have long brown hair. I’ll let you decide for yourself how the models do, but the plus size model definitely wins this photo, no contest:

Screen_shot_2009-12-23_at_3.23.47_PM.png

* Although, as one of the comments on the post points out, both models have been Photoshopped.

71 replies on “Model Fight”

  1. If Woody Allen and Sandra Bernhard had a child, it couldn’t be uglier than those clothes.

    40/mitten: “Unless you make a living on your looks, you are as beautiful as you are inside, period.”

    You can FEEL beautiful because of what you’re like inside, and others may think you have a great heart, but that doesn’t mean they’re going to find you physically beautiful and want to kiss you or fuck you.

    A person’s appearance matters to people. And, contrary to how many women like to portray it, men don’t have a patent on caring about looks. The way a man looks is very important to women.

  2. Asian 1981, why do you keep repeating yourself? You’ve made the same post at least 4 times!

    And as for the statement “Do yourselves a favor guys, marry an Asian girl. No cottage cheese ass,” I beg to differ. I live in Japan; I am the only white woman in a town of about 10,000 people and let me tell you, when I go to the public baths I see PLENTY of cottage cheese ass. Stop stereotyping Asian women as these magical stick figures that never age. They’re just as human as anyone else, and ridiculous statements like “Marry an Asian woman and you’ll be happy the rest of your life, “
    make you look like a racist fool. Asian women all get old, some of them get fat, and even the ones who don’t get fat sometimes do shit like decide they never want to have sex ever again. Asian does not equal skinny and certainly does not equal marital bliss.

  3. @ 53 – Asian 1981’s perspective is based on the fact that he only dates Asian hotties under the age of 25… Probably because, after a couple of dates with him, they figure out he’s a racist bastard and drop his ass like a hot potato covered with cottage cheese… heh heh….

  4. We all need intensive therapy.

    If you are fat (flab, jiggling, gut) then you’re fat.
    If you’re curvaceous (tight thunder thighs, defined waist and broad shoulders) then you’ve curvaceous.
    If you’re slender (slender) then you’re slender.
    If you’re emaciated (fatigued face, sallow complexion) then you’re emaciated.
    If you’re athletic (toned) then you’re athletic.
    If you’re petite (tiny, perhaps very thin but no jutting clavicle) then you’re petite.

    Just own it and be it. If you’re unhappy with it then do what you can to fix it. If you’re fat don’t call yourself curvy because you’re not, fatty, you’re fat, you’re rotund. If you want to be curvy then work out until you’re curvy. If you’re curvy and you want to be slender then workout and watch your food intake until you’re slender. If you’re athletic and want to be fat then drink all the milkshakes and eat all the pizza you want until you reach your goal.

    Whatever you are and whatever you want to be, be it. Quit hiding behind the language of ‘average’ (because anyone who is smart and takes a look around in this country KNOWS that our ‘average’ is due to unhealthy consumption, c’mon) and ‘curvy’ if you’re fat. Do you know why you get so defensive? because you’re insecure, because you don’t feel good about yourself. If you want to be fat then be fat but realize that you’re an acquired taste.

    I say this as a girl who has struggled with weight her entire life and who has dealt with both ends of the spectrum. I’ve felt insecure on both ends of the spectrum; for feeling like a fat freak to feeling like walking TandA when I was skinny. The only thing you can do is be happy with yourself. At the end of the day there will always be some dude/lady who will let you sit on his/her dick/face.

  5. i love all the angry fat women in this thread!!
    everyone knows that seattle is full of ugly ass women and the hot ones are always originally from somewhere else. if you are offended by skinny model chicks, go to the fucking gym and get in shape, being fat means you have no respect for your body and so thus why should i treat you with any kind of respect?

    ps–my ideal size is a 4-6 like my gf =)

  6. “I live in Japan; I am the only white woman in a town of about 10,000 people”

    In a Japanese village? I think I met you Ridia: you’re one of those gaijin birds who teach engrish for a year and NEVER gets laid while the gaijin lads get shagged silly. You usually leave after a year bitter and angry.

    And sorry, J-birds have much better bodies than 95% of white girls. I’ve been in J-land too and had my fair share there; great bodies, well into their 40s. Most white girls lose it by 30. Walk around Seattle and take a look; seriously fugly women here.

  7. I’m merely offering advice. If my brother had listened to me he wouldnt be staring at his wife’s, big as a Mac Truck, ass now she’s turned 35 and had two kids.

    So lads, take a look at your birds mum. If she looks like a troll, run like the wind.

  8. Asain1981, no white woman in their right mind would even want you. Take your AZN twink ass to the bathhouse and shove your thumbtack sized dick in between some 60 year old foot queen’s toes, charlie.

  9. Nice one number1! I guess the truth hurts. I’ve seen this anger in many Seattle guys as their white ladies hit their 30s but have the sagging, wrinkled, leathery skin of an elephant. Tits to their knees by 40, and enough feminist rage at 50 to carry them thru’ 3 divorces, and two Subarus with ‘Hillary for Prez’ bumperstickers.

  10. Please honey, you only wish you could get with a broad who didn’t look like a 10 year old boy.
    Merry Christmas to you AZN1981. Have fun not getting laid.

  11. None of the models are smizing (sp?) so both me and Tyra do not approve. Also, as stated, the clothes are not that great, the models are photoshopped, etc.

    Generally, the poses are pretty generic, I see better posing after a couple episodes of top model. So…. yay feminism?

  12. “a 10 year old boy”

    wow, I’d that what any woman under 150lbs looks like to you? You poor deprived thing. You must also be confused by women who aren’t hairy like apes and don’t consider oral sex a sacrifice?

  13. “Have fun not getting laid.”

    thanks for the laugh, my babe is Asian so has learned to separate sex from politics so is always more than happy put out, even on bad days.

    Sorry truth is, most white womyn in Seattle look and dress like shit. Seriously, even my dog wouldn’t hump the legs of 99% of the so-called womyn in this town; and my dog normally loves ugly bitches.

  14. All I know is, my fat ass is getting laid tonight. And, should I so desire, tomorrow night and the night after that.

    As soon as that stops being true, I’ll work on giving a fuck.

  15. “my fat ass is getting laid tonight. And, should I so desire, tomorrow night and the night after that. “

    Just let the poor fella’ come up for air occasionally……and do you provide them with snorkels so they don’t get smothered to death?

  16. It’s worth pointing out that the photo selection in the V shoot is very skewed towards Crystal standing out. Jacquelyn Jablonski can work it just as hard as Crystal is, it’s just the editors picked shots where she is less expressive.
    As for everyone crying photoshop, you do *not* want to see what unretouched hi-res shots look like. While photoshop is often used to liquefy girls to be thinner, or change the shape of lips and noses, its main purpose is actually just to cover up the horror that hi-tech cameras and printers reveal. Skin imperfections and flyaway hairs are more obvious and distracting in stills than they would be if you were staring at the models right in the face in real life, and I say this as someone who is on a photoshoot at least once a fortnight. Photoshop is 100% needed so that magazines aren’t full of errant hairfluff, distracting up-nose boogers and drunk party bruises.
    When they say size 12, I’m pretty sure they mean UK and Australian size 12, which is about a US six. A sample size model is generally around a UK 6-8 so a + sizer is 2-3 sizes bigger than that, makes sense.
    Also, I may get shot down for this but I have to agree with @37. Crystal’s exact proportions may not be achievable for every woman, but her size certainly should be.
    The styling in this shoot is totally hot (although bobby socks on a size 12 under 5’10 isn’t the best idea), to those crying ugly, I say, you’re boring.

  17. @71

    I don’t provide snorkels, but should somebody show up with one, I’m cool wit dat. GGG and all.

    A muff-diving snorkel isn’t a terrible idea, actually. Like, a nose-snorkel. I’ve gone down on (skinny) girls where the angle that they seem to prefer makes it tough to breathe. Definitely an idea worth developing. If you decide to go with it, drop me a line. I’ll let you eat me out with your prototypes. Give you some constructive feedback.

Comments are closed.