Street Carnage has some photos from next month’s V Magazine, in which a model-sized model and a “plus size model” (a size 12) face off in the same outfits*. Both women are five foot nine and have long brown hair. I’ll let you decide for yourself how the models do, but the plus size model definitely wins this photo, no contest:

* Although, as one of the comments on the post points out, both models have been Photoshopped.

Plastic woman on the right is much more desirable.
wrong, paul… more is not better in this case… mouth open too wide, nostril flared too wide and the body’s not broken down enough…
The end of the article says that “midwestern fatsos” skew the average when we all know it is the south-east that is the fattest. Also the fittest city in America is in Texas so I don’t think you can draw that many conclusions through geography.
All magazine layouts are photoshopped. I’d venture to say that about 99% off all images we see each day are photoshopped. So, it seems pretty pointless to say, “OMG photoshop.” See recently: demi moore’s missing hip chunk. At least this is a tastefully retouched layout. I doubt they slimmed anybody down for this one.
If that’s a plus-sized model, than I don’t want to know how I would categorize…
Is this actually two different models, or the same model grossly reduced in the first picture? The faces are indistinguishable.
the first picture is the only one in which the skinny model looks better.
That hideous outfit is making it impossible for me to evaluate the models themselves.
7
and then the dress!
the size 12 looks better in all of ’em.
The role of “Wingman” could be changing radically!
Oh yay, it’s the “Rating women’s bodies is not gross and completely fucked up as long as we choose the fatter one” game.
This is a fight between straight women and gay men. Straight men already know models are too skinny, so leave us out of it. And don’t come asking us why gays want to destroy womens’ lives because the truth is we don’t know. We never knew. Why should we?
Paul, are you the only one working this afternoon? Have a very merry Christmas and give your Mac a break, too
I like both shapes.
Strange that models only come in sizes -2 and ’12’.
Crystal Renn (the model on the right) is a size 12, still under the average American woman’s dress size, and hot as hell. Model on the left (Jaqueline something or other) is just there, while Renn owns the photo. She also has a book out about her career as a straight-size versus plus-size model, and it’s been noted that she’s had much more success as a plus-size model in generally straight-size arenas (Euro Vogue, runways) than she ever did as another generic emaciated girl.
Her new spread in Canadian Elle:
http://www.fashionising.com/pictures/s–…
I think “Caroline” blows everyone else in the blog away. Stunning. Gorgeous. Beautiful. I’m completely smitten now…
If American women were close to the size of the big chick, it’d be a miracle. You guys need to discover Asian babes, very few blow their gaskets after babies like white chicks do.
Of course the problem in Seattle is the women are just fucking ugly.
Plus sized model = normal slim person.
@14: you’re backed up by the photo at the bottom of the page. straight men’s ideal is a size 12, straight women’s is an 8.
Ok guys what u need to imagine is the honeys plus 20 yrs and 2 kids. Chick on left looks like chick on right. Chick on right has her ass spillibg into your seat on the plane.
Do yourselves a favor guys, marry an Asian girl. No cottage cheese ass.
Hey! Wha’s wrong with cottage cheese ass??
they are both hot and everything, it’s just that they don’t have that extra little something special.. like that hot gingerbread man earlier with the frosting/wax/ahem across their back so i’ll reserve judgement, for now.
I just spent all day looking at thirdanddelaware.com and have now realized that everything popular during Rosanne’s run is now in vogue again.
This begs the larger question – “Who cares?!!” Women of Seattle, are you so insecure that you give two shits whether the men of Slog prefer you skinny or chubby? I’ve seen a lot of these men in person and the last thing they need to be doing is sitting in front of the computer judging YOUR looks.
The fact that size 12 constitutes “Plus-sized” when the average woman’s dress size is closer to 14 is ridiculous.
FUCK the fashion industry for creating unrealistic expectations. It’s not about the size, it’s about how you own and work the size that you are.
I agree w @9, this outfit is too fucking ugly to judge anything. It would look gross on anyone, fat or thin!
These things make me depressed. It’s all flippin’ relative, to some I could loose a few and to others I need to gain a few. When the only thing that should matter is if I know how to use what I have. Bottom line, love what you got and be good to others.
I’ve gone blind by all the shininess of the models legs.
@9 @29 Bingo! That outfit is the ultimate boner killer.
The one on the left has the hem of her skirt near the crotch, and on her it looks extra attention-whorish.
she’s cute but people please
STOP MAKING OBESITY OK
that girl is not, but being fat is not ok.
questions of weight are irrelevant. it’s all about the V-card.
The “plus-size” model is way more fierce. The clothes, however, are god-awful.
I’m sort of pleasantly surprised by the fact that in the pictures at the bottom, the woman whose body looks most like mine is the “men’s ideal.”
Yeah, baby … when it comes to females,
Cosmo ain’t got nothin’
to do with my selection. 36-24-36?
Ha ha, only if she’s 5’3″.
@28: Just because the “average” American woman is a cow, doesn’t mean that the fashion industry has unrealistic expectations. It means that the average American woman is a cow.
Isn’t it amazing how American women have trouble maintaining “unrealistic” body weights that women in most other countries maintain easily?
Just as long as that plus size model’s pussy don’t stink, i’d give it to her.
I think we’re kind of missing the point here. It’s not about who’s hotter, as that would be body shaming, but that other sizes work in fashionable clothes and the proof of this is in the pudding.
I read a lot of fashion blogs and become a little numb to the same coat hanger body over and over because I’m looking at the construction of the clothes only, like they are art, but a lot is lost using their bodies in that way which is particularly obvious on sites that sell fashionable clothes or high end erotica also using fashion models. It’s not looking at clothes as art at that point, it’s projecting yourself and your concept of beauty on that model’s body, and when you look at their body ribs and protruding collar bones over and over and over, it almost becomes hideous. One body shape doesn’t fit every circumstance.
Recently a friend of mine who is crazy curvy bought a wedding dress and she is a GODDESS in it. This was made for her body, but the model was a skinny tall girl and it hung off her. Why? Because that is the standard. Put clothes on a variety of bodies!
Just to continue to put these images in their proper bullshit perspective, I’m about the same shape as the “bigger” gal (5’8/140#) and I fluctuate between a size 4 and 6 (in couture, designer AND off-the-rack labels), so what does that tell you? Saying this woman is a 12, at least a U.S. 12, is a LIE.
Numbers, weight, photographs, PhotoShop: It’s all bullshit. Unless you make a living on your looks, you are as beautiful as you are inside, period. Sticks and stones might be cast, but they ultimately have no effect on the individual beauty of a person.
Since the skeleton on most people is pretty much the same, the closer you are to bone-skinny the easier it is for a designer to fashion something for the catwalk and have it fit most models. They want the design out there first, then they can worry about making it fit on other people.
Plus-sized models, sad to say it, are often thrown up there to get attention for the show, but most designers like Lagerfeld and sometimes McQueen are averse to having to make and remake something beyond a size 0 or 1 when there’s legions of girls sized just-right already ready to put them on and strut.
And besides, if all your models are the same stick-thin look, you don’t really have to worry about someone stealing the show unless you want the attention.
That isn’t to say that there’s not a burgeoning field of plus-sized models and fashion lines (especially for men, now, with larger male lines taking the stage at the big fashion week, and even one bear-specific one), but since those lines and shows take up 4 or 5 pages of the 200 page fashion season magazines, it’s just not going to work as a major part of the fashion industry.
Your role model shouldn’t be a glorified walking coat hanger who is uninterested in inspiring the larger public.
This is why I hate fashion, it’s so technical.
” you are as beautiful as you are inside, period”
I often hear ugly white chicks say that. It’s why I date Asian babes. Nice skin, no cellulite, no neurosis, smart and a lot more ambitious than your typical Seattle thespian look-a-like dressed like a fisherman but with worse tattoos.
@ 21 FTW.
Those clothes are hideous
I highly doubt there are a lot of guys out there who would define the size 12 or the size 14 models you see after the jump as unattractive, or overweight. They look just fine. The problem is that most women who are a size 12 or 14 don’t look like that, nor do most size 8’s for that matter.
Pretty is pretty, ugly is ugly. There is actually a good deal of science behind what is generally considered attractive. Things like symmetry, smoothness, hip to shoulder ratios, etc. These things are really consistent from culture to culture, and there is a wide latitude or range, meaning that the skinny model and the ‘plus size’ model are both attractive. Give either of them bad skin, or a malformed nose, and they would be much less-so, not only to an American audience, but to people just about anywhere in the world.
Also interesting, female beauty standards are almost universally set by women, and male ‘tastes’ follow that lead.
And yes, both men and women in most western countries (to exclude any argument about food availability in non-western countries) are considerably thinner than in the US. I have actually gained about 40 pounds since moving back to the US 10 years ago. Some of that is age, and I’d like to believe a little of it is muscle, but a lot of it has to do with the lifestyle.
“Also interesting, female beauty standards are almost universally set by women, and male ‘tastes’ follow that lead.”
That’s pretty funny.
Um, you can put any girl that isn’t fat into heels like that and she’s gonna trigger the same response in just about any man’s head. That said, the chubbier one, if you saw her in real life, wouldn’t look nearly as good as the skinny girl. Photography is deceptive, and you can sultry up just about any woman with makeup and good lighting.
I’d bet all the money in the bank, if you put these two in a bar, %99 of the eyes would be fixated on the skinny one, and the %1 would be accounted for by the guy who’s too drunk to focus correctly. That eye would be focused two inches to her left.
Ideal bodies are exactly that — ideal. Stop complaining about setting an ‘unreal’ expectation, since %99 of men don’t give a damn. Sure, we’d look over your shoulder and check her out, wish you were a little skinnier and had legs like that, but that has almost no effect on our overall opinions of you ‘normal’ girls. Hell, when you’re not standing next to a girl that hot, we practically forget girls like that even exist… So don’t hang out with extra-hot girls and you’re fine.
That said, healthy is healthy, and we’re good at spotting that. If you have 20 extra pounds or so, it’s not our fault you need to lose weight. Go for a jog, or get out more.
Renn is def a size 10/12 by american standards. But a slender 10/12, probably because she is 3” taller than the average.
these are her dimensions as listed in nymag.com
Crystal Renn: 5 ft, 9 in; 36/31/41
a size 6- american- is listed as 34, 26.5, and 37.5
a size 12- american- is listed as 37.5, 29, 41
“Stop complaining about setting an ‘unreal’ expectation, since %99 of men don’t give a damn”
Well, they do, but they just close their eyes when they are fucking fat chicks and imagine they are fucking hot chicks. If you dated Asian babes you would have to worry about fat chicks with bad skin.
“if you dated Asian babes you would have to worry about fat chicks with bad skin”
you WOULDN’T have to worry….also, no hairy beavers.
You guys forget, women are like wine, it’s how they age that’s important. Most 18 yr olds look good in a swim suit, it’s how they look at 30 or 40 that matters. Fact is most white womyn in Seattle blow their gaskets after one kid and look like something the cat dragged in by 35. They stop dressing nicely and simply let themselves go to hell. Seattle is fill with trollish middle aged white womyn.
Marry an Asian woman and you’ll be happy the rest of your life.