To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
What the first headline proves (well, what the story proves) is that making a drug legal inherently makes it more destructive to society.
Apparently i was damaging all my organ systems last night.
I didn’t do any damage last night, but today’s another story.
The headlines on the drug study are so misleading. They’re seriously pissing me off.
What the first article shows is that while alcohol is safer to an individual that heroin or crack cocaine is, at the societal level, it does more harm.
I’d imagine that that is also true of situations like pistols and semi-automatic weapons: semi-automatic rifles are capable of killing a lot of people a lot faster, but more people are killed, society wide, by pistols, because there are so many more of them, and because they are the most common weapon used by law enforcement, etc.
In otherwords, this might as well have been published in the Journal of Obvious Results.
#5
Exactly. It’s saying liquor “in aggregate” is more harmful.
So, if you took away booze and replaced it with crack for those people, it would be overall many times worse for society.
In fact, you could look at alcohol as a “buffer” between people and hard line drugs.
No wonder the drug dealers want to give alcohol a bad name.
Recreational drugs, when done in moderation, cause a minimal amount of damage compared to the damage done by jailing everyone, letting markets pollute the drugs and fight over turf or not giving people adequate information about safe dosages.
I especially appreciate that the conclusion of the first article seems to be “alcohol is legal even though it’s dangerous, so anything less dangerous than alcohol should be legal as well”.
@1 huh wha?
you know, there’s a reason prohibition was repealed.
dunno where you’re from, but where I’m from, Chicago, we know just how much worse prohibition was than legalization and regulation. During prohibition, people died, lots of people died, due to the alcohol trade. People died from crappy knockoff alcohol, people died from mob violence related to alcohol sales, people died for resisting or trying to combat the mob, which also corrupted the political system. Not to mention the inherent injustice in putting people in jail for wanting to have a drink.
Alcohol is absolutely dangerous. Life is dangerous. Let’s not give up too many freedoms for safety’s sake. Instead, let’s take a sensible approach to combating the problem while still allowing people to have freedom of choice. Stop expecting the government to nanny you, you are an adult.
I think we’d be better off in this country if we stop treating drinking as a taboo (why can an 18 year old die for their country but not have a drink at a bar?) and teach your kids how to drink responsibly for starters. Having a couple of beers with your pop or your big sister (and gram, and aunty sue) at the house on New Years is way safer and saner than having your first drink with a bunch of other dumb irresponsible 15 year olds who have no concept of limits, alcohol poisoning, etc. and will leave your wasted ass at the side of the road if they hear sirens.
I grew up in a community plagued by alcoholics and crackheads. It’s an ugly thing. But some people eat too much chocolate and mcdonalds and that can get ugly too, should we make all foods illegal except broccoli? Adults should be allowed to make their own choices about how they want to live their lives- with consequences if they fuck up ours- and we can help them out of it if they want it.
@9, actually, Prohibition was moderately successful at its primary aim: reducing drinking, and the harm from drinking. People drank a lot less, especially at first (drinking eventually settled down to around half of what it had been before), and suffered the ill effects, including death, a lot less. That’s not why Prohibition was repealed.
Prohibition was repealed because people wanted it repealed, and because the lawlessness engendered by the illegal trade, which extended much further into every corner of society than cliches about “the mob” tell, was damaging American society more than legal liquor sales had.
The real problem with Prohibition in the US is the Prohibition mentality, which is Calvinist and Puritan in origin, and which holds that it DOES NOT MATTER whether it “works” or not, only that people must be compelled, whether against their will or not (frankly they like “against” better), to not only abstain from pleasures (though abstaining from pleasures is always a good thing) but demonstrate obedience and submission.
Americans have always been deeply suspicious of pleasure in others. The suspicion that our neighbors might be enjoying themselves, and a desire to see that controlled and stopped, is a fundamental American trait. As is the desire to get naked and drunk and burn down the house.
@ 9
You ever heard of a meth lab blowing up? Party kids lighting a building on fire? The appropriate response is to both tax and educate these people on how much they’re destroying themselves. I’m not looking for anything beyond what we do to cigarettes. Illegal drugs are “legalized” because of power and control, almost every drug on that list has been killed for. Ever heard of people creating acid that nearly kills people when used? Shit gets real in the drug world, plenty of people continue to die because of bad drugs.
A butter knife can be dangerous if you don’t know how to use it properly.
A more interesting metric, which is probably impossible to calculate due to incomplete data, is total net societal damage divided by total units consumed.
(Given that alcohol in moderation is shown to have mild health benefits, you’d have to calculate the net benefit of that and subtract it from the damage. You also need to include the economic benefits of production, marketing, distribution, sale, employment, etc.)
Considering the bazillion units of alcohol consumed annually in the United States, the per-unit detriment is probably statistically minimal when looked at that way. This is not to diminish the traffic deaths and medical damage caused by improper use, but just to look at the issue a little more realistically.
Don’t neglect the positive. As Benjamin Franklin said, “Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.”
@12: A butter knife can be dangerous even if you DO know how to use it properly, if you are wielding it in a dangerous manner deliberately.
I hate those sort of comparisons. Their own data negates their conclusions, but I guess that doesn’t grab many readers.
Like @13 mentions, they’re not making objective comparisons, quantifying what constitutes abuse, and seem to be completely dismissing moderate alcohol users. In other words, how many beers do they think equals a gram of meth? 2? I’d say closer it’s to 500.
@11: Actually, I never have heard of people creating acid that nearly kills people when used.
http://www.erowid.org/chemicals/lsd/lsd_…
It appears toxic OD is theoretically possible, though the LD50 is so far above the effective dose that it’s not terribly likely. Of course, if it’s cut/tainted with something highly toxic (as cocaine and heroine sometimes are, and crack is almost by-definition), then it may be lethal at only effective doses. All the more reason to have legality and the associated proper labeling, purity standards, and effective education about dosages as Vince (#7) suggests.