St James Cathedral: "All are welcome."
St James Cathedral: All are welcome.
  • St James Cathedral: “All are welcome.”

Call me naive. But I had pretty warm feelings toward Seattle’s progressive Catholics. From baptism until my early teens, I attended St. Therese Parish every Sunday, even taking my first Communion there—real fresh baked bread, not those godawful wafers—and I attended the St. Therese School for five years. Sure, the teachers were strict, but they were kind and gentle (Sister Maureen was a kind and gentle political radical, if I recall).

So when I went to St. James Cathedral on Sunday, I was expecting parishioners to give me a cordial welcome. I wanted to ask some of the congregation’s leadership about the proclamation issued on Friday evening by Seattle Archbishop J. Peter Sartain. In it, Sartain and three other bishops in the state declared a political campaign to stop a pivotal same-sex marriage bill in the state legislature, in the name of the “continuation of the human race.” They said that allowing same-sex marriage would result in “no special laws” for hetero couples and the decline of the species.

Since St. James is the official cathedral of the Seattle Archdiocese, which is headquartered across the street on First Hill, and my phone calls on Saturday went unanswered, I figured I’d ask in person if they agree with the proclamation and its logic. And if they disagreed—as many Catholics claim to behind closed doors—would they denounce this decree from the four local bishops?

After all, while the archdiocese may echo the Vatican, level-headed Catholics of Seattle can’t possibly believe straight people require “special laws” to make sure humans don’t perish. Gay-marriage laws are passing left and right and, um, the human race is booming.

As people left the mass, I approached a man in a long white robe wearing a mammoth silver crucifix necklace, and I asked him about the local bishops’ proclamation. “I can’t speak for any of those people,” said the man named Jerry who claimed he didn’t have a last name. “As far as I know, we are completely open to all the children of God. I go by the word of Jesus to love my neighbor, and that includes every neighbor.”

Do Seattle’s liberal Catholics believe the argument about procreation? “He, being the Archbishop, has to toe the line of Rome,” Jerry explained. “But for most of us, we toe the line of Jesus: He didn’t speak hatefully of anyone. There is a large lesbian, gay, and transgender population at St. James.”

Would they oppose this? “Yes, in many different ways,” said Jerry.

Jerry said I should catch up with Father Michael Ryan—who he assured me understood the plight of gays and lesbians—in the parish hall next door, where they were serving Filipino food. So I followed his instructions and walked into the room, which smelled of sesame oil and roasting meat, and then waited around near the entryway for Father Ryan. I hadn’t interviewed anyone but I had my reporter’s notebook out.

Does the leadership of St. James answer to the anti-gay Archdiocese of Seattle?
  • Does the leadership of St. James answer to the anti-gay Archdiocese of Seattle?

As I waited, a woman in her 30s or so rushed in front of me and told me to leave. I explained that I was a reporter and I’d been told to come speak to Father Ryan. “It is not appropriate,” said the woman, turning red in the face. She said she worked for St. James. As I noted that, she lunged for my hand and grabbed it and then shifted her grip to take my pen from my hand. Holding onto the pen, I asked, “What are you doing? I’m a reporter and you’re getting physically confrontational with me for taking notes.” She said she didn’t want to be named (I never got her name), briefly apologized for trying to take my pen, and then insisted I stand outside. So I went and stood in the snow.

At that moment, a man standing in the doorway said he wanted to speak to me.

“I support Governor Gregoire,” said Bill Baumgartner, 76, explaining his support for the marriage-equality bill in the legislature. “We should have marriage for all people.”

He didn’t necessarily believe the bishops’ procreation argument, either, and pointed out the church’s hypocrisy in targeting gay people. “Would the bishop say, ‘If you are divorced one or two times, leave the church,’ or, ‘If you have used contraception, leave the church’?” he posed the question. “But we don’t do that.”

He wasn’t alone in dissenting from the anti-gay-marriage proclamation.

One woman who was leaving stopped to talk but asked not to to be named. She said, “I think that anyone should get married who wants to. I don’t agree with [the bishops], because if you are born a certain way, you can’t help it.” But she wouldn’t speak out against the Archdiocese, she said, because, “It doesn’t bother me one way or the other.”

In the press, Joel Connelly at Seattlepi.com posted a piece last night that says, “The bishops’ letter left this recently returned Catholic perplexed at… how they treat people I know who are in loving, committed same-gender relationships, in several cases doing a splendid job of raising children.”

I stepped a few feet back into inside to see if Father Ryan was available when a woman, declaring herself to be an another employee of St. James, rushed up and literally began screaming at me. She accused me of trying to go “undercover” to ambush parishioners and trick them into talking to me. (For what it’s worth, I always introduce myself by name and identify myself as a reporter for The Stranger when I approach anyone for an interview, and I hadn’t asked anyone in the room for an interview.) She told me to leave and she would get Father Ryan for me, so I went back outside and stood under the sign that said, “All are welcome.”

I waited for an hour and half as it snowed.

Father Ryan never came. When another staffer stepped outside, he told me, “Father Ryan already left.” So I guess Father Ryan slipped out the back door.

I’ve since called St. James asking to speak to Father Ryan (he’s away and unreachable for a week, the receptionist said). I asked to speak to the church’s media spokesman and left a message, but he hasn’t called back. I also called the Seattle Archdiocese twice, but, again, no word.

Look, I acknowledge that some people at St. James and the Archdiocese may feel like they’re wrongly placed under the microscope by having a reporter arrive and call. But their leaders issued the proclamation, their leaders asked members to lobby Olympia, their leaders asked supporters to “do everything possible” to infringe on other people’s rights. If they get blowback, it’s because their institution initiated a conflict. The church isn’t the victim here.

So perhaps I was naive for having faith in Seattle’s Catholic leadership, for thinking that they were kind or at least brave enough to explain themselves. True, some of the flock seem grounded—albeit a little timid about challenging their leadership—but the shepherds are the collective problem. If the out-of-control staff at St. James are any indication, Seattle’s Catholic leadership is a confrontational, physically grabby bunch who join a priest that apparently runs away from plain questions. By refusing to repudiate bigotry, they are the ones defending it. But I’d still like them to prove me wrong.

73 replies on “A Woman Working for St. James Cathedral Grabbed My Hand and Tried to Take My Pen While I Was Covering the Seattle Catholic Church’s Campaign to Ban Marriage Equality”

  1. Fr. Mike Ryan has taken huge heat for supporting gay and lesbian folk. His strong support of Archbishop Hunthausen, who welcomed “Dignity,” a pro-gay Catholic organization, to St. James many years ago, likely doomed Fr. Ryan to life as a cathedral dean, rather than as an archbishop or cardinal. He has long supported equal rights for gays and lesbians and made a home for them at St. James, even against the wishes of his superiors, i.e. Archbishop Brunett. I’m sad the staff at St. James panicked at your presence, Dominic, but Fr. Mike Ryan is one of the Catholic church’s best, and he’s dealt with far more difficult issues than a Stranger reporter hanging around looking for a quick quotation.

  2. This Gandhi quote continues to be relevant. “I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.”

  3. Celebate clergy who molest children are FAR more of a threat to humanity than loving same-sex couples who wish to protect one another by entering into civil marriage. But I don’t expect the pedophile squad to see reason on this.

  4. It’s kind of amazing that the same catholic church which once claimed the right to crown kings and burned people at the stake over minor differences in the interpretation of scripture is now panicked by the thought of stating their beliefs in public.

  5. Doesn’t calling for – and running it sounds like – a political campaign violate the tax-free status of the church? I say we make them pay taxes.

  6. Look, I’m all in favor of local church leadership resisting the Vatican, but it sounds to me as if Mr. Holden isn’t going to be happy unless Fr. Ryan and others go on public record in this paper with direct opposition to a directive from the higher church.

    Mr. Holden must know that he’s asking local Catholic officials to risk defrocking or worse when he demands public, on-record repudiation of the Vatican.

    There is a lot a local priest can do to support gay rights that falls short of direct, public confrontation with the high church leadership. But Mr. Holden is demanding more.

    That’s fine, of course, but would it be too much to ask Mr. Holden to acknowledge that he’s demanding other people take on significant risks for his cause, in this particular battle?

  7. A) Yes, you are naive.

    B) @8, just to make clear, you’re saying we shouldn’t expect a priest to do what’s right if it may hurt his career?

  8. In the eyes of these Catholic clergy, gay marriage will result in the “decline of the species”. This would be hilarious if not so pathetic.

    OF COURSE these Catholic closet cases see a threat – they are all gay themselves, and in their self-imposed deprived sexual state (of confusion), by extension they see a human tsunami toward homosexuality.

    The real joke is that anyone continues to support this bizarre & corrupt organization that wants to take us back to the Dark Ages. Dumb, dumb & dumber!

  9. Ah, yes, the old “we don’t agree with the Vatican’s morally unsupportable positions, but we can’t talk about that.” I can tell that civil equality is a real moral imperative for these folks.

    There’s little practical difference between a bigot and a coward. One usually accompanies the other anyway.

  10. @9

    I am suggesting that Mr. Holden (or anyone else) should acknowledge the risks he is demanding others take.

    I offer no opinion on whether it’s better for a priest to work for a cause within the system, or to risk expulsion by confronting church hierarchy for that cause. There’s a place for both radicals and liberals*, in my book.

     

    * I am using “liberal” in the sense of “leftist, but preferring to work within established structures.” The term is sometimes used this way, and pejoratively, by radical leftists.

  11. Im not in Seattle, but how difficult would it be to have one or two people stand outside their office (in shifts if it takes that long), till that priest comes out and answers a few predetermined questions?

  12. @1…

    Mike Ryan ought to have been Archbishop…but his affiliation with Archbishop Hunthausen did that one in.

    Ryan is a good guy in a tough spot…as you noted, as are lots of Catholic clergy who don’t agree with this despicable authoritarian regime.

    As for Brunett and his ilk…fuck ’em. That is NOT the “Lord’s Work” they are doing.

  13. Well said in the penultimate paragraph. Politics ain’t beanbag, and if you take a side in an active political conflict you are not going to be treated with kid gloves. Scrutiny, criticism and even vicious insults are the natural price of political involvement and if you can’t handle that, stay out of the game.

  14. I don’t blame her for trying to take your pen. If I recognized you out in the world and you were writing something, I would smack that crap out of your hands too.

  15. They’ve been warned against your ilk since 1886. from Liberalism Is A Sin @ liberalismisasin.com originally El Liberalismo es Pecado by Don Felix Sarda y Salvany, a priest of Barcelona.

    The press has grown so omnipresent nowadays that there is no escape from it. It is therefore important to know exactly how to steer our course amidst the many perils that beset Catholics on this score. How then are we to distinguish between journals that merit or do not merit our confidence? Or rather, what kind of journals ought to inspire us with very little and what with no confidence? In the first place it is clear that such journals as boast of their liberalism have no claim to our confidence in matters that Liberalism touches on. These are precisely the enemies against whom we have constantly to be on guard, against whom we have to wage perpetual war. This point then is outside of our present consideration. All those who, in our times claim the title of Liberalism, in the specific sense in which we always use the term, become our declared enemies and the enemies of the Church of God.

  16. The stranger’s well known position on religion doesn’t exactly build bridges. There’s probably a middle ground between virulent atheism and dogmatic religion that exists for a broad swath of our society.

  17. “Look, I acknowledge that these church employees may feel like they’re wrongly placed under the microscope by having a reporter arrive and call. But they issued the proclamation, they asked members to lobby Olympia, they asked supporters to “do everything possible” to infringe on other people’s rights. If they get blow back, it’s because they initiated a conflict.”

    No THEY did NOT. THEY did not write the proclamation. THEY did NOT ask anyone to lobby. THEY didn’t initiate a conflict. 4 bishops? Yes. A couple thousand church employees? No.

  18. @8: Robobslave, regardless of whether Mr. Holden will be happy with a supportive or with an opposing statement from Mr. Ryan, it seems Mr. Ryan has avoided making any statement, and went so far in his cowardly avoidance that he left Mr. Holden standing in the snow for an hour and a half. I wish I’d been there with Mr. Holden to attend to the back door and remind Mr. Ryan of his visitor.

  19. @24

    Sure, Jesus was a radical. That’s not exactly a novel observation.

    I’ve noticed, though, that of the Christians I’ve had disagreements with, a lot more of them have been trying to Be Like Jesus, rather than just live according to the guy’s teachings.

  20. Fuck if religious apologists aren’t the most insufferable people in the fucking world. So the fuck what if Dom and The Stranger aren’t known for pleading fealty to your magic sky god, ya’ll are the ones with the holy book that says to love your neighbor, that choosing to do nothing when you could be helping is the sin of omission. If you find it so hard to follow your own fucking rules, pick an easier religion to follow for christ’s sake.

  21. @34

    I think we might be getting a bit ahead of ourselves there, Phil.

    We don’t know that Fr. Ryan was even told that Mr. Holden was waiting for him; from the behavior of the busybody who identified herself as a church official, I wouldn’t be at all surprised if she didn’t pass the message on.

    And once we’re sure that Mr. Holden’s demand has in fact reached Fr. Ryan, I don’t think I’m going to agree with you that a refusal to provide an “up or down” response to that demand constitutes “cowardice.”

    Mr. Holden wants a public statement from Fr. Ryan that either affirms or rejects a directive from the Church. Fr. Ryan may want to continue his work to promote gay rights without publicly repudiating that directive (nor affirming it). Though you, personally, may feel that that approach would be “cowardly,” I would not agree with your characterization.

    I’d have no complaint, though, if you wanted to call the behavior of anonymous-pen-grabbing-lady “cowardly.”

  22. @33) I though the nuance was apparent given the context, but your complaint is fair enough. I’ve updated that part to make the distinction clear between the bishops and the church staff.

  23. Wow, Public Relations 101 failing grade. The quote for me, however:

    He didn’t necessarily believe the bishops’ procreation argument, either, and pointed out the church’s hypocrisy in targeting gay people. “Would the bishop say, ‘If you are divorced one or two times, leave the church,’ or, ‘If you have used contraception, leave the church’?” he posed the question. “But we don’t do that.”

    The Bible is MUCH clearer on the sins of adultery and fornication, but if the priests/preachers started throwing people out for committing those sins (and let’s be clear, thinking about committing those acts are a sin, too), there would be nobody left. There is more than a fair bit of hypocrisy going on.

  24. @39

    I dunno about battery, but there was assault, and a try at theft, too. I think I’d go with attempted robbery, in our imaginary, purely rhetorical police report.

  25. @38

    When you do an update changing the text of your post, could you at least mark the parts that have been changed? There’s a substantial difference between misreading what you’ve written, versus fairly reading something objectionable or incorrect that’s since vanished.

  26. @42) The second-to-last paragraph changed from what @33 copied and pasted to what it says now, making clear the distinction between church staff and church leaders. Again, I thought it was clear within the context of the post, but I agree that, taken alone, it could have been ambiguous. So I changed it.

  27. For all of you who never were Catholic or went to Catholic school in a major city, let me say that its mostly a case of rather conservative attitudes when it comes to what is said, and rather tolerant attitudes as far as what is done.

  28. If Father Ryan wants to continue his work on behalf of gay/lesbian people, there are plenty of venues in which to do that work besides the Catholic Church. He needn’t continue the hypocrisy of staying in the Church and obeying his superiors, but helping those awful gays/lesbians out of the public eye.

    I can’t forget that when testifying about the pedophile priest who was transferred from Spokane over here, he said the equivalent of “we didn’t know it was wrong back then.”

    Hypocrite plus shaky moral compass equals someone I can’t respect.

    And this isn’t Dom Holden’s cause, this is–or should be–everyone’s cause.

  29. They said that allowing same-sex marriage would result in “no special laws” for hetero couples and the decline of the species.

    While this is, of course, ludicrous, it would be great if it would result in the decline of our species. Maybe then other creatures (and flora) could catch a break.

  30. @46

    Do you know where I can find a transcript of that testimony? “we didn’t know it was wrong back then” is a pretty damning paraphrase; I’d like to see if it fairly reflects the actual quote.

    I think I’m OK with Fr. Ryan (and other liberal Catholics) working for gay rights without leaving the Catholic church. I can see how you might regard that as “hypocrisy,” if you harbor a fairly one-dimensional view of the church, but I respectfully disagree.

    Gay rights isn’t Mr. Holden’s cause, certainly, but in the narrow matter of squeezing a “for ’em or against ’em” public statement out of liberal local Catholic leaders, well, Mr. Holden is the one who came up with that demand, and he is using his position at The Stranger to pursue it, so I think it’s fair to call it Mr. Holden’s demand (not “cause”).

  31. These people sound more like Scientologists.

    Also, doesn’t the fact that the leadership admit they have to “toe the line of Rome” sound just a little creepy (/totalitarian/out of place) to people who believe their Creator endowed them with free will?

  32. @49

    It’s only creepy if you don’t understand (or choose to ignore) the broader context of Christianity in general, and the Catholic faith in particular. Submission to SuperJesus is the basis of salvation in the former, and receiving the big J through the church hierarchy is central to the latter. Papism certainly isn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but for those who drink from it, deferring to Rome is definitely internally consistent.

    Of course, this doesn’t make the structure of the Catholic church any less hierarchical; if you’re the sort of non-Catholic person who gets the willies at the prospect of any submission to authority at all, then yeah, Catholicism is going to look pretty much like the Prussian Army.

    Oh, and it’s probably worth mentioning that deference to Rome has historically been one of the things that Protestant bigots have used in order to bash prominent Catholics, politicians particularly.

Comments are closed.