By now you’ve probably heard of the new demon drug du jour: “bath salts,” aka mephedrone. Another day, another designer drug popping up that mimics the effects of another, more expensive/difficult to find drug. (Like fentanyl for China White heroin in the Northwest, which is normally black tar territory.)

It seems like as good a time as any to bang this gong again:

We will always have drug users, abusers, and manufacturers just like we’ll always have drinkers, alcoholics, and distilleries. No matter what we prohibit, we will never change that fact. (See the Volstead Act and the 21st Amendment.)

What we can change is how drugs are made and consumed. Prohibition is not a good way to do that—prohibition abdicates government and social authority to the black market. It says “we don’t want to regulate and control, we’ll let people with guns and machetes decide how the drug markets work.”

Under prohibition, you get deadlier, dirtier, worse drugs: white lightning instead of Maker’s Mark, Tango and Cash instead of clean heroin (yes, there is such a thing), levamisole and who knows what in the cocaine, “bath salts” instead of cocaine or pharmaceutical grade amphetamine. Plus there’s all that carnage—like the 35,000 slaughtered in Mexico since 2006—when you abdicate market regulation to the people with guns and machetes.

Ending prohibition doesn’t mean that kids will be buying heroin in the 7-11 (instead of the parking lot behind the 7-11, which is where kids buy their heroin today).

There are all kinds of regulatory possibilities: maybe if opiate users had access to poppy and coca tea, they’d be less inclined towards heroin and crack, for example. But because the debate is split into Total Prohibition vs. Total and Unfettered Legalization, we never even get far enough to begin talking about realistic alternatives.

So the next time you read a story or see a news report about some dangerous new demon drug that’s wrecking lives, consider this: What if users had access to cheaper, safer access to the actual drugs (opium, coca) instead of whatever dirty, dangerous shit the black market is throwing at them?

Demon-drug scare stories should be fueling the argument for legalization and regulation, instead of stoking the irrational fears of the drug war.

Governments cannot eradicate drug use or drug production. But they can make the market safer, both for people in the U.S. and in the countries that are being mangled by the essential contradiction of the drug war: insatiable demand crossed with prohibitionist laws.

Brend an Kiley has worked as a child actor in New Orleans, as a member of the junior press corps at the 1988 Republican National Convention, and, for one happy April, as a bootlegger’s assistant in Nicaragua....

10 replies on “A Word about This “Bath Salts” Hysteria”

  1. Some interesting information about spray programs in Colombia and campesino econ 101. (For example: if you don’t have passable roads in your area, it makes a lot more sense to make and transport a kilo of coca paste instead of 100 pounds of apples.) Plus: the Mexico situation, alternatives to prohibition, stuff like that.

  2. I would like to see any evidence to support any of these ‘cleaner drugs’ assertions. I have lived in places w/ legal or decriminalized classes of drugs, and I clearly recall there still being plenty of black market, plenty of bad drugs, and plenty of crime and violence.

    And yes, we can reduce the incidence of substance use and abuse. Communities all over the nation have worked long and hard to produce real results that bring down all sorts of costs, including law enforcement, property destruction, lost productivity and low school achievement (and subsequent reduction in earning potential/tax revenue).

  3. @ 5. Portugal has shown some good results.

    “‘Drug decriminalization did reach its primary goal in Portugal,’ of reducing the health consequences of drug use, he says, ‘and did not lead to Lisbon becoming a drug tourist destination.'”

    They still haven’t gone as far as legalizing and regulating the drugs market, but their initial steps in that direction have shown positive results.

    The Swiss heroin maintenance program is another example of a small success.

    But every country (and every drug) is its own context and needs its own kinds of programs. Let’s at least begin the discussion about realistic alternatives to the foolish and destructive situation we’ve got going now in the Americas.

  4. These “bath salts” are legal (at least where I am). So how does making other drugs legal make people less likely to use them? (I don’t necessarily disagree with you, but I don’t follow your logic here)

  5. @6- I am not a proponent of criminalizing drugs. I have long felt that portugal’s model might be workable in some limited circumstances.. But it has not eliminated any of the the black markets, property and violent crime are still high in affected areas, and bad drugs abound all over europe, even in portugal, switzerland, netherlands et al.

  6. “These “bath salts” are legal (at least where I am)”

    The “safer” alternatives aren’t, you missed the point.

Comments are closed.