Yesterday, Seattle city council member and mayoral candidate Bruce Harrell proposed new “Police Accountability” legislation that would empower a civilian group to have more authority to review officer misconduct cases, and weigh in on whether they were handled appropriately. The legislation is slated for discussion during tomorrow’s 2:00 p.m. Public Safety, Civil Rights and Technology Committee meeting. However, this morning the ACLU fired back with a letter (.pdf), signed by ACLU deputy director Jennifer Shaw, warning that Harrell’s proposed legislation “is premature and will undermine and delay the work of the Community Police Commission [CPC].”
Shaw is also a member of the newly-formed CPC, which is a byproduct of the Department of Justice’s consent decree, and has been tasked with exploring police reform measures and establishing police priorities, among other things.
In a statement yesterday, Harrell’s proposed legislation was described as “add[ing] more teeth to our civilian oversight system” by expanding the Office of Professional Accountability Review Board (OPARB) from seven members to nine and making them responsible for annual reviews critiquing the one person responsible for disciplining Seattle police officers: The director of SPD’s Office of Professional Accountability (OPA). If you’ll remember, the OPA’s former director, Kathryn Olsen, resigned last fall after a review of her work showed that she only punished cops in about 12 percent of misconduct cases. The legislation would empower OPARB to review every closed case once the OPA director makes a decision or finding, and then prepare an annual report on the director’s performance and submit it to the mayor, city council, and police chief. (It’s embarrassing that the person in charge of overseeing cop discipline needs their own oversight committee but there it is.)
The legislation would also release OPARB from its public outreach duties to remove a conflict interest-y aspect of their jobs: Advocating for a police oversight system that they are also in charge of impartially reviewing.
Harrell office says the council member has also proposed a resolution asking the CPC to weigh in on whether OPARB should have the authority to look at open police misconduct cases, instead of just the closed ones. This is an incredibly tricky, sensitive issue that is opposed by Seattle police unions. Proponents of the idea (like The Stranger) have argued that it would greatly empower civilian oversight, promote transparency, and help Seattle residents regain trust in the department. The mayor’s office would likely have to negotiate for this right during the city’s next collective bargaining agreement with police unions.
However, that, too, might be a bit premature. As Shaw’s letter explains:
Part of the CPC’s mission is to carefully examine and make recommendations for improvements to the structure of the independent oversight components currently in place: the Office of Professional Accountability (OPA), the OPA Auditor, and the OPA Review Board. Specifically, in a Memorandum of Understanding, the City agreed that: “The Commission will review Seattle’s current three-prong civilian oversight structure to determine if there are changes it would recommend for improving SPD accountability and transparency.” The agreement goes on to detail the specific tasks that CPC will need to accomplish in order to complete this work.
The CPC is engaging in a careful and thoughtful review process to ensure that its recommendations will effect lasting and meaningful change. The Council’s current proposal to change OPA structure is premature. Passing this legislation now will undermine and delay the CPC’s effort to review the whole system and will needlessly result in more amendments after the CPC has completed its review. We ask you to withdraw your proposal until the CPC has completed its work.
In other words, Harrell, who’s working hard to appear strong on police issues in light of his mayoral bid, just got his ass politely handed to him by the ACLU and at least one member of the CPC for interfering with their work. I’ve called his office for comment; I’ll update when I hear back.
