Mary G. Montgomery High School in Semmes, Alabama mandates that all girls wear dresses to their high school graduation—under their ankle-length graduation gowns—or they don’t walk with their class. Which ruled out senior Samantha Armistead:
Samantha hasn’t worn a dress since she was 8 years old, her mother Debra told the Semmes, Ala. Fox affiliate.
“We’ve asked if she could be allowed to wear pants similar to boys, and we were told girls wear dresses, not slacks,” Debra Armistead told the station.
Armistead’s class walked on May 17th without her. Queerty.com weighs in on the constitutionality of this sad debacle over here.
h/t Sarah

I’ll bet money they wouldn’t let a boy wear a dress under his gown either, for what it’s worth.
I really hate the word “slacks.”
@2 I agree – it sounds so ’70s.
Alabama is a worse shithole than Mississippi, I think, and that’s saying a lot.
@2 & 3 – You rang?
“Slacks” trumps “pants”; the latter is confusing to the global village in which we live (and in which we put our bun-covers on one leg at a time).
Welcome to 1958.
It’s not 70’s and it’s not a question of would you let a guy wear a dress to the graduation. For certain occasions women should look presentable and wear a skirt or dress.It’s a matter of respect. If you read your Bible women should’nt wear pants anyway! It was only for ONE day and a couple of hours. Samantha missed a very important day just over a garment. That was DUMB!
Dang. State institutions in the South just seem determined to spite negative stereotypes by trying to be even more backwards and hateful than you expect.
A friend of mine was Salutarian at the high school he graduated from (that I left after 10th grade). He wore nothing but boxers under his robe and laceless work boots for shoes. He improvised his speech and was visibly baked. He was on his way to M.I.T.
I guess my point is the clothes don’t matter.
This was the rule at my high school graduation in VA in 2002 too.
This is just fucking stupid.
@13:
Yeah, I remember totally learning that lesson from watching “Fiddler On The Roof”…
@13 Sorry ‘established traditions’ change. Girls don’t “have’ to wear skirts anymore. Pants are perfectly acceptable. Gays are out in the open, unwed women have children, people divorce and remarry.
In AZ, it was so freaking hot at graduation that most of us were wearing tanktops and shorts underneath our ankle-length, heavy blue robes.
@4 Mississippi beats Alabama on the merits of literature. After that, it’s all one big fuckhole down there. From the Pacific to the Atlantic. One, big, nasty fuckhole.
I have a dear friend who graduated from City High in Iowa City completely naked under her robe. That’s rebellion. Some dreary ’70’s -era argument about dresses versus slacks is just dumb.
Do they check under the gown? Are students required to show? Are they training young police state residents?
We were supposed to wear business casual but I just wore regular clothes. No one checked no one cared. If the administration learned after the fact that this young woman didn’t wear a dress I wonder if they would even had cared.
@16: If guys can wear pants to graduation, why can’t girls? NOBODY goes to the opera in a t-shirt and shorts (hopefully), but her male classmates walked the stage wearing pants underneath her robes. A dress code is fine, but demanding that girls wear skirts rather than pants is sexist.
Crawl back under your rock, you antiquated asshole.
So what is the generally acceptable scholarly line now on the historical development of men’s vs. women’s clothing in the Western world, anyway? Of course any current notion of women needing to be in a dress or a skirt to be “presentable” is bunk, but how did women get saddled, so to speak, with undivided, open-at-the-bottom drapage for the lower body? Was it because of the need for non-constriction and easy access before the development of modern “feminine hygiene” products, or some patriarchal notion that women should be readily accessible for mating at the whim of a male (or should feel subtly vulnerable to same), or both, or something else entirely?
I have to say, that with current standards of comfort and hygiene, it seems like we SHOULD prefer the opposite of what now prevails: women might (I say MIGHT) prefer to feel more secure, and men might wish to be liberated from constricting clothing. Though I stop short of threatening to go buy a Utilikilt, I’m sick of having my nuts trapped in creases, and I’d really prefer my junk freely swinging in the breeze. Not wanting to force anybody to look; I have no objection to vertical curtains. I just want air circulation, dammit.
@16 – You’re frequenting the wrong opera houses. I’ve never been refused entry to the opera for wearing jeans & a t-shirt.
What if she wore pants under her dress? Also: is #8 a real person?
@25: Would society (or Med schools) melt down if a woman was coming to a graduation in a suit? How does refusing sexists rules show a lack of respect to the event?
@28: Every sexist rule? Yes, we intend to. And by “we”, I mean not just the faggots, but us straights, especially women, too. Who decided you weren’t a woman if you don’t have a dress? This bring us back to a time when a woman’s choice of career what the number of kids she would spend her life raising and the wealth of the man she would marry. She want to follow the dress code, she’s not asking to come naked or in jeans. Being a kid a kid is not a reason to be treated that way.
Furthermore, you’re a hypocrite. You say it is a matter of small importance, then you push raindrop to “keep sloggin”, clearly showing that it matters to you that this girl don’t get any choice.
Good Christ, there are so many grammatical errors in those two paragraphs it didn’t even make sense.
Or is proper grammar something else you don’t conform to?
When are lefties going to learn to do what the righties do and highlight the “anti-american” angle on what they do? Isn’t it un-American to say a woman can’t wear pants? Isn’t it un-American to be xenophobic? Isn’t it un-American to not respect freedom of religion?
The upside is it’s Alabama so there’s no requirement she wear shoes.
@13 Federal courts have consistently ruled that acting against a person for not conforming to traditional gender norms amounts to illegal sex stereotyping, prohibited by civil rights laws. Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins, 490 U.S. 228, 250 (1989)
@#28
Why do you support sharia law in the US?
sexist/racist troll is sexist/racist lulz
in regards to the article, I don’t think I’ll ever understand why people get their feathers all ruffled by something as silly as pants. they’re just pants! I wore jeans and etnies that matched my then-pink hair at my graduation (in a tiny town in montana, no less), and I graduated with honors and a 3.6 GPA. the world has not ended. women wear pants ALL THE TIME and our world hasn’t come crumbling down. IT’S GONNA BE OKAY.
then again, all dress codes have always confused me. I can still serve food to old people even if my hair is blue. I can still appreciate the opera while wearing cut-off shorts. I can eat food in a t-shirt, regardless of whether the plate is $8 or $80. no big deal!
@#35
Really? I thought you were a Moslem, after all you seem to agree with sharia law on most issues, are you sure you’re not Moslem?
I’m curious how @35 would feel if he was told he has to wear a skirt.
Does everyone remember King County Judge Jeannette Burrage, who forbid women from wearing slacks in her courtroom as recently as 2000? Bash Alabama all you like, but we aren’t immune to sartorial sexists in liberal Seattle, either! (And the same thing happened in a Santa Ana courtroom in 2004, so perhaps the legal field is especially prickly about women in pants.)
For the record, “slacks” is an excellent word.
@35: I’m pretty sure that wearing pants:
– doesn’t make me a drag king (at least not in any western country)
– doesn’t disguise me as a man (especially because most people use the upper part of the body to distinguish genders)
– doesn’t ruin anybody’s life (except yours, for a mysterious reason)
– doesn’t mean I prefer girls (or 99% of the American women are lesbians)
The rules are not perfect and they are changing all the time.
Why are you obsessed with sharia law? And why don’t you like it since it agrees with you?
@38:He would probably think you’re asking him to cut his balls.
I WAS going to wear a pretty dress for my graduation in June, but now I think I’ll go with a nice pair of jeans, just to piss off all the trolls in this thread. Hugs and kisses.
@16 – Wrong. An opera house or anywhere else actually would not turn away a woman for pants vs. a dress or skirt. Nice clothes are nice, period. This isn’t a case of shorts vs. a dress, buddy. Nice try though…
On a related note, the whole opera house analogy is a little off point – graduations are not, at least legally, considered voluntary events the same way that going to a play or a musical concert is. They’re considered part of your right to a public education (see, e.g., Lee v. Weisman, 505 U.S. 577 (1992)).
In other words, going to an opera house is more of a privilege, going to your high school graduation is more of a right. Just worth noting here.
I wonder what would have happened if she’d shown up in a nice pants outfit under her robe and tried to walk. Would they have physically restrained her? If they had, that might be a lawsuit waiting to happen.
Mississippi: at least we’re not Alabama.
Funny – if you equate “funny” with “assinine.” Like many women in the investment bank where I worked, I opted to wear business suits that came with *gasp* pants. No one thought this was anything less than professional. I also recall a (straight) girl wearing a very lovely pants ensemble to the prom one year. It was very stylish, not nearly as revealing as the majority of the prom dresses and fabulously comfortable looking in comparison. She looked sophisticated, while the rest of us looked like adolescents playing at dressup. Or escaped bridesmaids. And for a graduation? I fail to see why a dress is necessary. I graduated from college wearing a tank top and cut-off shorts underneath my gown (the ceremony was outdoors in a torrential downpour). No one knew what was under my gown.
Oh man, best excuse to miss graduation EVER. “Aw sorry mom, we’ll have to miss a two-hour ceremony with a bunch of assholes. Darn!”
My high school back in NC had the same rule. My girlfriend, who was Valedictorian, said she would wear pants or they wouldn’t have a valedictorian at graduation, and people would know why. They relented.