Two emails arrived this week from Catholics protesting the Seattle church’s recent campaign against marriage equality. And they confirm what you’d suspect: The progressive laity, by and large, is supportive of allowing same-sex couples to get married, despite the recent decree from bishops and the Archdiocese of Seattle to stop a marriage bill in Olympia. The first letter is from a parishioner sent to one of the priests at St. James Cathedral:

Father –

There is an article on “The Stranger” blog regarding St. James Cathedral. Unfortunately, it doesn’t make us seem like a very welcoming parish. The bishops do not speak for me regarding civil marriage equality for same-sex couples.

Regretfully, I need to withhold my 2012 pledged contribution to the Cathedral until I see what St. James Cathedral will do on this issue, which will likely be a ballot question in the Fall. I’m hoping that St. James Cathedral will not become complicit in the bishops’ anti-gay politicking.

Thanks very much,

Dave Clemens
St. James Parishioner

I can’t publish the letter he got back in reply, but let’s say that the administrative staff was a little touchy. Thank you for sending it our way, Dave. Next up: an email forwarded by a state lawmaker. A Catholic constituent wanted to make clear that the Catholic church’s lobbying campaign is not theirs:

I am writing to ask you to support the gay marriage legislation up for vote. I am a practicing Catholic, and I believe it is right and fair to help gay citizens have an opportunity to marry if they wish. I say this because I want you to know that all Catholics have their own opinion on this issue, and the Archbishop’s conservative opinion is not one that I share.

Thank you for serving our district.

Seattle Archbishop Peter J. Sartain, of course, did speak for these two Catholics and all the Catholics in Western Washington when he testified before a senate hearing yesterday. Alongside people who said that gay marriage will spread disease and promote pedophilia, Sartain perpetuated his lie that gay couples deteriorate humanity’s ability to procreate.

True, members of Catholic congregations should keep writing to their parishes and dissent from the bigotry of Sartain and Rome, but you know who really needs to speak up? Seattle priests. The priests—who we know don’t believe this bigoted garbage—need to challenge their bishops on this issue as marriage makes its way to the November ballot.

Dear priests: Dare the bishops to take away your pulpit. Let them try, and if they do, let your congregation stand up in your defense. If Farther Ryan at St. James Cathedral stood up for marriage equality and Most Reverend Sartian made a move, his congregation (and most of the damned city) would wage a holy war in the name of equality. The worst thing that happens is that you’re punished for spreading a message of love and doing what you know is right. That’s what that Christ guy was all about, right?

37 replies on “Catholics Withhold Donations From Church, Tell Lawmakers that Bishops Don’t Speak for Them on Same-Sex Marriage”

  1. The bishops will only move priests from African nations and southeast Asia to replace the Western ones in response to this. It’s not even about collecting more money from parishioners, it’s about pointing out the splinter in someone’s eye without pulling out the log in one’s own.

    Has anyone at The Stranger considered asking the local Ecumenical Catholic Church pastor Fr. Philip Knowles about same-sex marriage? If too shy or lazy, here is his most recent piece.

    It is easy — and I say this without meaning to be critical or uncharitable — to be a Pharisee, to quote chapter and verse, quite independent of the lives at stake. In a less charitable vein, I can understand a noisy display of rule adherence when one’s own house is rife with scandal that degrades the beauty and worth of those who are victims of the scandal. In this pressing human rights issue, the revelation of God is seldom seen or heard. God made all, and called it all beautiful. He did not call most of it beautiful and some portion of it “intrinsically disordered.”

  2. I agree with #4. Catholic priests have been carefully conditioned to be fearful of authority, and like everyone else in this economy, are worried about losing their jobs, their health benefits, and their pensions. Choosing this moment to self-immolate may sound noble, indeed Christ-like (since he’s the one after all who said “take up your cross and follow me”) In practice, however, we live in a real world where Catholic priests are, in the end, just regular human beings trying their best to hang on like everyone else.

    Still, keep the pressure on. Who knows, maybe a real gay martyr will emerge to challenge the hierarchy. Someone should be prepared to give him another job after he gets fired, however. That’s all I’m sayin’…

  3. @2 – Maybe not, but in a sense, “the people” ultimately change any social construct–religion, government, marriage, family, art–either by consensus, egress, or force. Whether, in the case of the Catholic church, it is desirable to try the first before resorting to the second (to say nothing of the third) is a decision best left to those who, unlike you or I, have some investment in the notion of being Catholic.

  4. I don’t get why you can’t publish the letter. If you are merely reprinting their words, start to finish, they can’t claim libel or defamation, nor can they claim to be quoted out of context.

  5. @5 –

    The bishops will only move priests from African nations and southeast Asia to replace the Western ones in response to this.

    Seems we could get natural enemies in the Tea Party to join us in condemning this. Importing labor for tax-exempt non-profits? The nerve!

  6. “The bishops do not speak for me regarding civil marriage equality for same-sex couples.”

    Yes they do. If you call yourself a catholic they speak for you. You don’t get to pick and choose. You also believe that you are eating Jesus’s flesh and blood. Not a symbolic act of remembering blah blah blah. His actual flesh and blood. You don’t get to pick and choose.

  7. @11 – because the copyright belongs to the author, not the recipient, and the author alone can decide if or how to publish.

    The reply was forwarded to The Stranger by the recipient, and so it is not theirs to publish.

  8. @13 – Maybe not as far as the church is concerned. But unless you believe that any religious doctrine is formally (and literally) “handed down” by divine, essentially anthropomorphic deity, your intellectual duty is to “pick and choose”. I can’t imagine I will ever see a unified body of assertions that appears both true and tenable in its entirety.

  9. @7,
    Maybe that the RC is neither a republic or a democracy, this is not to say that money and witholding it does not speak, but that in a sense the Roman Empire is alive and well in 2012 complete with a grizzled emperor wearing a funny hat sitting on a throne? So it is not very far fetched to think that the majority of priests believe in the heirarchy and hold faith that the Pope was chosen by God to lead, so they are very likely inclined to follow and obey their ’emperor’. Just a thought…

  10. @16 – The trouble with so much of the Protestant Revolution is that, while it saved the West from the Catholic hierarchy, it replace Catholic scholarship with enslavement to the five solas. It seems to me that only apostate religion–or at least religion with a certain amount of room for apostasy–can survive scientific discoveries and subsequent, corollary intuitive posits that challenge biblical literalism.

    All of which is to say that any religion (not just Christianity) would have to be small “c” catholic (that is, inclusive; reliant on multiple sources), bound neither by Rome’s hierarchy’s nor Protestantism’s embrace of a narrow and common poetry.

  11. I don’t get this Catholic insistence that the world will suddenly stop making babies if gays are allowed to marry. Did they not get the memo that the earth’s population just recently surpassed 7 Billion? I don’t think that the human race is in any danger of not procreating enough.

  12. For a little inspiration, this is how the complete dutch Jewish community dealt with their American chief rabbi after he signed a letter calling homosexuality a disease in their name, they kicked him out (admittedly they where already longer unhappy with his orthodox fundamentalism). Now the European orthodox council threatens to suspend the whole dutch community in turn and throwing charges of fascism etc around but the dutch leadership isn’t budging: http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/worl…

  13. you expect the priests to stand up against the catholic church on gay marriage? are you out of your mind? they didn’t stand up to the church when it functioned(s) as a child rape ring, and you think they are going to stand up for gay rights? time to get real. the catholic church is an utterly lost cause. they haven’t changed in 2000 years, they aren’t going to change now. just call them out for what they are, hateful bigots. i was raised catholic, i should know.

  14. @25

    Because that’s the way they’re addressed. Judges are called “Honorable” regardless of whether or not they’ve got any honor, too. And it’s not going to change just because you’ve decided to put a stick up your ass over it.

  15. If a priest is no longer content with obeying the Pope but still wants to practice essentially the same rites and uphold essentially the same beliefs, I’m sure the high-church Episcopalians would welcome him. There’s absolutely no excuse for remaining a Catholic priest when you cannot respect what the Church demands of you.

  16. @29

    Or maybe, just maybe, the Catholic church does some stuff other than tell its members how they should feel about gay marriage. Stuff that, for some strange reason, those members seem to find almost as important as this single, monumentally important issue.

  17. @31 – perhaps if you were deprived of the right to marry, a scenario you’ve probably never even imagined, you too might find that it is a “monumentally important issue.”

  18. “If Farther Ryan at St. James Cathedral stood up for marriage equality and Most Reverend Sartian made a move…”

    Please learn the difference between farther and father.

  19. Wow, they withheld donations for same sex marriage? Even the people who want the church kiddie diddlers held accountable didn’t get that!

Comments are closed.