More grist for the housing bubble analogy mill: Social science nerds devise the shortest theoretical game of Monopoly. Two players take two turns each.

(The action moves quickly, but the post writes up each turn in detail.)

They have more fun than anyone who has ever played non-theoretically. Monopoly destroys fun. It is a terrible, terrible game.

The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner and Paul Hughes.

The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner, Paul Hughes, and Mary P. Traverse.

18 replies on “Do Not Pass Go”

  1. I once babysat for a little girl who loved playing dress up, and was also a crack Monopoly player. When she was doing well in the game, she’d disappear and come back dressed in a princess outfit or fancy ball gown – and when she was doing poorly, she’d go change into a brown dress or overalls. It was one of the most entertaining things I’ve ever seen.

  2. Monopoly is the worst popular board game on the planet. It gets somewhat better if you play following the rules, but almost no one does (no free parking, all properties landed on are auctioned off, etc.).

    But with a small amount of statistical knowledge of the board, the game boils down to luck.

  3. I have never agreed more with anything than I do with the following statement: “Monopoly destroys fun.” I absolutely despise that fucking game.

  4. Monopoly is an incredibly boring and predictable game (well, predictable by about the third turn). For the life of me, I can’t figure out what draws people to it. It’s about as fun and exciting as playing tic-tac-toe.

  5. Don’t be too harsh with board games. I loved them as a kid – most of them. Candyland and Chutes and Ladders were pretty lame. Granted, they in no way compare with video games of today on the boring/exciting index. But there is a huge difference. Board games brought families together at least for a while back when TV was only on air for 12 to 15 hours a day. They may have kept people from killing each other. And you could do other things while playing them like listen to music. I think video games tend towards alienating participants. Not much chance for inter-game communication. They’re too quick and require full attention. This isn’t a judgment call. It’s an observation.

  6. Nice to see one commenter (Skit) actually comes down pro-monopoly. It’s a great game if you a) play by the rules: specifically no money in free parking and auctioning off property (especially when more than 2 people are playing), b) play quickly (works best with all players who know what the’re doing), c) making deals/trades if the game approaches a stalemate, and d) having a general understanding that a player will concede once it’s hopeless. If you play monopoly that way 2 persons games can easily be completed in 30 minutes or less and it’s fast paced enough to keep everyone interested. And while I agree there is a lot of luck involved, where/how to build and making deals are enough strategy to keep it interesting.

  7. @17 There is a 100% optimal strategy to playing monopoly. You can learn the strategy which takes out all decision making from the process. The key element of any game that makes it fun is the requirement to decide between two less than optimal options. There are other games like poker and blackjack that are also so dead simple that the best strategy in any situation is mathematically verifiable. This leads to ancillary strategy such as better patterns that actually form what the “game” is.

    Poker and blackjack are games and Monopoly is just luck/gambling. Some more examples are tic tac toe and checkers are not games but chess is because you can never prove what the best move is. In monopoly you can prove without a doubt what is the best move in any scenario.

Comments are closed.