It’s starting to look that way. A court recently ruled that children can wear anti-gay t-shirts to school—the shirts called for the execution of their gay classmates—but we haven’t had a ruling yet on pro-gay shirts, so we get shit like this.

Time to sue.

28 replies on “Does The Constitution Only Protect Anti-Gay Speech?”

  1. I think it also protects tattoos.

    I’d ask Rush, but he’s inside one of the nuclear reactors north of Tokyo, showing how radiation is good for you.

  2. I think I’ll design a t-shirt that says “Hey Bigot– Go Kill Yourself.” All the kids will want one.

  3. I’m missing something here. According to that link, the t-shirt read “Be Happy. Not Gay.” Which is surprisingly clever for bigot-speech. I don’t see anything about a call for executions.

    And the court ruled that if the school didn’t act to stop the gay rights Day of Silence, then they similarly can’t stop a reasonable expression of the other viewpoint.

    I mean, don’t get me wrong, fuck that little shit…or the big shits that raised him. But the court’s ruling here doesn’t strike me as outrageous.

  4. #3: Yes I’m with you.

    The worst mistake queers can make at this point in our gains and PR is become perceived as not wanting equal rights–but wanting to be the thought police.

    You actually do have a right to bigoted opinions in this country.

  5. Those are two separate events. This ruling, about Neuqua Valley school, doesn’t seem to have anything to do with the bible-quoting “shall be put to DEATH” shirts at St. Charles North High School, as far as I can tell.

  6. @5

    Different school, different shirt, different case entirely. I stand by what I said above regarding your first link.

    As to the other incident, that’s disgusting, and I believe the school administration did entirely the wrong thing in failing to discipline those kids.

  7. Yawn. Communities have quite a bit of leeway to determine what dress is appropriate–which means they can decide based on prevalent mores in those communities what’s best for their schools, etc. Not that I am down with Dallas’ supposed bigotry or anything, but it’s absurd to compare anti-gay shirts in Chicago to gay shirts in Dallas.

  8. In the interest of not talking out my ass, I pulled up the court opinion to make sure I have my facts straight. This ruling does apply specifically to the “Be Happy, Not Gay” shirts. There are actually portions of the opinion that make it pretty clear that the judges would have ruled differently to a more blatantly hostile shirt.

    From ZAMECNIK v. INDIAN PRAIRIE SCHOOL DISTRICT # 204:

    “The plaintiffs assert a constitutional right to make
    negative statements about members of any group provided
    the statements are not inflammatory[…]They concede that they could not inscribe “homosexuals
    go to Hell” on their T-shirts because those are
    fighting words, at least in a high-school setting, and so
    could be prohibited despite the fact that they are
    speech, disseminating an opinion.”

    and later

    “In this factual vacuum, we described “Be Happy, Not
    Gay” as “only tepidly negative,” saying that “derogatory”
    or “demeaning” seemed too strong a characterization.”

    Judge Posner’s full opinion available at: http://www.ca7.uscourts.gov/tmp/6D123UDL…

  9. Honestly, I have to say I can almost not bear to read anymore of these stories, because it drives me so completely crazy sometimes, and it totally puts me back into my Christian high school I had to attend, where students would wear their “Straight Pride” shirts and shove my gay friend into lockers.

  10. @11 – thanks for digging up the details. good to know that the court’s ruling was a narrow one, at least. however, i think dan’s point is that all anti-gay speech, however “mild,” is detrimental. my guess is the kid who hangs himself after years and years of bullying doesn’t distinguish between the “only tepidly negative” and outright hostile treatment. it’s all a part of the negative atmosphere queer kids have to deal with on a day-to-day basis. sometimes the mild sort of half-joking i-wasn’t-really-serious-i-just-thought-it-was-a-funny-tshirt stuff can cut you to the quick in a way that the outright hateful stuff can.

  11. @14 – It is not, and in my opinion, should not, be the government’s place to protect even young people from every possible harmful word or image.

    The dumbass kid in question has every right to both have and share his dumbass opinion. To mutilate a little Evelyn Beatrice Hall: Your dumbass shirt makes you look like a douchebag, but I will defend to the death your right to wear it. And look like an idiot.

  12. Did it happen at the same school or in the same jurisdiction? If not, the point is moot. But yay, revolutions and stuff.

    BTW the principal dude had grounds to make her cover it up anyway because “The shirt features a small ‘FCKH8.com’ footer.”

  13. I think that gay rights should be viewed the same as rights for racial equality. If the shirt said “White Pride. Be happy, not black”, what would people think? I hope we are going in the direction that 20years form now we will look back on folks who fought equal rights for GLBT in the samw way almost everyone looks at people that fought against the civil rights movement. Actually, in Canada where I live, we are almost there anyway. Even our conservative christian prime minister won’t touch gay rights.

  14. I bet if they were anti-insertraceofyourchoicehere-shirts, there would be a WHOLE different tune being sung here. Or anti-hetero shirts. I may have to make some of the latter now and wear them all the time just to prove the point.

  15. As much as I’m against bigotry, if those high school kids had work shirts that said “Straight Pride” ONLY then no one could really have said anything – bigoted speech IS protected. But with the Leviticus quote on the back that becomes hate speech and death threats, which are totally illegal and immoral.

    There’s nothing wrong with being straight or white any more than there’s something wrong with being gay or black. It’s just when you start spewing hate speech about your “superior” characteristics that it becomes a problem.

  16. @11, I appreciate that too. I was sick to my stomach thinking that the court defended t-shirts calling for the execution of gays. I’m no Posner fan, but I don’t he would allow that (and later be overruled).

  17. You know what else we can do to make a safer and more supportive environment for our students in Washington schools? Lobby to support HB1163 ‘Anti-Bullying’ bill tomorrow in Olympia!

    Join Equal Rights Washington for Equality Day rally and lobby day in Olympia, TOMORROW, MARCH 22nd from 9:30am to 3:30pm. Info and registration at equalrightswashington.org.

  18. I’m like the person who wrote that they where tired of seeing these kinds of things. I’m tired too. Tired of waiting for this country to come out of the middle ages, tired of waiting for common sense and science to have more credibility that some religious hack that is too lazy to do the hard work around tough questions, but would rather take some magical answer for everything. This country is falling behind in research, in science, in just about every area except how to max out a credit card on useless shit. I’m just tired.

  19. @17

    People would never accept the anti-black shirts because there is no choice as to what color you’re born. The majority of the U.S. seems to feel that *acting on* homosexual feelings *is* a choice and therefore is game for criticism. Mind you, the feelings aren’t a choice; they’re just pissed on the *acting on* them part. Totally bizarre since it affects them NOT AT ALL.

    @19

    Yeah, but someone could wear a shirt with, “Blondes are dumb, Brunettes have brains” and that’s clearly discriminatory against people who were born blond but no one would give a fuck.

  20. The “banned” gay shirt features the lovely “FuckHate” logo- poor Danny; people objecting to him indoctrinating their kids with his favorite crudity…..life is soooo unfair for a gay man in America

  21. The death comment needed to be hammered. As to the rest its double standard, BS. Talk to me when there is a straight, white, male pride days. Otherwise as long as people want special gay, Latino, black and purple pride days expect there to be push back and increasing levels of it.

  22. I think the school principal should have the right to stifle hate speech – or even “dislike speech,” say, in the case of something relatively mild like “be happy, not gay.” It’s just wrongheaded and vaguely unpleasant, like wearing a T-shirt that says “Guys below 5′ 3″ annoy me.” While hardly extreme, that could legitimately be construed as needlessly hostile toward the dozen or so kids in the school who are that short.

    And I don’t give a damn what the “majority of the U.S. feels” about homosexual anything being a “choice” and therefore blah blah blah. Wrong is wrong.

  23. Hold on a second! That FCKH8 shirt is distracting.

    Schools should be institutions of learning and I don’t think any Middle School principal should allow such a blatant and unnecessary use of “R” in place of an actual word, “are”. Frankly, it would have even improved the balance of the text.

  24. Time to bust out the “Be a Slave, Not a Free Black Person” t-shirts…

    Ohh! How about: “Be a Man, Not a Woman”?

    “Be Able-Bodied, Not Paraplegic”?

    Maybe just “Stop being an asshole, you homophobic fuck!”

    I’m all for freedom of speech, even hate speech, but if they’re going to allow that, then they should allow shirts calling out homophobes for being hateful fuckers, in exactly that language (based on my experience, this would not happen, as schools tend to frown on and ban swearing). The Day of Silence comparison is a false equivalency, though, as that demonstration is specifically about NOT engaging in speech. If they wanted to organize a day where they don’t spout homophobic crap in order to protest their ‘persecution’, I think we’d be more than happy to have them do so.

Comments are closed.