Say you’re a gay kid and you get online at school—let’s say you’re looking for LGBT scholarships to help pay for your education because your parents cut you off when you came out—so you get online at school and start Googling around. You quickly discover that every LGBT organization’s website is blocked. HRC is blocked, NGLTF, GLSEN, Trevor, It Gets Better, all the gay blogs, every gay publication, and every gay organization that offers scholarships to LGBT students. All blocked. But no anti-gay websites are blocked. PFOX, American Family Association, Exodus International, reparative therapists—every last anti-gay website, the website of every last officially certified anti-gay hate organization, is unblocked.

That’s a very specific kind of cyberbullying. It’s also discriminatory and unconstitutional. And if your school is blocking pro-gay websites, the ACLU wants to hear from you.

35 replies on “Don’t Filter Me”

  1. Easy way to tell if it’s blocked – get a friend at a Canadian school to see if they can see it, or someone else in another country (most teens nowadays have lots of friends who don’t live in the same country, due to online web pals, chat, language exchanges, and kids whose parents move overseas).

    If they can and you can’t – you’re being censored – and that’s un-American.

  2. it is censorship and it’s likely unconstitutional (though a school environment is different under the law) but it’s not bullying – not everything is bullying Dan even if that’s topic du jour – you’re too loose with the ideas when it suits your agenda and that ultimately devalues what your doing (which is good).

  3. @2, not trying to be a wise ass, but couldn’t you just try to go to the website and if it doesn’t work, you know it’s blocked?

  4. @3, I would argue that it is a very subtle and insidious form of bullying. What that kind of filtering does is tell a child that merely portraying being gay in a positive way is unacceptable and obscene enough to be filtered, while anti-gay propaganda is fine.

  5. @4 Not all blocking programs admit it. Some will give you 404 error or claim there must be a server problem. Still, if the pages in the vid all consistently always have a “server problem” when you try to access them from school, you can pretty much be sure they’re blocked.

    @3 Telling children “what you are is so bad we don’t even want our students reading about it,” is a form of bullying. Blocking a website implies that’s there’s something wrong with students reading it and getting the information it offers.

  6. WiS, it is most definitely NOT true that ‘most’ teens have friends who live overseas. There are not that many exchange students; while most kids who move here leave friends behind, those friends don’t usually have internet access. Most poor kids in Latin America and Africa don’t.

  7. Can’t they just claim “we’re aware of problems with our filtering and we’re currently taking steps to whitelist those sites”? Seems that proving discrimination would not be super easy.

  8. This is great. I can’t wait to see the results.

    Side note: I went to the linked ACLU page and the pic on the right under Other Multimedia caught my eye, having watched “Everybody’s Fine” the other night. Someone needs to get going on a script for “The Seth Walsh Story” before he gets too old for the lead role.

  9. @9 — These days, lots of kids have some way of contacting folks in Canada or the UK thanks to MMORPGs and any number of internet forums. He’s not talking pen pals from the 80’s. He’s talking about folks in the theoretical kid’s WoW guild and such.

  10. @13 I admit to having add blockers installed so maybe I’m missing something, but I sure don’t see any porn at it gets better or Trevor Project so what would be the excuse for blocking them?

  11. I’m wondering if a lot of schools have an “LGBT/GAY” filter that blocks everything tagged that way regardless of what the websites intentions are?

  12. @8 The comedy timing was terrible. They should remake the video. When his boss asks if he’s sure he doesn’t have the stapler, he should say, “Let me check…,” throw out the stapler, and THEN answer that he’s sure.

  13. Would this be everywhere, or just in particularly anti-gay locations? Things had been seeming fairly encouraging too, with so many anti-gay organizations whining that schools wouldn’t let them hold their super special awesome events there.

    This is quite disturbing. I hate the thought of young people being at risk of exposure to dangerous anti-gay propaganda. Now I shan’t be able to sleep for wondering whether it would be better to block or unblock both sides.

  14. What, am I the only person in the world who knows how to find a free wireless hotspot at a cafe?

    Honestly. Maybe your school and your library block these sites, but I’d bet you a $4 latte that Starbucks doesn’t. And as any young Seattlite will tell you, they don’t card you for coffee.

  15. Speaking of racism, I was floored reading this article about tolls in Washington state. It pretty much says that anyone who is an ethnic Eastern European is too stupid to understand English and know when they are being charged for a bridge?!!

    But it doesn’t stop there…like a Don Rickles Vegas headliner, the article runs through East Asians, Chinese…just about everyone, labeling and disparaging their intellectual abilities!

    http://crosscut.com/2011/03/25/op-ed/207…

  16. I haven’t checked lately, but I know that last year students at Seattle Public Schools were unable to use school computers to reach thestranger.com. This is probably because of associated “lustlab” pages and the like, but it’s unfortunate that the useful news coverage is dinged because of the prurient nature of some of the other pages at the site. I’ll have to check at school tomorrow to see if one can reach some of these other sites via SPS-linked computers.

  17. Yeah, I’m gonna say that in my city, you don’t see a lot of pre-teens or young teens carrying laptops around. For some children, school is the only place they have access to the internet.

  18. The point isn’t whether or not the kid can go to another location if he happens to have a laptop computer. Of course he could. The issue is the selective access process the school system has in blocking website. Gay help, resource, rights sites are blocked, while hate the gays pages are freely available. Public schools are government agencies funded by taxes on the public, and should not do this sort of bigoted censoring.

  19. I work at a DoE lab attached to a big midwestern university. We have a pretty strict filter. Of the sites you listed (both good guys and bad), only NGLFT is blocked. For the life of me, I can’t figure out why THAT one is blocked when the others aren’t.

  20. And the bigger point is that the ANTI-GAY sites are still freely accessible. It would be one thing if a student tried a search to find out something about homosexuality and got nothing at all, but to allow the search and only get the hate sites is completely different.

    Can you imagine the drama if schools did this so that only atheist sites showed up if one did a query on religion?

  21. @3 — I would argue that if you’re forced to be in an environment where searching for “gay” or related searches only provides anti-gay sites and no pro-gay sites, that’s a form of deliberate psychological bullying and just as harmful as constantly being called “faggot.” And I would argue that it’s no accident, either. Otherwise the anti-gay sites would also be blocked.

  22. Most districts have a procedure to request review of a blocked site: I’d recommend that anyone who finds such filtering in place use the process to politely and respectfully request said site to be unblocked. In most cases, the filtering is pretty much out of the box automated by an appliance vendor or software provider, and it’s only reviewed upon complaints.

  23. Also, I should point out that school districts are kind of between a rock and a hard place: if anyone can interpret material on these sites as being pornographic, and said sites are unblocked, the district can be found to be in violation of CIPA and COPPA, and stands to lose quite literally millions per year in e-rate funding.

  24. @ 15, WiS certainly did mention meatspace friends. And maybe my view of these things is skewed by working in a high-poverty school. But most teens I know do not play WoW or other on-line games. They spend most of their web time at YouTube or looking at manga. Most teens don’t have ‘lots of friends’ in other countries to chat with on line.

Comments are closed.