When I first glanced at the headline that said it would be a crime to say “gay” in the classroom in Tennessee, I cheered. Wait! Don’t file me in the circular file yet.
Last July, my stepson, age 19, came to stay with my husband and me. He grew up in rural Texas, and is racist, sexist, homophobic and FAR to the religious and political right. For him “gay” is an all-purpose pejorative. “I don’t like that shirt, it’s too gay.” After a few go-rounds of this, we explained to him (calmly, calmly) that such statements are NOT okay, in our household, or in San Francisco, where we live. He did not really understand why it was a problem (sigh), but after a few more discussions, he stopped.
Sooo… I initially thought the Tennessee bill was a sign of enlightenment, not another piece of homophobia. Just goes to show how wrong first impressions can be.
Love your column.
Lady Jean
Presumably the proposed Tennessee law makes an exception for using “gay” as an insult.

What a great video. Thank you!
Ha, Lady Jean brings up an interesting point, and one that would be worth pursuing: If discussing being gay, or using the word gay is banned, why wouldn’t that apply to the students as well? Could as case be made for recording students conversations in school, on the lookout for the “gay”? I would think that “don’t say gay” proposal would be shut down pretty quickly if those boneheads came to understand that it would mainly affect their name-calling sons and daughters in class.
(morning, gus!)
I admit I had a similar thought when I read the first headline about this piece of legislative idiocy (which was of course quickly quashed as I read thru the article)…
Oh man, wouldn’t it be awesome if they started prosecuting minors for saying “gay” at school under this law? Okay, well, maybe not awesome, but it would make the point…
I don’t believe censorship is ever the answer.
Hola, Canuck! When I first read the text Dan copied in I didn’t see the indent and thought it was just him launching into a family anecdote. Then I got to (calmly, calmly) and thought, waitaminute who is this?
That’s a good notion you float to show up the absurdity by talking about if it were tried with students too. Really highlights how this is a one-two punch of evil against two favorite political whipping boys: gays and public school teachers.
Hey, that shirt’s not “fag” gay, just “pussy” gay. What’s the big deal?
Hey, gus. Yeah, those gays and teachers are the cause of so much trouble…sigh. Did you see the wonderful op-ed piece by Dave Eggers in the NYT last Sun, I think? Loved his comparison of how we view soldiers vs teachers.
That was a terrific piece – having that show up just days after the Kim Ricketts appreciation he wrote for Slog was a real double-dose gift of Eggers goodness.
Hey, y’all. FInished watching PBS’ Stonewall Uprising last night after getting the DVD. Really good! Anyone else?
(Now off to track down the Eggers article…)
Ah I did see that — “The High Cost of Low Teacher Salaries.” I need to pay more attention to bylines 😉
Love.
Thanks for the reminder about Stonewall Uprising, BEG – I’m gonna watch it online tonight – so excited!
do let me know what you think, gus! i really enjoyed it, and it was also eerily similar to another pbs production called “Through Deaf Eyes” — the sense of lost/rewritten history, the sense of so much *more* history behind a particular event, the ways in which the majority compresses and squeezes the maligned minority under incredible pressures — wow…
gus and BEG, I watched the Stonewall documentary, and was surprised by how awful things were just a generation ago. I had actually ordered the dvd for the youth group sight unseen, and now I’m thinking it’s too hurtful in the beginning, I’d be interested in what you both think, from the point of view of a teenager.
@ 15 – Just wait and see what 4 years of a Harper majority government will do to Canada. Your teachers might also have to face a “don’t say gay” order soon. Hang on to that DVD, it might no longer be “history” in a few short years…
Let’s all pray that it doesn’t go that far… (oops, forgot I’m an atheist for a moment there).
Ricardo, I fully agree that Harper is a scary man, but I just don’t think something that blatant would fly here. Canada doesn’t have the extreme, well-organized religious right that the States does (other than the Catholic church), and this landed in my inbox this morning, hopefully a sign of things to come in other provinces as well as BC:
http://www.bclocalnews.com/vancouver_isl…
@ 17 – I sure hope you’re right, but history should have taught us to be a bit more wary of that sort of leader. No one believed that Hitler would turn out to be as bad as he was, for instance… (Calm down, y’all, it’s an example, not a direct comparison.)
My stepsons started to do that – use “gay” as a pejorative – when they were young teens, mostly because their friends did. We explained it to them the same way we would have had we heard them using racial or gender-based epithets – that’s offensive, it’s a direct attack on people you know and like, decent people don’t talk that way and here is why. We never did overhear them using the word that way again, and we did hear them chastising their friends for it. I think that’s a much superior approach to any kind of institutionalization of “forbidden” language.
Man, Canuck – now I’ll definitely report back to BEG and you. Thanks to both of you for laying the groundwork.
I have to have a side moment of squee that Kelly/Liam Sullivan is in this video. I <3 you, Liam/Kelly..!
Barring the word, ain’t gonna chase the gay away, TN..
I predict this bill will set an etymological precedent for using the word “yag.”
@15 Canuck — I’m not sure — although from the POV of the teenager I was, I’d say hell no. Adults were always thinking we couldn’t handle things we already were thankyouverymuch.
Honestly? I found the part (more in the middle) that showed this police officer lecturing a schoolroom full of kids not to get into homosexuality “because you WILL be found out and it WILL ruin your life” as far more problematic. The “Homosexual Will Show You Pictures And You Will Be Doomed” came across as a really badly done Leave it To Beaver thing o.O
The part where they describe how the police changed their tactics on the second and subsequent nights…yipes.
Are you talking teenagers 13-15 or 15-18?
And I tweeted what I considered THE quote in the show:
“Because I really realized that I was being trained as a straight person, so I could really fool these people.” — Martin Boyce, speaking of how he was raised as a child. http://bit.ly/jzxvra
If this thing goes to court it really has to be found unconstitutional. How can you abrogate someone’s right to say something. That’s counter to the first amendment isn’t it?
Damn. This sucks and blows.
Someone should make a law and Lock Up anyone who says anything negative about The Gay…
Oh Wait-
They already did!….
CA Senate bill mandates gay history in schools
By LISA LEFF, Associated Press – Thu Apr 14, 2011 3:05 pm ET
SACRAMENTO, Calif. – Gays, lesbians, bisexuals and transgender people would be added to the lengthy list of social and ethnic groups that public schools must include in social studies lessons under a landmark bill passed Thursday by the California Senate.
If the bill is adopted by the state Assembly and signed by Gov. Jerry Brown, California would become the first state to require the teaching of gay history.
Supporters say the move is needed to counter anti-gay stereotypes and beliefs that make children in those groups vulnerable to bullying and suicide.
Opponents counter that such instruction would further burden an already crowded curriculum and expose students to a subject that some parents find objectionable.
The legislation, sponsored by Democratic Sen. Mark Leno of San Francisco, passed on a 23-14 party line vote. It also would add disabled people to the curriculum.
The bill gives school districts flexibility in deciding what to include in the lessons and at what grades students would receive them.
But starting in the 2013-14 school year, it would prohibit districts and the California Board of Education from using textbooks or other instructional materials that reflect adversely on gay, bisexual and transgender Americans.
.
That’s what we’re talking about-
In The Qunited States of Gaymerica THEY’LL LOCK YOUR ASS UP if you say anything that reflects “adversely” on The Gay…
26
It’s funny that Slog and Danny never had a peep to say about that-
being such Fierce Advocates for Freedom of Speech and all…….
26
“prohibit from using textbooks or other instructional materials that reflect adversely on gay…”
So.
In a courses on epidemiology or the history of AIDS you’ll never hear the name Gaëtan Dugas….
Studying Criminal justice? Don’t expect to hear about Jeffrey Dahmer or Frank Lombard.
The War on Terror? Don’t expect to learn about Bradley Manning…
.
Censorship is soooo much fun.
FUCK FREEDOM OF SPEECH!!!
26-28
sorry the type is so faint, kids-
the FUCKING SLOG THOUGHT POLICE
don’t want you exposed to any awkward ideas
that violate the HomoHumanistOrthodoxy….
This is Slog!
We suspend the accounts of anyone who asks awkward questions.
Hypocrisy is a fragile little fungus, after all-
the GLARING LIGHT OF TRUTH will wither that mutherfucker in a second…
@28: Thank you, Mrs. DePoint.
BEG, officially the age range is 14-24, but I’d say most are 16 and up. My concern was that for some of them, they aren’t out at school or at home, and who knows why/what messages they’re getting in those places, so to see something that would make me–as an adult–roll my eyes, I thought might be disturbing rather than ridiculous for them…the electro-shock, the documentaries (as dated as they are) and yes, that one more recently by the police officer. They don’t always have great weeks, for various reasons, and I just thought it might be too much…?
….What is that noise? It’s so faint, I can barely hear it…oh yes, it’s the poor unregistered off-topic troll, playing the world’s smallest violin under his bridge…
LOL. So nice to have the dumb little closet-case zapped with invisibility.
@16 While Harper and (I presume) is most of the Conservative MPs may have their own personal issues with homosexuality, I feel like the majority of Canadians support gay rights and would raise a fuss if gay rights went backwards.
Mind you, I’m from Vancouver and people from cities tend to be more open-minded. You have to keep in mind that the metropolitan areas of Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver make up 1/3 of Canada’s population, though.
@34: I am with you. I can’t see any kind of roll-back on the rights Canada has achieved. Things are too ingrained – it’s no longer a question of passively accepting prejudice. There would have to be deliberate, active steps taken to revoke people’s rights and I can’t see us standing for that.
35
That’s funny.
When Canadians get a Bill of Rights, Freedom of Speech and Press and quit funding Religion with public funds get back to us…..
@36: Sure thing.
All this and health care too. Suck it, troll.