Posted yesterday evening and moved up.
The ticker below is counting the arrests, dollars, and lost revenue our nation is racking up in its ridiculous war on pot. Perfect or not, Initiative 502 is the only viable campaign we’ve ever seen in Washington State to end these laws—and surmount a real challenge to federal prohibition—and the measure, as I reported yesterday, is on the road to making the 2012 ballot.
But some medical-marijuana patients have recently come out opposing I-502. As we reported when I-502 was filed in June, the measure backed by prosecutors and public-health leaders is the most cogent, competent effort in US history to legalize, tax, and regulate marijuana. Certain medical pot activists, however, are complaining that I-502 doesn’t allow people to grow pot at home (only buy it in stores), that it only allows adults to buy and possess one ounce of pot (patients could still have up to 24 ounces, but they say the one-ounce limit is too restrictive), and that a DUI provision is so toxic that the entire measure should be rejected. They’ve even launched a website called Patients Against I-502.
Edward Agazarm, one of the initiative’s loudest critics promoting the aforementioned website, sent an email the other day with a subject line declaring that I-502 was “rape by cops w/guns and the ACLU.”
“Rape”?
The “rape”—according to Agazarm—is that I-502 sets a per se cut-off for stoned driving. It would penalize drivers with 5 nanograms of THC per milliliter of blood with a gross misdemeanor. “That level is NOT supported by science and would subject patients to highly-invasive blood testing, unnecessary confinement and a criminal conviction that will haunt them for life,” the activists’ website says. They’re right that the science is minimal and some people could exceed that limit if they are regular medical-marijuana users.
But it’s dishonest to declare this this measure will subject people to more blood testing or result in a change of policing protocol. If voters pass I-502, officers would be held to the same standards as they are today: They would still require probable cause to stop a car, evidence of driver impairment, and any tests would have to be conducted by a medical professional (typically at a medical clinic or an ER). Those are the standards now, they wouldn’t change, and we hardly ever see those consequences for medical marijuana patients now because they aren’t impaired and cops don’t have probable cause to stop their vehicles. If cops didn’t have probable cause or evidence of impairment, but took action anyway, a defense attorney could move to have the whole thing tossed out—just like today.
Some medical marijuana patients note that the cut-off is automatic—anyone who exceeds 5n/mg is automatically guilty of DUI. But I-502 actually does something very useful for marijuana users accused of DUI. It separates active metabolites, which indicate inebriation, from THC-COOH, the inactive metabolite that remains in the system for days or weeks. In other words, it tests to see whether people are currently stoned, not simply whether they’ve used marijuana in the past month.
Why include the DUI language and the provision about only purchasing pot in licensed stores? So the initiative will pass. That’s what New Approach Washington’s polling showed would win (54 percent to 38 percent). That DUI provision alone prompted 62 percent of voters to say they were more likely to support I-502, and only 11 percent said it would make them less likely, according to a poll in May by Quinlan Rosner Research. And the critics should remember: Authorized patients could still grow, use, and exchange pot under the existing medical-marijuana law passed by voters in 1998.
Explaining why the DUI provisions, analogous to the blood-alcohol content limit at 0.08, were so persuasive with voters, New Approach Washington campaign director Alison Holcomb says: “Nobody likes people driving a two-ton piece of metal on the public highway while they are impaired and putting people at risk of death or serious injury. That is not acceptable in our society.”
Is this new measure the perfect package—is it an ideal scenario for marijuana users? No.
No law is ever perfect for everybody, and waiting for the perfect law means waiting forever without ever changing the horrible law.
But is I-502 winnable? Is it better than what we have now? Is it the best shot this country’s ever had at lowering those numbers that keep climbing in the ticker at the top of those post? Yes, yes, yes. It’s too bad that minor—and likely inconsequential—elements of the proposal are being twisted by a handful of “rape”-screaming, histrionic, would-be supporters to undermine their own movement.

Yes Dominic it is not perfect and you are right generally that is not the most important thing.
But with something like this particular bill it needs to be perfect.
If this bill passes and it does not work out well (because it IS ill-conceived, not written well) it could lead to a quick repeal as well as make it even harder for other legalization efforts around the country.
Whichever big state or city leads the way, they HAVE to do it right, or it will hurt the cause more than help it.
I don’t get how one ounce is too restrictive… thats a lot of damn weed! and its not like you couldn’t go to the store for more, plus 24 oz for medical mj patients should hold just about anyone over, cheech and chong included, for like 6 months minimum (unless you’re dealing that is)
So ride a bike instead.
What whiners …
Will @#3,
Bicyclists are oblicated to follow all traffic laws, including those regarding intoxication (“are obligated to” != “do”, of course). Your broader point about whiners is entirely correct.
In before the SensibleWashington trolls show up.
Thanks Dom. I mean, Alison laid all this out when she announced the initiative, so people could have paid some attention there, or given a reasonable response. Instead we have histrionic vitriol and “trust me I’m a lawyer” from Doug and co. Good job guys. Way to stay focused on the goal of keeping thousands of Washingtonians out of jail each year.
i’m highly skeptical of the validity of the blood test. i read a letter from a medical marijuana patient who tested @ 13 (5 is the limit) 15 hours after smoking. looks like we are giving the cops another hammer to pound us w/ whenever they feel like it. and don’t give me that probably cause bullshit. this is america. cops have probable cause whenever they say to the judge that they felt they had it. the interpretations of this law that i’ve seen basically is that it makes it legal to be a pot smoker or be a driver. not smoke or drive. but be a smoker or be a driver. that’s a bad law & a tool that we can’t trust the cops w/ at all.
Here’s a question: Say we legalize MJ here in Washington state. Leaving aside the conflict with the Federal laws for the moment, wouldn’t MJ arrests actually go up then, because people would still be growing/selling/smoking so-called ‘bootleg’ MJ?
I mean, from all the MJ that’s around right now, the state receives no tax dollars. But for tax revenue to start rolling into state coffers, wouldn’t they have to crack down on the citizens’ grow ops? Wouldn’t they have to crack down on the people still buying from the black market (which is, at present, the ONLY market)?
See what I’m saying? I don’t want anybody’s head cracked over MJ, but my concern over legalization is that, once it’s in the Hands of The Man, won’t The Man really really want all that juicy tax money, at the expense of us poor punters who’ve been smoking the stuff right along?
This does not surprise me in this day and age of privilege …. not one bit.
It never ceases to amaze me the vehemence with which people can disagree with others who share common goals. The curse of being a “liberal” city is that the lefties are constantly at each others throats.
Well put, Dom. The important numbers are at the top of the page, ticking away; NOT the .5 nanograms or whatever bullshit. That can all be modified down the road.
@4: Nope.
I don’t understand how they can see the current situation as better than the proposed situation. Because that is exactly what they are advocating for.
This sounds like a good law.
@7 You must be smoking some good shit…
Boy, when I see someone use the word “rape” to describe a political/social issue, I just drop everything I’m doing & hang on their every word. If I don’t, surely, humanity will be destroyed.
New Approach Washington campaign director Alison Holcomb says: “Nobody likes people driving a two-ton piece of metal on the public highway while they are impaired and putting people at risk of death or serious injury. That is not acceptable in our society.”
Can you remind us who exactly is being “histrionic” here, Dominic?
Here are two scientific studies about cannabis and automobile crashes:
“There is no evidence that consumption of cannabis alone increases the risk of culpability for traffic crash fatalities or injuries for which hospitalization occurs – and may reduce those risks.”
M. Bates et. al. “Role of cannabis in motor vehicle crashes.”
http://epirev.oxfordjournals.org/content…
“The results to date of crash culpability studies have failed to demonstrate that drivers with cannabinoids in the blood are significantly more likely than drug-free drivers to be culpable in road crashes.
G. Chesher et. al. “Cannabis and alcohol in motor vehicle accidents.”
http://www.amazon.com/Cannabis-Cannabino…
You can find all this information – and more – at http://www.patientsagainsti502.org
Dominic – there are several doctors, lawyers and patient advocates who are willing to go on record should you decide to cover this issue in an unbiased fashion from here on out.
The feds will not go for this and will come in to stop the legal cannabis stores where people are supposed to go buy their ounces. If that happened, all we would be left with is 28 grams decriminalized, but no legal way to produce it or purchase it, and the DUI nanogram limit that is “0” for anyone under the age of 21, and “5” for anyone over the age of 21.
I have been keeping up with the Patients against New Approach Washington through their facebook paqe for several months now, and I really have not seen any patients comment that they are concerned, as this article points out, that this law only allows adults to buy and possess one ounce of pot. I haven’t noticed any comments about the fact that I-502 doesn’t allow people to grow pot at home, either, like this article claims. Patients know they would be unaffected by these issues, so it seems disingenuous that these items are included in the list of the patients concerns.
You are correct that Patients Against New Approach Washington are very concerned about the DUI part, and we thank you very much for the plug for our website! We are very disappointed that the writers and funders of this law have decided that patients in our state have to lose more of their rights in trade for a law that will not accurately test for impairment. What is frustrating as a patient, is being told to accept this loss of my rights when the reason I have to lose this right is a fraud, and the writers and the funders know this. There is no basis in science that can show a patient is impaired at 5 nanograms, but it was added to the law to ease voters fears, so the law can pass. Promoters of I-502 claim that law enforcement need probable cause to pull someone over, but a tail light out can get you pulled over, and patients frequently smell of cannabis, having recently picked up their medication, so the smell alone is enough to give police reason to believe the patient may be intoxicated, prompting a blood test. As the article points out, the way most of this will be handled is the same as it is now, that is not what would be changed. What would change is that the patient who would most likely test higher than 5 nanograms will no longer have a defense from being guilty of a DUI as they do currently, because currently there is no amount specified for a limit.
@15, cite all the research you want, but I can assure you that I have been stoned enough before that I was totally incapable of safely driving a vehicle. And I know lots of other people who have too. There is no way you can convince me, or the general public, that it is perfectly safe to drive while high as a kite.
As a strong supporter of full legalization, I am also realistic enough to understand that there is no way we will ever pass this in WA or any other state without some sort of DUI component. We can quibble about the details of the exact level at which this should occur, but you are living in a fantasy if you think you’ll ever get legalization without a DUI provision of some sort. Historically, the level of alcohol necessary to be considered impaired has changed over time, and is different in different states. It is reasonable to expect the same with marijuana. If they set a limit that you don’t like, advocate to change the limit; don’t kill the law entirely.
@15, I think you bring up a very important point and it deserves serious attention. I’m very curious, however, how you respond to @12. Despite the flaws regarding DUI, is the current situation better than the situation would be if the initiative passed? If so, how?
Let’s say it does pass. Wouldn’t you then be able to address the problems regarding DUI and home growing restrictions?
In Cali where I live, many of the medical cannabis folks were against the legalization initiative in 2010 because it would cause the price of marijuana to drop. Perhaps similar motives here?
@18 – Many problems can be addressed (and improved) down the road. Home growing is one of those things, so is the one ounce limit. The DUI statute is a totally different story. Once a THC level is set in stone, it will only be revised downward – much like BAC has been ratcheted down from .10 to .08. Fighting to raise the THC level implemented by I-502 would be political suicide. That’s why it is so important to get this particular provision right the first time.
Is the situation better now than it would be under I-502? That depends entirely on whether you use cannabis for recreational purposes, medicinal purposes or if you are under 21. If you are over 21, use cannabis for recreational purposes and don’t plan on possessing more than one ounce – you might benefit from I-502. But if you are under 21 or want to grow your own or want to buy in bulk or you are a medical cannabis patient, you will be WORSE OFF under I-502 than you are today.
Current state law for possession is a misdemeanor for up to 40 grams. Under this bill, anything over 28 grams is a FELONY!
Why was this necessary?
What possible reason could you have for making penalties harsher than current state law?
Can you see where some may question the ethical standards of I-502’s author(s) and supporters?
@21: “Can you see where some may question the ethical standards of I-502’s author(s) and supporters?”
Sorry, no. What I do see is a bunch of self-interested, pull the ladder up after they’ve climbed it, bullshit from some in the med-MJ community.
Fifteen years ago it seemed like med MJ might serve as the camel’s nose under the tent of prohibition and that med MJ might incrementally lead to other drug reforms.
Now, however, we have some in the med community who are little more than self-promoting idiots actively working to thwart serious drug policy reform under the guise of protecting patients. They’re lying sacks of shit who are trying to protect their little fiefdom at the expense of the hundreds of thousands of others who suffer each and every year under prohibition. If they won’t look out for the greater good, fuck ’em.
Dominic you’re not quite being completely forthright with the information you’re spreading (it’s not entirely surprising considered you used to work for Alison Holcomb at the ACLU);
“It separates active metabolites, which indicate inebriation, from THC-COOH, the inactive metabolite that remains in the system for days or weeks. In other words, it tests to see whether people are currently stoned, not simply whether they’ve used marijuana in the past month.”
That is completely misleading. The 5 ng limit is in no way an indicator of someone being “currently stoned”, as a patient or regular smoker can stop smoking for 10, 12 hours or more and still fail the test easily (http://blogs.westword.com/latestword/201…).
This is not only an extremely unfair system, but this exact limit was rejected because of a lack of consensus in a working group commissioned by the Colorado Legislature specifically to cover this issue: http://blogs.westword.com/latestword/201…
For those under 21 it would be a complete zero tolerance policy (recklessly refusing to acknowledge that you can be a patient in this state under 21), meaning patients ages 16-20 could fail a DUI test days after smoking. This seems to be a mandate that lacks compassion. Taking away the driving privileges of smokers, even when they’re not impaired, is not fair policy. Individuals can claim that if you drive fine, then you’ll be fine, but that’s clearly not true when you give police officers such power over cannabis consumers, who many of them harass to begin with (and with I-502’s strict liability limit, if you test over the 5 ngs you’re completely void of any legal defense).
For those questioning whether the situation is worse now than it would be under I-502, the answer is clearly yes. For one, the distribution system is legally void as it’s instantly preemptable by the Federal Government, for a number of reasons (one of the most obvious being that it forces the state to collect taxes from an item on the Federal Controlled Substance List). So, what you’re left with after an easy victory for the feds in court is a legal exception to possess an ounce and a terrible DUID statute that will prosecute a large amount of innocent drivers and patients, wherein most instances getting a DUID is far worse than getting caught with an ounce or less of cannabis.
I think people need to look deeply into this initiative and the science behind their proposed DUID statutes before putting their support behind this initiative (here’s an interesting article on the subject by Seattle Weekly Columnist and Tokeofthetown.com Founder Steve Elliott; http://www.thejointblog.com/naw-dui-limi…). If I-502 is accepted as a reasonable method to reform our cannabis laws, it will set the entire movement backs years.
gnossos @22 ftw!
For once, Dom, can you just give us an accurate, factual analysis rather than pushing some fucking agenda?
Face it – the authors of I-502 fucked up by including the 5 nanogram clause. This initiative does in fact make the situation worse than it is today (at least if you live in Seattle, where we don’t prosecute for simple possession, and pretty much anyone can get an MMJ card).
Bummer.
@ 25 Without that DUI provision it might not had a chance at passing. It seems simple, if you are high don’t drive.
The visit was useful. Content was really very informative. visit giftwithlove dot com(Online Florists).
@26: if you are high don’t drive
Wrong, the initiative says if you’ve smoked weed anytime in the past week, don’t drive.
This law is fucking disaster. No one who supports MJ rights should vote for this.
@28 sounds like plenty of people are though
@26 you say “Without that DUI provision it might not had a chance at passing….”
That is an opinion that is being forwarded by the promoters of this initiative. In reality, that DUI provision will be the fatal flaw, and this “legalization initiative” will not pass because of it.
P.S. The newapproachwa.org web site claims that science has demonstrated that THC impairs driving skills. That’s not true.
The only studies that show any THC effects are those using computer simulations. Studies involving actual drivers behind the wheels of actual cars show that while stoned drivers often self-report that their driving seems impaired, their actual performance is as good or better than “sober” drivers.
@30 – They back it up with polling, or did you miss that part?
I love how the mmj patients think they’re the only people who smoke every day. There are thousands more users than just the mmj patients, and they, and the non-smokers who think Prohibition needs to end, support this initiative.
@10: That can all be modified down the road.
Once the 5 ng DUI threshold is established, there’s no way in hell the limit will ever be increased, regardless of what the science says. It’s just not politically feasible.
And the fact that 5 ng doesn’t meet any scientific standard of impairment is legally irrelevant to anyone seeking to challenge a DUI arrest. The law is the law.
@22 – Patients Against I-502 in no way opposes legalization. In fact, many of us have personally pounded the pavement collecting signatures for legalization initiatives.
Unfortunately, I-502 is not legalization. It is an extension of prohibition. We cannot support a law that empowers police and prosecutors to harass, unnecessarily confine, wrongfully convict and brand cannabis users with a criminal record for life.
in addition to sending SOBER drivers to jail for DUI, I-502 actually requires licensed producers, processors and distributors to admit -in writing- to conspiring to break FEDERAL drug laws. It then requires state officials to cooperate with FEDERAL law enforcement.
You might as well call I-502 the “law enforcement wish list.”
I haven’t smoked in years, but way back when, the joke was (and it really wasn’t a joke) that the police could spot us a mile away on the highway. We were the ones driving 45 mph in a 65 mph zone on the expressway.
Unlike alcohol, which impairs your ability, including your ability to assess your ability, MJ tells you your ability is impaired probably even more so than it is.
All intoxicants are not the same. Alcohol is a central nervous system depressant that affects all the tissue in your body and significantly slows reflexes. MJ is a hypnotic and fucks with a different part of your brain, but doesn’t have the same biochemical effect on nerves. You’re much more likely to have a decent self-assessment of your capabilities on MJ.
That said, the shit you kids smoke today is probably stronger than the hashish we got back then.
@4 on roads maybe. Not on bike trails.
P.S.: As to feds showing up …
I know exactly how many feds there are, and how many are assigned to WA, OR, and CA.
Not that many.
It’s not the feds, it’s the Cities, Counties, and States providing policing and court resources to them to bust people for MJ.
End that, end that overtime, zero out those budget lines, and require a 2/3 majority vote of the people to authorize overtime for helping feds bust anyone for MJ.
Problem solved. Trillions of tax dollars saved.
5 ng/ml active THC is a fairly conservative cutoff, but it could have been worse.
Based on the pharmacokinetic data I’ve seen, the populations that would have 5 ng/ml in their blood are 1) people who have smoked within the last 1-4 hours, 2) people who have eaten some in the past 2-8 hours, and 3) regular, fairly heavy user, pretty much all the time up until several days’ abstinence.
Obviously the latter group is the most problematic (the other two are very likely impaired, and I don’t really have a problem with them getting hit with a DUI if they are.) However, chronic users at that level are much less likely to be impaired at levels near the 5 ng/ml cutoff, and thus less likely to be pulled over in the first place, as Dominic points out.
The pro se DUI provision is definitely not ideal, but I wouldn’t let it be a case of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good.
Decriminalizing 1 ounce isn’t groundbreaking (up to one ounce is a violation carrying a fine, not a crime, in Oregon).
I think others are right that, in light of the tightening of other restrictions, the net effect of this initiative could easily be negative with respect to enforcement.
@25 – I-502’s DUI provisions have nothing to do with being “high” or “stoned” (as Dominic Holden would have you believe).
I-502 makes it illegal to drive with a certain level of THC in your blood, even if you are not impaired in the slightest. For those under 21, I-502 implements a level of 0.00. That means an unimpaired designated driver could be convicted of DUI, simply for being in the presence of secondhand marijuana smoke.
How do you feel about having a needle stuck into your arm and your body tissue being extracted by police, after being pulled over for a brake light being out on your way home from buying your legal ounce? The moment police smell marijuana, you can guarantee they will be hauling your happy ass off to the hospital for a blood test. YES, IT HAPPENS NOW.
The key difference between the current laws and I-502 is the burden of proof required to CONVICT you of DUI. Under I-502, prosecutors will not have to prove you were impaired (as they do today). They will only have to prove that you exceeded a 5 ng/ml limit if your are 21 and over or a 0.00 limit if you are under 21. Again, you can be stone-cold sober and get a DUI, simply because of the contents of your blood.
Any money saved by I-502’s exception for one ounce will be immediately depleted by blood testing and court costs associated with convicting innocent people of DUI.
The above comment was directed at 26 (Democrat1234) NOT 25 (seandr)
@19: No, there is no profit motive behind opposing I-502 on behalf of Patients Against I-502. This is strictly an ethical position to oppose re-criminalizing MMJ patients.
@3: “Whiners” – really? I happen to know patients that are alive today because they chose a medicinal herb called cannabis for their treatment. Without their medicine, some will die.
The per se statute sets automatic guilt; and 5ng/mL is too low – all the evidence confirms this. Any patient found guilty under this new statute will be deprived of their life saving medicine through mandatory drug rehabilitation, and drivers license suspension as an automatic penalty; not to mention potential finical ruin associated with fines, lawyer, and court fees.
Zero tolerance for under 21 means anyone in the vicinity of cannabis smoke could test above 0.00 – without having used at all. This is the college age set, who will be exposed to marijuana use. Aside from the hardships mentioned in the above paragraph, this segment of the population stands to lose education funding for being found guilty of traces of a federally illegal substance in their blood stream.
To say that police would need “probable cause” is also BS. To ignore that profiling occurs is to remain woefully ignorant of reality. We know that marijuana use is heaviest among whites, yet 80% of marijuana incarcerations are minorities, specifically blacks.
Why the racial disparity, if not for profiling from law enforcement?
For further proof that probable cause is a fallacy, please read: < http://www.nydailynews.com/news/ny_crime… >
I-502 is an extension of prohibition, not an answer to it. If it were to pass, we would have decrim for < 28 grams, with no legal means of obtaining marijuana. Anyone applying for a “legal” cannabis business license will be admitting that they are about to commit a federal crime. The proposed taxation levels, combined with federal preemption will only exacerbate an illegal black market, not deter it.
This creates a perfect storm to ramp up the war on marijuana in Washington State, while providing law enforcement with a tool to find “suspects”. No self-respecting legalization advocate can support this bill.
For me, it comes down to one simple issue. Does I-502 convict drivers who are not impaired but have THC metabolites in their blood? It appears that impairment is not an issue, you can be convicted on your blood levels alone. How can that be OK? How are the other features in this initiative worth that?
I-502 appeases people’s fears, but shows no clear data that there is a serious issue from drivers with THC in their blood. Once again, it is appeasing the fears of people who have no experience with pot (for political expediency) rather than addressing a demonstrated public danger. Nobody thinks that impaired drivers should be on the road. That is agreed. I-502 simply does not address impaired driving at all. Where is the science?
Let’s see the studies, read the science, and create some model that convicts drivers who are impaired, not anyone who has smoked pot that day, or week, or month! There are great people who I respect greatly championing I-502, and it is painful opposing them on this issue, but this is the fight we have been engaged in for decades, and we cannot make a mistake as deep as this. This bill is what law enforcement wants. This bill offers law enforcement a trade-off. It makes law enforcement a deal. That is what the DIU provision is.
Is it a good law? In some ways. Can it result in non-impaired drivers being convicted of a new law (driving under the influence of cannabis)? Read the bill yourself.
@40@43@44 — I don’t buy it. There’s been a lot of people smoking a lot of pot in this state for a lot of years. Where’re all these supposed cases of happy asses getting hauled off to the hospital to get their blood drawn? I think you’re brewing a tempest in a teapot.
@45
Somehow setting a limit higher than current law (5ng per L is more than “any”) means more people will get busted, in their eyes. No mention of the current law and how many get busted for DUI in the same way as they would under 502.
@45 – Don’t believe people are getting pulled over for brake lights being out and hauled off to the hospital to get their blood drawn? Here ya go:
http://www.thejointblog.com/naw-dui-limi…
See the example of the local patient who was pulled over after a day spent trimming her personal crop. Her taillight was out, the cop smelled pot and she’s now getting bent over a barrel by the Skagit County courts. NOTE: The Drug Recognition Expert (DRE) in this case agreed that this driver was unimpaired.
The only difference between the above scenario and what will happen once I-502 is passed is that prosecutors currently have to PROVE the above patient was impaired. Under I-502, this patient will be automatically found guilty due to her blood reading of 18.5 ng/ml.
Let’s stop and think about this for a second. 18.5 ng/ml and the DRE said she was unimpaired! That’s almost 4 times the limit proposed in I-502. If this THC level is truly “analogous” to BAC like I-502 supporters suggest – this patient would probably be dead, not standing on the roadside completing sobriety tests with the DRE’s approval.
Still not convinced? See the independent analysis from 2 local DUI defense attorneys here:
http://www.seattlecriminallawyerblog.com…
http://www.seattlecriminallawyerblog.com…
Once again, all this information can be found at our website: http://www.patientsagainsti502.org
It’s time that sponsors of I-502 quit pushing their junk science to throw medical cannabis patients to the wolves simply to get their idea of legalization passed by the voters
There are plenty of REAL scientific studies out their that totally contradict the idea that you can judge impairment simply by calculating the THC level in a driver’s blood
The authoritative Consensus Report of NIDA’s Research Technology Branch (“Drug Concentrations and Driving Impairment (published in the Journal of American Medical Association) said:
“What is known about correlations between driving impairment and drug concentration? – Except for ethanol, determinations of drug concentrations in body fluids are at present of limited value for establishing driving impairment…”
The blood concentration of THC is meaningless as any predictor of psychomotor effect. Dr. Barry Beyerstein of Simon Frazer University said, “The relationship between THC (the psychoactive ingredient in marijuana) levels in blood and impairment of eye-hand coordination, reaction time and other components of driving skill is not a straightforward one. Also, individual differences of impairment among different users are so great that it would be very difficult to set a fair legal standard of impairment that would apply to everyone.” This is the same conclusion which the U.S. Department of Transportation reached.
The FDA approved package insert language for Marinol that driving and operating heavy equipment after use of synthetic Delta 9 THC is permissible. So will everyone on Marinol be guilty of DUI as well, even though the FDA believes that it’s safe?
National Highway Safety Study 1993
According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration study titled “Marijuana and Actual Driving performance” (published November 1993), “THC’s adverse effects on driving performance appear relatively small” and “Evidence from the present and previous studies strongly suggests that alcohol encourages risky driving, whereas THC encourages greater caution.”
According to this study, it is not possible to conclude anything about a driver’s impairment on the basis of his/her plasma concentrations of THC and THC-COOH determined in a single sample.
A 1993 study of cannabis and driving (Robbe & O’Hanlon, 1993) which was sponsored by the U.S. National Highway Safety Traffic Administration included a review of the literature. The authors’ comments in summary of their literature review and of their own results include the following:
The foremost impression one gains from reviewing the literature is that no clear relationship has ever been demonstrated between marijuana smoking and either seriously impaired driving performance or the risk of accident involvement. The epidemiological evidence, as limited as it is, shows that the combination of THC and alcohol is over- represented in injured and dead drivers, and moreso in those who actually caused the accidents to occur. Yet there is little if any evidence to indicate that drivers who have used marijuana alone are any more likely to cause serious accidents than drug-free drivers.
The U.S. Transportation study results were more than confirmed by a 1998 Australian study of 2500 injured drivers which found that drivers who use marijuana are less likely to cause road accidents than drunk drivers or even drug-free drivers. This goes even further than the Australian Government Report (1996) “There is no controlled epidemiological evidence that cannabis users are at increased risk of being involved in motor vehicle or other accidents.”
A study from Tilburg, The Netherlands reported in May 2004, “Researchers at the St. Elisabeth Hospital in the Netherlands estimated the association between drug use and motor vehicle accidents by conducting a prospective observational case-controlled study. Cases were drivers involved in road crashes requiring hospitalization. Controls were drivers recruited at random while driving on public roads.
Authors found that driver’s risk for road trauma significantly increased with the use of benzodiazepines and alcohol. Increased risks, although not statistically significant, were also assessed for drivers using amphetamines, cocaine, or opiates. The authors concluded that,
“No increased risk for road trauma was found for drivers exposed to cannabis.”
I care for an 18 year old patient with osteosarcoma (bone cancer). Under this law, with a zero percent tolerance, he would have to stop using his medication or stop driving himself to the doctor.
The truth here is that thousands of medical marijuana patients across the state will be criminalized the day this legislation is passed. Few patients will ever have less than 5 ng/ml in their systems. They will have no defense in court. They will have to stop medicating, stop driving, or risk jail. On average, a DUI costs a driver around $10,000.
With thousands of medical marijuana patients on the roads here in Washington every day, where are all of the traffic accidents being caused by their 5 ng/ml impairment? Are we passing this new DUI limit to solve a public safety problem that simply doesn’t exist?
It’s time that Dominic and Holcomb started telling the public the truth about their intentions. They are happy to throw medical cannabis patients under the bus if they think it will get them the votes they need to pass their seriously flawed legislation. Where’s the compassion for patients in this law?
Steve Sarich
CannaCare
steve@cannacare.org
@47 — So why is that patient getting bent over a barrel under the CURRENT law? She should walk, right? The prosecutor never should have even charged her with DUI in the first place, right? Especially with the DRE saying she was unimpaired and such.
Sorry, not seeing how this helps your argument.
I wish I could post Figure 1 from this paper here:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20112…
Because it really illustrates how quickly plasma THC (not metabolites) levels peak and recede after smoking. The legend may be somewhat helpful:
“Fig. 1 Plasma levels of total
Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC;
N=12) after smoking a cannabis
cigarette standardized to 7%
THC. Peak plasma concentrations
(Cmax) of 4.2–59.1 ng/mL
(20.9±16.9 ng/mL) occurred at
tmax of 5 min. Minimum detectable
amounts (greater than or
equal to the limit of detection,
LOD) were measured at 10–
360 min.”
The mean in this group was well below 5 ng/ml 20 minutes after smoking. (This was a group or people with a negative urine test before the study, but included causal cannabis users. )
Even though the baseline and peak are going to be different in different individuals, and with varying strengths of cannabis consumed, the general shape of the curve is going to be the same for almost everyone. Fast peak, relatively rapid falloff due (primarily) to metabolism.
Steve @48 is absolutely correct that it is very difficult to establish strong correlation between plasma THC and subjective impairment. (Especially compared to alcohol, where the correlation is supported by mountains of data and is really quite predictable.) In large part, this is because of a relative lack of studies actually having been performed.
But it does not follow from that that people are not acutely impaired by consuming sufficient amounts of cannabis. Anyone who has smoked more than a few good puffs *knows* that this is the case. (Just because you have successfully driven stoned doesn’t mean you weren’t impaired. Just lucky that nothing requiring rapid decision making happened.)
There has to be *some* provision to deal with potential/likely impaired driving. I’m not arguing that the 5 ng/ml cutoff is ideal. But I don’t think it rises to the level of forestalling an otherwise excellent step in the right direction.