While I’m sure Jen’s Egyptian friend is awesome, Jen’s friend didn’t choose to start wearing the veil ten years ago in some sort of social, religious, political, and cultural vacuum. The history of the veil in Egypt is a bit more complicated than Jen’s post makes it sound. (To say nothing of the history of the last ten years.) Jen’s friend is no more immune to the larger cultural forces swirling around her in Egypt—the larger majority-cultural forces swirling around her in Egypt—than, say, white people are immune to the larger majority-cultural forces that swirl around us in the United States.
Jen’s friend is free to wear that veil, of course, if she so chooses, and I’m sure she put more thought into her choice to don the veil than could possibly be conveyed in a single blog post. But I hope she put more thought into it than just, “I AM A MUSLIM AND PROUD!” (And… um… I guess I’m assuming that Jen’s Egyptian friend lives in Egypt, where Muslims are the majority. Isn’t screaming/capping “I AM [insert majority race/religion/sexual orientation here] AND PROUD!” considered a just bit—what? Tactless? Jingoistic? Xenophobic? I mean, it’s not okay—and I really mean it: it is not okay—when white/Christian/straight folks here in the majority white/Christian/straight US of A scream/cap “I AM WHITE/CHRISTIAN/STRAIGHT AND PROUD!” Jen’s friend’s blog has an international audience, I realize, and it’s in English, so perhaps it’s unfair to view it as somehow existing or being read in a majority Muslim context. But I have to wonder how statements like “I AM MUSLIM AND PROUD!” on an Egyptian blogger’s site go over with, ayedunno, Egyptian Copts?)
And while we’re on the subject of veils and Egyptian women… I spent some weeks in Egypt in the early 1990s and I didn’t see a single woman wearing the veil the entire time I was in Cairo. It wasn’t until I got to southern Egypt—practically Sudan—that I saw women wearing veils. When I got back to Berlin, where I was living at the time, I asked an Egyptian woman who worked at the US Army school where I taught German (a language I couldn’t speak; God bless the US Army) why I only saw women in southern Egypt wearing veils.
“Because veils are for Africans,” she said.
“But… aren’t you an African?” I asked.
“I am not,” she replied. “I am a Mediterranean.”
I’d say there were some powerful cultural forces at work on my Egyptian friend too, back in the day.

wow, you did a lot of things. you were in the army?
I used to wear a cross every day. Was that insulting to anyone who wasn’t a Catholic Christian? No. “I’m X/Y/Z and I’m proud” is sometimes spoken rather than screamed.
I checked out the actual post, to which Jen provides a link. I think the capitalized statement is actually addressed to Egyptians who are telling her what to do–the more “liberal” ones telling her she’ll benefit from going abroad because she’ll stop wearing her hijab, and the more conservative one telling her not to stop wearing it.
You used to teach German?!?!?!
@3, thanks for clicking through as you did. I did some roaming around there the first time Jen linked to her. It’s not in English only at all – she posts in Arabic and French as well. One of her posts in English last year speaks directly to Dan’s musings:
http://hebaelcheikh.wordpress.com/2010/1…
When Jen’s friend refers to wearing “the veil”, does she refer to a hair covering (which 90% of Egyptian women wear), or to an actual veil, like the niqab? If she’s chosen to wear a literal veil, I can assure you there’s no internal pressure in her culture telling her to wear it. There have been attempts to ban it.
A former Egyptian coworker of mine talked about how when he was growing up in the 70s and 80s that he never, ever saw women wearing the veil. He was convinced its popularity came about as a counterpoint to the repeated humiliation of Arabs by the wars with Israel and was therefore 100% political.
Just remember kids, it’s ok to be who you are and who you want to be. Gay, straight, Christian, atheist. Unless you’re a Muslim. Then you’re just a terrorist/brainwashed bitch with no will of your own, and any decisions you make are part of, oh hell, who the fuck knows what Dan is even hinting at.
Point is – be proud of who you are! Unless you’re a Muslim. Then you need to either change or be condemned.
@5 much of that post makes me sad.
are the birds free of the chains of the skyway?
Muslim women wearing veils and claiming to be free and liberated remind me 100% of white people proudly displaying Confederate flags and claiming not to be racist.
Maaaaaaaaaybe you are/aren’t, but I’m having a really hard time believing you.
If you have to convince others you are free then maybe you really aren’t so free?
Dan,
I was just in Egypt last year and I saw many Egyptian women from Alexandria to Abu Simbel, Arab and African wearing the full “chador” or the gown and veil covering everything on the woman save for their eyes which sometimes had a net across the slit for the eye opening. I wasn’t surprised.
However, I am surprised and not necessarily pleased that I see it here in America. In fact, in Sunday’s Seattle Times local section or maybe the magazine (?), I saw a photo of a women wearing one at what the caption said was an “all American BBQ”. That attire seems to be increasing too. I only started seeing it Seattle and Chicago where I’m from during the past ten years.
I remain dubious of Jen’s friend reasoning. It is far easier for her (Jen’s friend or Jen herself) to wear the burqua in Egypt than here in the USA. But, it would be foolish for Jen to wear anything less than a long sleeve white blouse and long skirt in Egypt. BTW, I was accompanied by two beautiful Canadian women on my trip. They sported bikinis at the hotel pool in Aswan. But they made damn sure they wore more modest attire when outside the hotel.
I just don’t understand why she doesn’t want to walk around in jeans and tshirts with ironic pictures on them all the time. C’mon!
Nothing like a muslim woman telling her own story and a white man mansplaining it to her.
Proud to be religious.
“I mean, it’s not okay—and I really mean it: it is not okay—when white/Christian/straight folks here in the majority white/Christian/straight US of A scream/cap “I AM WHITE/CHRISTIAN/STRAIGHT AND PROUD!”
but it is OK to have Gay Pride?
really?
just what we would expect.
your Tshirt is in the mail, Danny…
it says:
“I AM INTOLERANT/BIGOTED/NARROWMINDED AND PROUD!”
@11 That doesn’t make a lick of sense.
We covered this last semester in Global Feminisms; our professor studies Muslim women in Europe and the US, and with everything that was happening in Egypt this Spring, it was a natural focus. Older Egyptian women are not particularly likely to wear the veil, as there was a sort of liberal, secularizing cultural wave, and the sudden relaxing of cultural norms requiring hijab impelled many women to cast off the veil. Wearing the (any form) is increasing in frequency among the younger generations, as a show of Muslim or Arab solidarity, especially among activists opposing Western cultural hegemony or corporate hegemony.
@15: That’s not what I heard. I heard Dan saying that politics of difference are inherently divisionary and can breed extremism. To use the USA comparison, not everyone who drives a pickup covered in USA flag stickers and watches FOX News for the pro-White-Christian-nationalist messages is going to go out lynching people or blow up a federal building, but a culture of people identifying strongly and actively with the predominant ethnic/cultural group creates a safe space for extremists who vilify the other. In the same way that the Neoconfederate/Tea Party/White Christian Nationalist sentiment here provides cover for extremists like Timothy McVehy or Scott Roeder or gay-bashers etc., Arab or Muslim Nationalist identities/movements provide cover for extremists like the vigilante gangs of “religious police” in Iran or Saudi Arabia or Pakistan or Syria and groups like al-Qaeda or the more militant factions of Hezbollah.
Identity politics is inherently problematic, as it foregrounds differences between people as more important than similarities. While it’s sometimes a necessary survival tactic for marginalized or oppressed groups, it is, as Dan points out, a rather different issue when it’s the dominant cultural group that’s pushing identity politics, as this serves primarily to reinforce normative privilege dynamics and marginalize all ‘other’ groups. Even reading the original post, I don’t have enough information to do a fair discursive analysis on any count, but Dan’s statement doesn’t strike me as necessarily inaccurate nor drawing any sort of false parallel. Your overly-simplistic re-framing of the statement is especially unfortunate given that Dan actually expanded the complexity and nuance by bringing both time- and location- relative cultural frames and pressures into the discussion. Which, frankly, I thought was a little surprising, given that Dan is on occasion prone to unconscious White/male/American-centric perspectives, and here he’s busting out some fully-realized considerations of cultural contexts and the limits of cultural relativism.
Did you think at all before you posted this?
It sounds to me like she’s trying to throw her voice into an international discussion in which foreigners, mostly non-muslims, indicate how she should dress.
As for “the veil,” there are varying degrees of covering. I’d say niqabs aren’t even african–they’re popular in the gulf, and have spread. Hijabs are pretty overwhelmingly popular among Muslim women in Egypt, particularly when we’re talking about women who aren’t part of the elite.
This sort of conversation frustrates me pretty intensely, because too often, it’s filled with non-Muslims, mostly men, telling Muslim women how they should think and dress themselves. The reason the hijab has become such a hot topic issue is its history of Westerners focusing on it. As a result, it became a symbol of resistance against westernization for some. There are other productive ways of conceptualizing modest attire in Islam, but since westerners keep shouting about hijabs, it’s become something more important than it was in the past. Let’s just allow women to dress themselves and leave it at that.
Hi everyone!
To clarify: Heba calls it a veil, but it only covers her hair, unless she has changed it since I last saw her.
To clarify further: It’s a stretch to accuse Heba of xenophobia without doing some simplifying yourself. Heba’s a minority within a Muslim majority.
My post was a simple show of support for a woman trying to figure out her relationship to the complex powers around her on her own terms.
I don’t know what’s right for Heba. Rather, I’m pretty sure Heba would know that better than I do.
(Furthermore, Heba’s audience is tiny and her post was a personal statement, not an incitement to political action. Her blog is mainly for the people in her life. Therefore, when she writes that post, she is writing to the people in her life, asking them to stop pretending that they care about her decisions when in truth they’re projecting their own anxieties about the veil onto her.)
Man, I love it when white people argue about what nonwhite people are thinking. It’s like watching the cast of Fox and Friends having a circle-jerk behind the garage.
@22: What I meant to say.
(Also, Dan, I love it when you school me on the fact that women have histories!)
Religions clinging to centuries-old instituted differences in modesty requirements (“for thee but not for me” saith a male prophet) as symbol of their “holiness” are a good argument for atheism, as are religions introducing celibacy as a vow requirement because one religious leader had so many illegitimate children a thousand years ago that the church lost significant assets owing to property successorship laws.
Progressive writers and thinkers have this unfortunate tendency to swoon at the feet of reactionary douchebags in/from third world countries. Apparently, to liberal white people with a lotta money, barbaric behavior is not only totally tolerable, but absolutely necessary from such savages or WOGs as you’re likely to find in the colonies (irony, you idiots).
Some French intellectuals still insist that crimes against Poles are minutiae as all Poles are supposed anti-Semitic.
The left, just as well as the right, does some significant mental gymnastics to avoid conceiving contradictions in its own dogma.
Dan: The history of veiling is far longer and more complex than this article can ever begin to cover. First and foremost a better understanding of the practice of veiling can be found in Fatima Mernissi’s “The Veil and the Male elite” which follows the practice of veiling since pre-islamic periods. It’s been a few years since I read her book but I remember it actually being a Jewish practice, which was adopted by a jealous/annoyed Prophet Mohammed who was sick of having his wives used as political envoys for the various people in his community and so he instituted veiling and separation as a way of both shielding his wives from public politics and shielding himself from having to deal with political infighting within his multiple marriages. Anyone in a Poly relationship who has fighting partners could probably relate to his ruling.
Secondly, you seem woefully under-informed about street harassment in general which happens everywhere and you can learn more about at http://www.ihollaback.org/ . Street harassment happens everywhere and to regardless of religious or non-religious dress.
Thirdly, veiling in the modern day means different things in different places to different people. Having a whole bunch of white Christian/agnostic/non-muslims telling a woman how to dress and what her dress means ignores the poly-rhythmic world we live in where there are multiple conceptions and definitions of different things co-existing. Veiling in France can mean “I’m different from you and you can’t make me invisible.” or it can mean “I’m Muslim and you can’t stop me.” or it can mean “I want to veil because I don’t want to be judged by the shape of my body” or it can mean “My father/brother told me to veil or else…” It means different things to different people and saying that there’s a “history” in regards to veiling but only reflecting on the recent developments cited from a shitty Washington Post article is intellectually lazy.
People should be free to do/wear (pretty much) what they want…but everyone else should be free to discuss and comment on those choices as well. Your ideas of freedom are uni-drectional, apparently. I can tell you I don’t like your hat, and you can tell me to F*** off…it’s a great system.
shotsix@30: you’re not wrong, but wouldn’t it be better to not be that jackass making unsolicited comments on someone else’s fashion sense in the first place? The law shouldn’t mandate it, but simple politeness damn well should.
Jen’s friend is a coward.
What is the meaning of the veil? That women need to dress modestly lest they incite the urge of men to rape? That women – but not men of course – need to hide their faces in public?
What “brave” statement is she making? Please tell me what the relationship is between those societies where women are veiled and women’s freedom? Iran veils. So does Saudi Arabia. Every “enlightened” muslim woman who emigrates to the west and continues the veil provides additional cover for the perpetrators of religious misogyny to proclaim: “Look – its voluntary!”
We do not veil our women in the west. It is an evil practice fostered by an ancient belief that women, but of course not men, must cover their faces in public. We do not believe in the west that unveiled women are whores. We should never pretend that veiling is compatible with western ideals. The practice SHOULD be stigmatized with the rest of old world thinking – confederate flags, for example.
This veiled muslim is anti-thetical to women. No more than a woman in the 1920s burning her voting ID card. It is her right to do it and it is our collective responsibility to shun it.
Stick to the gay stuff, Dan. When you try and get all “worldly,” you tend to embarrass yourself. While I’m sure you consider those two weeks you spent in Egypt in the 90s as a tourist qualify you as an expert, *ahem*, it miiiight not be the case.
And you didn’t start wearing your teeshirts in “some sort of social, religious, political, and cultural vacuum” either, Dan. Sorry to say this, but your post has a weirdly condescending tone, like you can’t really hear Heba when she says “Back off, it’s my choice.” Is that because she’s a woman, or because she’s a Muslim?
No one seems to be applying the same religious bigotry to pentecostals. Those women can’t even wear PANTS. http://christianity.about.com/od/United-…
But those women make a “FREE CHOICE” because they live in the US and there’s no restrictive patriarchy here!
Tim Horton? You must be a fat-ass Canadian who eats a lot of doughnuts before playing the brutish, disgusting game of hockey! I can’t believe you support the wholesale patriarchy enforcing culture of violence which goes along with Hockey and Tim Horton’s doughnuts!!!
(That is the same argument you just made only applied to you.)
I am honestly pretty disappointed at how little you/your intern minions researched this, Dan. For the last roughly 15 years or so the veil has largely been used as a symbol of re-appropriation by Muslim women. While yes, for many Muslim women there is a large amount of pressure, if not a requirement, that they wear the veil, there is also a large amount of pressure for those feminist Muslim women to not wear the veil. Why can’t Muslim women wear their veil and be a feminist, Islam does not inherently mean suppressed women, in fact Mohammed’s wife and daughters are extremely important figures in the Quran.
In the 1980’s there were abundant ‘unveilings’ happening around the Middle East and Europe, it was a statement of pride as a woman to make the decision. Yet, people are not aware that many of the same women who led the unveiling movement, so to say, of the 80’s have themselves chosen to re-veil. For some it is a reaffirmation in their religion, for many married Muslim mothers it is about making a statement about their lifestyle, that they function as an individual with a job and they are still devoted to the family based ideals which the Quran preaches (and that does not mean devoted to being a housewife and serving the family, it means as any parent in any country should do, helping to support your children and spouse as much as possible).
What I am trying to say here is that the issue of hijabs and burqah’s is much more complicated than merely does a women want to wear a symbol of oppression. For most women that is not what the veil has come to mean in the contemporary world. So please, Dan, open your eyes to actual current affairs beyond the front page of the newspaper and do a bit more reading before you decide to write a post like this one. It makes me question listening to your excellent sex advice if I know that you are not bothering to do proper research; I thought you were a journalist that I could respect.
@36,
Seriously, stop listening. No joke. Let those questioning thoughts take action, and vow to never ever listen again.
Come back in six months and see who gives a shit.
Oh right, no one.
@35 Kate – I am not sure I follow your logic. Going to a hockey game isn’t generally a religious or a political statement. Wearing a veil is one or the other. Its not like putting on a Leafs hat.
I am not stereotyping muslims here. I am commenting on the fallacy that veiling is compatible with secular western values.
Fact – there isn’t a single country on the planet where veiling of women is the cultural norm where women also enjoy equal rights to men. It is my understanding, and correct me if I am wrong, that veiling was imposed because a woman who shows her face in public is immodest. Do you agree with this view? If not, why do you applaud someone for an outward representation of that ideology?
I would defend her right to wear whatever she wants. But I am not ashamed in my view that western-secular values are superior in their treatment of women/minorities/GLBT community and it is those values, as opposed to religiously bigoted of ANY variety, that should be celebrated here.
I am a white straight woman, and not ashamed of any of those characteristics – even though that’s not okay, apparently.
I am also a beneficiary, by virtue of my age and nationality, of the most liberal, enlightened, and egalitarian superculture that has ever existed for my gender.
MY clothing decisions don’t take place in a social, religious, political, and cultural vacuum. Where and for whom does this happen, exactly?
I’m dead certain that my granddaughter will look at what I wore (and, if I’m still alive then, still wear) and think it looks dowdy and restrictive, and the product of a fundamentally sexist and backward culture. I hope to God she’s right.
This is just far too complicated of a topic to cover in a blog post. Women have the right to wear what they want, from a sexy miniskirt and low-cut top to a burqua. I went to slut walk DC in jeans and a t-shirt because that’s what I normally wear and deserve to be able to wear that (without being called a dyke, as I have been numerous times when I sneer at catcallers, and without being raped as “just needing some dick to learn how to act like a woman”), just as much as my friends who showed up in something just slightly less revealing than underwear have the right to wear that (without being called sluts and having their rapes excused as “asking for it”) and my friend who showed up in a long skirt, loose top, and headscarf (yes, Muslim) has the right to wear that (without being harassed for her faith and possibly raped as “breaking her out of that repressive culture,” or being “to salacious” because her face is visible). We were all there supporting the same thing, the right of women to wear whatever we want and be treated as human beings with free agency, and, shockingly (/s), each of us could cite an excuse under which some assholes would think raping us might be justified.
Women covering themselves does carry some heavy implications. 32 is not wrong to rail against the idea that women should be modest to keep men’s uncontrollable rapiness in check. But along the same lines, women should not be expected to be “sexy” to conform to some cultural norm; women should not be expected to wear just the right makeup to look “natural and fresh” (and young, never forget the value of looking young for women); women should not be expected to check their deserved anger to avoid being labeled a “bitch;” and etc. ad nauseum. How vigorously do we fight each of these norms, respective of each other?
The only real solution is to have an honest dialogue about what one hopes to achieve by their look/dress/demeanor, and tear down expectations of these superficial paradigms wherever possible. But tearing down the norms will still leave some women dressing sexy, some women seeking the perfect makeup, some women always being the peacemaker, and some women wearing hijabs, all by choice. Once you’ve had the INDIVIDUAL conversation, you have to then respect the person’s choice.
“You’re a white man so your opinion is invalid.”
And I’m supposed to the sexist/racist one?
“This issue is complicated.”
Eh, sort of but not really. Someone may choose to do something for complicated, convoluted reasons but that doesn’t make the issue complicated. Veils are symbols and tools of oppression, like Confederate flags. People are still free to embrace them, and I’m free to think what I want to of them because of it. In the case of veils, I’ll think “She has internalized the oppression of her culture.” I’m sure she might think the same thing of a white girl wearing make up and a low-necked top.
Honestly if my earlier analogy doesn’t make sense to you, you’re probably too dense for this conversation.
Please folks, remember that she is talking about the head scarf, not the face-covering veil.
Dan, it’s great that you’ve admitted that you were wrong about the Iraq war, but it would be nice if you actually internalized some of the lessons of that moment instead of just using it as an excuse to pat yourself on the back for your faux humility. Lesson number one being that you don’t know jack shit about the actual internal politics and sociology of the middle east, and at this point in your life you are unlikely to actually learn. Lesson number two, following axiomatically from the first, is that you have nothing to contribute to the discussion but noise, and should consider ceding the stage to people who actually know what the hell they’re talking about.
Seattle’s a big city. Rather than running your mouth about what Muslim women might or might not feel about the veil in the complete absence of any expertise or evidence, how about finding a few of them and offering them a column?
This conflict sounds in deepening anxieties in the West about multiculturalism – is it a failed experiment (failing at what? what were its goals supposed to be?) and if so, what does that mean? The Rawlsian vision is one of parsimonious, free-to-be-you-and-me rule structures that relegate almost all forms of behavior and expression, even those (like the veil) that are often explicitly political, to the private sphere. We are told, then, that any woman who makes the choice to wear a veil in public is engaging in private, rather than political, expression, and that it is boorish and intolerant for anyone other than a Muslim woman to express, or perhaps even form, an opinion about that. Another view, expressed by people like Chantal Mouffe, would say that the attempt to banish what is clearly political expression to the realm of the private, where “tolerance” dictates that everyone is allowed their political expression but nobody else, especially nobody who might be different from them, is allowed to join that conversation, is an abdication of the political that is destined to fail. Both of these are positions that are associated with the left, and people on both sides of this debate see the other side as somewhat conservative or perhaps even reactionary. Which means we end up talking past each other much of the time. I guess I think it might be useful to think about the extent to which wearing the veil, and writing a blog post about the choice to wear a veil and irritation at people on both sides who seem to the blogger to be overinvested in that choice, is a political expression. If it is a political expression (and I think both the wearing of the veil and telling people to back off about it qualify as political), then to what extent is it a good thing, in a progressive democracy, for us to talk about such political expressions? What about the way we talk about them, and about the demographic facts about some of the people talking, is creating this chafing that so many commenters express (using words like “mansplaining”)? How can we bring the political back to the center of our discourse, and what do we have to gain, and risk, by doing so?