They’re still reserving those two magic syllables for the straights, but… real progress:

Brazil’s Supreme Court ruled Thursday night that civil unions between same-sex couples must be allowed in this nation with more Roman Catholics than any other. In a 10-0 vote, with one abstention, the justices said gay couples deserve the same legal rights as heterosexual pairs when it comes to alimony, retirement benefits of a partner who dies, and inheritances, among other issues. The ruling, however, stopped short of legalizing gay marriage. In Latin America, that is legal only in neighboring Argentina and in Mexico City.

And you gotta love this:

Brazil’s constitution defines a “family entity” as “a stable union between a man and a woman.” But the attorney general’s office argued the clause is only a definition and not a limitation, and thus the charter does not say a stable union can “only” be between a man and a woman.

Gay people in Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, and Columbia have more rights than gay people in the United States of America.

24 replies on “Equality—If Not Quite Marriage Equality—Comes to Brazil”

  1. If you think it’s better to be gay in Latin America than it is the U.S., you clearly haven’t spent much time there.

  2. they have more rights on specific issues related to being gay, in particular in a gay union, but more civil/human rights in full? that’s debatable

  3. @1 Yes, there’s a difference between legal protections and cultural acceptance. The Latin American countries listed are further ahead with the former but have much further to go with the latter.

    And Dan, it’s spelled “Colombia”

  4. Danny, doesn’t South Africa have Gay Marriage?

    Have you ever considered living in that Utopia?

    Here is a nice piece about attitudes toward Gays in Gay Marriage recognizing South Africa (sorry, can’t post the link, SOME FUCKING COWARD PUSSY DELETED OUR ACCOUNT…)

    “This may make for depressing reading with your breakfast, but there’s nothing new about the entrenched homophobia in South Africa, a place where men rape lesbians to “correct” them, a government minister last month refused to open a state-funded exhibition featuring photographic images of intimacy between gay women (the image above is an example), and Jacob Zuma, the country’s president, once said that when he was growing up gay men would not have stood in front of him. “I would knock him out.”

    Recently, the leader of the second-largest political party and premier of the Western Cape, Helen Zille, appeared at “a prayer rally” alongside evangelical preacher, Angus Buchan, who wants to “cure” homosexuals.

    Here‘s the introduction to an excellent take on homophobia in South Africa by Johannesburg-based researcher and activist Dale McKinley:

    “As much as those of us who identify ourselves as social progressives would like to believe otherwise, the reality is that South Africa is a bastion of social conservatism. Indeed, one of the most glaring contradictions of South Africa’s post-apartheid ‘transition’ is that the widely acknowledged (and regularly celebrated) social progressiveness of the Constitution is, in large part, at fundamental odds with the beliefs and views of the majority of South Africans themselves …. Besides the consistent defence of narrow-minded patriarchal social relations and ongoing displays of general indifference to the epidemic of violence against women, in more recent times the most publicly visible and propagated form of social intolerance has been homophobia. It was none other than Jacob Zuma who got the ball really rolling back in 2006 when, at a public function, he proudly stated that, “When I was growing up ungqingili (gay men) would not have stood in front of me. I would knock him out.”

    Zuma’s complimentary remark that, “same-sex marriage is a disgrace to the nation and to God”, and the positive reception such a view received from sizeable numbers of South Africans, gave firm indication of a deep seated and widely held social conservatism.”

  5. “Gay people in Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, and Columbia have more rights than gay people in the United States of America.”

    Thanks for the proof that the USA is superior to Latin American nations.

  6. @8: Wait, SB, didn’t you just say this less than twelve hours ago:

    “I know that I’ve never argued that homosexuality should be punished by law, discriminated against or otherwise treated as a legitimate public policy issue.”

    But now, the USA is superior because it denies rights to homosexuals?

    This is the truth about you: you like to talk a good game and present a genteel face, to say that you don’t dislike gays or want to see them persecuted, oh no, you just disapprove of their lifestyle, that’s all. But scratch the surface and you are a fucking homophobe who would like to see them all closeted away or confined to mental institutions or jails if they won’t turn away from their perverse, “bestial” – another of your favourite words – behaviour.

    Your attitudes are as reprehensible as the Period Troll’s, and you yourself are far more dangerous because you are able to coat them with a thin veneer of civility.

  7. SB: Thank you for providing evidence of just how resentful you are that gay people exist and want equal rights. (But then again you do this with each post, don’t you?) And @9 is right: it’s just a matter of time.

    Being Brazilian, I must say that it’s difficult to compare the public acceptance of gays in Brazil and in the US. What do you want to compare: São Paulo and Knoxville? Rio de Janeiro and Phoenix? San Francisco and Cuiabá? Portland and Manaus?… Things vary from place to place. Just as in the states, there are better and worse places in Brazil for homosexuals to live, there are people who accept them and then there are people who don’t. I don’t know how to calculate an average measurement that could tell you if gay acceptance is now better or worse in the US or in Brazil; all I can say is, it depends on where in Brazil (or in the US) you live.

  8. Having said this, I add that there clearly are places in the world that are much worse for gays to live in — Uganda comes to mind, of course, but also Eastern Europe (an area I’m emotionally linked to). Gays in Poland, in Ukraine, in the Baltic states (have you seen the problems with the Gay Pride parade in Riga?) have it much worse than either in the US or in Brazil.

    I wonder if someone somewhere does a ‘gay acceptance / gay quality of life’ measurement for the countries of the world, to provide a comparative perspective. What place would the US have on a list based on this parameter? Or Brazil?

  9. @7: Aww poor Period Troll. Live by the Spam, be deleted as a Spammer. It’s not rocket science. But you still have your sock puppets to cuddle up to, so quit your bawling.

  10. 10
    gosh-
    What exactly is REPREHENSIBLE?
    poor baby- do opinions that differ from your own scare you?

    They obviously scare Danny, who can’t bring himself to answer a really simple question.
    Quite odd…..

    Deleting an account, or sitting around with your fingers in your ears humming “I Can’t Hear You…LaLaLa…”, it’s basicly the same thing.

    When we have no answer there’s always the good folks at IT who can bail out our FUCKING COWARD PUSSY ASS, right Danny?

  11. What Savage said was that gays in Brazil have more rights than in the US. Gays are fully equal citizens with the same rights I have as a heterosexual in the US. So the only rational conclusion is that Brazil grants gays the special citizen status whiny Dan Savage would like for them here. This is what I resist, not the obvious conclusion that what consenting adults do is their business.

    As for the hyperbolic nonsense at BB about jailing or institutionalizing people for homosexuality, please note one place I’ve ever made such calls. Still waiting. Still. Yep. Still waiting.

    Logic isn’t difficult, if you only try a little.

  12. @19 And, as to my “hyperbolic nonsense”, do you remember this:

    “She could share her foul mouth with the hookers in a holding cell.”

    That was when you suggested a woman be thrown in jail for saying “fuck” in public, and compared her to a prostitute.

    I think it’s pretty clear what you would like to see done with those who violate your idea of what is appropriate behaviour.

  13. @21 I think it likely that at some point SB had something traumatic happen to him and trolling here is some kind of consolation prize coping mechanism.

  14. @21

    So, standards of appropriate public behavior are anathema too?

    Good thing you folks are a minority. The kind of cesspit society you’d create, well intentioned or not, would be unbearable for decent people.

    (Here’s a clue. It isn’t ‘my’ ideas that matter. It’s those of the larger society. It’s those ideas with which immature whiners like Mr. Savage, or the woman on the plane you reference are entirely unwilling to live. They have that right, but the social condemnation that follows is entirely their own doing. Not a civil rights issue. Not a free expression issue. Just the consequences of ones’ behavior.)

    @22

    The only traumatic experience I’ve had was trying to get a liberal to make sense. Thanks awfully for your concern though! Mainly I post here for amusement at the vapid arguments raised to support appallingly poor policies, and the vociferous support those arguments receive from people, well, like you.

  15. @23: Let’s be clear here. You weren’t suggesting social condemnation for the woman who said fuck in public. Social condemnation would be people looking down on her, people shunning her, her friends pulling her aside and saying “That was rude; please don’t use that sort of language around me.”

    You said she should be put in jail.

    As to “the larger society” and its standards, you may find that you are being left behind.

  16. @23 Nah, you spend far too much time and energy here for it to be considered run-of-the-mill amusement. It’s pretty obvious you have some underlying issue, everyone here can see it and denial just makes it look more obvious. Go see someone about it, you might feel better =)

Comments are closed.