The Supreme Court has decided to review the awesomely named Schwarzenegger v. Entertainment Merchants, which means that California’s law banning the sale of violent videogames to minors has one last chance. Given the Court’s extreme deference to corporate free speech rights, it’d be kind of a shock if they upheld the law, but since they could have killed it by simply refusing to hear it, anything is possible.
Even if they do uphold the law, it’s effectively just a means to erode game retailers’ profits by forcing them to create age checks beyond those already in place. It shouldn’t have any impact on kids’ access—any tween or teen who can’t find a way to play any game they want either isn’t trying very hard or has been locked in the attic by their loving tyrants. There’s certainly no way game publishers will change their behavior in response, so the best California can hope for is a few temporarily appeased parent/voters and a somewhat speedier shift away from bricks & mortar game stores and toward digital game distribution. Win-win?
The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner and Paul Hughes.

More like Lose-Lose.
This is the activist Supreme Court you’re talking about, the one that thinks, contrary to the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, that corporations are people.
They’ll probably invent some additional corporate power to treat American citizens like serfs, probably involving tattooing bar codes on us to prove age of eligibility to consume video games.
The more violent, the better! Bring on the bloodspray, SCOTUS.
First Amendment >> the rest. Should be an easy decision unless some fine point of the law is written in such a way that it really caught one of them to pay attention. I’m betting they’ll just affirm things in a specific way?
How would this law even work with online retailers?
And why single out one medium? Are there similar fines for selling ‘objectionable’ music? DVDs? Books?
I’m glad that California has such a surplus of funds that they can afford this litigation and the subsequent Vice Squads needed to ‘sting’ stores.
This is the same Supreme Court which struck the federal law banning depictions of animal cruelty. 8-1! First Amendment issues don’t fit in a liberal-conservative analysis. Scalia voted to strike a law banning flag burning.
@4 “I’m glad that California has such a surplus of funds that they can afford this litigation and the subsequent Vice Squads needed to ‘sting’ stores.”
Zing!
Bloooooooodddddddddsprrrrrrrraaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyy