Sorry, haters, while you crushingly voted down discussion of World of Warcraft, people still wanna talk games. So, for those who are excited about Star Wars: The Old Republic comes this post from a disgruntled employee of EA (Electronic Arts) via Furious Fanboys. It mostly focuses on the failure of Warhammer, but there’s some relevant bits about The Old Republic:
They’ve spent more money making the Old Republic than James Cameron spent on Avatar. Shit you not. More than $300 million! Can you believe that?
And you know what they’re most proud of? This is the kicker. They are most proud of the sound. No seriously. Something like a 20Gig installation, and most of it is voiceover work. That’s the best they have. The rest of the game is a joke. EA knows it and so does George Lucas, they’re panicking, and so most of Mythic has already been cannibalized to work in Austin on it because they can’t keep pushing back launch.
Old Republic will be one of the greatest failures in the history of MMOs from EA. Probably at the level of the Sims Online. We all know it too…
Of course it’s hard to determine whether this dude’s got the inside scoop or is just full of crap, but it’s always fun to speculate.

‘panicking’ always looks misspelled to me.
Anyone playing Mafia II?
EA and Atari have a way of turning every studio they touch into crap within a few games. The only thing they have is capital. They buy creative vibrant gaming studios and then corporate-soul-suck them until they are dried husks and use the profits to buy their next victim.
I’m going with “inside scoop of crap.” We’ve all known that disgruntled employee that just HAS to talk shit about anyone and everyone. They probably just got written up for harassing a teammate and needed to blow off steam. I would be shocked if this wasn’t full of exaggerations, half-truths and out-and-out lies.
Then again, there’s usually some small kernel of truth in those rants too. Nothing so catastrophic as THE GREATEST FAILURE IN THE HISTORY OF MMOs (All Points Bulletin and Tabula Rasa already vie for that dubious title). But it wouldn’t surprise me if the consensus after it comes out is that they spent far too much time on some things that a large portion of players won’t care about, such as voice acting… everybody just skips the quest text in every other MMO, I’m not sure why Bioware think ADHD teenagers are going to change their gaming habits for this game.
Jesus. I pointed you to EALouse a week ago. Way to follow up on a hot tip, Mary. And what’s with pointing the post to a referring site? Did EALouse go down? (It didn’t. I checked.) How about an interview with the guy? Here’s his blog: http://ealouse.wordpress.com/
In other Video Game news, Microsoft has launched an entirely new service embedded in its game console: it’s called Xbox Live! Check it out.
Feeling left behind? Here are three sites you should read if you’re going to report on video games. They will lead you to others, and so on.
Kotaku.com
Penny-Arcade.com
Gamasutra.com
Good luck, Mary.
Not worried. Bioware consistently does amazing work.
@5 FTW — those quotes, purportedly from a EA Mythic/Bioware employee, were the talk of the industry last week (see his/her first post on EAlouse).
@6: I was going to say “Lionheart wants to talk to you about that amazing work”, but I realized that was Black Isle Studios, and not Bioware. You’re right .:P
@5: She got voted down when she wanted to talk about WoW, but is still one of the very few Sloggers willing to throw us MMO freaks a bone and you feel the need to immediately start newb-bashing her? Holy Galactus, take your condescension to a trade channel, plz.
I try out pretty much every Major MMO that comes down the pike (at least, the ones with a free trial), and I can’t say I’ve seen anything about SWTOR that makes me the slightest bit interested in it.
That said, with the combined force of all the starwars and bioware fanboys behind it – I doubt it will fail that spectacularly. I mean, unless it’s FFXIV level bad.
Also – as someone who’s been subscribed to WAR off and on for a few months over the last year and a half – I’m happy to finally be able to say I feel like they are making some progress. I might actually resubscribe to test out some of the new stuff that’s supposed to be out before year’s end.
@6: It’s not really the same Bioware folks working on SW:TOR — EA just named their MMO division Bioware so that they could capitalize on the former Bioware company’s reputation. Most of the people working on SW:TOR never worked on SW:KOTOR or any other Bioware product from before the EA acquisition of it.
@5 Yes, I was a bit tough on Mary, but come on! I posted a link to EALouse a week ago on the WoW article! Also, no one wants to talk about WoW. 😉
@11 has it right. The Old Republic is being built by an EA studio out of Austin that they re-named “Bioware” and not the boys from Toronto that we’re all so proud of.
Video games are a hot topic. Why limit yourself to WoW?
This is not at all surprising. From what I have seen, the game does nothing that we haven’t already seen before. More combat with a hotbar and spells on cooldown.
On EA: they’re better than they used to be, though closing Pandemic was pretty fucking boneheaded.
Long post ahead, laced with an insider’s thoughtful blovations.
I’ve been tracking this, along with the aftershocks from the Louse post, for about a week. SWTOR is rumored to have spent $125 million this far. I wouldn’t be shocked if the number was a lot higher (Dev price tags are always risky to talk about, and are usually released after the game comes out, either highlighting how much money the game made or the reason why the game imploded).
Full disclosure. I’m in the business. I’ve worked on games that were built with stacks of cash. We’re entering an age where AAA-titles almost require a $50-$60 million budget just to be visible, or to catch the attention of the consumer base. GTA 4 supposedly had a price tag of $80-$100 million. Halo 3 was supposedly $60 million. Red Dead Redemption was about $100 million in the making. Blizzard products, like WoW and Starcraft 2…I shudder at the price tags.
SWTOR’s big problem is going to be delivering on all the investment they have made. Once they release their game, they still will be burning money through server time, support, expansion-pack development, advertising, and the myriad costs that a studio generates (what, you thought that free soda in the lunch room was really free?). Let’s say SWTOR comes out next year with a $200 million price tag.
It’s a subscription-based game, let’s say $15 a month. Let’s also say it’s $50 to buy the product either digitally or in a cardboard box.
So, $200 million and $230 for a user to buy the game play for a year. EA and Bioware (assuming they pool the developer/distributor split for this) will need about 870,000 subscribers to recoup their investment in one year (assuming they incur no other financial strains).
Now, here’s the problem. First, they will be burning money to keep the servers running and to pay staff to keep the game fresh and interesting with tech patches and new content drops. The good news is, they won’t need so many people to do this (which is why you see so many layoffs from studios after they ship their game). The bad news: they will have to maintain or build their population base in order to keep the lights on, stock the soda, and put out expansion packs (the lifeblood to any MMO).
Bioware/EA are both going to have to be careful when they launch. There’s a slew of MMOs coming in 2011 and 2012, all of which are waiting for SWTOR to slip up. Guild Wars 2, TERA, Rift, and whatever Blizzard has up its sleeve. SWTOR will have to hit the ground running and dominate the way WoW did a few years ago. The problem is, WoW is waiting at the top of that mountain, and it has dined well on the bodies of many potential rivals.
SWTOR also had an unfortunate run of bad luck over the summer with bad press. Their space exploration/combat was revealed to be an uninspiring rail shooter. They got skunked out of major awards at Gamescom and PAX. Some of their in-game footage (especially at the starter levels) looked buggy and stodgy, making the earlier descriptions of “It’s WoW with lightsabers” look more apt.
Here’s the really bad news for Bioware/EA. WoW has 12 million players. Half those players are in Asia markets. From what I’ve seen from SWTOR’s content, they aren’t gearing their game to Korea, China, Japan, or any of the Asia gaming markets. Companies like Trion, Blizzard, and NCsoft have, thus giving them a foothold in the East and West.
Now, in a year, I could be wrong. In a year, SWTOR could be gangbusters. Or it could be the next Star Wars Galaxies. The point is, the onus is now on Bioware/EA to make a decent game that can make up its massive investment. If EA Louse is half about what he (she?) writes, SWTOR could be stunningly average, something that a big-budget MMO can’t afford to be.
You’ve somehow gotten under the strange impression that “haters” who hate WoW don’t play or want to talk about video games.
I like movies but I don’t want to talk about G-Force: Gerbil FBI or Baby Geniuses 2.
Now the kwanzai version of Chiba Cthulhu – that was cool.
For the record, Games != WoW. There ate other games out there. Just because i don’t give half a shit about WoW doesn’t mean I’m not, for example, going to take off work early to rush home where I see my copy of Fallout: New Vegas was just delivered eight minutes ago.
Haters? Why would anyone hate games? Or gamers? It makes no sense. What’s to hate?
While I have some interest in some games, it will never occur to me to check Slog for related news, any more than I would check Penny Arcade for important political developments. Not saying this blog can’t successfully diversify, but video game news isn’t the intuitive topic to pursue when so many other dedicated game sites are always going to do it better.
In addition to the fact that Lucasarts can not make a playable game, Nothing will ever pull away from WOW. WOW is a lifestyle choice now, those people will never leave, so the other more casual gamers wont leave either, thar be people on these servers.
I mean I am sure that The Matrix online was totally awesome, but you cant play with less than 300 people on the server…