A Democratic lawmaker in Minnesota speaks out against a GOP-backed constitutional ban on same-sex marriage. It’s required viewing:

Via JMG.

143 replies on ““How many gay people must God create before we accept that he wants them around?””

  1. Who is “.” and why is he/she trolling with such vigor? Does a minimal command of invective, logical fallacy, and rhetorical sneakery really mean anything when preaching to this crowd, aside from some masochistic joy in being reviled? And most importantly, are there enough donuts for everyone?

  2. @ 51 – You don’t even know what words mean. He says he THINKS that’s true; he doesn’t say “that’s true”. This means that he is only stating his opinion, not trying to impose it.

    As far as I know, as an American, he’s got the right to do that, doesn’t he? It’s the imposition of religious-based opinions, like what you’re trying to do, that he’s against.

    Once again, you prove my point (see 50).

    How many millions of people will need to tell you that you’re extremely stupid before you actually get it?

  3. You know, for the past couple weeks I was impressed with the period troll’s lack of restraint. He would post one dumbass comment per post, and that was that. Now that restraint has gone out the window. I would guess this guy’s exuberance is gonna flag in a couple more weeks…

    …that is, if the rest of you just leave him alone. Where’s the restraint the commentariat showed over the past couple weeks? Honestly, if you engage with him you’re just as responsible for his shenanigans as he is. The guy’s an obsessive compulsive; leave him alone and he’ll whither on the vine.

    In other news, big ups to Mr. Simon for knocking this one out of park.

  4. Wait, is the Period Troll actually pulling a trick on us? Secretly, he’s repeating flawed and uninspired arguments just to encourage active, well-thought out argumentation against the ill-defined, poorly developed positions he seems to be taking!

  5. @ 55 As I’ve stated quite a few times before, don’t take this too seriously, it’s just for the fun of it. (As in: “Angry at your boss? Take it out on the period troll! He’s so dumb he won’t realize he’s being played!”)

  6. Dear . (dot, period?)

    You insert activity into the motives of persons who disagree with you. Foster, subsidize, writing beliefs into laws, and other phrases to similar effect. Your interpretation is wrong. We do not want laws written to give us rights, nor do we desire the state to support us in any way differently from any one else.

    What we want is for laws to not be passed which take the action of restricting our rights. What we want is to be treated as just any other defective human is treated.

    Now, then, . , here’s is our question for you: What’s Your Name? You’re so brave speak out about your beliefs, but without a name, you do not really exist.

    My name is Gryphon MacThoy. I live in Seattle, WA. I am a homosexual. And I believe that I *chose* my sexuality. I may or may not have been born this way. But I remember the very moment when I considered the question of what I want from my life, and I actively chose to be a homosexual. Even if sexualiy is a choice, you may not restrict my human rights. You will not restrict my right to be who and what I want to be, as long as I do not cause material harm to other persons or property.

    Stand up for your beliefs, ..

  7. God didn’t create gays. God created men with the free will to make good or bad choices.

    Or, if you are an atheist, men are born with the free will to make bad or good choices with no deistic involvement at all.

    Some of these we grant protection under the law, like the choice to claim or disavow a religion, or the choice to say stupid things like ‘God created gays.’ Some choices we don’t give such protection since they don’t involve basic liberties like expression or the freedom of religion.

    As it happens gays have full civil equality. They can’t be discriminated against in housing, employment or public accomodation. They have the same protections from violence I have, and more protection from speech they don’t happen to like. (That’s HATE speech!) They may marry any consenting person of the opposite sex, just as I can. But this isn’t something we owe them societally. It’s an expression of how dedicated to civil rights we are in this country that we protect even self destructive choices.

    Oddly, I missed the finding of the gay gene. Ricardo and Mr. Mehlman seem dead certain science supports the notion of born gay, but forgot to cite where this seminal scientific accomplishment occured. I’m sure it was just an oversight.

  8. @ 60, as I’ve challenged many in your postion before, I want you to please tell us about the time you chose to be attracted only to the opposite sex.

  9. @ 60 – So what are you, SB, period troll senior? This thread doesn’t really need you by now.

    I wasn’t even 3 years old when I had my first crush on a man. It’s my third memory of life. I don’t need any scientific study to figure out I was born this way. Or, as many here have asked you and all those who come up with such lame arguments as you consistently do, when did you choose to be straight? But you won’t answer that, will you? Because you can’t. In your case, there’s no doubt that you were “born this way”, as in stupid.

    Finally, see my comment @ 39. It’s about you.

  10. 63

    I knew my sexual preference WAY before I knew what sex was too (in my case, girls). That’s why I assume SB is bisexual. Because he got to make a choice, we didn’t. And that’s how I’m refering to him from now on.

  11. Jeez, I don’t think bisexual people get to “make a choice” either 😛 I have no control over the fact that I like ’em both. And I have no idea if the next person I fall in love with will be a man or a woman. Those things just happen. And I’ve seen gay people choose to go right into heterosexual marriages, so “choices” are available to all, even if they totally blow up later.

    I just find both aspects — nature vs. nurture — to be incredibly pointless.

  12. @64

    “That’s why I assume SB is bisexual. Because he got to make a choice, we didn’t. And that’s how I’m refering to him from now on.”

    Whatever floats your boat, Tex.

  13. I know I didn’t choose to be hetero. I like girl humans way more than man humans but I am married to a man human. Because I love him and love to fuck him. If I didn’t get a choice, I think it’s highly likely that most (please note, most) other people didn’t get to choose, either. I spent many a night pondering my preferences. Did I REALLY like men, or was that just society and the media telling me what to think??!?!?!!!!?!!?? (Melodramatic teen? Me??? No!) I came to the eventual conclusion that man humans were sexually preferable.

    This politician is doing a truly noble thing. He is standing up to his opposition with clear logic and straightforward speech. He uses their god against them. Challenges them to reflect on their so-called morals and then dares them to stand up for them. What an amazing thing! This guy is a great man. We should give him his due. Let’s stop getting caught up in petty challenges, as irritating and ill thought out as they are. Let’s just be thankful there is a man like this in politics SOMEWHERE.

  14. I look forward to they day when being LBGTQ is as innocuous as being tall or having brown hair. It’s going to be a long wait I’m afraid.

  15. @ 67, you can’t answer my question (61), can you? It’s funny, I’ve yet to meet one person who shares your opinion (that gay is a choice) who can. Do you know why you can’t?

  16. @39

    Yes. Thomas Aquinas is usually considered a feeble minded man. So was Beothius, or Marcus Aurelius. And most people think Isaac Newton was an absolute dunce. Abraham Lincoln with his amazing autodidactic talent with words, what a moron! I mean, all of them believed in God in some form, so they were all stupid, right Ricky?

  17. @70

    I don’t choose sickness, but I can choose to pursue health. My family has a history of heart disease. So I should stop exercising, eat badly and give in to the inevitable heart attack, since that’s the predilection I have.

    Or not. I make choices about moral or physical failings and those choices determine my character, not the failings themselves.

    I never chose to be straight any more than I chose to have 2 arms and 2 legs, or to breathe through mouth and nose. It simply is the natural default position for human beings.

  18. @2:

    See, that’s the entire reason for the existance Exodus Ministries, “being gay is a choice”, and a century of trying to cure homosexuality through psychotherapy and drugs.

    The fact is, they just don’t see it that way.

  19. @ 72, if that’s the case, then how do you explain people who are attracted to the same sex? Surely it’s not beyond your ability to understand that attraction has to come first. You’ve never felt it; neither have I.

    It’s interesting that you brought up having arms and legs and breathing, but that has nothing to do with sexuality. It’s a lot more like the color of one’s skin or eyes – something that is different from person to person, and just as natural.

    You read about the pre-pubescent experiences of @ 63 and @ 64; I can recall my own experience (being incredibly turned on by a picture of a girl in a bikini when I was 6). I’m sure you can recall something similar if you try. If we’re all straight, how can Ricardo and Texans have had those experiences?

    BTW, you’ve avoided this question before so I’ll ask again – in light of medicine’s understanding that homosexuality is not a disease, something I’ve seen you concede, why do you keep comparing it to one? It doesn’t make any sense.

  20. Oh dear, Seattleblues is now equating himself with the likes of Thomas Aquinas, Isaac Newton and Abraham Lincoln… Proof that we’re dealing with a self-deluded, self aggrandizing nut job….

    Seattleblues you have assumed that all gay people don’t believe in God. Like straight people the gheys run the gamut of beliefs- atheist, deist, Christian, Agnostic- you name it…

    So tell me Seattleblues- are all those other creatures in the animal kingdom (who apparently willfully ignored their “default” switch) going to go to hell too?

  21. If the Bible had a rule about shunning the color blue, and everyone followed it for thousands of years, such that the color almost never appeared in art or clothing or architecture, and it was almost universally agreed that liking blue was a sign of moral depravity, would that imply that there was anything inherently wrong with the color blue?

  22. @71: Thomas Aquinas and Beothius also believed the world was flat and 6,000 years old.
    And they were wrong.
    Marcus Aurelius believed in Zeus.
    And he was wrong.
    Isaac Newton believed he could turn lead into gold.
    And he was wrong.
    Abraham Lincoln believed leaches and opium were sound medical treatments.
    And he was wrong.
    They weren’t stupid men. They were ignorant of certain facts.

    So what then, pray tell, is your excuse ?

    Why don’t you come to Slog Happy and you can tell me allllllll about it.

  23. In the early days of the Internet, I got into an infuriating argument with a troll not unlike Period Troll. A few days later I found out he was a snickering, pimply 14-year-old boy. I’ve never argued with a troll since, but I do enjoy imagining what irrelevant asses they are in real life.

  24. @52: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=dan+savage+polygamy
    He talks about why he opposes the legalization of traditional polygamy, and why it is unrelated to the issue of gay marriage, in THE FIRST LINK.
    Go fuck yourself.

    @60: You seem oddly bent on ignoring the possibility of an innate characteristic that is NOT genetic.
    See, there are several characteristics that are determined by environmental factors in the womb, rather than genetics alone. For example, metabolism is partially a product of uterine environment; children born to mothers who ate sparingly during pregnancy develop with stingy metabolisms and are likely to suffer from obesity, while children born to well-fed mothers have faster metabolisms and tend to grow up leaner. Another illustration of this effect comes from crocodiles (as well as many other reptiles), in which gender is not genetic, but rather determined by the temperature at which the egg is incubated.
    There is ample evidence that sexuality is determined in the womb by variations in hormonal levels, which cause slight differences to emerge in brain chemistry in certain areas. Deal with it. (Period Hive Drone at #16, take note.)

    @79: Leeches and opium actually do have legitimate medical uses. Opium is a painkiller, albeit one that has been supplanted by less addictive and more effective ones, and leeches’ saliva contains several extremely useful anticoagulants, while leeches themselves are still preferable for clearing hematomata in some cases.

  25. @80: Yes of course, but I was thinking of the practice of blood letting as a treatment for diseases from acne to tuberculosis, as well the over prescription of opium at that time. I should have been more specific.

  26. 81

    Get with the program, Junior.
    We’re talking about 2011 Polygamy where either gender can have multiple spouses.
    Your links are out of date and irrelevant…..

  27. @86: No. You asked (repeatedly) what Dan’s position was on polygamy, and now you know. So be a good little troll and say thank you to Venomlash for going to all that trouble for you.

  28. @79: Marcus Aurelius was a Stoic and somewhat of a pantheist; he didn’t believe in any God in the traditional sense. Boethius and Aquinus, like all educated men of their time, knew the world was round.

    @87: Well, that post didn’t really address the main question, which is whether consensual multi-way relationships deserve legal recognition. Dan was talking about traditional polygamy, not modern polyamorous relationships. There’s certainly an argument that we should recognize and grant poly relationships legal rights. There are significantly more legal obstacles to work out, but we have legal constructs like an LLP to base them on.

  29. @86: You wanted Dan Savage’s opinion on polygamy. I gave you Dan Savage’s opinion on polygamy, and several times over.
    Now, you and I can debate up and down (assuming you have the mental capacity to present and defend an argument that doesn’t revolve around calling me “Junior”) whether or not polygamy is morally acceptable, but the fact remains that our legal system has no framework for dealing with such legal contracts between more than two parties. That’s just how our legal system works.

  30. 89

    You vomited up a
    really old
    really really long
    really really really tedious
    critique of Old Testament polygamy.

    Damn Junior-
    you should know better that anyone that nobody pays any attention to that stuff anymore…

    Have someone read @88 to you and explain to you what it means.

  31. Seattlebules, li’l period: the point is simple. If homosexuality is a choice, so is heterosexuality; calling it a ‘default condition’ would imply that homosexuality is simply a ‘rarer setting’ of the same natural parameter. In other words, something you’re born with.

    Thinking it’s a disease without any evidence of it is like thinking that being born left-handed is a disease. Do you think so?

    And if you don’t believe in “default conditions”, or at least don’t think that “default conditions” (and therefore also the other possibilities) are innate, then you have to admit being heterosexual is also a choice of some kind. If so, and if you equate “choice” with “not preordained by nature”, then you’d have to say “heterosexuality” is not natural.

    Sorry, but you can’t get rid of this. You can dance all the way around it if you want, but you can’t have your cake and eat it too. No matter how hard you try not to, you have to choose, if you want your opinion to be consistent.

  32. Rach3l, there’s something to be said in favor of ‘feeding the trolls’: it keeps your arguments clear and sharp, and it helps you show an emotional argument for what it is: a mixture of “eewww” and “bwaaaahh”. It’s good to keep your muscles toned and exercised. Of course the trolls will keep repeating the same things, but that’s not the point. One’s sparring partner should not stop and say “let’s be friends”; or else he is not helping us improve.

  33. @88: Oh for the love of god.
    Can we agree that all three of them had some basic misconceptions regarding the natural world, which we can take as an example that, intelligent men though they were, their deeply held beliefs were mistaken? Due to ignorance of the facts? As opposed to Seatteblues, who has access to facts regarding homosexuality (such as it being removed from the DSM as a metal disorder) and yet refuses to face them? Which was. My Point?

    Period Troll’s only concern about polygamy is finding a way to win a game of “Gotcha” against Dan. He could give a hairless rat’s patooty about anything else on that topic. Which surely you must know.

  34. Seattleblues didn’t choose to be straight, but does he choose to be a know it all, POS? Or is that more of a nurture? Anyway … Blues, you’re just so righteously hot hot hot!!!

  35. @93: yes, of course, I just couldn’t resist correcting that. 🙂

    And I don’t give a fuck about period troll — I think we should just ignore him — but I am interested in the rights of polyamorists. Which is an interesting and relevant topic.

  36. @95: And I thank you for the correction, as one big brain to another. 🙂 Having two boyfriends, I must also agree with you that it is an interesting and relevant topic.

  37. @90: I gave you Dan’s opinion on traditional polygamy. I also gave you Dan’s opinion on modern polyamory in a previous thread; I’ll reproduce it here for the sake of your piss-poor web skills. And I gave you a brief explanation as to why our legal system CANNOT accommodate marriage contracts between more than two people without a drastic overhaul. When you ask a question, it’s considered proper to listen to the answer. Don’t you ever read things?
    But there ARE some people who still pay attention to the Pentateuch. I’ll give you a hint: they’re not Christians.

  38. Wait a sec yall, trolls and whatever aside, it’s great that the senator agrees with us on the issue of gay marriage but there’s still a big problem with his argument. If we accept that God only creates things that He wants around, then we have to accept that God wants mass murderers, nuclear armaments, the AIDS virus, etc. around just as much as he wants gay people around, and therefore we should support and protect all of them equally.

    Bad arguments are still bad even if they lead to the right conclusion, and they don’t convince anybody that isn’t already convinced.

  39. @ 99, one thing all forms of Christianity agree on is free will. That means that the things you listed are created by people, not God. So you’re incorrect in attributing all those bad things to God. Not one theologian would agree with you.

    Don’t treat these things like they’re arguments that would have to pass muster before a doctoral committee. Political arguments are about emotional appeal, and if a large number of undecided or uniformed people can be persuaded by this one, I’m all for it.

  40. 91

    It IS simple.

    Humans are heterosexual.
    Warm blooded, oxygen breathing, bipedal heterosexual organisms.

    Were there a state of being one could call “homosexual” it would represent a defect that renders those afflicted with it incapable of reproducing. There is no evidence that such an innate condition exists.

    The concept of “orientation” is impossible to quantify, measure or verify.

    Some humans self-identify as “homosexual” but demonstrate that they are fully functional heterosexuals, engaging in heterosexual acts and reproducing heterosexually.
    And many humans that self-identify as heterosexual engage in a variety of homosexual acts.

    The only possible conclusion is that “orientation” is a mirage and that humans are heterosexual and choose to engage (or not engage) in a variety of sexual behaviors.

    Simple….

  41. “As far as I’m concerned, everybody is gay, until they prove otherwise. And then I’m not always convinced.” — Buddy Cole (Kids in the Hall)

    Pretty much how I see it.

Comments are closed.