Usually, news from my conservative home state makes me mad enough to shit bullets. But this news of an Idaho woman—Jennie McCormack—filing a lawsuit challenging a ban on abortions after 20 weeks on the grounds that it violates the Constitution, is incredibly brave. Her lawsuit comes after a county prosecutor pressed criminal charges against her for allegedly inducing an illegal late-term, at-home abortion.
Not only is filing a lawsuit a brave move for a single mother of three hailing from the ultra-religious, conservative backwaters of Southeastern Idaho, it highlights the horrifying measures women are forced to take when their access to safe, affordable medical care is restricted.
Via HuffPo:
McCormack was charged with a felony in June after police said she took pills to terminate her pregnancy last December. Police found the fetus in a box at McCormack’s Pocatello home Jan. 9, and an autopsy determined it was between five and six months gestation. Police said McCormack told them she didn’t have enough money to go to a licensed medical professional, so her sister helped her access abortion-inducing drugs online.
…In the lawsuit, McCormack challenges the lack of access to abortions for women in her region, as well as the ban on abortions after 20 weeks.
She notes there are no elective-abortion providers in southeastern Idaho, forcing women seeking the procedure to travel elsewhere.
McCormack was unmarried and unemployed at the time of her pregnancy—with an income of $200 to $250 a month—and already had three children. She couldn’t afford the time or money it would take to travel to Salt Lake City to get an abortion, the lawsuit says.

I, too, applaud her effort. Although she has little choice but to fight it. I certainly hope she uses birth control of every type in the future.
Let the troll-fest begin.
She kept it in a box?… WTF?!?!?
Maybe she was just emulating the Santorums, @3…
No, Braindrip, it was actually pretty bang-on.
@7: Sadly, it’s not a frothy mix joke. Santorum really is that bat-shit crazy:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn…
What else was she gonna do with the fetus? Maybe she planned on burying it.
Jesus, what a horrible situation. My heart goes out to her.
Quoth @11:
You really wanna stand by that statement?
So if the Santorums decided to preserve the fetus in a glass case, which they wheel out for family dinners (a la Jeremy Bentham), that wouldn’t be evidence of bat-shit craziness.
And if they stuffed the body and kept it on the mantleplace, so that it would always watch over the family, that wouldn’t be evidence of bat-shit craziness.
And if they brought it into their bedroom and had lots of sex near it, so that its soul could rejoin them as their next child, that wouldn’t be evidence of bat-shit craziness.
Etc. I think you took too extreme a position in your attempt to justify their behavior. The more defensible opinion is “I don’t think the specific actions they took are necessarily crazy.” Which were:
1. Spending several hours kissing and cuddling the dead fetus.
2. Having their three kids also kiss and cuddle the dead fetus.
3. Taking photos, singing lullabies in his ear, and holding a private Mass. (this one isn’t so bad)
If you think [1] and [2] are not evidence of crazy, then you and I simply differ on our definitions of “crazy.”
They did all the numbered points. You can read the article; Santorum openly discussed it in the interview.
Anyway, you’ve apparently changed you position from “how they chose to do X is not evidence of crazy” to “how they chose to do X is not my business.” And I do agree that what families do behind closed doors is none of our concern. Of course, Santorum believes otherwise, so I don’t have a problem subjecting him to the same standard he seeks to impose on everyone else.
@11,
So since you support limitations on a woman’s ability to get an abortion, you aren’t a true conservative and you don’t give a fuck about limited government.
@16: Then I repeat my point in @13: if you think that spending several hours kissing and cuddling the dead fetus– and making your kids do the same– is not evidence of crazy, then you and I just have different definitions of “crazy.”
Although I have to wonder whether your definition is so restricted as to render the distinction meaningless.
@11, You would be correct. If there were ever a true conservative running for office that would be a lovely sight. A candidate who believed that small government meant more than “let corporations do whatever they want and don’t tax them” it would be incredible. If “conservatives” started promoting a small government that actually kept it’s hands out of my decisions on who I have sex with, what sort of medical care I get and when I have a child I would be very impressed. If you find one, let me know.
Seriously? No one had anything to say about the fact that this woman clearly is not the brightest person in the world (or she wouldn’t continue having kids she can’t support). A single mom of three and pregnant again?
I support a woman’s right to abortion but I don’t support the right to be a dumb, thoughtless person. That said, she gets to be that whether I like it or not.
Sorry, but where abortion is limited, so is birth control. Rural SE Idaho is a bit of a wasteland in some parts. In the winter much of it closes down – good luck trying to find a gas station open in one of those small towns during a snowstorm (been there, done that), let along a pharmacy that actually carries birth control products (tad conservative there) – and the distance between the larger towns is pretty lengthy. Salt Lake City would have been a 4-6 hour drive depending on where exactly she was in Idaho.
That area is practically the Republic of Gilead, not surprised at all.
@22: Is the rational choice of being devoid of sex or -while living among the best of western medicine- is the rational choice to abort an unplanned pregnancy?
I always do wonder though, what percentage of people pull out, even if there is hormonal birth control involved? Wouldn’t that greatly reduce chances of fertilization?
Mass sterilization …. humans are just not smart enough to manage the responsibility they take on with sex, plain and simple. Hell, I’d advocate mass neutering of most everyone to, but there’s no chance of that because of the huge addiction society has with sex. For those who think I’m joking, I am not.
@20: Funnily, I thought you would go with a lame “grief” justification next. You really can’t stick to a position, can you? First it’s “he’s not crazy,” then it’s “it’s not our business,” and now you’ve gone to “maybe he was crazy, but grief does funny things.” Talk about ends-oriented reasoning.
And yes, I’m well aware that grief fucks up the rational mind. Here’s the thing: once it passes, you realize how fucked up the shit you were doing was. Santorum doesn’t: it’s been many many years since the miscarriage, he’s had three kids since then, but he still proudly talks about the fucked up things he did with the fetus and he still shows the photographs. He still sees kissing/cuddling the dead fetus for hours as OK. It wasn’t a moment of insanity for him.
BTW: your continual need to cook up new justifications for Santorum’s behavior shows that you KNOW it’s on the crazy side. If I were arguing that showing pictures of his living kids was crazy, you would say I was nuts and walk away. The fact that you feel the need to come up with new justifications is evidence of your awareness of just how weak those justifications are. Notice that I’ve maintained the same position and the same reasoning throughout this little exchange.
Re: Nut Bag 1 (“Keeps it in a box” Santorum) vs. Nut Bag 2 (“Keeps it in a box” McCormack)…
Doesn’t a VERY relevant part of analyzing the “Craziness Factor” of each party’s reaction to their dead fetus in a box hinge on what they believe they have in the box?
Nut Bag 1 = Box full of dead child (corpse)
Nut Bag 2 = Box full of dead cells (human waste material)
Permitting each to have a box full of what they believe they have, by their own (individual) definitions, isn’t this conversation the equivalent of comparing a one party’s Box-O-Dead-Baby™ to another party’s Box-O-Poop™? Both are rather unsettling, but one is, arguably, more tragic.
Seems to me that someone who aborts their fetus for convenience, and then mourns its loss, is conceding that they killed something they thought was a person (and their own child), and therefore must be a particularly reprehensible individual.
Likewise, someone who aborts their fetus, and then keeps it as a memento (like a lost tooth!), must be a particularly disturbed individual.
I really hope Nut Bag 2 believes she has a Box-O-Poop™, and look forward to seeing her on a future episode of Hoarders…
@26
I concur completely. It should be illegal for anyone to breed without a valid government issued license to do so (which should be easily obtainable by anyone capable of convincing a board of review that they are emotionally and financially prepared for the responsibilities of parenthood). This can be easily enforced by mandating that all pubescent, pre-menopausal girls and women be provided with, and required to use, government supplied Norplant. The penalty for removal of said Norplant without obtaining a valid breeding license should be immediate sterilization.