Is this HP’s new tablet, running Windows 7? And if so, are they nuts?
The hardware looks fairly nice—complete with Windows and “Intel Inside” advertising stickers!—but as always, trying to run a desktop operating system on a touchscreen device is an instant failure. It’s clear that nothing is made to be tapped, it’s all a hacky touch layer on top of a system made for a mouse. You can even see the mouse pointer for a second when the system loads before whatever script comes along and hides it. The reviewer describes the scrolling as “pretty fast.” He’s nuts too.
It looks as if HP and others think that the success of the iPad just means that the tablet computer’s time has finally come, and they can release the same thing they’ve been trying to make work for years with a new case that makes it look like an iPad. They’re very wrong. The iPad’s success isn’t because the world was suddenly ready for it, it’s because Apple started from scratch. Because they’re not lazy as fuck, and because they care obsessively about user experience. Sometimes too obsessively, sure, but that’s better than this garbage.
The topper is the dedicated hardware button to summon the onscreen keyboard. You actually have to push this button to make the keyboard appear, even if you’ve just tapped into a text field. WTF.

So close, so far away.
Which is why this isn’t a consumer device. It’s enterprise-only for use in specialized sectors.
What 2:19 said.
Where is my commercial grade Android tablet that is a competitor to the iPad?
Well, if Appleholics would just “settle” for a TRUE table PC, like my HP TZ 2500, then the rest of the lemmings wouldn’t feel compelled to buy a Windows version of your punk-ass enbiggened iPhone…
@2 – Who cares? People in those “specialized sectors” are going to pulling their hair out.
@3 – The Samsung Galaxy Tab looks pretty promising, but could be quite expensive. But in any case there will be an overabundance of Android tablets soon enough.
@4 – Yes, you’re correct. Everyone else is wrong. Stated for the record.
@6:
Thank you for acknowledging that fact.
Even techies hate it. And that takes a lot.
this was painful to watch.
On the sidebar of the youtube page was a video from HP earlier this spring — the UI in their video looks much more iPad-like than Windows 7: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AeDalRBjy…
Shouldn’t the control-alt-delete button actually be three buttons awkwardly placed all on different edges of the device?
@5 Who cares? Anyone who needs to install windows software on a tablet form-factor. Anyone who needs to run internal software or use an existing enterprise network on a tablet form-factor. Anyone who wants to do photo editing or graphic design on a tablet form-factor which also supports a pressure-sensitive stylus (as this does). Believe it or not, there are still people who use computers for stuff other than dicking around on the internet and nifty but mostly useless apps.
I can’t fucking believe there is still such little competition to the iPad. AND people speculated for years, before iPad was announced, that they’d come up with one!! That is why NOW ‘iPad’ is synonymous with ‘tablet computer.’ ftw
I heard Steve Ballmer personally designed this.
@14:
Well, if that’s the case we can at least be thankful he didn’t create it from a solid block of magnesium or whatever…
I’d really love to know when this video was made. If it predates the Palm acquisition, then hopefully this monstrosity will never ship — hell, it might be the reason they bought Palm.
Oh god, I just got to the middle:
“Sorry about the video quality, I’m recording on my iPhone.”
Game, set and match to Apple.
Yes, it’s klugy and ugly, but it would be worth the hassle if it could actually run Autocad, Cubase, Excel, Photoshop, etc. But this thing is so underpowered that it can barely handle Windows, let alone Windows apps. At least the iPad doesn’t pretend to be anything more than a toy.
Apple didn’t start from scratch when they made the Ipad, they started from Iphone.
Hahaha what a piece of crap. I like how the dweeb in the video seems to think that by saying “Pretty fast.” over and over he’ll make it come true.
Ugh. Good thing I was not remotely considering buying one of these things.
Honestly I haven’t even found a need for an iPad yet. My 13″ MBP is all the portable computing I need. Battery life is similar to the iPad and it’s way more powerful and versatile.
Recording the video on an iPhone. He doesn’t get the irony, does he?
It has a “control-alt-delete” key. I think I peed in my pants when he said that! 😉
HP is using the Palm OS on the Slate. Why do you think they acquired Palm? It wasn’t because they sell a lot of mobile phones.
@19 Actually it was the other way around; Apple R&D developed an early iPad, but Jobs decided to put it on hold and use the concept first for the iPhone / iPod touch; then go back several years later and do the iPad.
I can’t WAIT for the endless parade of “iPad killers” that the corrupt tech media will shill for, one after another, as they crash, burn, and disappear. Its going to be quite a show – bring ’em on!!
And may Steve Ballmer remain CEO for as long as it takes…