Saying that gay-rights opponents were never in danger, US District Court Judge Benjamin Settle handed down a ruling this morning that orders the state to release the names of over 100,000 voters who signed petitions for Referendum 71. Signers of R-71 were seeking to put the rights of same-sex partners to a vote in 2009.
Here is Judge Settle’s 31-page order.
Christian activists behind the petition drive had claimed in Doe v. Reed—a case that went all the way to the Supreme Court—that making the names public (as all petitions are) would expose them to harassment and violence. Settle knocked down that argument, declaring in his judgement, “The facts before the Court in this case, however, do not rise to the level of demonstrating that a reasonable probability of threats, harassment, or reprisals exists as to the signers of R-71.”
Anne Levinson, who chaired the campaign to uphold the partnership rights for gay couples, predictably declared the decision a “victory.” Then she added this biting statement: “The irony should not go unnoticed that these right-wing groups promote divisive measures and then demand a special right to secrecy because the strong disagreement that follows makes them uncomfortable. Yet these same groups and individuals who say they may be harmed by the public having information about an election are never troubled that the very laws they try to get passed through these campaigns result in real harm to LGBT individuals and families.”
A group called WhoSigned.org wanted to post the names and addresses of R-71 signers online, they said, in order to let people civilly confront anti-gay petition signers.
After reaching the Supreme Court, the case was kicked back down to the lower federal court, which issued today’s ruling. Secretary of State’s office spokesman Brian Zylstra did not know when the petitions would be released or if there was any further potential for appeal.

“Secretary of State’s office spokesman Brian Zylstra did not know when the petitions would be released or if there was any further potential for appeal.”
Meaning that the the office, no doubt under direct orders from Secretary of State and GOP gubenatorial candidate McKenna himself, will stall, then drag their feet, then equivocate, then start stalling all over again, for as long as they possibly can.
The state Supreme Court has spoken. The United States Supreme Court has spoken. The federal courts have spoken, several times. What has to happen before they will follow the law?
@1) I dunno… McKenna and Reed have led the charge to release the records. It’s their case.
Let’s hope this judge’s decision Settles the matter once and for all.
Hahaha. I know it won’t; I just like his name.
Is there any way they can be fined or jailed for failure to comply with a court order?
this one’s going to the SCOTUS, where justice shall surely reign. as it always does.
#4 – You mean it will go to the US Supreme Court for a second time? The Court already heard the case once, and ruled in favor of release (on a condition that was handed back down to a lower federal court to review, resulting in this ruling.)
If they’re afraid to have their names released, they should feel how scary it is to always have religious fanatics deciding their rights. Now that’s scary. Fucking coward assholes.
@5: oh, i forgot. this feels like it’s been going on forever, probably because it has.
I hope none of them stiffed any bartenders on the Hill.
@3 if someone anonymously put the names on Torrent, and directs the Stranger and other media to it, what are they going to do? Once public records are outed, that’s it.
@9 – Can we just wait a little while until they actually get jailed for contempt of court? Then release the names.
@10 perfect situation there and amusing. Equally amusing, if you ask me, if someone leveraged the full anonymous firepower of the properly-wielded Internet to stick them in the eye.
So once we finally get the names, who wants to go in on some Metro bus ads that say “I’m a Mormon” then lists as many names as we can legibly fit on one ad, and then keep putting them out till we’re through all the names?
@1 Do you have any understanding of how the state government operates? McKenna is the Attorney General, not the Secretary of State. That is Sam Reed, a very different man than Mr. McKenna in both duties & temperament.
You might do better hand-wringing over whether gremlins or orcs will attack you.
When can I look up the names, I want to never patronize any business that signed this.
@13 – You are right, my bad. Sorry about the mix up.
The R-71 petition signatures are currently being posted online at
http://www.scribd.com/HaxoAnglemark