Just months after voters roundly rejected two liquor privatization initiatives, lawmakers in Olympia are scrambling to introduce liquor privatization bills, because, you know, “the will of the people” and all that. Fucking hypocrites.

Yeah, I know, I’m in the minority here on Slog amongst both readers and writers in regards to my opposition toward privatization, and so I don’t expect to change many minds here on the fundamentals of this issue. After all, the nearest liquor store to our office is over a block away, so I can understand the outrage. But what really galls me is the way special interests and their surrogates in the legislature are attempting to disingenuously use our state’s current budget crisis as cover for literally giving away the store.

For example, take SB 5933, which is creatively titled “AN ACT Relating to enhancing state revenues by reforming laws regulating the distribution and sale of spirits and wine,” but is really focused on enhancing shareholder value at Costco, Safeway, Kroger, Albertson’s and other retail giants. SB 5933 is essentially a retread of last November’s failed I-1100, but with two main differences: It doesn’t touch beer distribution, thus removing the beer industry from the fight (and the millions of dollars it pumped into last year’s No campaign), and it denies retail licenses to stores smaller than nine thousand square feet, eliminating the effective rhetorical argument against selling liquor in neighborhood minimarts… while also eliminating competition to giant liquor resellers like Costco.

Clever, clever.

But what the bill doesn’t do is enhance long term state revenues. It doesn’t attempt to sell off the state’s profitable retail and distribution systems to the highest bidder(s), and it sure as hell doesn’t protect the interests of future budgets. The bill does levy a license fee equal to 10 percent of sales for the first two years, and three percent of sales for years three to five, but after that the annual license fee is $166.00. Of course, these private liquor retailers would pay tax, but we already collect a tax on the sale of liquor so that’s a wash. Unless, of course, liquor consumption dramatically increases… which is exactly what a recent study by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) says will happen, and with devastating results:

Following privatization, consumption of privatized beverages increased substantially (median relative increase of 48.2%; interquartile interval [IQI]: 0.0% to 136.7%), and there was little effect on per capita consumption of non-privatized beverages (median decrease of 2.0%; IQI: -5.0% to -0.4%), resulting in substantial net increases in per capita alcohol consumption.

[…] According to the Single Distribution Theory, patterns, or “distributions,” of alcohol consumption are similar across many societies, such that most people drink a small or moderate amount and some people drink a large amount. Because of this pattern, when per capita—or average—consumption changes in a society, consumption changes across the board, but mostly among those who drink excessively. There is extensive evidence supporting the Single Distribution Theory, which allows the inference made in this review that when privatization results in substantial per capita increases in consumption, there are at the same time substantial increases in excessive consumption.

Because of this substantial increase in consumption by those who drink excessively, and based solely on the associated public health consequences, the CDC now officially recommends against further privatization, concluding:

The maintenance of government control of off-premises sale of alcoholic beverages is one of many effective strategies to prevent or reduce excessive consumption which is one of the leading causes of preventable death and disability.

I’m not raising the public health impact as a moral argument, but rather to point out that there are very real costs associated with excessive consumption, costs to taxpayers which no fiscal note will ever attempt to quantify. Costs which are totally ignored by those who argue that dramatically increasing consumption will ultimately “enhance” state revenues. Make the libertarian or convenience argument if you want, but this is not a revenue enhancement bill.

At the same time SB 5933 seeks to give away the store to Costco and other large corporations, there is another proposal, as recognized in the House budget, that would generate an estimated $300 million in revenue upfront by leasing out the state’s liquor distribution operations. I’m not entirely trustful of this proposal’s backers’ motives either, but as explained to me by spokesman Sandeep Kaushik, it’s a much better deal for taxpayers. Kaushik says the proposal calls for putting out an RFP to competitive bidders, and that in addition to the $300 million upfront payment, the lease would include substantial payments throughout its 20-year term, $1.7 billion total. Then after 20 years, the state would own any improvements made to its distribution system, and either resume control or put operations out to bid for another lease. Compare that to the roughly $382 million SB 5933 would generate for the state over the same 20-year period by privatizing both distribution and retail, and more than tripling the number of outlets selling liquor. (Ironically, this bill would likely reduce the number of outlets throughout much of rural Washington, were communities are currently served by small mom-and-pop licensees.)

Perhaps the distribution privatization proposal really would ultimately earn the state more money than its current operations. Perhaps not. We’d have to see the bids. But it wouldn’t change the character of our state, and it wouldn’t dramatically increase excess consumption. On the other hand, SB 5833 is just a bad deal for taxpayers, yet another naked money-grab by Costco and its cohorts at a time when we can’t afford to be giving away revenue.

23 replies on “Latest Liquor Privatization Proposal a Bad Deal for Taxpayers”

  1. Hey Goldy, would you support one that was truly revenue neutral, at least, to the state overall?

    Because you know, some of us would just would like to be able to legally buy any hooch we’d like, even if the state doesn’t feel like carrying it, and without ordering a case.

  2. @2: pretty much this. also goldy, it may be a block away from stranger hq, but it has hours that are tighter than bankers’. i might let the luddites who think state ownership is a good idea have their 1950s if the stores would stay open late and on the weekends.

  3. Im a little confused. Stranger cheat sheet guide said to vote yes on I-1100 back in November 2010, which would have done the same thing this law would have done, punch a biger hole in the state budget.

    How is the state “Fucking hypocrites” for wanting to resurect a law that the stranger originally endorsed?

  4. @4,

    What’s hypocritical is the way lawmakers won’t consider tax increases because voters said no last November, yet they’re so quick to embrace liquor privatization just months after voters said no.

    As for the Stranger’s endorsement, I don’t see what this has to do with Olympia’s hypocrisy on ballot measures, but that said, the endorsement was wrong. I said so multiple times on Slog last fall. We are not Borg here. We disagree.

  5. I’m with Goldy on this one. Why should liquor revenue go to giant corporations instead of the state general fund? We should be agitating for changes withing the WSLCB such as later operating hours and looser control over bars instead of giving away the farm.

  6. Your liquor store may be a block away, Goldy, but fuck Capitol Hill. There was no store between U Village and the far end of Ballard, to as far north as 105th, for YEARS. There must be 100,000 people in that catchment area, people with some serious money, too, but no liquor store for you. Now we’ve got one back, just one, in an inconvenient corner of Wallingford.

    FUCK THE WSLCB.

    I still refuse to believe that the outrageous overhead the state pays to run it’s 80-year-old distribution system and store network isn’t gobbling up a lot more of that supposed state revenue than they’re claiming. Christ, even their website looks like it was designed in 1933.

    FUCK THE WSLCB. It’s a legal product, let people sell it. Sell the licenses at a couple grand a year or whatever rate recoups the revenue, and watch the tax roll in.

    Goldy, your anti-booze argument is pure Prohibition. Let people make their own decisions.

  7. @6: For that matter why should any sort of revenue go to giant corporations instead of the state general fund? Why is liquor different from other goods in this respect?

    Look, I’m all for taxing the shit out of corporations. Let’s just do that and do it effectively instead.

  8. @9, as we see every day, big corporations are better at tax evasion than states are at taxation. I drink, I don’t think liquor is hard to get, I don’t find the selection too small (have you bought liqour in a bodega?, and I don’t think the prices are too high. I have lived in states with private liquor stores, it’s all about neighborhoods. Hell, they have local option in Texas and Oklahoma, that’s a weird system for you.

  9. I like Oregon’s approach: the stores are franchised, and while the state dictates a number of hours open per week, it’s up to the franchisees to set those hours.

    Goldy, like you I like the current arrangement just fine, but I do think extending opening hours and offering more selection could still keep to the idea of restricting availability and reducing alcohol abuse, which is why the state is in the booze biz in the first place…

  10. @8, what the fuck are you talking about now? It didn’t have fuck-all to do with the UW, it had to do with them closing the store at 45th and Stone Way (where Archie McPhee is) and not finding other retail space in Wallingford for several years. The UW isn’t anywhere near Wallingford. You’re a fucking idiot.

  11. @8: god do you anything about anything? Aside from not having one on campus the U had nothing to fucking do with it. The restrictions on liquor near campuses went out long ago.

    The lack of stores was due to sheer indifference and incompetence at WSLCB. The liquor board is like the last vestige of East German state run markets living on in the west.

  12. Goldy I wholeheartedly agree with you, and thank you for posting relevant data to support your argument that will then be ignored by the legion of keyboard-mashing illiterates.

  13. @8 the hell it was. The University has little influence (if any) over Ballard. WiS is wrong about something again, how surprising.

  14. @8 and if you’re referring to the exclusion zone, that went out DECADES ago. How old are you, and when was the last time you were even in the U District?

  15. @12 Just nitpicking here, but it was only a little over one year between the closure of the Stone Way store and the opening of the one by Dick’s.

  16. Goldy, you talk to the spokesman of one proposal, accept his numbers at face value, draw conclusions, and call yourself a journalist? Why didn’t you talk to the proponents of SB 5933. What is their take on HB 2085 and SB 5942? How do you know that HB 2085 and SB 5942 aren’t what you call “money-grabs?” How do you know that HB 2085 and SB 5942 don’t “give away the store?” HB 2085 and SB 5942 do nothing for the consumer, about whom you don’t care anyway. If we don’t care about the consumer, why can’t the state manage the distribution system to obtain the benefits the proposed lessees say they can obtain. However, you’re right to question the main backer of HB 2085 and SB 5942, Tom Luce, about whom KUOW wrote the following: http://www.kuow.org/program.php?id=20941

  17. As long as Washington is too dumb to get their tax revenue progressively, and from income, and instead uses these idiotic flat taxes on sales, Washington deserves to buy liquor from dismal, mismanaged Soviet Russian-style state run stores. The people of this state did this to themselves.

  18. @18, really? It seemed a lot longer to me. Of course, I let my subscription to WSLCB Daily Bulletin lapse, and I try to avoid driving down that stretch of 45th if I can possibly help it, so I didn’t know it was there for a long time. Time passes slowly when you’re wandering the aisles of the dismal Greenwood store.

    Of course, during that time frame I was out of state numerous times and got to admire the many large, bountifully stocked stores in more civilized parts of the country, which made it worse. We should have at least one store here that puts Lee’s in Las Vegas to shame. But no.

  19. “Just months after voters roundly rejected two liquor privatization initiatives”

    I’m kind of impressed by the way you can lie through your fucking teeth and smile at the same time.

    We didn’t REJECT either of them. We voted for BOTH.

    I’m straight up calling you a liar Goldy. A liar and a closet conservative with a prohibitionist social agenda.

    fuck you.

Comments are closed.