On the heels of Costco’s liquor privatization bill comes a pickled beast of another breed: A proposal to hand over the state-run liquor distribution warehouse to private management—a proposal that could streamline sales and net the state an additional $300 million during the current biennium, according to the measure’s proponents.
“The state would continue to control regulation and enforcement but they’d have a private partner that would operate the wholesale side of business for a set number of years—20 years or so,” explains political consultant Sandeep Kaushik, who’s helped draft the measure in collaboration with Tom Luce, a Tacoma business consultant. “In exchange, the private partner would make a major one-time contribution of $300 million or more to the state, as well as share a percentage of the profits.”
The good news for union folks: The proposal would retain state-run stores (and thus, union jobs). The bad news for everyone else: the proposal would retain state-run stores (whose hours are set on the clock of a retiree).
Kaushik says the proposal is based on Maine’s current liquor distribution system, which privatized in 2004 (and not without problems). Washington’s state-run system has been in place since prohibition. A private company, he argues, could make the process more efficient, and usher in new, more varied liquor selection. This would give both the public and bars better access to products (every bar in the state must buy from a certain state liquor store. If that store runs out of a particular brand of liquor that they want, the bar is basically SOL).
Another upshot of the measure says Kaushik: it won’t impact public safety by expanding liquor outlets—a concern raised with last year’s dueling privatization initiatives.
“Our proposal is an alternative to privatization—it’s a modernization proposal,” says Kaushik. ” I think we’ve got an idea that would be a good for taxpayers.”
But what’s unclear, at this early stage, is how much new revenue—outside of that one-time private contribution—the proposal would generate for the state. Still, $300 million is a sprint ahead of Governor Christine Gregoire’s proposal to open 15 new state liquor stores, including specialty stores, “super stores,” and a few stores within supermarkets—all to generate roughly $4.5 million in revenue.
And thus far, Kaushik says stakeholders are open to the idea—labor unions, legislators, beer and wine stakeholders, and community leaders concerned about the public safety hazards of full privatization have all shown interest in the proposal.
His group is interested in dropping the bill this session, most likely in the next week or two.

A private company improves efficiencies when it is forced to due to competition from other private companies. That is not the case in this proposal. This is just a private company buying a monopoly from the state.
This does exactly squat to allow me to buy vodka at midnight in a large city.
@1 Again, the drunks at the Stranger care more about easier access to booze than good policy.
@I’ve lived in two Canadian provinces with public liquor distribution systems. they are unionized. They also have huge selections and great hours. These concepts are not mutually exclusive.
Public liquor systems deliver a LOT of money to public coffers, paying for services you rely on.
Instead of lobbying for privatization, lobby for better service.
So governement gets what they want, business gets what they want, and the customer keeps getting fucked, just like always. We get to pay double the price for a product so everyone can have their cut. It costs me 8 hours each way, and 100 in gas, to drive to California. Bootlegging is profitable once again.
Kaushik has lost his mind. The liquor privatization ballot measures failed last fall for two reasons: (1) there were two competing measures, which confused and split voters; and (2) both had serious flaws.
Likewise, Costco’s current bill and Kaushik’s proposal are also both deeply flawed. Costco’s bill sets up a structure that grossly favors large stores and large distributors, virtually guaranteeing the closure of many of the smaller liquor stores, and driving small micro-brewers and wineries out of business. It would actually make it less convenient to buy liquor in densely populated cities, like Seattle, where we don’t have warehouse-sized stores in neighborhoods. Kaushik’s proposal sounds like nothing but a giveaway to a private management company that would provide almost zero benefit to consumers or taxpayers, and lock it in place under a 20 year contract. No thanks.
Look, I’ve stated many times that I think the state has no business holding a monopoly selling a legal retail product, and that this is a stupid nanny-state holdover from the Prohibition era. But if you are going to do away with state-monopoly liquor stores, you have to do it right. Set up a tax structure that is revenue-neutral to the state. Set up a regulatory/licensing structure that provides good oversight and public safety, without providing a handout to warehouse businesses and choking out all the micro-brewers and wineries. It really shouldn’t be this difficult.
This proposal is a “pig.” For what distributor are Kaushik and Luce working?
Is this the same Tom Luce referred to in this story?:
http://www.kuow.org/program.php?id=20941
It baffles me that Slog writers (except Goldy) and commenters are such conservative libertarians on this issue.
Liquor store hours and hours have NOTHING to do with privatization. We can increase hours and add more stores and increase revenue and add good jobs and make it easier for businesses WITH state liquor stores, by modernizing and reform.
There is absolutely no need to privatize except for the sake of following libertarian philosophy (or if you’re a Costco executive and want a 4th boat).
@4 is correct.
We can change our model, but we use it to hand out patronage appointments to politically-connected people.
Which means the incumbents of both parties don’t actually want to change it.
How much does the state make per year from the warehouse/distribution end of liquor sales?
This is 20 year deal for $300 million up front. So if the state currently makes anything more than $15 million a year, this is REALLY HORRIBLE idea!
(Reminds me of the 90s when the big thing in business was to sell off your corporate property or subdivision to another firm for up-front cash then lease the site/service back at a monthly rate — makes the books look really great for this quarter, but fucks the stock holders (or in this case, the citizens) interests in the long run.)
And for the love of Thor, why do legislators ever go for the “one time payment”? If Costco wants a monopoly so bad, make them pay for it year after year.
Hey, Carl, look! Recurring costs are making us go over budget!
Not to worry, Tom. This one-time infusion of cash will solve all our problems forever!
Good thinking, Carl. Now let’s never tax millionaires.*
m!
* (Sorry.)
@1 is correct. What’s wrong with the state system isn’t just that it’s a state system, it’s that it’s a monopoly. All that stuff about having to buy from the same store, that’s just a rule; it could be changed tomorrow with the stroke of a bureaucrat’s pen. But the bureaucrat will never move his pen until the fear of competition forces him to.
This does nothing but transfer the monopoly. The state needs to get the hell out of the liquor business ENTIRELY, and let people compete over it. This could easily be done without costing the state money.
Or revenue positive.
And what’s the need for keeping it public other than preserving a laughably small number of unionized jobs? You do realize that most grocery chains are union shops? You do realize that many non-unionized grocery chains have similar pay and benefits as unionized stores? What is the government interest in running what is a private enterprise in any non-Puritanical state?
You are fooling yourself if you think the state’s reluctance to change the system is anything less than alcohol-related hysteria and the liquor control board’s determination to preserve *their* overcompensated and superfluous jobs. Both of these things, by the way, are why we will never have the “reform” you say we can get and that will be as good as privatization.
The State Liquor Control Board’s 2009 report said they made $332.7 million in net revenue in 2009 alone (http://liq.wa.gov/publications/2009-WSLC…). This one-time payment of $300 million seems like a pretty shitty deal to me. Try again, Costco.
@10 has a very very good More Corporate Giveaways of Middle Class Tax Dollars point.
oh, hey, if you’re in Canada, you should really check out cbc.ca/voteelection – it’s a cool interactive quiz that lets you choose which parties most closely match your own beliefs.
I was surprised that it said I was a Green, not NDP, and that my son was a Liberal.
Mind you, even the Conservative party up there is way to the left of the Democrats here.
More liquor, please, more DUIs, more street fights, more beaten spouses (female, male, transgendered, etc.) and children, more dead and homeless people, more, more, more, bring it on, all of it. But don’t legalize cannabis, it’s the gateway to Hades.
Any bill that doesn’t make it legal for me to buy from Bevmo and have it shipped to my home is useless to me.
#5 has it!!! I’ll take a long summer trip or ask a friend to mail me some bottles.