If you haven’t already, go read this article on the arrest of David Flory, the New Jersey professor accused of running an elaborate prostitution website out of New Mexico. According to the article, Flory told police that he wasn’t in it for the money. “He flat-out told us his thing was he wanted to create a safe place for prostitutes and johns to get together,” said a New Mexican lieutenant who questioned Flory.
And for three years, the website seemingly made sex safer for 200 prostitutes and 1,200 clients:
Police said the Southwest Companions website had three levels or ratings for johns: probation, verified and trust.
“In order to get off probation you had to sleep with one of the prostitutes on the website and she in turn would tell the moderator (Flory) what acts occurred, how much they paid and any comments,” he said. “That opened you up to verified status. Once you got into verified status that opened you up to different girls available. Then, some would e-mail the moderator, ‘This is the act, this is how much he paid, these are my comments about it.'”
After so many of those, Roseman said, members moved into trusted status, which afforded access to features such as training videos on what do if you got caught by police. Members who reached the trusted level also could rate prostitutes.
This idea sounds brilliant—these are the kinds of checks and balances we need in place to make paid-for sex, which will never stop happening, safer between strangers. If Flory did indeed create the website, he should be awarded with a goddamn medal; His idea should be adopted and expanded in every state.
Instead, he’s arrested by police and labeled creepy and “irresponsible” by closed-minded former students. And his job might be in danger. What bullshit.

New Mexico tax dollars hard at work. How much did they spend on this? Did they find any exploited (underaged, human trafficed, and other unwilling types) ho’s? Anyone who had ever threatened a prostitute before? Did they find any real crimes in this investigation?
Selling is legal.
Fucking is legal.
Why isn’t selling fucking legal?
Why is it illegal to sell something that’s perfectly legal to give away for free?
-George Carlin
I’m not specifically calling Cienna out on this because I’ve seen it a lot lately, but when did “closed minded” become “close minded”? And how do you have your mind physically near something?
I was hoping that SLOG would pick up this story when I first read it yesterday. Yes, assuming that there are no other angles to his motivations, the man should be thanked and applauded rather than arrested.
Nitpick: The first student quoted described him as not creepy; her entire quote was basically complimentary.
@3 – Thank you. It has taken every pedantic bone in my body to not complain about that. Glad I wasn’t the first to snap.
@5 I was just going to point this out, too. Also, the former students didn’t arrest him; cops did. Also, he’s a NJ professor, not NY.
There are prostitute review boards in every state in the country.
Why isn’t there anything about the arrests made in the Jennifer Walstrand case up yet?
The burden of a phony Christian morality.
@all, thanks for the nit-picking; I put this up fast and will make small corrections.
But regarding the creepy comment–the student says “I never got that creepy vibe from him.” Notice her use of the word *that* instead of *a*. I took her quote to mean that she found his alleged website creepy and that he was by proxy a creep. She’d just never before gotten *that* vibe from him.
But maybe I’m reading too much into it.
Ugh. If his only motivation was creating a safer work environment for prostitutes, I don’t see what he did wrong.
@11, Even if his motivation was profit (did he even get a cut?) I don’t see what he did wrong. He made sex-work safer, so what if there was a profit motive, too.
And now reading the article, it doesn’t sound like there really was any money in it for him. Cienna’s right, the dude deserves a medal, not our censure.
How about this? I think producing and selling meth is dangerous to those who do it. I think otherwise decent people get into bad habits and break the law to maintain or support those habits. It isn’t THEIR fault that society hates mind warped tweakers who think only about their next high, after all!
So, I’ll set up a website connecting meth labs that have good OSHA standards for production and an abiding concern about the toxic chemicals used in that production with reputable addicts victimized by societies hatred of their honorable habit.. I won’t make any money on it, since my only interest is the safety of the bottom dwelling scum who risk their health and that of their neighbors by making their homes a hazmat site. And of course, I wouldn’t want the brain addled meth addict or hooking tweaker who can’t hold a job to have to go to disreputable dealers, for goodness sake!
This is about conspiring to break the law. Whether prostitution should be illegal or not is a different question. As it happens I think it should be legal so that we can monitor sex workers health and really nail the bastards who try to hire underage prostitutes.
But this (hopefully former) academic is trying to contravene the law as it stands. At least he should lose his job. At best he should also spend some quality time with others who break the law at the expense of his county in a pleasant concrete room with bars at the door.
It really takes a special kind of stupid to take the postitions Madrid takes. I mean, this is ‘award for brain twistingly moronic’ stupid here! Congrats Madrid, just when I thought you could get no more idiotic, you go and prove me wrong!
@Seattleblues, the law is wrong. Should slaves in the Antebellum South have waited until slavery was illegal to attempt escape from bondage and abuse?
Should Susan B Anthony have waited until 1920 to cast a vote in a presidential election?
Was Martin Luther King Jr.’s campaign of non-compliance truly criminal?
Was it truly inexcusable to dodge the draft during the Vietnam War?
As it is, the law makes prostitution very dangerous for many women and girls. Why should women have to wait for the law to roll over to their side to try and make themselves safe?
Somebody who screens clients to filter out ones who are not trustworthy? I think that frequently falls under the job description of a pimp. At least he was a seemingly benevolent pimp, but I do not see how that is worthy of a medal.
20 posts and still nobody’s noticed the huge typo in the headline.
@14: See #2 to understand why prostitution and meth are not really comparable.
@14: Yes, Seattleblues. Selling sex is exactly the same as meth. I’m glad you’ve brought up another shitty analog. Congrats.
@3, @5 – your “close minded” and “closed minded” are both wrong. “Close-minded” and “closed-minded” are both correct.
The thing is, I know you think it ought to be legal, and I think it ought to be legal, but the fact is, it’s not legal. The man is abetting the commission of crimes. Cops don’t make the law, they enforce the law. If you don’t like it, contact your legislature. Good luck with that.
@21,22
They’re both illegal. They’re both engaged in by addicts who’d risk marriages, jobs or anything else to get their fix. They both are associated with nuisance crimes. (Among the biggest reasons cited for keeping prostitution illegal, btw, not morality as such.)
Again, I think prostitution should be legal for consenting adults. But the silly ‘everyone does it anyway, so it should be legal’ argument isn’t why. I just happen to think we can help the prostitutes who are the victims a great deal better with substance abuse or other psychiatric help, career training and so on. Or we could continue giving them criminal records that make a meaningful constructive life that much more difficult for them, force them to hide physical assault or rape for fear of prosection and so on.
But the biggest thing, they’re both illegal. The good professor can stand up in his class and passionately advocate for legalized prostitution. He can spend his weekends on grass roots campaigns to achieve that end.
What he can’t legally do is advocate for or conspire to assist in crimes. He got caught, and should get whatever the law provides as penalty. And he should be fired, and ideally not re-hired in education.
@24: Your opinion is valid. But do you seriously think that running a “responsible” prostitution ring is akin to running a “responsible” meth lab?
I’d say it’s more like providing clean needles to addicts than supplying them with drugs.
@24: “They’re both illegal. “
RULE OF LAW IS AWESOME
I agree with Reg @20. He wasn’t doing this for charity; he was, in fact, pimping. Not to say the website idea isn’t a good one — it is — but the way he went about it was dumb, obviously illegal, and for those reasons, kinda creepy. At the very least ya gotta admit it was bad activism. Comparing him with Martin Luther King is wrong on so many levels.
Interesting that the police were tipped off by prostitutes and johns. Why would they blow his cover if the site was working out so well for them? It’s a legitimate question to ask.
@27, I do not mean to say he was like MLK Jr, my point to SB is simply that breaking the law is not always wrong. This fellow was not making any effort by way of this website to take leadership in a social movement, but if the scheme worked (I am curious about the tips from prostitutes and johns as well) he was directly making the lives of 200 sex-workers safer, and that deserves some respect, I think. Sure it was dumb, and obviously illegal, but nothing about it was necessarily unethical (again, I am curious about those tips).