PI:
A list from Travel + Leisure Magazine paints a pretty vivid picture of Seattle: We’re the girl who went to prom with a purse full of books.
The yearbook probably said we were voted most likely to write a great American novel, and we’re wearing braces in our senior-class picture.
The magazine released its list of “America’s Favorite Cities” Monday, and Seattle doesn’t come out looking so loved. Sure, we’re ranked first for coffee bars and second for levels of intelligence. (Portland came in first in the smarty-pants race.) But Seattle landed in the bottom 10 in three important “people” categories: attractiveness, friendliness and style.
Because Travel + Leisure Magazine lists Charleston, South Carolina as the most wonderful city in America, we can suspect the presence of Boeing money in all of this. But it’s impossible to disagree with the opinion that Seattle desperately needs an influx of stylish people.

so many bad looks in this thread.
I would also like to point out that this thread is now number one in most commented. Charles owes us all a drink.
@147 I think you a word from your post. Also you said everyone in Seattle looked like potatos regardless of their disgusting clothing.
@149- Hell’s Angels thoughtfully write their identities on the back of their jackets. I recognize bike shoes, sure. I recognize construction helmets and the more extreme subculture uniforms. BUT I don’t know what makes a suit an in-style suit or an out of style suit. When I got a suit for interviews (back during the abortive Librarian career), I talked to the guy at the suit store because I would have bought something retarded if I didn’t. A suit is a suit to me, unless it’s a tuxedo. I think everyone in a tuxedo looks like a waiter. When I pick out a shirt to wear, I make sure it’s not the same color as the pants I’m wearing because an ex-girlfriend told me that looks bad. When I pick out a shirt to buy I make sure it’s a solid earth tone and on sale. I am only participating in fashion because I am not allowed to completely divorce myself from it. I don’t have to choose a sweater over a hoodie. I own ONE hoodie. I also own a fleece vest for when the hoodie would be too warm. (Yeah Fnarf, fleece. Soft, warm, breathable fleece. Like a functional relationship, it never confines you but always keeps you safe. It’s hoogly like a Danish puppy.)
When I meet other people, I do not notice their clothes. I see it, I can describe it, but I’m generally looking at their faces for their expression and listening to their voices. I’ve been told I “pay great attention,” which I think might be a nice way of saying I stare. I really hope women haven’t put any effort into dressing up for me, because aside from the revealingness of their garb, I it’s passed me by. I’m pretty face-blind, so when people dress differently than usual I have trouble recognizing them and it bugs me.
Lissa, you obviously care a lot about clothes. I believe you. Can you believe I don’t care and don’t notice? That getting dressed is like blowing my nose, a slightly unpleasant task that circumstances require I endure?
I have never worn anything other than a dress, at least since I came here on the greyhound from Lafeyette, Indianna,
But then again, I have spent all my time in a basement on Beacon Hill, so I don’t know that anyone has noticed.
@ 153 Of course I believe you, and again I’m not going to judge you for what you wear. I know my profession makes me more sensitive to these things just like yours makes you more aware of all the subtleties of bicycles and your back ground in Library Science gives you special insight into the many ways information can be organized and conveyed. I am not hoping to convert you. What I would like is that you recognize that even though something doesn’t click with you doesn’t mean it is with out value.
“Style” is, by definition, a waste of time, money and effort”
That statement is true for you, but it is not a universal, and it was that which set me off. I mean Fnarf could say the same about fleece! So give the Sparkle Pony a lump of sugar, and we’ll call it even shall we? 🙂 And come to slog happy.
#140 right on! i agree wholeheartedly.
i really had no idea regarding the passive aggressiveness or seattle freeze when i moved to seattle from brooklyn, ny. in new york city, a city where there is so little personal space people do not make eye contact on the street, it was incredibly easy to make friends. i made friends at work at concerts at art shows, everywhere. lots of my friends lived in new york before i did and their friends would embrace me as a friend when they knew we had a friend in common. my social circle was huge in new york (and included a significant amount of people in new jersey, too). people were genuine and did not pretend to be your friend if they didn’t like you. people say what they mean and mean what they say and there is no time for passive aggressive bullshit. (though there is plenty of aggressive bullshit there and assholes are there, just like seattle, just like everywhere) and the diversity in brooklyn and nyc was so awesome – people, food, music, whatever – a million different flavors of each.
i moved to seattle and was like where did everybody go? it is SO WHITE. and segregated. and 90% of my friends were people who were not natives. i had the blessed fortune of meeting one native whose philosophy is you introduce the good people to the good people – she always shares her social circle, invites people in, connects people, and her life is full of more friendship, love, and happiness than anyone i know. the few natives i did become friends with were through work or a shared political cause (trying to get bush out of office in 2004).
my first social experiences in seattle? i went to the cha cha (i had moved to capitol hill and it seemed like a nyc divey type bar). sat down at the bar and tried to initiate a conversation with someone sitting next to me (not an unusual thing to do at a bar) and the guy actually said he wasn’t interested (“i’m alright” he said and TURNED HIS BACK TO ME AND IGNORED ME THE REST OF THE TIME I WAS THERE). a barista on capitol ill constantly interrogated me about brooklyn whenever i wore my brooklyn sweatshirt (what’s the zip code what’s the area code? blah blah blah – why someone who makes coffee cared so much about my brooklyn sweatshirt and felt i had no credibility to wear it is beyond me) and when i called him out on his passive aggressive BS he acted all horrified like i had slapped him in the face. people i met casually who said ‘yeah let’s meet up at happy hour’ wouldn’t show up. no call either. at work people would say i was being aggressive when i was just being direct. i had to relearn how to communicate. i had to subjugate a great deal of my personality when initially dealing with people (which for the most part i am not good at doing AT ALL). i took a personal physical defense class with Home Alive because Seattle felt scary and empty and dangerous at night (whereas NYC was always full of so many people). i was physically touched by homeless people asking for money – something that really freaked me out and had never happened in new york.
i really, really love seattle. it took a LONG TIME to adjust after living in brooklyn. i blew through tons of people who were fakes, liars, losers, and lame, but as time went on, i found such an amazing group of friends – people who moved the world for me when my world came crashing down and i became ill and had to leave seattle. they got me home. they are my home. it took time and energy to find them and nurture those relationships but it was worth all of the time and energy. i miss seattle every day.
i absolutely disagree about people not wanting to get into each other’s business. the one thing i missed about nyc more than anything when i moved to seattle was the anonymity. i witnessed first hand, over and over, how people in seattle, especially anyone known (local celebrities, musicians, record label people, etc.) lived in this suffocatingly oppressive fish bowl. everyone is SO UNBELIEVABLY CONCERNED about what other people think about them. i had people who i truly believe are my friends behave so strangely in certain social settings – like doing anything more than acknowledging my existence would somehow jeopardize their social standing or create too many questions. at first i was pissed when it happened and then it became clear it really wasn’t about me. in the end i found myself being split between having empathy for how strangled their lives are because of other people (people who are supposed to be their friends, their social circle!, their people) and being completely turned off by the whole thing – seriously GROW A PAIR! WHO GIVES A FUCK? WHY DO YOU CARE SO MUCH? i also witnessed people ostracize others for whatever reason (mostly for their own ego reasons, especially insecurity) and i was also ostracized.
i now live in upstate ny and after seattle and brooklyn i feel like i live in siberia. i have yet (3 years in) to find any of “my people” here. being disabled now only adds to the challenge.
seattle, like every place, has its pros and cons. it all comes down to what you make of it, wherever you are. i miss my friends. i miss the mountains. i miss the coffee. i miss the music. there’s a lot i don’t miss, though, too and that’s fine. when i left nyc it was the same – i loved brooklyn and missed the food and the cultural diversity and oh man did i miss the subway, but i didn’t miss the roaches! or the noise. or the dirt. or the stress.
as for the magazine’s commentary on fashion and attractiveness. whatever! i don’t care about fashion (other than converse, rock tees, and jeans and maybe a cool haircut) and attractiveness is really just way too subjective and personal for sweeping statements.
actually i wonder if my rude cha cha encounter was with COMTE.
I work in a place frequented by tourists, many from the Midwest and South, and one of the most common comments is “people are so friendly here!” On the other hand, I’m routinely subjected to the bitching of people who aren’t from here and don’t want to be here. What gives?
Also – a few weeks ago I was coming down from a phenomenally joyful mushroom trip, feeling elated and at one with the world. Every person I approached in that singularly open and friendly state returned my friendliness in kind. You get what you give, people.
Hey Lissa!!!! You are the topps!!!!
@159 Aww *blush*
This is an awesome thread, to which I had nothing to contribute *until now*: Calgary has its fair share of fleece/fanny-pack/merrell shoe people, but they are in the minority. In the city, and at the more upscale malls (yes, I realize saying “mall” is like throwing chum into the shark waters) people are quite well dressed. I love it, and it’s not about the amount of money spent (those people are the least interesting), it’s about appreciating the unique looks people can put together (for me, at least.) SO, last night I’m sitting at Chapters, waiting for Junior Canuck to finish terrorizing the mall with his friends, and 2 boys wander over to wait for their coffee. They look amazing, one was wearing hot pink Chucks, eyeliner, had a very cool bag slung over his shoulder, the other was wearing an equally interesting outfit, and I was thinking, for all the bullying we’ve been reading about, it’s heartening to be in this place where there are so many openly gay kids who can walk around shoulder to shoulder, or have an intimate conversation like these two were, and its just “business as usual.” Then an odd thing happened: A man, his wife, and their daughter moved into view. The adults were wearing sweat shirts and 20 inch rise jeans, and when they guy turned around, I saw that his huge nylon jacket said “Seattle Mariners.” Way to represent! (I realize that the *average* person being discussed on this thread is more of the “fleece, twigs-in-dreadlocks-hair, fanny pack, hiking boots” kind of person, but still…)
And Fnarf, I think you and I could communicate on a cellular level–keep rotating your shoes! And taking your shirts to the cleaners! Resist the urge to wear “evening fleece”! I wage a similar battle in my house, and I tell ya, people just don’t understand that dressing well is simply our way of saying, “thank you for not making my eyes bleed, and I’ll do the same for you.”
Aw, you’re just touchy about the whole deer-on-the-shirts thing. (Mine have elk, by the way.)
xina, thanks for joining us from NY. Seattle misses you too! You sound like a lot of fun.
Let’s be charitable and assume the gentleman in question was having a really bad day. I do believe he realizes he behaved badly, if only because several of us have pointed that out to him. I don’t know COMTE personally, but he’s involved with several good organizations and I gotta believe he’s basically a good guy.
Funny thing is, you and I are here mostly anonymously but he is a public figure here under his own name. Although the arts organizations in town get most of their money through government and corporate grants, they also depend on local donors for money, and they have to demonstrate local support to get those grants. And donors (and I am one) don’t really care for egotistical assholery. There’s one organization I write large checks to every year because I believe in their particular goals, but the head (related to the founder) is famously horrible to others at every level (artists, directors, board members). Maybe I’d write even larger checks if he were nicer to his staff and subordinates; I don’t know. I should say that I get that a leader has to lead (I have to assert control in my professional life too) but in general I think courtesy is required at all levels.
I got touchy, 5280, the day a friend of ours gave me a “Federal Ammunition” T-shirt with a big turkey on it (was he trying to tell me something??), and it wasn’t even a V-neck…
While visitors certainly didn’t rank Seattle people high on those three categories (attractive: 20, friendly: 20, stylish: 22) I found it interesting that Seattle residents rated people lower on all three of those categories (attractive: 28, friendly: 26, stylish: 29) than visitors did.
I don’t find people here that unattractive but I would say we’re probably below average. Part of that may be due to our lack of style. Dressing with some kind of style (and “style” doesn’t mean you have to spend a lot of money on clothes; it just means some kind of color/design sense) can help make you look attractive. A great example: people in Paris & Rome. While I do think that people in both those cities are more genetically blessed with good looks than Seattleites are, I’ve seen plenty of women (and men) in both cities who are average-looking but quite striking due to how they’re dressed. If they dressed as frumpy as people in Seattle do, they likely wouldn’t look as good.
I’d definitely rank Seattleites below average on friendliness. I think we’re polite, but not very willing to engage with others. A friend of mine who has lived in D.C. for many years says that, while living here, he never thought of people as unfriendly but when he comes back now to visit, he says they seem that way compared to people back there.
I noticed a woman on the P-I comments claim that men here are passive and whenever I hear a woman say that I have to laugh. Men here are probably not as aggressive as men in cities like New York or San Francisco, but men here do ask women out, and do try to strike up conversations with women. It’s women who are the passive ones. Just go anyplace where people are mingling and watch. When conversation is initiated, it’s almost always the guy doing it.
I am pretty far from stylish but can we all agree to stop pretending that flip-flops are acceptable public footwear? Seriously people you look like convicts.
SLOG Look Book! GO!
@167 Oooooo I like how you think!
Charles posted this because he’s still trying to justify his behaviour vis-a-vis his daughter’s hair incident 😛
“It’s like the entire region is full of introverts, vs the South which is full of extroverts.” That’s just it — our culture here is to be introverted, and those from more extroverted cultures who move here will just have to adjust. I think it’s a bit rude to move somewhere and insist that the locals change for your benefit. (This is not directed at a specific individual.) I don’t believe that we are unfriendly, it’s just that our definition of “friendly” differs, and the social mechanisms we use differ from those in other places. Whether it’s from the Scandinavian background, or the geographical isolation of the PNW, or whatever, we’ve developed a style of interaction that’s noticeably strange to those from elsewhere. This shouldn’t be surprising, really. It’s just like the differences you see in different countries. Different body language, different customs, etc.
(Fourth generation Western Washingtonian here. Would be fifth except my grandfather didn’t father my dad until he was in his 40s, so there’s a missing generation in there, sort of. At any rate, I come by my introversion naturally.)
The style thing… yeah, maybe we aren’t stylish, but the thing is that the old Seattle attitude was that wealth shouldn’t be flaunted, so that’s part of it. That’s clearly not true among nouveau Seattleites, though.
When I first moved here I used to think everyone in Seattle was a dick.
Now that I’m a dick too I couldn’t care less.