Two days ago the Oklahoma legislature—overriding a veto by Democratic Governor Brad Henry—instituted two new abortion laws that require women to pay for an ultrasound before getting an abortion and prevent women from suing doctors who withhold information about birth defects while the fetus is in utero. According to the NYTimes article, “Oklahoma’s new law says that the monitor must be placed where the woman can see it and that she must listen to a detailed description of the fetus,” including the heart, organs, and limbs (but remember: doctors are free to fabricate those details if they choose). Neither law includes an exception for the victims of rape or incest.

Oklahoma now has the strictest abortion laws in the country. Congrats, fellas!

And there’s more to come from the state:

Two other anti-abortion bills are still working their way through the Legislature and are expected to pass. One would force women to fill out a lengthy questionnaire about their reasons for seeking an abortion; statistics based on the answers would then be posted online. The other restricts insurance coverage for the procedures.

This includes banning state insurance plans from covering abortions and severely restricting private insurance coverage.

To recap: You wind up pregnant in Oklahoma. You need an abortion. First you’re forced to pay for an ultrasound ($300-$400), then forced to watch and listen as a doctor describes the health of the fetus (or lies about it. Whatever!). Then you’re forced to fill out an invasive 38-part questionnaire that advertises all of your personal information online, making it easy to identify you should you live in a small town (questions include: age, race, level of education, marital status, number of previous pregnancies—including how many were aborted and how many were carried to term, the county in which the abortion was performed, the woman’s reason for the abortion, and her method of payment). Then you’ll be forced to pay for your abortion, without the aid of insurance.

I wish Oklahoma was a backwater anomaly. I wish smart women could just shrug their shoulders and move on to more progressive states, but such states are becoming fewer and farther between.

Two weeks ago, Nebraska outlawed abortions performed after 20 weeks gestation.

And via Politico:

This year alone, the [Center for Reproductive Rights] has filed lawsuits against six abortion-related laws—two in Oklahoma, two in Alaska, and others in North Dakota and Arizona—a caseload that Northup describes as “higher than we’ve seen since the late 1990s. It’s a total uptick.” They’re currently tracking about 500 state-level bills that would curtail abortion rights.

Take Florida. Yesterday, Senate Republicans snuck in a last-minute amendment to a nursing home reform package that would force all pregnant women considering an abortion to first pay for an ultrasound (even in cases of rape). The bill will also require women to hear a description of the fetus—unless they can prove they have been raped or are a victim of domestic violence by providing a copy of a police report, restraining order, or medical record. In addition, it would ban nearly all private insurance companies from paying for abortions, coverage that currently is included in more than 85 percent of all insurance policies, according to the article.

More states are attempting to put the burden of sex—both consensual and forced—on women. They’re risking their constituents’ health by making abortions unaffordable and needlessly traumatic.

What amazes me is that they’re succeeding.

Former Stranger news writer Cienna Madrid has been a writer in residence for Richard Hugo House, a local literary nonprofit. There, she taught fiction classes and wrote 4/5 of a book about a death-row...

113 replies on “Oklahoma, Florida, and Nebraska: Aggressively Attacking Women’s Rights”

  1. Slavery was a monstrous immoral blight on the nation.
    But it was legal for 90 years.
    The nation finally stamped out that unspeakable evil.
    Good for us.

    Abortion is a monstrous murderous immoral blight on the nation.
    A legal one.
    But the nation is starting to listen to its conscious…..

  2. Oh jeez, wiser and more experienced activists have always warned me about the horrors of the age of coathangers and life in a time when governments created hundreds of hurdles for sensible termination of pregnancy, but, god, I didn’t think we’d go back to that. I didn’t even think we’d go back to a time when we could even remotely consider it.

    I want to go to these capitols and just hang a whole bunch of coathangers from the trees with signs attached that say, “In case of unplanned pregnancy, insert carefully into uterus. Please sterilize before and after each use”.

  3. I have to say, this is outrageous. They are just attempting to scare women away from abortions, thus causing them to resort to extreme measures or go out of state. The fact that they don’t make allowances for women who are victimes of rape or incest is cruel. Require a police report in Florida? What if it’s their own father or a family member. It’s hard for the victim to escape from thier own family. My mother was raped by her father and he took her to have two abortions in her early teens. What was she supposed to do? They don’t even consider the feelings of these women. I had an abortion two years ago, and I still think about it every day. They think it’s easy, like birth control? It’s not. Besides, this world is over populated as it is. In 50 years, the same type of people will be restricting birthing rights as well.

  4. Well, to be fair, is the personal information posted online as an individual profile? From the way I read the quote as you excerpted, it would be compiled into statistics and then released as such.

    But yes, it is all monstrous, the same.

  5. @ 1 – You’re a penis-possessing person, I take it?

    Come back and give your opinion on abortion when you yourself are at risk for one, ie, when you possess a uterus instead of a fuckstick.

    Fuckstick.

  6. It gets worse – the doctor has the right to insert the ultrasound monitor vaginally if that will “provide the best view of the fetus” and the patient has no say in this. Talk about violation.

  7. I’m sorry, is there some federal law I don’t know about that prevents women from leaving Oklahoma, Florida, and Nebraska if they don’t like the laws there? Not that I agree with the anti-abortion laws, but if they have enough votes to override a veto, it seems that there’s plenty of popular support for the idea in those states.

    Liberals are all about states’ rights when we’re talking about repealing drug prohibition.

  8. Clearly America is developing (devolving?) into a nation split in two: One part (the coasts, the Urban Archipelago and a few scattered bright spots) filled with rational, inclusive, forward-thinking people, the other (the south, much of the midwest, and a few scattered dark spots) filled with rabid xenophobes, racists and sexists, proud to associate themselves with the newly-created Red Jesusland.

    There are some states that are hatin’ on their brown neighbors, hatin’ on their blacks, and hatin’ on their women. And then there are the states.. that don’t.

  9. @9,

    I’d take it you’d use the same argument to argue against repealing Jim Crow laws? Or, as usual, are you just an asshole to women?

  10. I am so thankful that I live in Washington and that when I needed an abortion I was treated with the respect, dignity and compassion every step of the way from every professional I saw. Why the lawmakers in this state feel the need to treat their own constituents in such a cruel manner is beyond me.

  11. @1 and @9, I think women get enough shit from conservatives already, so if you aren’t going to be thinking about women in a positive way, get the fuck off the forum. You aren’t bringing up discussion points, you’re just being insensitive assholes.

    @9, once again, what if it was an incest victim that was terrified what it would do to her family if they found out her father was raping her? By what means and money does a 13 or 14 year old have to get to more accepting states. Don’t talk about things you don’t understand.

  12. Judah, it costs money to move to a new state. Not every women or girl has the resources to move to a place with safer and easier access to reproductive health care.

    It is so incredibly important that we protect the mental, physical and spiritual health of the women and girls of this country. Making abortion care inaccessible, prohibitively expensive and needlessly traumatic will not make for stronger families with better values. It will assure a future like Baconcat describes–full of self-abortion casualties and unwanted children.

    It makes me sad how much we hate women.

  13. It’s obviously all God’s punishment for women for not being subservient to men and getting all uppity and shit. You know, back when God created the universe 6,000 years ago, you didn’t hear any of this kind of backtalk.

  14. @10: We’re hitting our Malthusian limit, and when that happens, you begin to notice how one population will prepare (rationing, greater care for health) and the other side will begin to cling to superstition and irrational attacks on preparative measures (unsustainable growth, opposition to generalized distribution of health care).

    Yay historic precedent.

  15. @9 No federal law, though if you’re poor, you’re pretty much stuck popping out a kid or having a potentially deadly procedure done rather than having a safe, legal abortion done by a trained provider. How many poor women can afford to travel out of state for an abortion, let alone move just because they don’t like the policies?

    Ironically, the people who are so against abortion and birth control are also the same ones railing against the fact that so many women and their children are on welfare…. obviously their brains don’t handle logical thinking.

    BTW – Arizona already passed legislation to prevent insurance from covering abortion.
    http://wonkroom.thinkprogress.org/2010/0…
    And they’ve got more abortion legislation in the works…. the replacement governor Jan Brewer and the racist GOP’ers are determined to stick it to brown Arizonans in general and poor women in particular.

  16. @12 Amen. Can’t wait ’til I can get the hell out of Utah (where the prevailing GOP attitude is that women are only good for breeding and taking care of the house, and definitely not smart enough to make decisions regarding their own uterus) and back to Washington.

  17. @9 – No, there’s no Federal law preventing it, but there’s also no Federal law protecting women from a state law being passed that says that pregnant women must remain pregnant until delivery or a law that says pregnant woman may not leave the state until she delivers.

    And that is where this movement is headed.

  18. What really gets me about this is that the conservative fuckheads who passed this law requiring women to pay for these ultrasounds are likely the same folks who claim that the mandate for individual insurance is unconstitutional, and that the government can’t make you buy a product or service.

  19. Back in the bad old days, OB/GYN wards used to be full of septicemia cases – women with horribly infected reproductive systems from botched and partial abortions, whether self-induced or back-alley. Outlawing abortion doesn’t stop it. You cannot hold a woman prisoner to her uterus for 9 months. All outlawing abortion does is fill the OB wards with sick and dying women again. It doesn’t “save” any “babies.” It just punishes the women.

    Abortion rights are suffering the death of 1000 cuts in a handful of states. There are counties entirely without an abortion provider. States that require women to have a “waiting period.” States with parental/spousal notifications, even in cases where said parent or spouse impregnated the woman in question via a rape. None of this will “save” one single “baby.” But these restrictions are guaranteed to make life even harder for a woman of limited means. Women with means have always had access to safe abortion; they can afford to go somewhere where abortion is safe and legal, they can afford childcare while they’re away, they can afford to take time off work. A housecleaner working three jobs with no sick leave and no options for childcare who can’t get an abortion within 150 miles and whose state requires a 24-hour waiting period is FUCKED.

  20. Also: if your decision not to abort is based upon your inability to afford a $300-400 ultrasound, good luck raising a healthy kid without further government assistance. This policy is cruel, misogynistic, and fiscally shortsighted all at once.

  21. @11

    Are Jim Crow and abortion rights addressed under the same constitutional provisions? No, they aren’t. Do the doctrines addressing them have the same constitutional weight? No, they don’t. Do you have the foggiest notion what you’re talking about? Not really.

    And just as a point of order, I’m an asshole to all kinds of people. You’re just such a fucking ideologue that you only notice when I’m being an asshole “to women” (keeping in mind that that’s just your gloss for when I say something you don’t agree with).

  22. wow what a bunch of whiners.
    if you don’t want to have a baby don’t get pregnant.

    it’s your body
    and your choice.

    choose wisely…..

  23. @13

    We’re thinking (in a very positive way) about the 450,000 innocent women slaughtered in this country every year by physicians sworn to do no harm.

    Slaughtered before they ever got to feel the sun on their face or draw a breath.

    Who are you thinking about?

  24. @5

    You’re jealous- is that it merry?

    Human rights is the concern and responsibility of everyone, no matter what their gonadal status.

    And Life is the Most Basic of Human Rights.

  25. Why don’t they just pass a law forcing women to purchase cute little shoes for the fetus while they’re at it?

    @ 24 “I’m an asshole to everyone!”

    That DOES make it OK. whew!

    (I’m just glad I don’t have to live with you. And your legal analysis isn’t worth responding to. Does your brain even touch your spinal chord?)

  26. I love how the republicans are all like “zomg, if the government is in control of healthcare, they’ll decide what can and cannot be covered”….then they go and ban A PRIVATE BUSINESS from providing abortions. It’s almost comical, if it wasn’t so heart breaking.

  27. Deuteronomy 22:23 – If a man happens to meet in a town a virgin pledged to be married and he sleeps with her,
    Deuteronomy 22:24 – you shall take both of them to the gate of that town and stone them to death—the girl because she was in a town and did not scream for help, and the man because he violated another man’s wife. You must purge the evil from among you.

    Women are the ones responsible for their own rape according to the bible. Does it surprise you that modern wingnuts would also hold this view?

  28. @29

    That DOES make it OK. whew!

    Yeah, it does. Being an asshole is different than being a sexist. As far as the larger moral “OK” of being an asshole — I’d rather be an asshole than a hypocrite.

    And your legal analysis isn’t worth responding to. Does your brain even touch your spinal chord?

    Isn’t it? Why do you say so?

    And no, my brain doesn’t touch my spinal cord. I control my body with telekinesis.

  29. I wonder how the tea baggers and anti-health right would feel about an insurance plan giving a bonus for having an abortion. It would reduce the costs of caring for the baby. I bet in that case they would be ok with a government takeover of private insurance, fucking hypocrites.

  30. Nebraska is such a weird state. Like, part of the population consists of the usual mild-mannered bland-but-perfectly-pleasant Midwesterner types, and another part (mostly in the Western half of the state) is comprised of isolated ranchers and dirt farmers; both pretty much have a live-and-let-live attitude, as long as someone isn’t rocking the boat too much. But then there’s this really weird evangelical contingent that dominates politics from local all the way up to state offices and sees themselves fit to meddle in people’s personal business to no end. I blame suburban Omaha.

  31. @25 I’m certain that no woman chooses to get raped, yet she may end up pregnant because of it. How is that her fault?
    And pregnancy as a result of incest? Is that the girl’s fault as well? What choice does she have?
    Then there are those who deprived of sex-ed, in places like Utah, Missouri, etc. Believe me, some of them are pretty clueless as to how girls get pregnant and/or how to prevent pregnancy, particularly in some of the small towns where even internet access is limited and heavily filtered.
    If only it were as black and white as “your body, your choice”, but it’s not. Too many dicks out there like to stick theirs in where it doesn’t belong, hence the need for abortion, birth control, and emergency contraception.

  32. Is it any surprise that OK is the state that is considering starting a Tea Party Militia? Which is especially ironic given that another right wing militia set off a bomb in their capitol.

    Hopefully all progressives will go out and vote in November, even if, like me, we have to hold our nose and vote for a blue dog democrat. Make no mistake, the right wingnuts are only going to get bolder.

  33. and at the same time that they enact these laws, which will have to be fought in court, they also cut pre-natal and other child care related services… what dicknozzles! gah.

  34. @ 28 – Since you asked, no, that is most definitely not it. Amusing, though, that you would bound right on over to that hackneyed old cliche — indicative of your thinking process, it appears.

    I’m going to (with difficulty) ignore my first impulse in response to you (“the only abortion you should be discussing is the one your mother should have had”), and instead I’m going to go this route —

    Try to follow along now —

    1) No one LIKES to have an abortion. It is a painful, heart-wrenching situation to be in, and it is not, and SHOULD NOT be considered a form of birth control.

    2) You can pass all the anti-abortion laws you want, pass ’em till you’re blue in the face, pass ’em till the cows come home, and NOT A SINGLE ONE OF THOSE LAWS WILL ELIMINATE ABORTION. All those laws will do is push abortion to the back alleys & fill the hospital wards with sick women (see Geni’s post @ 22).

    YOU CANNOT LEGISLATE AWAY A MEDICAL PROCEDURE THAT YOU HAPPEN TO DISAGREE WITH.

    YOU CANNOT LEGISLATE AWAY A MEDICAL PROCEDURE THAT YOU HAPPEN TO DISAGREE WITH.

    YOU CANNOT LEGISLATE AWAY A MEDICAL PROCEDURE THAT YOU HAPPEN TO DISAGREE WITH.

  35. 35

    1% of abortions are rape/incest.
    One percent.

    Abortion should be an option in the case of rape, incest; and we’ll throw in the health of the mother without you even asking (of course, that medical decision will have to be seconded by an impartial physician who is not part of the abortion industry…) (and we are going to charge the rapist/relative with some version of murder or manslaughter- the lawyers can work out the details…)

    Now.
    Let’s get rid of the 99% (about 890,000 a year) of abortions that kill a human just because the “adults” that created it now find its existence to be inconvenient…..

    I think we’re making great progress here!

  36. @39: “Now.
    Let’s get rid of the 99% (about 890,000 a year) of abortions that kill a human just because the “adults” that created it now find its existence to be inconvenient….”

    no.
    because no human is being killed, your argument is false.

    so fuck off with that shite.

  37. @40 for the win!

    @39–sounds like you need to get out into the community and meet some real, live, poor, undereducated, abused, afraid, desperate, unhappy, innocent, ashamed, drug-addicted, underage (and all the other adjectives that may or may not apply) girls and women who are facing the real, hard choice of what to do with a crisis pregnancy. Do that, and then let’s talk.

  38. 43
    lets educate those girls and give them the knowledge and self esteem to make better life choices.
    let’s not kill their babies.

  39. it’s a clump of cells
    it’s a parasite
    it’s a fingernail clipping
    blah
    blah
    blah

    The transformation of a sperm and egg into a human is the most wondrous miracle in the universe but you girls blind your souls to it because it doesn’t fit into your ideology and inconveniences you.

    that’s sad.

  40. @44–and where exactly is all the progressive sex-education legislation happening? I used to live in Arizona where I worked at Planned Parenthood and at a public high school. From what I understood it was legal for parents to opt their kids out of sex-ed classes at school. This meant that I saw girls in my clinic who were pregnant with no idea how it happened. I agree with you, prevention through reproductive education is key. But I just don’t see a strong movement towards that.

  41. 38

    now merry…
    don’t be grumpy.
    you’re not living up to your name

    we do realize that emotionally abortion is a heart breaking gut wrenching thing for a woman to do or even contemplate and physically it is taxing and that behind many abortions lie a tragic sad story.

    and biology is totally unfair in that women/girls bear the brunt (actually all…) of the burden of unintended pregnancy.
    society can and must step in to even the scales and make males (we haven’t the stomach to call them men) accept and bear responsibility for the children they father, no matter what course the pregnancy takes.

    we recognize that making abortion of convenience illegal will not end it.
    however murder, rape, theft and littering are not eradicated either even though they are illegal.
    non-compliance is not a reason to refuse to outlaw immoral behavior.

  42. @45: Science is actually pretty boring. Calling it “miraculous” is either a careless choice of words or you’re betraying your own lack of understanding.

Comments are closed.