John Aravosis isn’t buying the results of a recent study that put the number of LGBT Americans at something under nine million:

There is no way you’re going to get anywhere near 100% of gay people admitting they’re gay, period. I wonder if you get more than 50%. Married gays, forget it. Dating a girl, forget it. Closeted, forget it. People afraid for their jobs, forget it. Work for the military, forget it. Older gays, less likely. Living in a scary state, or small town, more likely not to admit it. And on and on.

Until one of these studies starts estimating how many gay people are NOT admitting that they’re gay to the questioner, these studies per se underestimate our community, significantly I fear, and all the media will do is repeat the low-ball number and say, “See, you’re not that many after all.” And it’s all well and good to say, “Gosh, our civil rights shouldn’t be based on how many people we are,” but sorry Charlie, numbers matter, especially in politics. These studies continue to hurt us, and they continue to put out these numbers they know are false, and they know will be misquoted against us.

134 replies on “Re: Counting Queers”

  1. @46

    A certain percentage of people get cancer, or develop a phobia. By your reasoning a low incidence of abnormality should define what’s normal. Sorry, don’t buy it.

  2. @48

    Point by point-

    Whatever electoral results dictate is the way our nation should go, within Constitutional boundaries. I no more believe that if a majority of my peers disagree with me that my will should hold, than I do that any minority should be able to set the terms of public discourse or policy. Including gays.

    Nor do I advocate attempting to cure gays. In the first place a psychiatrist trying to do so would lose his or her license to practice. More importantly a behavior that impacts only the actor is that persons business, not mine.

    No, I don’t have a problem with taxpayer dollars incentivizing socially stable behaviors. Tax code encourages home ownership, retirement savings and other socially desirable goals. And tax and other government code encouraging marriage and family help to stiffen the backbone of any worthwhile society, the family. By definition a same sex coupling can’t serve that purpose and shouldn’t receive governent incentive.

    The level of ‘hate crime’ a community suffers isn’t relevant. Theoretically the law punishes a person assaulting another evenly, whether they struck a Congressman or a street-walker. Of course it doesn’t in fact. That’s the nature of any flawed system. But it ought to be the goal, and treating one class of victim as more equal than others harms that goal for all of us, gays included.

    And yes, it sucks that people aren’t better than they are. It sucks that people in the South, or anywhere else, felt better than black or female fellow citizens, and that it took a long time to make the progress we have. Welcome to the world. We do the best we can and hope for the best result from our efforts, and that’s all we can really do.

  3. @ Seattleblues, your response @49 lacks substance. It’s one thing to make the assertions you do about the “costs” to society, but if they are as @48 says, those costs are too miniscule to quibble over, particularly when the cost pays for greater freedoms, and there are many, many more wasteful things government buys with our money. (If you disagree, some figures would be appreciated.)

    As far as hate crimes go, they wouldn’t exist if mere assault and murder charges were sufficient in deterring them. Thus, society’s need to codify and prosecute them as such. You may call it “thought policing,” but society needs structures for bringing about changes (and all societies are always changing) – since we don’t have a single religion to do that, it might as well be government.

    And @ 53 – By definition? You know that there are such a thing as “gay families,” right, where same sex couples are rearing children? It appears that biology doesn’t define families.

  4. “Tax code encourages home ownership”–There are highly negative consequences to this particular subsidy, such as reducing labor mobility and worsening the housing boom/bust cycle.

    “By definition a same sex coupling can’t serve that purpose”–By your backward, ignorant definition.

    “More importantly a behavior that impacts only the actor is that persons business, not mine”-Yet you have very much made it your business, and to a rather extensive and obvious degree.

    “No, what matters is whether a person is entitled to such protections for a CHOSEN minority status”–Well, I never chose to be straight, it is simply what I am. I didn’t choose it. And I imagine most gay people are the same–they are gay because that is what is in their DNA.

    “Placing oneself in a position of general social disapprobationy”–That’s how it used to be. Not anymore. The beliefs of most individuals and of society have changed, and for the better. Your ever-dwindling minority has lost, and the rest of us will not be going back.

  5. @55, The funny thing is SB knows his side has lost (or will soon). He sees us quite literally as the barbarians gathering to overrun the Roman Empire, and himself as some kind of soldier fighting the righteous battle for his conception of Western Civilization though he knows he’s doomed.

  6. Well, that’s poor writing. Yes, SB believes Queer people and their allies are actually Gauls and are presently going to cross the Rubicon into America and pillage the countryside, steal Juno’s geese, and rape the Vestals.

  7. @53: There is a great deal of anecdotal evidence supporting (and no evidence contradicting) the possibility that gay couples can raise children just as well as straight couples. I’m sure you recognize that the stability generally provided by marriage is beneficial in the parenting process, and that a married couple, on average, is a more attractive adoption candidate than an unmarried couple. Wouldn’t it be in the nation’s best interests, therefore, to encourage such responsible behavior as marriage (among homosexuals as well as heterosexuals) so as to be able to better fill the role of parents? Or are you just refusing to believe that homosexuals can parent as well as heterosexuals can, despite any wealth of evidence to the contrary?
    (I’ve mentioned her before as an example, but I believe I should bring up my lesbian cousin; she and her partner have two young sons, and they have taken to motherhood like fish to water. And yes, the little boys play with toy cars and plastic dinosaurs, not with dolls. Are you saying that their family is somehow detrimental to society?)
    You seem to be fundamentally unaware of how hate crime laws work. They don’t prescribe extra punishment for crimes committed against a minority, or even hate crimes committed against any PARTICULAR minority. All they do is list protected categories against which a crime can legally be considered a hate crime. If a gay man is beaten up, that’s not necessarily a hate crime. If a gay man is beaten up by people who scream homophobic slurs at him throughout the attack, that is probably a hate crime, because there is evidence suggesting that the crime was MOTIVATED by the victim’s status under one or more protected category. Additionally, hate crime laws do not provide protection to any one status under a protected category, but rather to all statuses under those categories. If a gay man goes to Alabama and is beaten for being gay, that’s a hate crime; similarly, if I were to go to Boystown and get beaten up for being straight, that’s also a hate crime. Adding sexual orientation to the list of protected categories is not giving special protections to gays; it’s giving protections to gays, straights, bisexuals, asexuals, and queers (that is to say, everyone). Nobody is more equal than anyone else under hate crime laws.

    Yes, it did take a long time to make the progress we’ve made. And people like you were fighting us every inch of the way.

  8. SeattleBlues, let’s assume that being gay is a matter of choice (I personally think that it is a much more complex matter involving genetics and environmental conditions, but let’s take your assertion at face value). As such, you would maintain that it’s perfectly reasonable to treat gay people with bias and to not allow them to benefit from certain government protections and subsidies.

    But, you would be screaming your head off if you were not allowed to marry, or if you were taxed for exercising your “right” to marry.

    There are no passages in the constitution that define marriage as pertaining to a man and woman alone. In fact, there are no passages that give people the right to marry at all, let alone benefit from governmental subsidies associated with marriage. What is your justification for allowing heterosexuals to marry and homosexuals to not marry…simply that it bothers you and goes against your religious tenets? Your argument is illogical and hypocritical, considering that you benefit from many government subsidies and protections as a result of your choices alone.

  9. @53 and I quote . . . No, I don’t have a problem with taxpayer dollars incentivizing socially stable behaviors. Tax code encourages home ownership, retirement savings and other socially desirable goals. And tax and other government code encouraging marriage and family help to stiffen the backbone of any worthwhile society, the family. By definition a same sex coupling can’t serve that purpose and shouldn’t receive governent incentive.

    So, what about myself and my wife who, despite being of opposite genders and as far as I know fertile, don’t intend to add to overpopulation? Should we receive the same government incentives as married couples who confuse the wife’s vagina with a clown car? What about infertile couples? Do they have to adopt before they’re allowed the benefits of marriage?

  10. @43
    ‘I have yet to meet one gay person who was comfortable with the fact that I’m straight. In their minds, I’m always some repressed idiot who’s trying to pretend that a “gay” side of me doesn’t exist.’
    have you lost your mind ?..
    huh ? whaaa?
    well ok then..
    .*outstretched hand *
    my name is riz.. pleased to meet you.. glad you’re straight. don’t want to fuck you. don’t think you want to fuck me or others like me.. never thought it..never have and never will.and now i’d like you to meet some of my other friends..
    ( jeez..i go away for few hours and all sorts of crazy wander in )

  11. @43 5280
    i should say that i’ve met a couple of gays who think that way…a couple. those peoples are silly. on that and a whole host of issues. silly peoples come in all stripes. but me and the author of this post don’t think that way. so now you know two of us
    pleased to make your acquaintance.

  12. The only reason anyone on these threads accuses Seattleblues of being a closet case is because of the inordinate amount of time he spends talking about all the sex gays are having. It seems to take up a fair portion of his day.

    Maybe 5280 is really James Franco, which would explain a lot… 🙂

  13. @52

    Thats a bullshit straw man that you’ve created. In one comment you say that homosexuality is an abhorrent moral decision and know you state that it’s a disease? A small percentage of North Americans are African American, should we add that to your list of ‘Moral choices’?

    But one redeeming thing in your comment is that you named diseases that are never by choice.

  14. @38

    if by “straight” you mean heterosexual then the answer is never.

    no one ‘chooses’ to be heterosexual.

    we, ALL OF US, just are.

    its how we reproduce.

    everyone: flaming queers, Dan Savage; EVERONE is a heterosexual being. and most “homosexuals” have engaged in heterosexual behavior before. just ask Dan…

    let us rephrase your question, and direct it to you:

    WHEN
    DID
    YOU
    CHOOSE
    TO
    BE
    HOMO SAPIENS?

  15. Ha ha, seattleblues. You’re going down in this argument. Although for while it looked as though your pomposity might just cover up the holes in your argument.

  16. If this percentage is right, then I think I’ve had sex with every gay man in the world already.

    Funny, though, coz I keep finding more and more…

  17. @65: whether there are 0.5, 3 or 10% gays in the world, there still are enough heteros to prevent the human kind to disappear.
    Unless the only goal of your life is to reproduce as often as possible, I don’t the problem.
    Some gays have had hetero sex (curiosity or peers pressure). Some closeted gays married. Some straights have had gay sex. So what?

    You can know is an animal is homo sapiens by looking at his DNA, its bones… You can’t do that for sexual orientation. You obviously can’t choose your specie more than your eye color. Again, so what?

  18. As entertaining as it might prove to envision how, if certain people’s fondest wishes cae true, heterosexual marriage might end up being entirely sabotaged from the inside, I shall avoid that line of thought.

    The numbers game always recalls to mind images of Sarah Harding telling Tim Stamper she can get him any numbers he likes. My first reaction is that the haters still in charge needed a number small enough that they could tell our allies we’re too insignificant, and at the same time large enough to tell their excitable base that we’re spreading. This is the number they settled on, and it’s the number they got. There are intriguing side points about counting and inclusion, but my main point of interest in the final count is to speculate on why the desired result is what it is.

    And if it turns out I’m just too cynical for my own good, okay. I’m not right every time.

  19. I have to respectfully disagree with Seattleblues here. I think  the true conservative position should be to support gay marriage. It’s the best way to separate the gays from more general faggotry. Make them get married  and take on all the responsibilities that come with family and monogamy. Can’t handle it? Go back to faggotry.  Marriage by it’s nature is a conservative institution; letting gays marry forces them to live by it’s rules.

    So sorry poofs, no more shaking your bottoms at each other on a Wednesday night, it’s 10 pm bed times and PTA meetings for you. Don’t like it? Well, then you can’t have marriage.

  20. @70 that’s why we need to sabotage faggotry first by making them get married. Let them get married and live by rules of monogamy, self-sacrifice and family responsibilities and obligations. Then we can separate the gays from the pooftas and end all the silly ass-tickling called ‘gay pride’ with its obnoxiuus, incumbent parades.

  21. @70&71: marriage don’t always means monogamy. Open relationships, polygamy (even though there is only one official marriage) can survive marriage.
    Gay Pride is a parade, not a life style. If you don’t like it, don’t go watch it.
    Gays already have families, commitments and obligations. But, hey, if that convince you that they should have the right to marry, whatever works.

  22. @74 then it’s not marriage. It’s a freak show we put on Jerry Springer to show how it spreads disease, poverty and misery. If you think allowing gay marriage means we must redefine marriage beyond monogamy, well then stick to faggotry and all its incumbent miseries.

  23. @74 then it’s not marriage. It’s a freak show we put on Jerry Springer to show how it spreads disease, poverty and misery. If you think allowing gay marriage means we must redefine marriage beyond monogamy, well then stick to faggotry and all its incumbent miseries.

  24. Oy vey, troll feeding, (and soon-to-be dead thread), but I can’t help it. OK, Seattleblues: you seem to be unable to realize when you lose a point in an argument. I’ll give you an example. You had been challenged by Helenka to answer the question “when did you choose to be straight?”, with the obvious implication that you didn’t, and neither do gays. In post 40, this was your response:

    “You might as well ask when I chose not to be schizophrenic. Health is maintained, not chosen. Sickness however can be chose [sic] by not maintaining health.”

    Here you clearly equate gayness with schizophrenia. And then in the very next sentence, you assert that “health” – i.e. that absence of schizophrenia – is not chosen. In other words, you supported Helenka’s point, not your own.

    You are completely unable to prove either of your two main contentions: 1) that homosexuality is a choice, and 2) that there are any measurable or likely “costs” to society from gay marriage. In fact, you make no attempt whatsoever to prove either contention

    The hate-crimes thing is a side issue. Don’t drag it in to muddy the waters. Either prove your points, or you may as well stop pretending to be rational and just start writing gibberish in ALL CAPS. It would be more entertaining.

  25. “Gay Pride is a parade, not a life style.”

    Thanks for the laugh. Legally you can do what ever u like in marriage, but that doesn’t mean you won’t and shouldn’t be socially ridiculed and receive no sympathy when the costs of your choices, poverty, disease, messed kids, cone back to YOU.

    ” If you don’t like it, don’t go watch it.”

    Thats not much of a choice since it involves tax layers money, public roads and well publicized acts of human selfishness.

  26. “when did you choose to be straight?”,”

    My dna did, About 400 million years ago when life appeared on the planet and created two genders necessary for reproduction.

  27. @78 And I thanks you back for the laugh. Having an open relationships means you will loose your job, get cancer and you child will be a murderer? Thank god you warned me.

    I don’t like most parades (too noisy, boring…) They cost money and use roads as well, but I don’t whine about it and I don’t go watch them.

    @75: I don’t want to redefine anything. I merely point out that people (including straight people) lready define their own marriage the way they want. Most of the time, they don’t talk about it to everybody because, well, it’s private.

  28. “Gays already have families, commitments and obligations. “

    And as I said, that’s why I say gays can and should marry. Settle down, live in healthy monogamous relationships and set aside their personal sexual urges for the good if their families and children. If, however, you also want to define marriage beyond that, to the kind of wanton selfish desire u see at a Gay pride parade, well the answer is no. You will be ridiculed for that and when you become diseased, poor (aka divorced), have messed up and abandoned kids, you fully deserve a public stoning on Jerry Springer. And don’t expect sympathy or public assistance when you fail to live up to these standards.

    So in short, grown up poofs. You can marry

  29. @79, 400 million years ago? Hahaha, I guess that’s progress from 6 thousand years ago. Perhaps you’d be surprised to know the majority of species have no gender, some have more than two genders, and gender in our own species is more like a spectrum, with some individuals falling off it altogether.

    @78, Saying you get no choice in the matter of ignoring Pride parades because your tax dollars go to the streets they use is absurd. I have no problem ignoring the Westboro Baptist Church, yet my money goes to fund the streets they demonstrate on as well. It’s public space, people can say and do what they so long as they aren’t hurting anyone, funding the streets they walk on is not the same as funding their words.

  30. ” (including straight people) lready define their own marriage the way they want.”

    If course they dO and we punish them with expensive divorces (and poverty), messed up kids (that’s a fact, look it up), disease and the Jerry springer show. And now, fortunately, we are cutting the gub’ment strings that financed those bad choices.

    So settle down, keep you dicks/pussies in your pants and grow up.

  31. @81, Well I’m glad you’re for marriage equality. I am glad, however, that you do not have the power to define how married couples must legally act.

  32. @81, Well I’m glad you’re for marriage equality. I am also glad, however, that you do not have the power to define how married couples must legally act.

  33. ” Perhaps you’d be surprised to know the majority of species have no gender, some have more than two genders, and gender in our own species is more like a spectrum, with some individuals falling off it altogether.”

    Yes, we call them animals.

  34. Oops, sorry for the double post.

    @83, We do not punish them, they punish themselves. It has nothing to do implicitly with whether or not people keep their genitals neatly tucked away, it’s that they make commitments they can’t keep, and then fail to keep the genitals tucked away. This is not something we legislate against, and it should be no different for gays. If a couple (with partners of any sexual orientation) fucks up their relationships for whatever reason, that’s their problem.

  35. @86, Except the majority of species are not animals at all. And even within the animal kingdom, gender is not as cut and dry as xx/xy.

  36. ” I am also glad, however, that you do not have the power to define how married couples must legally act.”

    Actually we do through expensive divorce laws, parental support laws, cutting off welfare to single parents, and then nature and disease do a marvelous job too. Unfortunately public shame for divorce has whithered but then again I haven’t met a divorced person not financially screwed. Then the final punishment is day time talk shows where people who fail to live up to our standards are publically stoned and exploited for their moral failings.

  37. “Except the majority of species are not animals at all.”

    Bacteria are not a life form I look to for moral leadership.

    “gender is not as cut and dry as xx/xy”

    It 10-20 years those DNA mutations will be repairable.

  38. @90, Not everything is a disease in need of repair. Simply because you can’t conceive of other ways of being does not mean those who are different from you are in need of “repair” or want to be “repaired”.

    @89, Those costs do not dictate how married couples act. Those are the costs of divorce, something completely different, many of those “costs” by the way are the results of poor personal choices, not the law.

  39. @everett: there are plenty of divorces every years of people with boring sex lives who just can’t stand each other anymore. I agree with samktg, you and the law don’t have any power over happily married people. For exemple you can’t stop them to swing (which won’t create messed up children) You seem to think that people who don’t have a very very vanilla sex life or/and don’t believe in monogamy will be less happier than other. If so, you’re wrong, there is a whole wonderful world outside pope’s vision of marriage.

    There are diseases, and there are condoms. People are slowly learning how to protect themselves. Nature isn’t taking its revenge on gays.

    I don’t know (don’t care) the talk shows you’re referring to, but you look like a vulture getting off on people’s misery.

  40. @79:
    >My dna did, About 400 million years ago when life appeared on the planet and created two genders necessary for reproduction.
    >400 million years ago when life appeared
    >two genders necessary for reproduction
    One, life has existed for 3.7 billion years; you’re off by an order of magnitude. Two, sexual reproduction (two genders rather than one) has only been around for about 1.2 billion years. That’s right; for 2/3 of the history of life on Earth, the only living things were GAY. Three, there’s a difference between genotype and phenotype; your genome alone doesn’t determine your characteristics.
    @81: Straight slutty people are allowed to get married; I don’t think the government checks in on their sex lives. Are you saying we should monitor gay people (but not straight people) as a prerequisite for marriage?
    @90: Wow, you have NO understanding of biology. Sure, we can identify chromosomal abnormalities. But even if we could take a man with Klinefelter’s and somehow remove his extraneous X chromosome (leaving him with an euploid genotype), he’d still suffer from the effects of having developed with the disorder, and he’d still have streak gonads and gynecomastia. Once a person has grown, no amount of gene therapy will cure developmental problems.
    Also, I wouldn’t look to humans for moral leadership either.

  41. @94, Nature doesn’t give a shit if you’re gay, not wearing a condom with a sex partner who doesn’t know if their infected or not is stupid behavior gay or straight. Higher infection rates among gay people is a complex issue, but it has nothing to do with the will of Nature.

  42. Oh, so this isn’t about letting gays marry. It’s about letting any old behavior be equal in the eyes of the law and society.

    Well thanks for being honest.

  43. “nothing to do with the will of Nature.”

    So homosexuality is natural. HIV is natural. Homosexual behaviour is natural. But high HIV rates among irresponsible homosexuals us not the result of nature.

    How pc can u get?

  44. @99, What does PC-ism have to do with it? It isn’t PC-ism to say people infected with STIs got them because of irresponsible behavior. Nature does not dictate irresponsible behavior, Nature incarnate does not teleport into the bedrooms of gay men and confiscate their condoms. The idea that gay people are inherently more irresponsible than straight people is patently absurd, and to suggest the reasons for higher incidence of infection in the gay community is a result of said irresponsibility is intellectual laziness. Trying to discount my points as PC-ism run amok is likewise intellectual laziness. If you can’t make an argument more complex than the “will of Nature” or “those irresponsible sodomites”, maybe you’re really not cut out for debating with the educated, coastal homo-liberal elite.

  45. Nature has no will.
    Homosexuality is natural: proof is, there are plenty of homosexual among animlas (cf wikipedia) Not that it would change a thing if we were the only species on the universe.
    HIV doesn’t rate high among homosexual: it rates high among male homosexual (because sodomy is an act that transmit more easily that disease) So nature is angry at gays, but not at lesbians?

Comments are closed.