People are digging into Rick Perry’s back catalog, and they’re finding some quotes he’ll have to answer to. For instance, Jonathan Capehart at the Washington Post points out this doozy, from Perry’s book On My Honor: Why the American Values of the Boy Scouts Are Worth Fighting For:
“Even if an alcoholic is powerless over alcohol once it enters his body, he still makes a choice to drink,” he wrote. “And, even if someone is attracted to a person of the same sex, he or she still makes a choice to engage in sexual activity with someone of the same gender.”
Right. Because we know that when people “choose” to go without sex, they become totally normal. The Perry campaign has yet to respond to requests for comment on this statement.

So weird. Alcohol destroys lives – car accidents, domestic abuse, etc. Having consensual sex with someone of your same gender… does what? Does nothing. Causes zero harm. How does one even begin to try and equate the two??
Isn’t this pretty much the same thing that Dan Savage has been saying about bi’s?
@ 1, it’s because the LORD told us not to do that. And he wouldn’t do something like that and then hardwire people to be attracted to the same sex, now would he? That would just about undermine an entire religion if you found that that could be true.
Start with this hugely flawed premise, and it’s impossible to find your way to the truth. And this is where Rick Perry, Seattleblues, the thankfully departed loveschild, and all their ilk begin.
Nuns howerver, can go without sex and remain normal.
@4
I spent ten years in parochial schools. I knew a lot of nuns. Some of them were far from normal.
I don’t see where he’s saying people choose to be gay. He says they are gay, they choose to act on it. It’s a dumb quote to be sure. I’m hungry and choose to eat. I’m straight and I choose to have sex with my honey.
His quote on alcoholism is stupid too. Even non-alcoholics have no choice on how alcohol acts once it enters our body.
These quotes only indicate Rick Perry is a moron & we already knew that.
The illusion of freedom of will is often used as a pretext, by the powerful, to damn the untouchables.
He’s semantically right, of course. Regardless of how you are born with regard to anything, conduct ultimately is a choice. It’s consistent with the fundamentals of republican ideology as well.
What he hasn’t done, as commenter #1 points out, is draw a link between, say, homosexual conduct and any societal benefit/harm and therefore eligible for government intervention.
It’s obvious why he draws the comparison— He’s struggling to keep his own “alcoholism” in check.
And by “alcoholism”, I mean “gayness.”
The new census report says divorces are higher in the conservative values bible belt than the north east U.S. Romney would say just because someone can divorce they shouldn’t make the choice to do so.
Yeah, right. Fucking hypocrites.
@ 6, depends on how much a person is invested in the particulars. Millions of “Bible believing Christians” (that is, literalists) ignore things like the ban on eating shellfish.
I trust this same camp will still be around in the future, telling us how to live, but somehow reconciled to the existence of queers as normal human beings. They eventually got over the separation of the races, after all. But that one did cost them some members, churches did break up over it, and there are still tiny sects that teach that black people are subhumans suffering God’s divine punishment of Ham. Accepting LGBT equality and learning to ignore Deuteronomy will do the same.
Perry’s unlikely to lose many votes over this. The sort of people who might consider voting for him will not care, will agree, or won’t be paying attention. Not to say pointing out something like this is a worthless endeavour, but it isn’t something “he’ll have to answer to”, unless by answer, you mean he’ll say, “Yeah, I believe what I said.” There will be no meaningful political backlash on this.
I meant Perry and not Romney. Six of one…
This is a good example why it’s generally a waste of time to argue that homosexuality isn’t a matter of choice. Perry’s phrasing is technically correct: having an orientation doesn’t compel you to act on it. Of course, *he’s* saying this in the context of “TEH GAY SECKS IS EVUL”…and if you believe that, whether the orientation is a matter of choice is irrelevant.
The argument shouldn’t be that it’s not a matter of choice. The argument should be that who I or you or anyone else cares to fuck is none of Rick Perry’s goddamned business.
I remember the night that Rick Perry chose to be gay with me. I was stranded at the Hyatt at DFW, quietly getting plastered in the lobby bar, when he sat down next to me.
At first it was just guy talk, and I have to admit that I was impressed by his intake and ability to hold his liquor. Then i noticed his leg was rubbing up against mine. After a while he asked me if I liked tequilla. I told him yes, and he said that he had some great stuff up in his room, and would I be interested in a nightcap.
I was curious, so I went along, noticing how snug his wranglers were as he walked in front of me. We rode up the elevator in silence, accompanied by an elderly couple who were at the hotel for some sort of religious convention.
When we got to his room, I asked if I could use the restroom, and he said sure, slapping me on the behind as I went in. After relieving myself, I noticed all the grooming products he had. I thought he must travel with a separate makeup case (this was before the 4oz travel restrictions)
When I came back in the room, he was naked, and taking a huge hit of poppers. An empty shot glass stood on top of the televison, next to a half empty bottle of tequilla.
“Make yourself at home, baby” He said, refilling the shot glass “I’ll show you how we do it in Texas”
Delicacy forbids me from going into detail. Suffice to say, it was a night of unbridled passion. Perry was a demanding lover (I think the term the kids are all using these days is “power bottom”) and quite verbal. His fantasies were strange and somewhat creepy to me, but I was GGG, and we finally both fell asleep, exhausted.
In the morning, he kicked me out uncerimoniously. I was lucky to get out of there with my clothes on. It was like it had never happened with him, and in all honesty I wish it hadn’t. The memory of his odd cries and unusual demands rang in my head, combining with my tequilla hangover to make it quite an unpleasent memory.
Thank you for that, Catalina.
@17, ah, Catalina. No one can tell a tale of unusual demands quite like you.
Rick Perry knows a great deal about one characteristic that is definitely not a choice: stupidity.
Ms. Vel-DuRay, you are your generation’s Mary McCarthy.
Brava!!
Paul: Perry (not my favorite person) is not saying (at least not in this statement) that BEING gay is a choice. He is saying that having gay SEX is a choice. His unfortunate choice as a comparative confirms that he believes the action, not the condition, is “by choice” and strongly implies (if not actually states) that the condition is not only not a choice but is, (gasp) biological and genetic. Alcoholism is a condition that is broadly acknowledged to have biological mechanisms underpinning it including, but not limited to, genetic predisposition. Any migration of far right “religious” thinking away from gay as “demonic possession” toward gay as a “physiological condition”, at any speed or measure, must surely be a favorable thing.
Roll further down the comparative and one realizes that if Alcoholism is the addiction to, or dependency upon, drinking excessive amounts of alcoholic beverages, and that if being gay is just like being an alcoholic, then homosexuality must be the addiction to, or dependency upon, having excessive amounts of gay sex, implying that there if your not addicted to, or dependent upon, EXCESSIVE amounts of gay sex, you’re just a guy who enjoys some cock now and then… :-/ Hmmm…. The train kind of jumps the rails there and drops into IT’S NOT A CHOICE ravine on the gay side but rolls along rather nicely on the drunken frat boy side. I can live rather happily in that world.
That said, being a gay man who has gay sex and drinks but is not an alcoholic, I find his statement offensive on multiple levels. (Just what is an “excessive” amount and how do I know when I have it?). But, my battle field today is Gay Marriage. To paraphrase:
Obama: “Marriage should be between a man and a woman,” and that the legalization of gay marriage should be left up to the states.
Perry: “I’m not fine with gay marriage” but the 10th Amendment grants the authority for such decisions to the states. It’s hard to find much daylight between either of these bastards on that topic.
I’m guessing that while Perry may be more moderate in his personal beliefs he’s modifying his politics for the extreme right, thus I read the emphasis of his statement to be on the 10th Amendment part (after all, the “I’m not fine with it” was a fairly vague reposition (a pander) he gave to Tony Perkins of all people). I believe that Obama is attempting the same thing in pandering to the extreme left, but that puts his rather vague reposition (it should be left up to the states) into the pandering pile and leaves his very clear statement “marriage should be between a man and a woman” as his actual belief.
Such a choice…
I had to google that one, LuisitaPhD. I’m very flattered.
Personally, I’ve always thought of myself as a second rate Mary Bard.
Oh dear… I think I love you Miss. Vel-DuRay.
Remember kids, you’re only gay when you’re f***ing.
I think Rick Perry is conflicted about his own feelings for guys.
I mean, it’s pretty obvious …another screaching, scratching & clawing homophobe, deep in the closet.
It’s all about freedom, until you wanna use your genitals with consenting adults….
Because I am an animal and my ancestors killed for food to survive, does that mean that my instincts to kill another person to survive is OK. should i be reading the bible upside down? Let’s face it…if reproduction wasn’t intended then it shouldn’t be. I truly love a lot of my friends and i would do anything for them but come on being gay is a choice in my book, or is it ok that i kill for food because i must survive or should the human race come to an end.