Now the news is over on the BBC (also nice and high up on the home page).

It must be said: You don’t have to be the Queen of England to know that you don’t punch a lady in the face.

Someone (hello, new chief?) better straighten out Seattle’s police but quick.

87 replies on “Seattle Cop Punch Goes Worldwide”

  1. Ladies don’t fight with cops — especially while their (far more sensible) male companion tries to pull them away from all the ruckus!

  2. If a cop sees you break a law (albeit, a dumb one) and tells you to stop and come over – you do what the cop says. And, you definitely don’t start scrapping with the cop. The girl is lucky he didn’t shove her face into the cement. Had she been male and a bit older, I’m positive that’s what would have happened. You don’t scrap/resist with a cop unless you want to pick gravel out of your face.

  3. Ladies walk a little further down the block to use the sky-bridge the city installed especially for them instead of illegally jaywalking and then verbally and physically assaulting a police officer.

  4. “Someone (hello, new chief?) better straighten out Seattle’s police but quick.”

    No, someone needs to straighten out these kids with their false sense of entitlement.

    Someone should kick that ‘Lady’ in the clack.

  5. This is why we need someone like Brazier.

    @2 for the Police State win. Kudos, comrade! Salute your soviet masters!

  6. Whoa, uh, Bethany?

    Your post is uber-sexist. ANYONE who hits a cop is going to feel some negative repercussions from it.

    The average fellow does not punch the average lady, no. That was most definitely NOT the case on Rainier Ave on Monday afternoon — we had a police officer and a couple of entitled-feeling teenagers: nary a lady in sight.

    Please reset your feminism filters. Thank you.

  7. Bethany,
    No one should ever accost/taunt a person with a loaded weapon. Period.

    Given a choice, the young women were extraordinarily fortunate to have a police officer, male or female just punch one of them in the face. If it had been any other adult person carrying a loaded weapon they wouldn’t not have been so lucky. A loaded weapon carries a far more lethal “punch”. What they did was categorically stupid. And, they hardly acted like ladies.

  8. omg, please just shut off slog comments….ya’ll are just infinitely repeating yourselves.

    go to the original post, read the comments there and find the one that verbatim says what you are about to write and be satisfied it has been said for this specific topic.

    the horse is dead

  9. If the horse is dead, why are most of the Top Ten Slog Commented threads filled with this then, Andy?

    If wishes were videos than Perez Hilton would be duking it out with Miley Cyrus’ dad.

  10. Pretending that this is police brutality distracts from real instances of police brutality. And we have genuine instances of this happening recently and nearby, on tape.

    As for punching ladies in the face: never done it myself, but would do it for sure if said lady were attacking me. Fortunately, I don’t have a line of work where that happens a lot.

  11. Girl got exactly what she asked for. I’m usually the first to think the cop is in the wrong, having come of age in a town with a violent and corrupt police force, but the video is clear. Girl – no lady – brought this down on her own fool head. Since when do criminals caught in the act just get to wave The Hand of Dismissal and walk away? Throw the book at her.

  12. If he would have just flipped her over his back and pinned her down with his boot on her face when she attacked him from behind, nobody would have heard the first thing about it.

  13. Thanks for setting back both feminism and the focus on ACTUAL police brutality, Bethany!

    Maybe for your next post, you should explain how ladies don’t perspire, they glow.

  14. I’m totally with the “get off me, get off me” girl. Fuck that bullshit. Nobody gets to grab my body and force it to their will unless they are trying to protect another human from my actions. It freaks me out that we give this kind of power to the cops, and freaks me out even more that people (like these commenters) are so blindly obedient to the notion of physical authority that the police assume.
    That guy just punched a 17 year old chick in the face over a JAYWALKING incident!!! You have got to be fucking kidding me? If he doesn’t know of a better way to enforce jaywalking laws then he’s not smart enough to be trusted with authority.
    (Also, at what point does punching a 17 year old girl STOP a mob from happening?)

  15. That’s right, you don’t punch in the face who bigger than you and is assaulting you, you Taser her or spray her with pepper spray. He was punched her as a courtesy instead of the Taser if you ask me. Give me a break with this chivalry crap, some females today are just as vicious and violent as males. And I’m a liberal who hates police abuse. Paul Schene, Shandy Cobane and Matthew Paul are the real abusers who should be fired and prosecuted.

  16. Oh heatherly , I can’t wait ’til the day you get violently mugged. Do us a favor when it happens, don’t call the police for help.

    All this incident makes me think is, thank god I live above the Ship Canal.

  17. That guy just punched a 17 year old chick in the face over a JAYWALKING incident!!!

    No – it started as a jaywalking incident; then the girls escalated it to a resisting arrest incident, and then to an assaulting a police officer and interfering with an arrest incident. She didn’t get the punch until the third-tier escalation.

  18. You don’t punch a lady in the face? Are you trying to make Cienna Madrid look less awful for heaping ridicule middle aged womens’ boobs this morning?

    Is everything now an opportunity for the Stranger go make asses of yourselves? Everything?

  19. @29: It’s called the social contract. We vest certain kinds of authority in civil law enforcement personnel as a way of keeping order without resorting to vigilantism and chaos. They have the authority to stop and detain people for investigation of wrongdoing — even wrongdoings that you think should be legal — and the authority to use force to stop people who do not voluntarily cooperate.

    That’s pretty much where their authority ends, though. They are not the judges, and they cannot convict you of a crime, nor unilaterally force you to pay the fine for a traffic infraction. They are there to ensure that people who are suspected of breaking laws cooperate with the due process which the United States constitution guarantees to both the accuser and the accused. Without that, we would not have laws that meant anything.

    It’s astonishing to me how many people are ignorant of basic civics. You reap tremendous benefits from living in a society that vests the power of arrest in civilian law enforcement, and yet apparently believe that people should be able to pick and choose when they want to cooperate with police orders. Fail.

  20. Again, didn’t see how this started in the video (how it led up to the punch and why he was physically handling her and arresting her for a minor violation like jaywalking), but these “do whatever cops tell you at all times or you’ll deserve what you get” responses to this are really disturbing, similar comments appeared during the Henry Louis Gates flap — you do whatever a cop says, even when no crime is committed and even when you’re in your own home without disagreement… or else you deserve the consequences? Is this a police state? It’s bullying. Disgusting.

  21. @38: Saying that the police have the authority to detain someone under investigation is different from saying that people must do whatever the police say. Moreover, Gates was in his own home when that incident happened, and the girl who got punched in this video was attempting to use force to prevent a police officer from detaining a suspect.

    Trying to draw equivalencies here hurts the conversation. There is a very real need to check police authority, but when people like yourself try to throw every single use of force into the “OMG POLICE STATE!!!!” bucket, it hurts any real attempt to increase accountability.

    To me, it seems like a real shame that people are willing to lump this guy in with Paul Schene. Schene lost his shit and beat the crap out of a smaller girl because she was mouthing off. The cop in this new video NEVER lost it — he was in control of himself the entire time, wasn’t trying to hurt anyone, didn’t cause any injuries, and successfully detained both suspects.

    Yes, there may be problems with the way he attempted to handle too many people without any backup, and yes it all started with a minor traffic infraction. But this was not an abuse of authority, and it wasn’t someone looking for skulls to crack. This has nothing to do with life under the gestapo.

  22. Seattle is a police state? You know you don’t look intelligent saying that…in fact, you sound like you’ve never traveled or lived a real police state like some of us. You sound like rubes.

  23. Where’s the proof that the girls were walking away from the officer? In the police report, written by a cop covering his ass.

  24. @27 and @41 FTW(s)

    SLOG has lost it on this one. I love to join the policy brutality bandwagon as much as the next knee-jerk anti-police liberal hereabouts, but in this case the cop was COMPLETELY within the bounds of his job as far as I am concerned.

    It’s totally beside the point whether it was worth his time dealing with jaywalking infractions. Once the girls assaulted him, they were going to get taken down. And this cop did NOT lose his shit in any way.

    Did he have to punch them? I.e. could he have used some other means to subdue them? Maybe, maybe not – but it was well withins his prerogative as a cop.

    And WTF – who cares what a polite gentleman would do in OTHER circumstances? This ain’t polite discourse. This is assualting a cop fer chrissakes.

    And any other means may have been worse (taser, chokehold, etc).

    SLOG – get a grip.

  25. Maybe you’d better changed your by-line to Anne Arky…

    In my experience, driving down either Rainier or MLK at night or day is like playing human ten pins wherein ‘pedestrians’ are basically expressing their right-of-way and daring you to hit them.

    The record shows that several pins have in fact been knocked down. But then most Seattle pedestrians with their little hand-held devices are walking in their bubble-boy world, oblivious to the potential loss of life they seem to be assiduously courting.

  26. Here’s what mystifies me: since everyone besides obvious retards agrees the cop was completely justified in what he did, why is this story being picked up by CNN, BBC, etc?

    Comments on every news site are running like 10 to 1 in favor of the cop, everyone but the fringies (Bethany, Heatherly, the NAACP) knows this was just a cop doing what he was supposed to do, and yet every media outlet from the Stranger to BBC is treating it as some kind of police scandal. I honestly do not understand.

  27. You don’t punch a lady? Um, he didn’t.
    Get off your pedistal. The law should not treat violent females with more respect than violent males. That is sexist.

  28. All the news outlets are stupid. Everyone’s got their opinion about this case. Am I the only one laughing? And rewinding and then laughing even harder? Where’s the YouTube video remix that shows her getting punched over and over again in rapid succession? I’d make it myself if I knew how. LOL!

  29. Funny how no one mentions the extensive criminal record that these women have. Actually, jaywalking looks kind of sad when your resume contains Burglary, Auto Theft, Strong Arm Robbery, Assault. Perhaps they felt they needed to turn things up a notch.

Comments are closed.