This is the gun that got University of Washington student Miles Murphy killed:

DSC_0036_resize.JPG

The Seattle Police Department held a press conference earlier this afternoon to talk about the events that led to Murphy’s tragic death on New Year’s Day.

SPD Chief Gil Kerlikowske said that as officers were taking up positions outside of Murphy’s home, the 22-year-old man came out of his house wearing a German military uniform and pointed a Kar 98 bolt action rifle—which was apparently loaded with blanks—at officers.

Kerlikowske says officers, who were in uniform, ordered Murphy to drop his weapon three times. Murphy did not respond, and instead raised the rifle, pointed it at officers, lowered it, raised it again and stepped towards officers.

Two officers carrying rifles—Adam Elias and Kirk Waldord, who’ve been with SPD for 7 and 10 years, respectively—fired seven shots, fatally wounding Murphy. Witnesses had apparently told police that Murphy was firing blanks in an alley next to his home, however, Kerlikowske argued that “officers don’t get the option to believe everything they’re told by a witness.” He also stated that it is not department policy to use less lethal weapons like Tasers when a gun is involved. “It’s just not done,” Kerlikowske said, later adding that “’shoot to wound’ is purely myth.”

According to Kerlikowske, SPD previously confiscated Murphy’s rifle in November 2006, but he would not elaborate on why. The rifle was returned two months later. The chief also noted that Officer Elias has taken an extensive deescalation course with the department and stated that neither officer has been involved a prior shooting. Kerlikowske believes “alcohol was certainly a factor” in the shooting and that officers made the right decision. Police found a box of live ammunition in Murphy’s house after the shooting and detained two men for questioning. No arrests were made.

According to Murphy’s friend Andrew Swanson, Murphy was depressed, but he doesn’t believe his friend committed “suicide by cop.”

“He definitely had his issues with depression. He was kind of a sad guy,” Swanson says. “A lot of us are too, so we could relate to him in that way [but] I can’t say any of his emotional problems had anything to do with what happened.”

Jonah Spangenthal-Lee: Proving you wrong since 1983.

107 replies on “Seven Shots”

  1. How could emotional problems NOT have anything to do with donning a WWII military uniform and pointing a rifle at police? I would say that regardless of what police should or shouldn’t do, this whole thing had to be the result of mental illness.

  2. What about the other guys? Is it true that there was a second guy shooting in the alley? Is it true that three more guys were there — a total of five of them? What do they have to say for themselves?

    I mostly want to know how they could have let him come to the door carrying that gun in the first place. And how they all agreed that shooting blanks in the alley was a good idea in the first place. How drunk were they? Is this the first time they all got drunk and played with their guns? Have they fired blanks in the city before? Are they still in police custody? Will they be charged?

    These people who were close to Murphy have a lot to tell about what led up to this.

  3. Even so, having a militarized police force whose problem solving skills are limited to shooting everyone is sight certainly isn’t helping.

  4. Also. Was Murphy an actual member of a real reenactment group? Was there any live ammunition in the apartment? Questions. Questions…

  5. Look, I realize that the US police are dealing with a heavily armed, borderline psychotic population, but similiar incidents of police-caused deaths in Canada and England cause national scandals–here it’s just a Thursday.

    Clearly something’s gone cuckoo.

  6. @3 This doesn’t scream mental illness to me. The guy liked military history (particularly German, Russian, and Cossack, it seems) and battle re-enactment. Plenty of non-mentally ill dopes dress up and do Civil War re-enactment all the time. So what if he was a little obsessive/eccentric about it and liked to dress up in old uniforms? Is it, at its face, that much weirder than goth or punk kids?

    I’m assuming here that he was not, in fact, obsessed with Nazis in an admiration of their ideals or a neo-Nazi kind of way — I haven’t seen anything written that would suggest that. That being said, as everyone else has said, if the officers told him repeatedly to drop his weapon, and he didn’t. Well… that was a huge, lethal mistake.

    I do wonder why Tasers are not an option when a gun is involved. I was under the impression that this type of scenario (uncertain risk) would be the perfect one to use a taser. You’re not certain whether the guy is actually a threat or not (as opposed to someone who is in fact shooting at the cops), so you incapacitate him with a Taser. They seem pretty effective to me…

  7. @ Julie in Chicago,

    Tasers are not the end all answer, as the on-going controversies over their use in Canada and England have shown.

    There was an article recently about how the various Taser models sometimes deliver lethal jolts despite their settings.

    Often it seems that the people killed by cops are drunk or mentally ill. Shouldn’t there be a better way to deal with them than opening fire??

  8. it’s looking like he made an unfortunate decision in those last moments. since there was no knock, it sounds like the police were not set up yet, perhaps caught a little before they were ready with their best plan. or that he didn’t know for certain there were cops outside.

    but the clarification was good — the police were told about the blanks. in cases like that, it’s tough. it was a school, so do you plan to stop the “assassin” before columbine III, or do you try to find out if it’s a drunk kid fooling around.

    the whole thing makes me sad. and i still want to hear from any witnesses.

    and though elenchos lack of sympathy bugs me a little, it’s true, his friends should have done everything they could to stop him. i won’t say they are at fault – we all make our own choices. but a little intervention may have been the difference between life and death in this case.

  9. Point a flashlight, wallet, or cellphone at a cop and they will shoot you.

    Pointing a rifle may as well be an engraved invitation to be shot.

  10. Infrequent, I’ve had friends exactly like that: obsession with guns, or explosives, and binge drinking. I took a stand against that idiocy. I did not quietly sit by and say nothing, and I sure as fuck didn’t help.

    Ironically, based on what we know so far, the SPD were his only real friends, when they took his gun away. I’m getting the sense that everyone else thought he was merely amusing. Guess they were wrong, huh?

    If an organized reenactment club accepted him, I’d be more willing to believe that he was harmless. But if they considered him too reckless, and he was forced to stage his own private “reenactments” with people who had lower standards, well…

    I don’t know. I’m asking. What’s the story?

    @18 — Thanks. I missed that. So would he have switched to live rounds if he where drunk enough? Just wondering…

  11. Early 20’s is the prime age for manic break.

    It could be that he was having symptoms of increased importance or even actually believed he was in the military and was defending himself.

    If he had a known history of depression it is possible that he had swung into a mania — disregarding social norms (firing weapons in the street)

    I’m not trying to diagnose I am just really trying to understand how the fuck this guy could let so many details of reality and proper behavior get out of his grasp.

    When will the autopsy results be in to find out if he was drunk?

  12. i really don’t know… perhaps your experiences have shaped your view on this, just as mine have. was he a binge drinker? did he try to join any re-enactment groups? was he admitted or not? was the live ammo his — or for that rifle? was he out of control … or was this night a surprise to even him?

    yeah, if i had a friend who got trashed and started playing with a gun, i would not be comfortable nor cool with it. i would just about tackle him if i knew there were police outside and he headed for the door.

    but i wasn’t there, and i don’t know all the details. this is a sad happening. i’m not sure yet how easily it could have been avoided. was he on course to self-destruct? could friends have intervened? could the police modified their response? could anything have been done differently?

    but i’m still a little ticked the original information disseminated played up the nazi angle — tainting opinions on this. we were waiting for an update, andas the pro-police usually like to say, what have you got to hide?

  13. hear there is a wake where you can only get in wearing a uniform carrying an old Army rifle – or AK-47, I think is OK too, as well as Lugers

    is this true?

    by the way, my gaydar went off, look at the pictures of this eccentric young man

  14. Whatever the specifics in this particular case, whenever the police use lethal force, it’s a setback for them and it limits their ability to deal with the people they’re supposed to be protecting because they lose (have lost?) the public’s trust.

    Hell, I would only call the police as an absolute last resort. It seems they just make the situation worse.

  15. differing views lead us to different questions:

    you ask: was he about to switch to live ammo?

    i ask: did the police really identify themselves and order he drop the weapon multiple times?

    i will agree, however, that your question is a great concern, too.

  16. “[Neighbor Mike] Kedziora said [to the Seattle Times] he heard confusion outside and could hear police warning the man to drop his weapon. A few minutes later, they watched out the window as the wounded neighbor was taken away and SWAT teams searched the neighborhood.”

    “Uniformed police officers warned Murphy several times to drop his weapon” according to police spokesman Jeff Kappel.

  17. The cops did what cops are trained to do. I don’t like most of ’em, but in this case they seem to have responded appropriately. Yes, the young man probably was harmless. Probably. But how exactly were the police to know by his behavior (also witnessed by his neighbors) that he was harmless?

    This young man is dead because his friends and family seem to just shrug off his dangerous, silly, and inappropriate behavior as “eccentric”. They turned a blind eye to a very unsafe combination of alcohol (& possibly drugs), depression, and guns. Now he’s dead and they are ranting about the “pigs” and injustice. Perhaps if they cared so very much about their friend they should have done something before he got killed.

    p.s. That picture of him riding the horse in uniform looks pretty Nazi-like to me. I’m sure the neighbors were afraid of him before he and his pals decided to make-believe shoot up the neighborhood. And don’t a lot of Jewish folk live around there? This kid was lacking in common sense and good taste all around (even while sober)…and so were his friends who keep passing it off as “eccentric”.

  18. Of course people/friends are going to say ~ZOMG~ THE POLICE DINT IDENTIFY THEMSELVES

    ~ZOMG~ he would have never pointed a rifle!!!!

    friends will always say that.

    The fact is that neighbors were interviewed and reported hearing the (uniformed) police ordering him to drop the weapon a number of times.

    then the friends say ~zomg~ the neighbors are liars.

    it’s textbook defensiveness and fingerpointing.

  19. Did this guy think the uniformed police officers were in on his war game????????? That some of his disgusting friends found some more contemporary uniforms?

  20. Drunk or not, wearing a Nazi uniform or not, shooting blanks or not, any cop in the country would have shot this kid if he pointed a bayonetted rifle at them at 2:00am. As they should.

    I’m sorry he’s dead. It really is unfortunate. But he has nobody to blame but himself.

  21. Original Andrew – What do the police in other countries do if you point a rifle at them and refuse to put it down? Do they duck? Do they let you get a shot off first? Please enlighten.

  22. i agree with elenchos, where were his buddies when he walked out of his door carrying that weapon? we know of at least two men that were in the house and from other reports it sounds like there were more people. not one of those people, supposedly his friends, stood up to say, “put the fuckin’ gun down before you go out there?”

  23. @ Original Andrew @18:

    Often it seems that the people killed by cops are drunk or mentally ill. Shouldn’t there be a better way to deal with them than opening fire??

    Are there no workhouses, are there no prisons? Seriously, with the mass de-funding and closing of mental institutions, there is no place for the mentally ill to go but halfway houses and homeless shelters. Granted, this guy probably wasn’t a candidate, but having the mentally ill stirred into the general population just means you have to be extra careful because the dangerous ones don’t all wear Napoleon hats or mouth guards.

  24. I can’t imagine him being intent on killing himself in the midst of what sounds like news years celebration. As stupid a thing to do as it was, I can’t imagine they were firing off their guns for anything other than having fun. Further, I doubt they intended on attracting police for the purpose of setting up a firing squad for Mr. Murphy… its simply unfathomable.

    It sounds like he was wasted beyond comprehension. Keep in mind the context. I mean, what better night to drink excessively?

    The suicide angle just doesn’t make the cut. Are we to expect everyone in their early twenties with a love for drinking/partying and a few emotional imperfections to kill themselves?

  25. LSD – not Jack Daniels….

    sad, only one person made major mistakes, the dead guy

    his friends are idiots, too polite to read him the riot act about his behavior, shit on those phony feel good friends – he was a trinket on the trinket shelf – not a human with some behavior problems

    the new American middle class way of dealing

    and this guy was no kid, SENIOR in college is a bit beyond childhood, smart student, stupid in real life

    sad, he was cute, and as someone commented, looks VERY queer to me – maybe that was the driving force behind his depression – his true queer self with, so he thought, no path to come out ???

    by the way that old rifle with live ammo will kill a moose quite nicely

    sad, RIP dear Sojournner, perhaps, all is finally well in your current dimension

  26. COMMENT DELETED: Spam
    We’d rather not moderate your comments, but off-topic, gratuitously inflammatory, threatening, or otherwise inappropriate remarks may be removed, and repeat offenders may be banned from commenting. We never censor comments based on ideology. Thanks to all who add to the conversation.

  27. @37: What behavior are you talking about? His unusually obsession with history? I was thinking something similar, that he needed to be sat down and scolded for his every discrepancy before he was allowed to do this to himself. He should have been wearing stuff from the Gap, playing football instead of reenacting wars, studying business instead of foreign cultures. Just be normal. Kind of like the Japanese proverb… hammer down the nail that which sticks out the furthest.
    Our youth is becoming too weak and liberal. This is a perfect example of open mindedness reaching its failing point… with needlessly fatal results.

  28. It’s funny how people like #40, when being facetious, leave out all the vital details like “dressing up like a nazi?” “shooting a gun off in the city?”

  29. After reading his myspace page (posted in yesterday’s thread somewhere), it seems pretty tragic to me. He was into vintage military costumes period, not just Nazi ones, so I think playing up the Nazi thing isn’t the right story. Playing with guns and drinking abusively all the time is obviously not a safe hobby, but people are self-destructive in lots of different ways, I wouldn’t just dismiss this kid as too stupid to know cops shoot to kill. Maybe he was on Prozac or some antidepressant you shouldn’t combine with alcohol. I gotta say I feel sorry for the cops in this situation too. Cops have to make some shitty choices…I can’t even decide what cookies to buy at the supermarket in less than five minutes.

  30. Listen up, internet. I want to clear the air here before anything I have said or will say gets misconstrued. What I meant today when I spoke with Jonah is that we had been through similar life experiences as Miles had (you know, the normal fresh adult business, such as break ups, “so-and-so said this” banter, career uncertainty, yada-yada… we’ve all been there). I also said to Jonah that we could all, as Miles’ friends, identify with these types of feelings. To reiterate, I would encourage everyone not to speculate about these factors. I would never suggest that Miles wanted this, and furthermore I wouldn’t suggest that the policeman are murderers. As easy as it is to cobble together miscellaneous bits of information to create a dramatic piece of news, I would hesitate to ascribe the causes of the events that led to Miles’ death to any singular source. I understand how journalism goes, and I understand that it’s any reporter’s inclination to write a compelling piece, especially in these sorts of situations. To the readers: take anything you see in the media with a grain for salt. Read it with as much objectivity as possible. Don’t try to make up something that makes sense to you. It doesn’t even make sense to those of us that know Miles. To the reporters (and Jonah, I’m not saying that you have misrepresented me): please do not reinterpret our words in order to generate a more captivating narrative. If we had seen this coming, I can assure you that not a single one of us would have sat back and allowed it to happen. In fact, the last time I saw Miles on the Sunday after Christmas, he was in good spirits. Make all the assumptions you want, but let it be known that none of us are going to contribute to any sort of speculative conclusions or to the formulation of false explanations for these tragic events. As it stands, this is simply (or not-so-simply) a series of extraordinary misunderstandings that ended in the death of Miles Murphy. I can speak for all of us when I say that our thoughts go out to Miles’ family, his friends, the witnesses, and to all of the authorities that are currently involved in this horrific tragedy.

    Goodnight all. Rest in peace, Miles. We’ll miss you.

    -Andrew J.

  31. taser probably would not have worked in this case. Tasers have a failure rate of some 32% when subject has on thick or baggy clothing. I suspect that german military uniform with a heavy overcoat (as was reported in the papers) would be too thick.

    Also, both probes need to hit the subject and would require close range firing of the taser (at 18′ the probe spread is 30″); I’m not sure how close the officers were in this instance but Miles wasn’t that big of a target and he had on thick clothing. What if he wasn’t shooting blanks and the tasers missed or were ineffective….

  32. @12 the reason is that America is built on violence at least as much as on ideals. At every significant turn in our country’s history the path chosen has almost always been the violent one – even more than the one that makes the most money – though a lot of times they go hand in hand. So yeah it’s small wonder that violence – by police or citizens – is the norm here. In my high school days (circa 1979) there were no school shootings and no one had heard of the phrase “going postal”. Now days most high school students expect guns in school. WTF!! So violence . . . by the police and everybody else . . . yeah, welcome to America. (very sad)

  33. Andrew, your first mistake was talking to the biggest failure in local Media: Jonah S.L.

    You probably didn’t now this at the time, but he really really sucks.

Comments are closed.