To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
That’s so the cops can pepper spray you.
Siri likes cops.
What, no mention at all of World AIDS Day, Dan??
Well, THAT is a disturbing bias, Apple.
WOW. That is SO NOT COOL.
Your consumer product made by underpaid labor in a totalitarian regime doesn’t provide you with the First World comforts you’d expect.
That’s a shame… e_e
This concerns me about as much as Eliza not being able to do rape counseling, and it actually is the same problem, just on a greater scale.
Whatever databases that Siri is hooked up to happen to have holes in these specific locations. It isn’t malice, it’s just an incomplete expert system (a feature which basically every expert system shares.)
Actually, Siri does give you results if you’re searching for Planned Parenthood:
http://www.tuaw.com/2011/11/30/debunked-…
But please, do go on with your shrill knee-jerk reactions. They’re really entertaining.
various debunkings:
http://www.theatlanticwire.com/business/…
http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/30…
Shouldn’t the Stranger also be asking if Siri can find a bathhouse in the city?
You’re a day behind on that story. Apple is blaming its data sources and Siri’s beta status. http://www.blogforchoice.com/archives/20…
I know this is seriously stupid of Apple and all…..
But personally, my phone’s voice recognition software is not the first resource I would go to for my reproductive health services advice.
Just sayin’
I am outraged that a beta voice control product is so imperfect I have to type in my request into the browser provided on the same phone.
This is clear evidence of a conspiracy by anti-voice pro-typers,
@8: Excuses =/= debunking. At best those comments represent a promise to fix it. And a promise is only as good as your follow-through.
These complaints are bogus.
http://tidbits.com/article/12653
Siri does return searches for Abortion Clinics in a bunch of cities, and if you asked for directions to the business name instead of the generic category, it would tell you.
Jesus fucking Christ, Siri is BETA. Give the developers a break for not immediately thinking “Oh, better give em an abortion option!”.
@6,
No, it isn’t malice. It’s just evidence that male programmers in Cupertino don’t know or give a shit about women’s reproductive issues.
They programmed Siri to give cutesy answers when you ask “what’s the meaning of life?” or “will you marry me, Siri?” Their oversight of programming Siri to correctly respond to searches about women’s issues is just that, an oversight, not a glitch.
If you’re going to come into a story 36 hours late, at least read all the background on it before posting hysterically.
Siri actually isn’t great at finding donut shops either. Wait a decade and she’ll probably be awesome, but right now she’s mostly useless.
@16,
Siri also gives inappropriate cutesy responses when you tell her that you’ve been robbed. Just because some phrases have pre-written responses doesn’t mean that you should expect *every* phrase to have a pre-written response. It’s just ludicrous.
Lots of good comments here. Dan, you really kinda blew it on this one.
@7, 8, those aren’t so much ‘debunkings’ as they are ‘responses.’ A representative of the company being complained about explaining that this is a problem and that it hasn’t been fixed yet doesn’t mean that the problem doesn’t exist. At most, it pushes the question of WHY there’s this lacuna back a step or two, but doesn’t actually answer it.
If they’d pointed out that there were other huge gaps in Siri’s database, well, that’d be a more reasonable debunking, but that’s not what the articles are doing. In fact, all three of the articles that have been linked as responses just note that Apple claims that this is a glitch, and not due to any moral objections or agendas. Which, as pure assertion, is decidedly less compelling than the original question.
Jesus, Dan, behind on the news cycle much?
Anyone who thinks that Apple Inc is a hotbed of anti-choice sentiment needs a serious reality check.
(I’ve got $5 that says that the real backstory here is that the apple-vs-google tiff meant that they had to use someone godawful like yelp or yp.com for their local business listings.)
I think it’s pretty telling that people are excusing this glaring omission as if treating women’s health issues as backseat to social or political pressure is some sort of new thing thats never happened before.
Yes, it should have abortion services. At the bare minimum, it should have been set up with all the Planned Parenthood offices.
But for the life of me, who would ask an iPhone for information about medical procedures? (“Siri, I need to get a kidney transplant. Who do you reccommend?”) I would be afraid that any result would be based on some sort of marketing agreement (which is probably why it recognizes Viagra).
And what about the so-called “Pregnancy crisis centers”? How is an app supposed to differentiate between legitimate women’s health services and some sort of crackpot “pro-life” center – and even if it can, how can it do that in 144 characters, or whatever the limit is?
As for the way it handled the rape reporting, and domestic abuse, that’s bad – but should you be telling a phone app about a crime you were victim to? Should it just connect you with the nearest 911? What if you don’t want to report it?
Some things are just too important to leave up to cell phone apps.
I want to jump on board the Apple hating, but it is still in beta, after all. That seems pretty juvenile. Still, some of these made me laugh.
“I need the morning after pill.”
“Is that so?”
“Yes, Mother, now tell me where I can find it, goddammit!”
@21, that is real sophisticated of you, but you missed Brian’s link @14.
Is it me or is “Beta” meaningless now? I don’t know anything about programming, but it seems crazy to offer a product, advertise it all over the place, and explain excuses by saying, “it’s in Beta.” I mean, I know at least one person who bought he phone for the Siri feature.
Anyway, if they fix the problem, I’m willing to accept that it was an oversight, not intentional. That doesn’t mean it’s not worth complaining about though.
That is very upsetting. It’s one thing to block or miss locations of products/services, quite another for Siri to be a snarky bitch when you ask for the morning-after pill. How the hell does she know to be a snarky bitch when you ask for emergency contraception, unless someone programs her specifically to do so? Or does “Siri” think it’s a funny joke like hiding a dead body?
@28: oh good lord. Siri has a set of “funny” responses that she spits out to any question (of a certain form) that it doesn’t know the answer to. “Siri, why are you a cannibal?” will produce the same type of response as “Siri, why are you pro-life?”
So what? Oh no, the location engine can’t find everything you say. Fucking Google it. Unless you had your thumbs raped off.
I guess the upside to this is that in Siri, Apple apparently has a product that more or less passes the Turing test for a lot of people: it works well enough when it works that when it fails, people’s first thought isn’t “oh, programming error” but “man, Siri hates my politics.”
Ok, just testing it now with names of local clinics. So far it’s found them all and given me directions. Found 6 locations matching Planned Parenthood. Gave me directions to Cedar River Clinics in Tacoma.
Someone use Microsoft’s TellMe feature to ask for ‘Abortion Clinics’. I’d be interested to know what results turn up.
Siri was no help at all in finding my wife’s g-spot.
Siri, I need to take it up the ass, unprotected, from multiple anonymous males at a bathhouse and then blame republicans when things go wrong. Where can I go?
@34:
[Siri’s answer]: http://gopconvention2012.com/
@16 THIS. What 23 yr old male code monkey thinks about abortions?
@36 – Yep, @16 wins the thread.
Doesn’t matter about Siri being in Beta. Matters about 23 yr old male code monkeys.
AND NOW THEY’VE BEEN FOUND OUT. Fix it.
You guys, really, read Brian’s link at 14 before you go awarding wins here.
Does this surprise anyone? You will like whatever Apple tells you to like, so shut up and continue to throw money at them, while protesting corporate bullshit.
@35 wins at ZING!-age.
@ 38 – I did read the link, and awarded a win anyway.
In the original story that Dan linked to, the writer DID ask for directions to business names, several times, and Siri remained clueless.
It’s an oversight. Made by male code monkeys. That needs to be fixed.
No one’s calling for heads to roll, it’s just.. disappointing that, more than a decade now into the 21st century, women’s issues are STILL just un-thought-of, and that that’s the standard. Disappointing.
People are on a hair trigger these days.
Patience is a virtue.
(Not @you, merry. You make a valid point.)
Maybe I’d care if it was about something important, not Apple’s latest gimmick.
Internet feminists know where their priorities are, ie: their iPhones.
Apple likes boner havin creeps.
And people wondered ten or twenty years ago why I never objected to and generally approved of hiring for balance. If I wanted to, I could probably make a little round and collect twenty dinners at once – but, like Alice, I’d rather go without twenty dinners at once than have to eat them all in one sitting.
Eesh, can everyone please calm down? This is not some conspiracy. It’s a fucking natural language processor hooked to a database of businesses, and it’s evolving as people use it. There are countless things that Siri won’t find, and it doesn’t mean a fucking thing. Please read the link Brian posted – http://tidbits.com/article/12653.
Oh hey, everyone’s already posting the Adam Engst story. So no more clicks here, please. No more ad views. Leave. The intelligent person on this matter has spoken. It even appears one of Dan’s coworkers agrees with Adam’s analysis.
Which anyone with half a brain would. Sheesh.
You’d think Dan would have at least put a bit more effort into crafting his clickbait story. “Siri’s sexist!”, “She’s also anti-choice!”
No. “She” is an algorithm that sometimes returns poor results.
22’s right. They’re using Yelp and some other, lesser-known databases, due to not being able to play well with Google. You want to complain about the search returns? Either blame Yelp, or blame Apple and Google for not being able to make nice.
It’s worth considering if they ought to have programmed in some words that would *not* trigger a cutesy response–rape, abuse, robbed, etc.